what's your take on this?
Posted 1/14/2008 2:31:33 PM by Ophelia

I think it's ridiculous.

Oscar Pistorius vows to fight Olympics ban
(John Giles/PA)
The ruling today said the "cheetah" blades were technical aids in clear contravention of IAAF rules
Jonathan Clayton
Johannesburg
Oscar Pistorius, the South African double amputee dubbed “the fastest man on no legs”, has vowed to fight a decision barring him from competing at next summer’s Beijing Olympics.

A report commissioned by the International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF), released today, concluded that carbon fibre “cheetah flex-feet” prosthetics used by the 21-year-old athlete gave him a significant advantage over able-bodied runners.

Pistorius, known as “Blade Runner” for his achievements with his state-of-the-art false limbs, was unavailable for comment.

Three days ago, however, after he was informed of the decision, a downcast Pistorius, who won gold and bronze medals at the 2004 Athens Paralympics, denied the sickle-like blades gave him “an unfair advantage” and vowed to challenge the ruling.

Related Links
Pistorius banned from Olympics
Pistorius Olympic hopes hit by report
‘Would I want my legs back? I’d have to sit down and think about it’
Nightmare visions of athletes using all sorts of mechanical aids to improve performances prompted the IAAF to amend its rules last year. The IAAF banned technical devices incorporating “springs, wheels or any other element” giving athletes an advantage over their competitors.

Pistorius, who wanted to realise a lifetime ambition of competing against able-bodied athletes, decided to test the new regulation. Last July, the young South African ran in the 400m B race at the Golden Gala in Rome, finishing second. Two days later he finished last in wet conditions in Sheffield, Britain, and was then disqualified for running out of his lane.

A study, carried out by Professor Peter Bruggeman at the German Sport University in Cologne on behalf of the IAAF, compared Mr Pistorius with five able-bodied athletes of similar ability.

“Pistorius was able to run with his prosthetic blades at the same speed as the able-bodied sprinters with about 25 per cent less energy expenditure,” the report concluded. It said the returned energy from the prosthetic blades was close to three times higher than the ankle joint.

“It is evident that an athlete using the Cheetah prosthetic is able to run at the same speed as able-bodied athletes with lower energy consumption,” the report added.

The findings of the report have been unanimously endorsed by the IAAF’s ruling council which decreed that Mr Pistorius should not be allowed to run in Beijing or in any other meeting sanctioned by the world governing body.

Pistorius, whose legs were amputated below the knee when he was 11 months old because he was born without fibulas, last week condemned the report’s findings as “premature and highly subjective” and pledged to continue fighting to realise his Olympic dream.

An IAAF official said the world governing body had been concerned about the implications of prosthetic aids. “It’s for the future,” he said. “It’s about what might happen in 20 or 30 years.” However, Peet van Zyl, Pistorius’ manager said his charge had competed more against able-bodied athletes than disabled.

Mr Van Zyl said the appeal would be based on advice from experts in the United States who had told them the Bruggeman report “did not take enough variables into consideration”.

The IAAF does not ban all prosthetics and athletes have completed marathons with artificial legs or feet. Its decision last year to tighten the rules upset many disabled athletes.

The latest ruling looks likely to spark a furious debate over what is fair to both sides given technological advances.

“It may sound ludicrous to say it, but a man with no legs could have an advantage over able bodied athletes and what would happen if those same athletes start using similar technical aids - the whole issue is a mine field,” said a South African sports writer sympathetic to both sides.

Pistorius is a hero to many in sports-mad South Africa who have watched his struggle against adversity with admiration.

The double-amputee is a world record-holder for the 100 metres, 200 metres and 400 metres. Last year, he won a silver medal in the 400 metres at the South African able-bodied championships. His personal best of 46.34 sec would have been fast enough to have won gold at every Olympic Games before 1932.

Although a few tenths outside the qualifying standard for this year’s Games in Beijing, he was confident that he could bridge the gap and become the first athlete to make an unprecedented transition from Paralympics to Olympics.

That was before today's ban. Now, not for the first time in his life, he is staring at almost insurmountable odds.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Print Post      Close Window