UPDATED Marriage Ultimatums

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by jerseypanda

But I thought I read more into your post. You said your friend is 35 and wants ANOTHER baby. Does she already have a baby and is he the father? If that is the case I guess my question is why does she need to be married to him to have another baby if they already have one together? I'm sure it's just something she wants like a lot of women.





Wow. I totally missed that. Fantastic point!

But the child could be from a different daddy. Doesn't have to be his. There is definitely more to this story.

Either way, if she already has a child, she is really in no position to be giving out ultimatiums.

Just my two cents.

Posted 2/11/09 4:23 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MichLiz213
Life is Good!

Member since 7/07

7979 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by MrsQ-in2007

Posted by Christine
In some ways it makes sense to me. If you want to move forward in a relationship and your SO doesn't or is not sure, I don't think there's anything wrong with being clear about what you want, in this case marraige. If this is not what her SO wants, then she should know now and move on.

I don't like calling it an ultimatum since that sounds threatening but I can see having a time limit.



I agree that she should make it clear what she would like out of the relationship, but my problem with giving an exact time limit and ultimatum is that it basically forces the guy to make a decision that he may not be ready to make. And if in fact she feels that he has to propose by a certain date, then hopefully he will either be honest and tell her he's not ready so she can decide what to do, or he will propose because he really WANTS to, not because of the ultimatum.

I know someone who did this and the guy did propose, but I always wonder if she ever thinks WHY did he propose. I know quite a few people think she forced him into it and the guy wasn't ready, but they seem to be happy.



I agree. I think there needs to be a mature discussion between two people, not an ultimatum.

Posted 2/11/09 4:26 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by Blu-ize

Ultimatum..no, but clear communication about what I expected in the relationship, yes.



This is how I see it as well.

I would be curious to know how many of the above responses are from people who got married in their 30s. For a woman in her 30s who wants to have a child and has been dating a guy for 2 years, I don't think it's unreasonable to ask if marriage is on the horizon, if that is what she wants. I think some guys need a kick in the pants to take the initiative and she probably knows best if her guy is like that or not.

I think if you are going to have this conversation, however, you have to be prepared for the answer you don't want, and walk away if the guy doesn't want to get married and you don't want to keep dating.

I was 37 when I got married, no ultimatum here, but I was OK with not having a baby if that was what was in the cards for me.

Posted 2/11/09 4:38 PM
 

MrsPorkChop
Twinning!!

Member since 5/05

9941 total posts

Name:
Missy

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

well its sh*t or get off the pot with this guy.

i think if she is willing to lose him, then yes, give him an ultimatum

it may end up being good thing for both of them.

the truth will come out.

Posted 2/11/09 4:40 PM
 

imthecindyofcindyandkevin
Four-nado

Member since 8/07

7972 total posts

Name:
Cindy

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Here's an idea:

Rather than give him an ultimatum, why doesn't SHE propose to HIM?

I mean, it is 2009 after all.

That way she'll have her answer, yes or no, right then and there!!

Posted 2/11/09 4:47 PM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by dpli


I think if you are going to have this conversation, however, you have to be prepared for the answer you don't want, and walk away if the guy doesn't want to get married and you don't want to keep dating.



One of my friends from high school was in this situation. She had been dating a guy for about 5 years and they were living together. She wanted to get married but apparently found out that he was perfectly happy with the way things were. The relationship was not that bad, but my friend wanted to get married. She realized that was not what he wanted and she left. I give her so much credit for that because she was following her heart.

It came down to an adult conversation, not an ultimatum, but she wanted to know if marraige was in the cards for him. When he said no, it was her decision to make. He would have stayed in the relationship.

I can understand why she would want to give an ultimatum, but I think that when women do this they think that by giving a deadline the guy will jump into action. Like the pp said, she needs to be prepared for an answer that she may not be happy with.

Posted 2/11/09 4:48 PM
 

MrsFab
this is bliss.......

Member since 10/08

1234 total posts

Name:
Mb

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

ummm when I didnt get a proposal in what I thought was a reasonable amount of time, I broke up with my then boyfriend and set about to find someone serious

that boyfriend is my dh. it took almost a year for him to convince me to come back to him, but when I did, we got engaged 3 months later.

I didnt officially give an ultimatum- but I guess leaving was it, he knew in order to be with me, we had to be headed to marriage. It worked for us, but he really did come to his own conclusion and realized without me, that he wanted to be with me.

Posted 2/11/09 4:56 PM
 

Teachergal
We made a snowman!

Member since 1/08

3239 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

I had a friend that gave her boyfriend an ultimatum. He proposed and they got married. A year later they were divorced. I do not think ultimatums are a good idea because it is forcing someone's hand when they may not be ready for the next step just yet.

Posted 2/11/09 5:50 PM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

ultimatum has such a negative conotation to it.

I think 2 years in a couple should be talking about their futures...maybe not at 18, but upper 20's and older.

I think a bigger problem is the male/female difference. Women are hit with so many instances that once we are 35, child bearing becomes difficult and dangerous. I don't think men understand the number as much as their bodies will be able to reproduce until the day they die.

Posted 2/11/09 6:48 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

the thought crossed my mind, but we were not together long enough for me to issue an ultimatum. but I definitely let him know my goals and aspirations!

2 yrs is not long enough to issue ultimatums about marriage - JMO

Posted 2/11/09 6:50 PM
 

BabyBoy
is Skylar Elizabeth

Member since 5/05

4189 total posts

Name:
Tom

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

2 yrs is not long enough to issue ultimatums about marriage - JMO



ita

Posted 2/11/09 6:54 PM
 

CkGm
They get so big, so fast :(

Member since 5/05

13848 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Honestly, if they have been together a long time and there is no end in sight, why not? She just has to know that it could end her relationship.

I did the ultimatum(not really I will break up with you but more of I need to know where this is going) and he flipped out and accused me of a million different things. Proved to me the answer I needed to move on...

Posted 2/11/09 7:41 PM
 

CkGm
They get so big, so fast :(

Member since 5/05

13848 total posts

Name:
Christine

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by BabyBoy

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

2 yrs is not long enough to issue ultimatums about marriage - JMO



ita



At age 35, where her fertility is now an issue? TOTALLY disagree.

Posted 2/11/09 7:42 PM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

My brother's ex-gf gave him an ultimatum after 10 years. She is now very happily married to someone else and has 3 kids. My brother is still unmarried, although now in another long term (10 year) relationship with no marriage on the horizon.

Posted 2/11/09 10:15 PM
 

Lizzie217
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/09

611 total posts

Name:
elizabeth

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

I think a woman should let it be known what she wants. If the man wants to marry her he will ask.

I have never been in this situation and think it must be very hard. Im not sure I like calling it an "ultimatium". I mean id they agree they both want this and time passes and it never comes......

then perhaps she will have to decide if she wants to hang around and hope it will happen or find someone who is marriage minded.

Hard situation for sure.

Posted 2/11/09 10:38 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

My best friend IRL just gave her boyfriend of a year an ultimatum. She will be 32 in a little over a month. He is in his early 40s. I know that she wants children. I can understand her and your friends POV, that is the worst part is that she will have broken up with the person, but at least she can move on with her life. With your friend, she already has a child. Is the man in question the father of that child? I understand that she wants another child but her circumstances are different of that than of my friend. In your friends circumstances, I think she needs to look at the total picture.

For me, I never gave DH an ultimatum but I did ask him his thoughts on marriage. At a later date, I also asked him if he could see marrying me at some point in the future. He responded that he knew I was the one on our first date. He then showed me a text message he sent to his friend after our first date saying that I was the one. So with all this, I really think it is ok to want to know where you stand in your relationship and where it is going.

Posted 2/11/09 10:44 PM
 

imagin916
LIF Adult

Member since 6/05

1826 total posts

Name:
Valerie

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

There are plenty of men out there who are dating the same woman for years that they have no intention of ever marrying. If I was a woman in a relationship like that, I would like to know sooner rather than later.

A girl I know was with her bf for 6 years, he kept saying he wasn't ready and all that BS. He broke up with her after 6 years, and a year later married someone else. He later told friends that he always knew he would never marry her.

If it were me, I would have a discussion with the guy and see where he stands on the issue, and in my own mind, I would set an ultimatum. If he did not propose or change his mind about marriage by x date, than I would be gone. I wouldn't warn him, or threaten, but if that day comes and nothing has changed, than goodbye. To me that is not a threat, or in any way pressuring the guy. That would be my own decision to leave if he couldn't give me what I wanted.

Posted 2/11/09 11:14 PM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

I understand about ultimata and how they're bad for all the reasons listed.

However, I think sometimes you have to set a limit for how long you're willing to stay with someone without that level of commitment. It can come as a serious discussion, but sometimes those discussions don't resolve it.

I was dating FH for 4.5 years before we got engaged (we were young). I already had it in my head that if he didn't propose soon that I'd have to rethink it. i don't know if I would have made an ultimatum ..I really might have. But I knew in my mind that the time was coming for him to show he was serious about me and we were getting married or for me to move on (and I was only 21). From our discussions FH knew it too. He said he didn't feel pressure...(I used to gently tease a lot), but he did know that I wasn't going to stick around with the ring on my finger. Now he says he wished he had proposed sooner. It actually made our relationship a lot better because I felt much more secure.


Posted 2/11/09 11:59 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by MrsPorkChop

well its sh*t or get off the pot with this guy.

i think if she is willing to lose him, then yes, give him an ultimatum

it may end up being good thing for both of them.

the truth will come out.



This is what I am saying.

Posted 2/12/09 9:12 AM
 

LuvmyShihTzu
<3 I <3 my DD <3

Member since 8/08

3325 total posts

Name:
Happiest Mommy <3

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

I think that based on the situation, it would be a good idea. For example: if a person is with somebody for like 10 years and they are getting to the age where there will be complications if they wanted to have a child, then I'd say they have the right to say LET'S GO!

I think that 2 years isn't that long and maybe he wants to get married, just not quite yet. It all depends on the situation at hand.

Posted 2/12/09 9:16 AM
 

Kelly9904
Mommy to 2 amazing little boys

Member since 5/05

9306 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by MrsPorkChop

well its sh*t or get off the pot with this guy.

i think if she is willing to lose him, then yes, give him an ultimatum

it may end up being good thing for both of them.

the truth will come out.



This is what I am saying.



Agreed!

She is 35 and if she wants kids she can't wait too long, after 2 years you either know that you want to marry th is person or you know that you dont...if you are still unsure...its not meant to be....

Posted 2/12/09 9:58 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by CkGm

Posted by BabyBoy

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

2 yrs is not long enough to issue ultimatums about marriage - JMO



ita



At age 35, where her fertility is now an issue? TOTALLY disagree.


I disagree as well. Like someone else said sh!t or get off the pot.Chat Icon

Posted 2/12/09 10:05 AM
 

robynfs
12/6/10!!

Member since 9/05

4947 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by Shelly

Posted by Kara

I think she should just end the relationship and move on if she isn't getting what she wants and they want different things out of the near future.



I agree.



Exactly how I feel. If I am not on the same page with someone, it's not their fault, no ultimatum necessary, it's just not the right relationship for either party.

Posted 2/12/09 10:11 AM
 

nferrandi
too excited for words

Member since 10/05

18538 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by Blu-ize

it almost came down to me packing my bags and leaving. He got the hint and proposed 2 months later.

He is a procrastinator and if I left it up to him he would have never done it.

I know my man. We were together 9 years when we got married. He is a self admitted procrastinator. He loves me and wanted to be with me but he needed a push.

We are together a total of 20 years this month and celebrating our 11 year anniversary this month as well.

Ultimatum..no, but clear communication about what I expected in the relationship, yes.



My situation was similar too. And to be honest, maybe I'm in in the minority, but sometimes people need a push. And it shouldn't be "we must be engaged by X date" but more so, "you need to prove to me that you see us married in the future and that is something we both want."

Posted 2/12/09 10:12 AM
 

SoinLove
Making big changes

Member since 5/05

16541 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by MrsPJB2007

If you have to FORCE a man to propose -- then you are setting yourself up for failure and you'll start your marriage with 2 strikes against you.

I'm sorry this type of ultimatum just wreaks of desperation and control to me. (No offense to your friend.) Telling someone they MUST do something OR ELSE is so controlling and manipulative -- why would you want to start your life together like this? I will never understand it.




ITA. I had a friend that did this and she got dumped and as much as I adore my friend, I say good for that guy! You're setting yourself up for a divorce before you even get married if you do something like this IMO.

Posted 2/12/09 10:19 AM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Another spinoff to living together before marriage... PiyoPika566 3/15/06 37 Families Helping Families ™
who did not live with DH before marriage nancygrace 3/14/06 38 Families Helping Families ™
Spinoff to Living With DH Before Marriage... mrswask 3/14/06 62 Families Helping Families ™
for those who lived on your own before marriage... nancygrace 3/14/06 47 Families Helping Families ™
Lost marriage license??? wp 3/12/06 3 Families Helping Families ™
Marriage/Pre-marital Counseling JenniferEver 3/10/06 5 Families Helping Families ™