UPDATED Marriage Ultimatums

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

DoublyBlessed09
LIF Adolescent

Member since 12/08

862 total posts

Name:
KK

UPDATED Marriage Ultimatums

Just curious as to how everyone feels about a woman giving a man an ultimatum/drop-dead date by which he must propose or the relationship is over.

I have a friend that has done this as of this weekend, and I must say I thought it was a bad idea, but wonder what you think? She is nearing 35 and wants another baby and has been with him 2 years - so that is her reasoning.
******

UPDATE: Several of you have asked about her child. She is divorced and had a child in her previous marriage to someone else. She has been divorced about 3 years. Her son is 7.

I will post another update after this weekend and let you know if he met his ultimatum deadline.

Message edited 2009-02-12 15:30:40.437000.

Posted 2/11/09 1:00 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

snowbunny
LIF Infant

Member since 11/08

146 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by DoublyBlessed09

Just curious as to how everyone feels about a woman giving a man an ultimatum/drop-dead date by which he must propose or the relationship is over.

I have a friend that has done this as of this weekend, and I must say I thought it was a bad idea, but wonder what you think? She is nearing 35 and wants another baby and has been with him 2 years - so that is her reasoning.



He should run, not walk, out the door

Posted 2/11/09 1:02 PM
 

Kara
Now Zagat Rated!

Member since 3/07

13217 total posts

Name:
They call me "Tater Salad"

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

I think she should just end the relationship and move on if she isn't getting what she wants and they want different things out of the near future.

Posted 2/11/09 1:06 PM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by DoublyBlessed09

Just curious as to how everyone feels about a woman giving a man an ultimatum/drop-dead date by which he must propose or the relationship is over.

I have a friend that has done this as of this weekend, and I must say I thought it was a bad idea, but wonder what you think? She is nearing 35 and wants another baby and has been with him 2 years - so that is her reasoning.



In some ways it makes sense to me. If you want to move forward in a relationship and your SO doesn't or is not sure, I don't think there's anything wrong with being clear about what you want, in this case marraige. If this is not what her SO wants, then she should know now and move on.

I don't like calling it an ultimatum since that sounds threatening but I can see having a time limit.

Posted 2/11/09 1:07 PM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

If you have to FORCE a man to propose -- then you are setting yourself up for failure and you'll start your marriage with 2 strikes against you.

I'm sorry this type of ultimatum just wreaks of desperation and control to me. (No offense to your friend.) Telling someone they MUST do something OR ELSE is so controlling and manipulative -- why would you want to start your life together like this? I will never understand it.

Posted 2/11/09 1:12 PM
 

LoveyQ
Stalkers, get a life.

Member since 11/07

12820 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by Christine
In some ways it makes sense to me. If you want to move forward in a relationship and your SO doesn't or is not sure, I don't think there's anything wrong with being clear about what you want, in this case marraige. If this is not what her SO wants, then she should know now and move on.

I don't like calling it an ultimatum since that sounds threatening but I can see having a time limit.



I agree that she should make it clear what she would like out of the relationship, but my problem with giving an exact time limit and ultimatum is that it basically forces the guy to make a decision that he may not be ready to make. And if in fact she feels that he has to propose by a certain date, then hopefully he will either be honest and tell her he's not ready so she can decide what to do, or he will propose because he really WANTS to, not because of the ultimatum.

I know someone who did this and the guy did propose, but I always wonder if she ever thinks WHY did he propose. I know quite a few people think she forced him into it and the guy wasn't ready, but they seem to be happy.

Posted 2/11/09 1:15 PM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

I waited 8 years for a proposal. People thought I was stupid but you know what? I 100% KNOW that my husband was ready to marry me and I can enjoy my marriage with OUT a tiny doubt in my mind that it was of his own free will.
ETA: the OUT LOL

Message edited 2009-02-11 13:36:16.847000.

Posted 2/11/09 1:15 PM
 

JenMarie
One day at a time

Member since 11/07

7397 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by MrsPJB2007

If you have to FORCE a man to propose -- then you are setting yourself up for failure and you'll start your marriage with 2 strikes against you.

I'm sorry this type of ultimatum just wreaks of desperation and control to me. (No offense to your friend.) Telling someone they MUST do something OR ELSE is so controlling and manipulative -- why would you want to start your life together like this? I will never understand it.




I completely agree. I have a friend like that too. I don't understand it at all. If a woman has to make a man propose, then 1) they are not ready to be married; 2) she's avoiding the reason why he hasn't proposed yet; 3) I agree with MJ in that it sets the marriage up for failure. I waited 8 years for DH to propose and am just glad he did it when HE was ready for it. I'd rather wait that long than rush him into a marriage he may not be ready for.

Posted 2/11/09 1:18 PM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by MrsQ-in2007

Posted by Christine
In some ways it makes sense to me. If you want to move forward in a relationship and your SO doesn't or is not sure, I don't think there's anything wrong with being clear about what you want, in this case marraige. If this is not what her SO wants, then she should know now and move on.

I don't like calling it an ultimatum since that sounds threatening but I can see having a time limit.



I agree that she should make it clear what she would like out of the relationship, but my problem with giving an exact time limit and ultimatum is that it basically forces the guy to make a decision that he may not be ready to make. And if in fact she feels that he has to propose by a certain date, then hopefully he will either be honest and tell her he's not ready so she can decide what to do, or he will propose because he really WANTS to, not because of the ultimatum.

I know someone who did this and the guy did propose, but I always wonder if she ever thinks WHY did he propose. I know quite a few people think she forced him into it and the guy wasn't ready, but they seem to be happy.



I guess I see it as being honest about what she wants - this woman wants to get married and have kids. She is giving him time to think about it and if he doesn't want the same thing then she knows to move on. If he's not ready to decide, then he may not be the right person for her. I think dating someone for 2 years is a long time when in your mid-30s, especially when the woman wants to have kids.

Posted 2/11/09 1:25 PM
 

OStewarts
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1096 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

I think it depends on their relationship. Maybe this guy needs to be prodded a little bit or he is averse to change??

I am not saying its ideal, but I know a few people who have done this and it all worked at fine in the end.

Posted 2/11/09 1:25 PM
 

JessInCA
live laugh love

Member since 8/06

5082 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

I have mixed feelings on this. On one hand, no one should ever give an ultimatum or force the issue of marriage for so many reasons... on the other hand, no one should have to wait indefinitely for the possibility that the person they're with may or may not want to marry them, when they themselves are ready to commit and are certain that they want marriage in the near future.

I don't think it's a good idea to say "You propose by X date or it's over," but I do think it's reasonable for her to let him know that she'd like to be engaged soon for x, y, and z reasons, and if that's not a vision of the future he shares at all, it's only fair for him to let her know, so she can move on to someone who wants that too.

Posted 2/11/09 1:27 PM
 

anonttcer
BOOOO for fall!

Member since 7/06

10082 total posts

Name:
Meaning a NON ttcer!

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

My theory has always been this:

If I have to give you an Ultimatium to marry me, then I have no desire to be with you.

I want to marry someone who WANTS to be with me- not someone who is FORCED to.

End of story.

Posted 2/11/09 1:31 PM
 

shiv
Twinsanity!!

Member since 5/07

4747 total posts

Name:
Shiv

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

when my DH and I were dating (after 5 years), his lease was up and he wanted to move in with me. I said fine but you only if we'll be engaged in the next year because I'm against co-habiting if there is no move to marriage, he agreed. We both knew we wanted to marry eachother eventually, it was just a matter of it happening sooner than later if we were going to be living together. Now if i haden't said anything, he may or may not have proposed that year but I'm not one to keep my feelings hiden- open and honest communication of what you want in life. It wasn't desperate- we were in a long term relationship, he loved me and wanted to marry me- he wouldn't have asked if he didn't.
He planned and proposed to me on his own about 6 months after we moved in together and we are happy as pie to be married to eachother and we're eachothers best friends.

ETA: we were both young (DH younger than me) in our mid-twenties, so there was no rush I just didn't want to live with someone I wasn't engaged to.

Message edited 2009-02-11 13:46:24.313000.

Posted 2/11/09 1:44 PM
 

HoneyBadger
YourWorstNightmare.

Member since 10/06

15979 total posts

Name:
BahBahBlackJeep

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

I think it's a bad idea.

I could understand talking to your SO to discuss how you feel about wanting to get married and figuring out where he's but to give someone a deadline, that's just not a good idea.

Even if he comes through for her and proposes, it will ALWAYS be in the back of her mind that it was forced.

My other thought is if she needs to make that kind of decision then she really needs to think LONG and HARD about this relationship and where it's headed and what this guys wants out of it.

Posted 2/11/09 1:47 PM
 

Otherme
Square head cutie pants

Member since 3/06

6899 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by anonttcer

I want to marry someone who WANTS to be with me- not someone who is FORCED to.




My thoughts exactly.

I could never imagine being in a marriage where I gave an ultimatum. i'd always be wondering.. does he really love me or did i force him into this?
Ugh, no thanks.

Its fine to want to know if the relationship is going to move forward, and then to discuss it with your SO - thats what a relationship (and especially a marriage) is. No reason to stay in the relationship if the goals aren't the same. But to force someone's hand can only end badly IMO

Posted 2/11/09 2:32 PM
 

RocPin
Life's Beachy <3

Member since 2/08

6765 total posts

Name:
Heather

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by Christine

Posted by DoublyBlessed09

Just curious as to how everyone feels about a woman giving a man an ultimatum/drop-dead date by which he must propose or the relationship is over.

I have a friend that has done this as of this weekend, and I must say I thought it was a bad idea, but wonder what you think? She is nearing 35 and wants another baby and has been with him 2 years - so that is her reasoning.



In some ways it makes sense to me. If you want to move forward in a relationship and your SO doesn't or is not sure, I don't think there's anything wrong with being clear about what you want, in this case marraige. If this is not what her SO wants, then she should know now and move on.

I don't like calling it an ultimatum since that sounds threatening but I can see having a time limit.


ITA!! I think if a woman is even close enough to give an ultimatum than her SO should know where she wants to be in life already. I feel he owes it to her to move forward or let her move on esp at her age.

Posted 2/11/09 2:37 PM
 

Ambersmom
Straight up nasty

Member since 5/05

7740 total posts

Name:
Sharon

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

My friend is in the exact same situation (I wonder if we're talking about the same person LOL). She's 35 and has been dating the guy nearly two years. She wants in the worst way to be engaged, start a family, etc. but she always manages to find these committment phobic tools that ultimately want nothing to do with her.

Well, her birthday just passed and he told her that "good things" were coming this year. The good things was basically that he was going to make up his mind whether or not he was ready to look towards marriage; not that he would propose, but that he would make up his mind if he was ready to think about marriage?? Chat Icon Chat Icon I told her she's basically wasting her time. He's clearly not on the same page with her in terms of their goals and quite honestly I think he's taking this year to "window" shop for something better yet keeping her on the line for sex, etc.

Posted 2/11/09 3:23 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by Kara

I think she should just end the relationship and move on if she isn't getting what she wants and they want different things out of the near future.



exactly!

Posted 2/11/09 3:27 PM
 

Shelly
She's 7!!!

Member since 8/05

14624 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by Kara

I think she should just end the relationship and move on if she isn't getting what she wants and they want different things out of the near future.



I agree.

Posted 2/11/09 3:32 PM
 

itkocak

Member since 7/07

7639 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Message edited 2011-11-23 15:50:19.343000.

Posted 2/11/09 3:46 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

I don't know, I think she's just being honest about her feelings. She wants to be married to him and she wants kids and she's letting him know. She's asking him to really reflect on whether or not he wants to be married to her. If she's 35 and wants kids she doesn't have years and years to figure it out.

I guess I don't see it as a real threat "propose to me or I'm gone". If he doesn't want to marry her, he is in no worse shape after the ultimatum expires and she moves out so the ultimatum is not hurting him.

Posted 2/11/09 3:48 PM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

it almost came down to me packing my bags and leaving. He got the hint and proposed 2 months later.

He is a procrastinator and if I left it up to him he would have never done it.

I know my man. We were together 9 years when we got married. He is a self admitted procrastinator. He loves me and wanted to be with me but he needed a push.

We are together a total of 20 years this month and celebrating our 11 year anniversary this month as well.

Ultimatum..no, but clear communication about what I expected in the relationship, yes.

Posted 2/11/09 4:07 PM
 

RocPin
Life's Beachy <3

Member since 2/08

6765 total posts

Name:
Heather

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by Blu-ize

it almost came down to me packing my bags and leaving. He got the hint and proposed 2 months later.

He is a procrastinator and if I left it up to him he would have never done it.

I know my man. We were together 9 years when we got married. He is a self admitted procrastinator. He loves me and wanted to be with me but he needed a push.

We are together a total of 20 years this month and celebrating our 11 year anniversary this month as well.

Ultimatum..no, but clear communication about what I expected in the relationship, yes.


ITA!! My situation was much like this

Posted 2/11/09 4:09 PM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

I agree with many previous posters who said they are not for giving the ultimatums. I just don't think that someone should be forced into making a decision like that. I would think that more often than not, they guy ends up not proposinig because they don't like to be backed into a corner.

But I thought I read more into your post. You said your friend is 35 and wants ANOTHER baby. Does she already have a baby and is he the father? If that is the case I guess my question is why does she need to be married to him to have another baby if they already have one together? I'm sure it's just something she wants like a lot of women.

If it were me and there was a child involved, I would have to think long and hard before issuing an ultimatum that could possibly break up a family.

Posted 2/11/09 4:12 PM
 

ave1024
I Took The Wrong Road

Member since 12/07

6153 total posts

Name:
That Led To The Wrong Tendencies

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

The OP hasn't given any indication that he isn't into her. Is it his fault that she was 33 when they met? I don't think dating for two years is really THAT long, regardless of age.

I can understand not waiting around forever, but to propose an ultimatium is just foolish.

She should "know" if he is really into her or not and she should know if he will eventually propose or not.

If she is not happy now, she should get out. But if she wants to be with him, marriage is a two-way street. She can't just have it her way.

Do they discuss marriage at all?

Message edited 2009-02-11 16:19:31.117000.

Posted 2/11/09 4:19 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Another spinoff to living together before marriage... PiyoPika566 3/15/06 37 Families Helping Families ™
who did not live with DH before marriage nancygrace 3/14/06 38 Families Helping Families ™
Spinoff to Living With DH Before Marriage... mrswask 3/14/06 62 Families Helping Families ™
for those who lived on your own before marriage... nancygrace 3/14/06 47 Families Helping Families ™
Lost marriage license??? wp 3/12/06 3 Families Helping Families ™
Marriage/Pre-marital Counseling JenniferEver 3/10/06 5 Families Helping Families ™