Re: what's your take on this?
Posted 1/14/2008 3:14:29 PM by Ophelia


Posted by headoverheels


Posted by Blu-ize

i've got volumes to stay about this, but there are really only two points.

It takes 15x the energy to walk with a prosthesis..I can't imagine how much more energy it would take to run. I don't know where they got that info about less energy, it's just incorrect.

Not having his legs means he works out differently and trains differently. He tries harder than any other athelete has to. it's really a smack in the face. I've seen the prosthesis and while it is impressive, it take different muscles to use it than a regular leg.

It's crap.



i would agree with this, but the IAAF found that he was able to run just as fast while expending LESS energy than "normal" runners - which gives him an unfair advantage. it would be the same thing as taking a drug that allowed you to utilize less oxygen and run as fast as other competitors - you might not be able to run faster, but you could compete for longer amounts of time without having to reserve your energy.

in this SPECIFIC case, i agree with the ban. i think each case should be reviewed individually.



Lacne Armstrong's chemo left him with the ability to do so. and look how far he went.

regardless of how much "engery" is expended, the legs are not attached to his body.

his brain is not attached to those legs. he doens't feel with those legs.

they are still attached to him, every day.

He still managed to get his velocity up, with feet that look about has graceful as flippers.

I think all told, the energy "benefit" is cancelled out here.

if they legs had a motor attached, I could see it...
Print Post      Close Window