Re: what's your take on this?
Posted 1/14/2008 3:18:31 PM by GoldenRod


Posted by headoverheels

i would agree with this, but the IAAF found that he was able to run just as fast while expending LESS energy than "normal" runners - which gives him an unfair advantage. it would be the same thing as taking a drug that allowed you to utilize less oxygen and run as fast as other competitors - you might not be able to run faster, but you could compete for longer amounts of time without having to reserve your energy.

in this SPECIFIC case, i agree with the ban. i think each case should be reviewed individually.



I agree. If they have done tests, and shown that he expends less energy, then the ban should stand. If the test is inaccurate, or needs to be revisited, that's a valid argument. All Olympic sporting events have rules to keep things fair. If the fake legs give him an advantage, how is that fair to everyone else? I need a bicycle to keep up with most runners, and a car for marathon runners.

Prosthetics that rival or surpass "normal" limbs are a new topic. The IAAF is doing it's best to keep up with changing technology and methods. It's not an easy position to be in, but judging bodies in all sports go through this on a regular basis.

Print Post      Close Window