Re: what's your take on this?
Posted 1/14/2008 3:31:15 PM by Ophelia


Posted by GoldenRod


Posted by Ophelia

even if the limbs...the prosthesis..are in fact "better" than human arms or legs..

there is still the human factor. the fact that there is no neurons sending information to the brain from prosthetic limbs...there is no biological connection to brain or body.

that in and of itself seems to be an EXTREME handicap to overcome.

so this athlete does it. he overcomes it and finds a way to have his total body come together in a way that makes him a contender with other total body (ie able bodied) athletes, and he is rejected b/c he utilizes his prosthesis to the fullest advantage?

that hardly seems fair. at all.



If he had an arm-powered bicycle, and he had the gearing set up so he could travel twice as fast as the fastest person on legs, would that be OK to use? The bicycle isn't a part of him, but it would be a huge mechanical advantage, and would defeat the entire purpose of the Olympics. Mechanical advantage is potentially a big issue, which is why we keep inventing mechanical advantages to help us out.



the difference here is what is powering the device.

in this case, the MAN is powering the artificial limbs foward. there is no additional propulsion source.

If there was, it would be a different story.
Print Post      Close Window