UPDATED Marriage Ultimatums

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3]

headoverheels
s'il vous plaît

Member since 6/07

42079 total posts

Name:
LB

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

i am so torn on this - only because a friend of mine said that he won't propose to his girlfriend of 3 years unless she gives him an ultimatum Chat Icon

so i guess in some situations it may help the guy realize that his girlfriend is prepared to walk away if he doesn't do something about it... but i would think in most cases the guys is already well aware of the fact that his girlfriend wants to get married, and he is actively choosing to ignore it and not propose.

Posted 2/12/09 10:19 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

watersdeb04
Back to school is here

Member since 12/07

1052 total posts

Name:
Deb

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Message edited 2013-06-02 23:27:32.040000.

Posted 2/12/09 10:24 AM
 

HeatherRose
Life is Good :)

Member since 11/07

6605 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

I think its not a good idea. if he doesn't want to marry you now, and you force him into it, he's not going to want to stay married.

Anyone in the situation should look at the bigger picture and address WHY he deosn't want to get married.

Posted 2/12/09 10:44 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by nferrandi

Posted by Blu-ize

it almost came down to me packing my bags and leaving. He got the hint and proposed 2 months later.

He is a procrastinator and if I left it up to him he would have never done it.

I know my man. We were together 9 years when we got married. He is a self admitted procrastinator. He loves me and wanted to be with me but he needed a push.

We are together a total of 20 years this month and celebrating our 11 year anniversary this month as well.

Ultimatum..no, but clear communication about what I expected in the relationship, yes.



My situation was similar too. And to be honest, maybe I'm in in the minority, but sometimes people need a push. And it shouldn't be "we must be engaged by X date" but more so, "you need to prove to me that you see us married in the future and that is something we both want."



Sometimes it is needed! Chat Icon

Posted 2/12/09 11:40 AM
 

architectnycity
LIF Adult

Member since 1/06

2592 total posts

Name:

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by imagin916

There are plenty of men out there who are dating the same woman for years that they have no intention of ever marrying. If I was a woman in a relationship like that, I would like to know sooner rather than later.

A girl I know was with her bf for 6 years, he kept saying he wasn't ready and all that BS. He broke up with her after 6 years, and a year later married someone else. He later told friends that he always knew he would never marry her.




ITA. This happens a lot. At a certain point both people deserve to know what the other person thinks and where the relationship is going. I think when you're 30, 2 years is long enough to know if you want to marry someone or not. And if she wants to get married and he doesn't she needs to move on.

If they do have a child together, they desperately need to have a conversation. She shouldn't be stuck with someone who doesn't want to be married to her just for the child.

Edited to ad: An engagement doesn't always mean marriage. I know a couple who lived together and got engaged. He wouldn't set a date for a wedding. Five years after the proposal she decided to move on. What a waste of time!!!

Message edited 2009-02-12 13:39:19.240000.

Posted 2/12/09 12:29 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by HeatherRose

I think its not a good idea. if he doesn't want to marry you now, and you force him into it, he's not going to want to stay married.




See, but that's the thing-you're not "forcing" anyone to do anything.

You're just saying "this is what I want, and I need to know by XX date that it's what you want too".

The only thing you might be "forcing" him to do is to think about what he really wants from this relationship.

P.S. This isn't directed at you, I just noted a number of people saying that an ultimatum is forcing someone to marry you.

Posted 2/12/09 1:53 PM
 

DoublyBlessed09
LIF Adolescent

Member since 12/08

862 total posts

Name:
KK

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by jerseypanda

I agree with many previous posters who said they are not for giving the ultimatums. I just don't think that someone should be forced into making a decision like that. I would think that more often than not, they guy ends up not proposinig because they don't like to be backed into a corner.

But I thought I read more into your post. You said your friend is 35 and wants ANOTHER baby. Does she already have a baby and is he the father? If that is the case I guess my question is why does she need to be married to him to have another baby if they already have one together? I'm sure it's just something she wants like a lot of women.

If it were me and there was a child involved, I would have to think long and hard before issuing an ultimatum that could possibly break up a family.



She is divorced and had a child in her previous marriage to someone else. She has been divorced about 3 years. Her son is 7.

Posted 2/12/09 3:22 PM
 

Kidsaplenty
Sister love

Member since 2/06

5971 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by HeatherRose

I think its not a good idea. if he doesn't want to marry you now, and you force him into it, he's not going to want to stay married.




See, but that's the thing-you're not "forcing" anyone to do anything.

You're just saying "this is what I want, and I need to know by XX date that it's what you want too".

The only thing you might be "forcing" him to do is to think about what he really wants from this relationship.

P.S. This isn't directed at you, I just noted a number of people saying that an ultimatum is forcing someone to marry you.



ITA. You can't force the man to marry you. I don't see anything wrong with telling him to sh.t or get off the pot.

Posted 2/12/09 3:27 PM
 

IrishLasss334
I'll be there soon!

Member since 1/08

6549 total posts

Name:
Patty

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

I think there is a difference between delivering an ultimatum and having conversation about where the relationship is going and is there an intention for a long term relationship (aka marriage).

I don't think an ultimatum is a good idea.

Posted 2/12/09 3:28 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

honestly, rather than giving an ultimatum, I'd like to know what his reservations are in the relationship.

WHY isn't he proposing or making a more of a solid showing of where he thinks it's going?

it could be that there are certain things about HER he is NOT that thrilled with holding him back.

and those things could be addressed and perhaps resolved so they can move forward.

sometimes the problem is YOU, and not me....kwim?

Posted 2/12/09 3:31 PM
 

DoublyBlessed09
LIF Adolescent

Member since 12/08

862 total posts

Name:
KK

Re: UPDATED Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by Ophelia

honestly, rather than giving an ultimatum, I'd like to know what his reservations are in the relationship.

WHY isn't he proposing or making a more of a solid showing of where he thinks it's going?

it could be that there are certain things about HER he is NOT that thrilled with holding him back.

and those things could be addressed and perhaps resolved so they can move forward.

sometimes the problem is YOU, and not me....kwim?



From what she tells me, he has some uncertainties about her stepson (thinks he is a handful/has discipline problems etc); also, due to her divorce she had some credit problems which bother him... Yadda yadda. He has some other concerns too - I wish they'd break up if you all want the honest truth. I think she can do better than this guy.

Posted 2/12/09 3:34 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: UPDATED Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by DoublyBlessed09

Posted by Ophelia

honestly, rather than giving an ultimatum, I'd like to know what his reservations are in the relationship.

WHY isn't he proposing or making a more of a solid showing of where he thinks it's going?

it could be that there are certain things about HER he is NOT that thrilled with holding him back.

and those things could be addressed and perhaps resolved so they can move forward.

sometimes the problem is YOU, and not me....kwim?



From what she tells me, he has some uncertainties about her stepson (thinks he is a handful/has discipline problems etc); also, due to her divorce she had some credit problems which bother him... Yadda yadda. He has some other concerns too - I wish they'd break up if you all want the honest truth. I think she can do better than this guy.




what she should do is get her kid and her personal finances together, then worry about finding a husband.

taking on a kid with behavorial problems will make ANY man think twice, no matter how awesome the woman is as a mate.

she really can't expect anyone to be chomping at the bit to sign on for that...whether she deserves better or not is a different story, but she can start attracting better by addressing these issues in her life

Message edited 2009-02-12 15:38:54.050000.

Posted 2/12/09 3:37 PM
 

timanda
Puppy Love

Member since 6/08

1627 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by HeatherRose

I think its not a good idea. if he doesn't want to marry you now, and you force him into it, he's not going to want to stay married.




See, but that's the thing-you're not "forcing" anyone to do anything.

You're just saying "this is what I want, and I need to know by XX date that it's what you want too".

The only thing you might be "forcing" him to do is to think about what he really wants from this relationship.

P.S. This isn't directed at you, I just noted a number of people saying that an ultimatum is forcing someone to marry you.



I agree with this.

The word "ultimatum" sounds bad, but really, we all have a point where we decide that we either need a relationship to move forward or we are moving on. She is just telling him when that point is for her.

Posted 2/12/09 3:40 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: UPDATED Marriage Ultimatums

At 2 years, I issued many ultimatums in my head & the deadlines would pass. I was very vocal about wanting to get married to him. It wasn't that I just wanted to get married. It wasn't an aging factor. I wanted to marry HIM.

Finally, I broke up with him. I told him we wanted different things and if & when he was ready for something more serious to call me. If I wasn't dating anyone & he wasn't dating anyone, maybe we'd give it another try.

Then I went home & bawled like a baby. I am not a crier by any means. but I mean cried like I never cried before - for 1.5 weeks. I couldn't even tell my family or friends. I would tell them that he was working because I didn't want to talk about it. Just when I was ready to pick myself up & move on, he called to get back together.

After 9 years of being married and 2 children later, I still hate that it came to that. During the wedding planning, it bothered me even more. I remember complaining to my friend that not one fairy tale I read as a child ever had a prince that had doubts or "wasn't ready". In my opinion and from my experience, sometimes you have to adjust your fairy tale to a different happy ending.


No it's isn't ideal to issue an ultimatum. If she is, just prepare her that she needs to be ready to go through with it. Even though my relationship worked out and I never issued a verbal ultimatum, I lost a lot of respect for myself by not following through.

Message edited 2009-02-12 16:02:32.083000.

Posted 2/12/09 4:00 PM
 

imagin916
LIF Adult

Member since 6/05

1826 total posts

Name:
Valerie

Re: UPDATED Marriage Ultimatums

Posted by nrthshgrl

At 2 years, I issued many ultimatums in my head & the deadlines would pass. I was very vocal about wanting to get married to him. It wasn't that I just wanted to get married. It wasn't an aging factor. I wanted to marry HIM.

Finally, I broke up with him. I told him we wanted different things and if & when he was ready for something more serious to call me. If I wasn't dating anyone & he wasn't dating anyone, maybe we'd give it another try.

Then I went home & bawled like a baby. I am not a crier by any means. but I mean cried like I never cried before - for 1.5 weeks. I couldn't even tell my family or friends. I would tell them that he was working because I didn't want to talk about it. Just when I was ready to pick myself up & move on, he called to get back together.

After 9 years of being married and 2 children later, I still hate that it came to that. During the wedding planning, it bothered me even more. I remember complaining to my friend that not one fairy tale I read as a child ever had a prince that had doubts or "wasn't ready". In my opinion and from my experience, sometimes you have to adjust your fairy tale to a different happy ending.


No it's isn't ideal to issue an ultimatum. If she is, just prepare her that she needs to be ready to go through with it. Even though my relationship worked out and I never issued a verbal ultimatum, I lost a lot of respect for myself by not following through.



I see your situation as quite the opposite. It seems like you are saying that he was "forced" to marry you.

Instead, I see it as you didn't "force" him to do anything but think about what life would be without you, and when he did, he realized that he didn't want to be without you for the rest of his life.

IMO, the fairy tale here is that he thought about how much he missed you and that he couldn't imagine a future without you. If he was OK with moving on without you, he would have since you were already broken up.

9 years later and still together shows that he knows he made the right decision marrying you, and I'm sure he is hoping for many more to come!

Posted 2/12/09 6:06 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Another spinoff to living together before marriage... PiyoPika566 3/15/06 37 Families Helping Families ™
who did not live with DH before marriage nancygrace 3/14/06 38 Families Helping Families ™
Spinoff to Living With DH Before Marriage... mrswask 3/14/06 62 Families Helping Families ™
for those who lived on your own before marriage... nancygrace 3/14/06 47 Families Helping Families ™
Lost marriage license??? wp 3/12/06 3 Families Helping Families ™
Marriage/Pre-marital Counseling JenniferEver 3/10/06 5 Families Helping Families ™