what's your take on this?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
what's your take on this? I think it's ridiculous. |
Posted 1/14/08 2:31 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: what's your take on this? i've got volumes to stay about this, but there are really only two points. |
|
Posted 1/14/08 2:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: what's your take on this? Posted by Blu-ize i've got volumes to stay about this, but there are really only two points. It takes 15x the energy to walk with a prosthesis..I can't imagine how much more energy it would take to run. I don't know where they got that info about less energy, it's just incorrect. Not having his legs means he works out differently and trains differently. He tries harder than any other athelete has to. it's really a smack in the face. I've seen the prosthesis and while it is impressive, it take different muscles to use it than a regular leg. It's crap. i would agree with this, but the IAAF found that he was able to run just as fast while expending LESS energy than "normal" runners - which gives him an unfair advantage. it would be the same thing as taking a drug that allowed you to utilize less oxygen and run as fast as other competitors - you might not be able to run faster, but you could compete for longer amounts of time without having to reserve your energy. in this SPECIFIC case, i agree with the ban. i think each case should be reviewed individually. |
|
Posted 1/14/08 3:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: what's your take on this? their testing is flawed. This is incorrect. It takes much more energy. although I was not there when they tested him, there is no way that a person with an artifical limb could expend less energy. It takes so much more. |
|
Posted 1/14/08 3:12 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: what's your take on this? Posted by headoverheels Posted by Blu-ize i've got volumes to stay about this, but there are really only two points. It takes 15x the energy to walk with a prosthesis..I can't imagine how much more energy it would take to run. I don't know where they got that info about less energy, it's just incorrect. Not having his legs means he works out differently and trains differently. He tries harder than any other athelete has to. it's really a smack in the face. I've seen the prosthesis and while it is impressive, it take different muscles to use it than a regular leg. It's crap. i would agree with this, but the IAAF found that he was able to run just as fast while expending LESS energy than "normal" runners - which gives him an unfair advantage. it would be the same thing as taking a drug that allowed you to utilize less oxygen and run as fast as other competitors - you might not be able to run faster, but you could compete for longer amounts of time without having to reserve your energy. in this SPECIFIC case, i agree with the ban. i think each case should be reviewed individually. Lacne Armstrong's chemo left him with the ability to do so. and look how far he went. regardless of how much "engery" is expended, the legs are not attached to his body. his brain is not attached to those legs. he doens't feel with those legs. they are still attached to him, every day. He still managed to get his velocity up, with feet that look about has graceful as flippers. I think all told, the energy "benefit" is cancelled out here. if they legs had a motor attached, I could see it... |
Posted 1/14/08 3:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: what's your take on this? Posted by headoverheels i would agree with this, but the IAAF found that he was able to run just as fast while expending LESS energy than "normal" runners - which gives him an unfair advantage. it would be the same thing as taking a drug that allowed you to utilize less oxygen and run as fast as other competitors - you might not be able to run faster, but you could compete for longer amounts of time without having to reserve your energy. in this SPECIFIC case, i agree with the ban. i think each case should be reviewed individually. I agree. If they have done tests, and shown that he expends less energy, then the ban should stand. If the test is inaccurate, or needs to be revisited, that's a valid argument. All Olympic sporting events have rules to keep things fair. If the fake legs give him an advantage, how is that fair to everyone else? I need a bicycle to keep up with most runners, and a car for marathon runners. Prosthetics that rival or surpass "normal" limbs are a new topic. The IAAF is doing it's best to keep up with changing technology and methods. It's not an easy position to be in, but judging bodies in all sports go through this on a regular basis. |
|
Posted 1/14/08 3:18 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: what's your take on this? even if the limbs...the prosthesis..are in fact "better" than human arms or legs.. |
Posted 1/14/08 3:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: what's your take on this? I think most of the disagreements are on the testing portion of the argument. I was basing my opinion on what the test results gave. I have no way of knowing how the tests were done, or what the true results are. I can only go by what is published. If he isn't getting a mechanical advantage from his limbs, then he should be able to compete, but the testing needs to be agreed to by various parties, and there still needs to be guidelines for future athletes. |
|
Posted 1/14/08 3:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: what's your take on this? Posted by Ophelia even if the limbs...the prosthesis..are in fact "better" than human arms or legs.. there is still the human factor. the fact that there is no neurons sending information to the brain from prosthetic limbs...there is no biological connection to brain or body. that in and of itself seems to be an EXTREME handicap to overcome. so this athlete does it. he overcomes it and finds a way to have his total body come together in a way that makes him a contender with other total body (ie able bodied) athletes, and he is rejected b/c he utilizes his prosthesis to the fullest advantage? that hardly seems fair. at all. I totally agree. I see what my brother goes through with wearing his artificial leg. He's exhausted after wearing it and can't wait to take it off..it becomes heavy and annoying, not to mention that the stump always remains somewhat sensitive. Ok, so I am adding some of the volumes I mentioned. |
|
Posted 1/14/08 3:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: what's your take on this? Posted by Ophelia even if the limbs...the prosthesis..are in fact "better" than human arms or legs.. there is still the human factor. the fact that there is no neurons sending information to the brain from prosthetic limbs...there is no biological connection to brain or body. that in and of itself seems to be an EXTREME handicap to overcome. so this athlete does it. he overcomes it and finds a way to have his total body come together in a way that makes him a contender with other total body (ie able bodied) athletes, and he is rejected b/c he utilizes his prosthesis to the fullest advantage? that hardly seems fair. at all. If he had an arm-powered bicycle, and he had the gearing set up so he could travel twice as fast as the fastest person on legs, would that be OK to use? The bicycle isn't a part of him, but it would be a huge mechanical advantage, and would defeat the entire purpose of the Olympics. Mechanical advantage is potentially a big issue, which is why we keep inventing mechanical advantages to help us out. |
|
Posted 1/14/08 3:29 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: what's your take on this? Posted by GoldenRod Posted by Ophelia even if the limbs...the prosthesis..are in fact "better" than human arms or legs.. there is still the human factor. the fact that there is no neurons sending information to the brain from prosthetic limbs...there is no biological connection to brain or body. that in and of itself seems to be an EXTREME handicap to overcome. so this athlete does it. he overcomes it and finds a way to have his total body come together in a way that makes him a contender with other total body (ie able bodied) athletes, and he is rejected b/c he utilizes his prosthesis to the fullest advantage? that hardly seems fair. at all. If he had an arm-powered bicycle, and he had the gearing set up so he could travel twice as fast as the fastest person on legs, would that be OK to use? The bicycle isn't a part of him, but it would be a huge mechanical advantage, and would defeat the entire purpose of the Olympics. Mechanical advantage is potentially a big issue, which is why we keep inventing mechanical advantages to help us out. the difference here is what is powering the device. in this case, the MAN is powering the artificial limbs foward. there is no additional propulsion source. If there was, it would be a different story. |
Posted 1/14/08 3:31 PM
|
|
|
Re: what's your take on this? Posted by Ophelia the difference here is what is powering the device. in this case, the MAN is powering the artificial limbs foward. there is no additional propulsion source. If there was, it would be a different story. I still think we're arguing the same point from different sides. You disagree that there is mechanical advantage in artificial limbs. I would definitely agree with this, except for the fact that the IAAF supposedly tested these particular limbs, which are not "standard" limbs, and in this particular case, they determined that there was a mechanical advantage. That advantage is similar to my arm-powered bike analogy. The bike is only powered by the human, but by the way it is built and designed, it gives an advantage. I agree with you 100% about it being much harder to use an artificial limb for the average amputee, but I am making my statements solely on what the IAAF results came out with. |
|
Posted 1/14/08 3:37 PM
|
|
|
Ophelia
Member since 5/06 23378 total posts Name: |
Re: what's your take on this? Posted by GoldenRod Posted by Ophelia the difference here is what is powering the device. in this case, the MAN is powering the artificial limbs foward. there is no additional propulsion source. If there was, it would be a different story. I still think we're arguing the same point from different sides. You disagree that there is mechanical advantage in artificial limbs. I would definitely agree with this, except for the fact that the IAAF supposedly tested these particular limbs, which are not "standard" limbs, and in this particular case, they determined that there was a mechanical advantage. That advantage is similar to my arm-powered bike analogy. The bike is only powered by the human, but by the way it is built and designed, it gives an advantage. I agree with you 100% about it being much harder to use an artificial limb for the average amputee, but I am making my statements solely on what the IAAF results came out with. I see. and they are full of sh1t. |
Posted 1/14/08 3:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: what's your take on this? Posted by Ophelia Posted by GoldenRod Posted by Ophelia the difference here is what is powering the device. in this case, the MAN is powering the artificial limbs foward. there is no additional propulsion source. If there was, it would be a different story. I still think we're arguing the same point from different sides. You disagree that there is mechanical advantage in artificial limbs. I would definitely agree with this, except for the fact that the IAAF supposedly tested these particular limbs, which are not "standard" limbs, and in this particular case, they determined that there was a mechanical advantage. That advantage is similar to my arm-powered bike analogy. The bike is only powered by the human, but by the way it is built and designed, it gives an advantage. I agree with you 100% about it being much harder to use an artificial limb for the average amputee, but I am making my statements solely on what the IAAF results came out with. I see. and they are full of sh1t. I'm not going to argue with you on that point.....
|
|
Posted 1/14/08 3:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: what's your take on this? On an emotional level it seems ridiculously unfair. |
|
Posted 1/14/08 3:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: what's your take on this? if it's so much better to have these artifical limbs and you can run faster with less energy, then why isn't everyone doing it? |
|
Posted 1/14/08 4:00 PM
|
|
|
Re: what's your take on this? Posted by Blu-ize if it's so much better to have these artifical limbs and you can run faster with less energy, then why isn't everyone doing it? I'll tell you why.. because it's not true. They haven't developed the testing necessary to tell if the energy expenditure is more or less. They are using old testing on new technology. These are not bionic Lee Major artifical limbs, they are great technology that allows amputees to function as they did before. Some of them run marathons and sprints and some of them just walk. These limbs can't cure cancer or fly to the moon, they are just better than the old technology. Do you think they would give a rats azz if he wasn't winning medals? i think i get how you feel b/c of your brother but if i understand correctly, your brother does not have a "high-tech" lightweight prosthesis that would enable him to run long distances, like the man referenced to in this article. i am not saying you are wrong AT ALL, i am just saying in this case, i think it's two different things. depending on the style of his prosthesis, this man may not be exhausted at all when he goes home at night - it may, in fact, be conserving his energy, which is what i think the IAAF is arguing. on a side note, how is your brother?
|
|
Posted 1/14/08 4:13 PM
|
|
|
Re: what's your take on this? Info on the Cheetah prosthetics: |
|
Posted 1/14/08 4:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: what's your take on this? Posted by headoverheels Posted by Blu-ize if it's so much better to have these artifical limbs and you can run faster with less energy, then why isn't everyone doing it? I'll tell you why.. because it's not true. They haven't developed the testing necessary to tell if the energy expenditure is more or less. They are using old testing on new technology. These are not bionic Lee Major artifical limbs, they are great technology that allows amputees to function as they did before. Some of them run marathons and sprints and some of them just walk. These limbs can't cure cancer or fly to the moon, they are just better than the old technology. Do you think they would give a rats azz if he wasn't winning medals? i think i get how you feel b/c of your brother but if i understand correctly, your brother does not have a "high-tech" lightweight prosthesis that would enable him to run long distances, like the man referenced to in this article. i am not saying you are wrong AT ALL, i am just saying in this case, i think it's two different things. depending on the style of his prosthesis, this man may not be exhausted at all when he goes home at night - it may, in fact, be conserving his energy, which is what i think the IAAF is arguing. on a side note, how is your brother? if he was an athelete he would be fitted for a leg that would allow him to do everything he did before and insurance would pay for it. It takes a while for people to get used to prosthetics and there is no substitute for having your own leg. Not a doubt in my mind that it's MUCH harder to do anything with a prosthesis. I've had lots of exposure to this and I've seen many amputees over the last 9 months. Without knowing who decided to enforce the ban personally, I can only say that they should have their legs cut off and be forced to function with articial limbs. They will find out how easy it is. My brother is having issues..but that's to be expected. Thanks for asking. |
|
Posted 1/14/08 4:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: what's your take on this? On a purely athletic basis, you cannot compare someone who has full use of their limbs to someone who does not. They are two different 'creatures', so to speak. This is why men and women compete separately. Men and women have different physical mechanics...just like this very special athlete. Message edited 2008-01-14 16:52:45.270000. |
|
Posted 1/14/08 4:51 PM
|
|







