Unions Picketing
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6 | |
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by nrthshgrl Posted by Bearcat Albeit, a less important union since it's OK to break their contracts and change their benefits that their union fought hard for. That's the inherent irony *I* see in all of the pro-union uniontastic posts on here. Where are these pro union comments when people attack the police union contracts and benefits? Chiming in because I've been posting pro-union posts. I think it's fine to debate benefits in a contract. It's acceptable to debate diminishing those benefits & then the union agrees or disagrees with it. It's not ok to break an existing contract. I still can't believe they were able to do that. Thank you for responding. Right - collective bargaining IS a necessary function of a union. Key word being collective. And bargaining, haha. I can't believe it either. And the litigation that has ensued is only prolonging any kind of resolution. |
|
Posted 6/8/12 10:04 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Unions Picketing I only got half way through this thread so I apologize if I am missing something but I just have to agree with the people who have said that generalizing people into one large category is wrong. Whether they are union or non-union what they did is wrong. If you saw a non-union worker act this way, would this post even be up here? Would you have taken time out of your busy 60 work week to post about how the non-union workers are unprofessional and lazy? It is clear that you don't like unions for whatever reasons you have. |
|
Posted 6/8/12 11:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by SlurpeeDad Posted by nrthshgrl My husband's union. I'm in HR & not union. It's not about winning jobs based on your work. It's about the systematic loss of benefits & protecting worker's rights. While I don't condone creating a safety issue, the workers have every right to assembly & to picket. As for not hiring a union worker, next time you're on off on the weekend, your vacation, have a sick day or have a holiday, be sure to consider without unions, employers would have never offered those benefits. For today's workforce, who see their co-workers laid off, pick up their work for little or no extra money... For my friend whose company just laid off 10% of the workforce with no severance & took a 10% paycut... For every construction worker on a non-union job where the employers cut out equipment & procedures to keep them safe I'm thankful the organizations are still around. Protecting works rights? What rights are those? The right to slack off and have extended breaks and protect the weakest link? I have no doubt that unions, AT ONE TIME, protected and fought for the rights of their workers. Now, they just protect the weak. Ask your husband who the union benefits the most? ------------------------------------------------------ With all due respect Slurpee Dad, I dont think you know what you're talking about. I trust that you saw what you saw with regard to the picketing, but to then state that all unions do is protect their members' right to extended breaks and slacking off proves to me that you do not even have a very basic understanding of labor unions and labor relations. I would also bet my last dollar that you never worked a day on a construction site or in any sort of manual labor whatsoever - because if you had you would know that this kind of work is some of the most grueling, dangerous, back-breaking work any person could do to make a living. I am almost tempted to offer you a days work on one of these sites so you can see for yourself how hard it is do dig a ditch, raise an I-beam or hump, cut and hang 70 panels of sheet rock a day. I am so tempted to offer you a day because then you would see for yourself that employers aren't concerned about their workers' safety, or even the safety of the public walking by the site, and that it's really the unions that are always pushing for more education and safer worksites. And your comment about protecting the weak? Are you serious?? Go spend five minutes talking to some construction workers and you'll know that they're ridden so hard all day long to produce or they're fired at the end of the day or that week. There are no free rides. If you knew what you were talking about, you would know that Unions help raise the standard of living for all workers, not just their own members, since they help drive up wages and benefits for everyone, especially here in NY, and in other highly unionized areas. If you knew what you were talking about, you would know that unions help organize workers who are the most vulnerable and who would otherwise be exploited by unscrupulous employers who steal their wages, dont pay them at all, or dont pay them their overtime pay. If you paid attention, you would know that there are hundreds of thousands of people working today in America that are being subjected to horrific working conditions and that the only private organizations that are interested in helping them are unions. For example, I had a case involving non-union workers in Brooklyn who were exposed to asbestos, day in and day out, by an employer who couldn't care enough to give them a .10 cent dust mask. Who brought their case to light?? A union that was concerned about their safety. I have had unions report instances where workers were beaten, locked in sweatshops and not paid for their work, so if you want to call that protecting the weak, then so be it. To then say that unions are only concerned about protecting their own members is not only factually inaccurate, its offensive. If you knew what you were talking about, you would know that unions dont make teachers less effective. In my view, higher pay and benefits are responsible for the excellent schools we have here, as compared to down south, where teachers aren't generally represented. I think everyone can agree that the schools in New Jersey, for example, are far better than those in Mississippi. New Jersey teachers also happen to be the most organized as far as union density. So, I think you need to examine things a little more closely and pay a little more attention to the world around you before you come on to a site and make such baseless comments. Message edited 2012-06-08 16:05:47.670000. |
|
Posted 6/8/12 4:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by nrthshgrl My husband's union. I'm in HR & not union. It's not about winning jobs based on your work. It's about the systematic loss of benefits & protecting worker's rights. While I don't condone creating a safety issue, the workers have every right to assembly & to picket. As for not hiring a union worker, next time you're on off on the weekend, your vacation, have a sick day or have a holiday, be sure to consider without unions, employers would have never offered those benefits. For today's workforce, who see their co-workers laid off, pick up their work for little or no extra money... For my friend whose company just laid off 10% of the workforce with no severance & took a 10% paycut... For every construction worker on a non-union job where the employers cut out equipment & procedures to keep them safe I'm thankful the organizations are still around. THIS! Signed, A union wife |
|
Posted 6/8/12 4:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by OStewarts ------------------------------------------------------ With all due respect Slurpee Dad, I dont think you know what you're talking about. I trust that you saw what you saw with regard to the picketing, but to then state that all unions do is protect their members' right to extended breaks and slacking off proves to me that you do not even have a very basic understanding of labor unions and labor relations. I would also bet my last dollar that you never worked a day on a construction site or in any sort of manual labor whatsoever - because if you had you would know that this kind of work is some of the most grueling, dangerous, back-breaking work any person could do to make a living. I am almost tempted to offer you a days work on one of these sites so you can see for yourself how hard it is do dig a ditch, raise an I-beam or hump, cut and hang 70 panels of sheet rock a day. I am so tempted to offer you a day because then you would see for yourself that employers aren't concerned about their workers' safety, or even the safety of the public walking by the site, and that it's really the unions that are always pushing for more education and safer worksites. And your comment about protecting the weak? Are you serious?? Go spend five minutes talking to some construction workers and you'll know that they're ridden so hard all day long to produce or they're fired at the end of the day or that week. There are no free rides. If you knew what you were talking about, you would know that Unions help raise the standard of living for all workers, not just their own members, since they help drive up wages and benefits for everyone, especially here in NY, and in other highly unionized areas. If you knew what you were talking about, you would know that unions help organize workers who are the most vulnerable and who would otherwise be exploited by unscrupulous employers who steal their wages, dont pay them at all, or dont pay them their overtime pay. If you paid attention, you would know that there are hundreds of thousands of people working today in America that are being subjected to horrific working conditions and that the only private organizations that are interested in helping them are unions. For example, I had a case involving non-union workers in Brooklyn who were exposed to asbestos, day in and day out, by an employer who couldn't care enough to give them a .10 cent dust mask. Who brought their case to light?? A union that was concerned about their safety. I have had unions report instances where workers were beaten, locked in sweatshops and not paid for their work, so if you want to call that protecting the weak, then so be it. To then say that unions are only concerned about protecting their own members is not only factually inaccurate, its offensive. If you knew what you were talking about, you would know that unions dont make teachers less effective. In my view, higher pay and benefits are responsible for the excellent schools we have here, as compared to down south, where teachers aren't generally represented. I think everyone can agree that the schools in New Jersey, for example, are far better than those in Mississippi. New Jersey teachers also happen to be the most organized as far as union density. So, I think you need to examine things a little more closely and pay a little more attention to the world around you before you come on to a site and make such baseless comments. My initial post was based on what I saw. I forgot that I am not allowed to post the negatives of unions, cops, or teachers. I'm so sorry to have offended you and everyone else on this message board. You people are all right, unions are the best thing since sliced bread. Those big rats are an amazing asset to have too...so pretty to look at. I think it is a great thing you guys do, picketing places and drawing attention to yourselves by blowing whistles, air horns, and use fowl language. I think all that good that you just mentioned tends to get overlooked by the asses that represent you while picketing. To the person that said I have never done manual labor, you are right, I haven't worked in construction. I have done jobs that require physical labor, but none that required me to put an I-Beam in. And to that, I say, good for me. I have said it many times before, I love what I do and no one on here can make me feel bad about it. I don't have to agree with you, and I still believe that one question has been left unanswered. What do unions gain by blasting horns and harassing workers that are trying to do their job? Are you hoping that the next job in that area, that might require your services, hires you because they are afraid of what you might do. Seems like some good bully tactics to me. I guess bullying is bad unless it favors you. |
|
Posted 6/8/12 5:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by SlurpeeDad I think it is a great thing you guys do, picketing places and drawing attention to yourselves by blowing whistles, air horns, and use fowl language. Wait...fowl language? Shame on these unions for exploiting innocent chickens! (I guess you weren't paying attention the day your union teacher covered homophones.) Message edited 2012-06-08 17:58:26.137000. |
|
Posted 6/8/12 5:51 PM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by myboysmyheart Posted by SusiBee Posted by rojerono Posted by MsSissy My husband was a union worker. And he would never act that way. It's a shame a few ruin the image of many. Same. I know that those behaviors are not sanctioned by the Union. There are assholes in every profession - union and non-union. Ditto. My husband IS union, proud of it. There is a solidarity amongst union members that you don't necessarily see amongst non-union workers. Keep in mind that union workers keep you safe - FDNY, NYPD. They pick up your crap - DSNY. They take you to work - MTA, NYCTA. They teach your children. They keep your lights on, keep the phone lines running, and so on. If the noise bothers you, get earplugs. And sorry to say but in other states, all of these jobs are done just as well without being union. The issue is the destruction of the middle class. Loss of benefits, loss of pensions, loss of job security. Why shouldn't unions fight to protect their workers? If you were faced with losing a pensions you had worked the past 20 ears for, wouldn't you fight? If you were faced with having to now pay thousands for sub-par insurance, wouldn't you fight? All this when CEO are getting HUGE bonuses. Why shouldn't worker fight to protect their way of life. It's not like unions members are multi-millionaires. We are mostly taking about blue collar workers struggling to make it with what they have now. |
|
Posted 6/8/12 6:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by faithann Posted by SlurpeeDad I think it is a great thing you guys do, picketing places and drawing attention to yourselves by blowing whistles, air horns, and use fowl language. Wait...fowl language? Shame on these unions for exploiting innocent chickens! (I guess you weren't paying attention the day your union teacher covered homophones.)
|
|
Posted 6/8/12 6:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by faithann Posted by SlurpeeDad I think it is a great thing you guys do, picketing places and drawing attention to yourselves by blowing whistles, air horns, and use fowl language. Wait...fowl language? Shame on these unions for exploiting innocent chickens! (I guess you weren't paying attention the day your union teacher covered homophones.) I forgot that every typo gets picked up here. Maybe my union teacher packed it in years prior, and just half assed her way through the latter part of her career. I'm sure she would say it was my fault and not hers though. That's how it works, right? If I had not made a mistake, all credit goes to my union teacher. Since I made a mistake, I must not have been paying attention. |
|
Posted 6/8/12 6:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing I will preface this by saying I'm a teacher, so obviously I am pro-union. I believe in the right to picket. |
|
Posted 6/8/12 7:25 PM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by SlurpeeDad Posted by Kerie-is-so-very The old days of us "needing unions" were really not so long ago. If we suddenly ban unions, many workplaces would go back to the cheapest methods possible, which are often methods that have no concern for safetly or health. If not for unions, all of our employers could lock us in at our workplaces. To expect unions to change laws and then go awy is ridiculous. Union work is more expensive for many reasons, one of which is the cost of safety. The unions do sometimes protect the weakest link but they also protect the best workers. False...one of the ways to "protect the best workers" is to get rid of the weakest link and not protect them. If someone is not cut out for their job, you remove them and not protect them because they pay union dues. Protecting the weak, weakens the strong. It is not always the case that the union is protecting the weakest link. I'm union and we have a system in place that would enable management to fire the weakest link. The problem is that management doesn't have the guts to fire anybody! There are at least two people that have personnel files 2 inches thick of discipline that still work for my agency. The reason they are still employed is NOT because of the union, it's because the big boss is a weanie who is TERRIFIED of firing anyone for performance issues. |
|
Posted 6/8/12 7:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by Teachergal I will preface this by saying I'm a teacher, so obviously I am pro-union. I believe in the right to picket. However, some questions are going unanswered here: 1. Why *should* the picket workers be allowed to use bully tactics while picketing simply because they are in a union? 2. What are the people who *need* jobs to support their family supposed to do when they can't get into a union because there is no room? I am asking honestly if anyone knows or has any answers. these are some of the same questions i ask 2 pages ago but I think is more important to argue with someone that have a different POV than to answer real question about people who are trying to understand things better. |
|
Posted 6/8/12 9:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by Honey2223 First of all , union corruption is down to a minimum. Snce the mafia has buried itself , most unions are regulated with a federal monitor, paid for by the union itself and not your taxes. Secondly, a union, is based on American morals and definitely protects workers rights and safety. Ask the non union workers that are be "harassed" ,what type of medical insurance they have?, or who is the company that does their certified payroll. I will bet my hefty union check , that this scabs are working for CASH, and not paying any taxes whatsoever. Now that's AMERICAN! Scabs are mostly paid a unreasonable wage ,creating an undesirable living arrangement for them, and their families. I'll leave that alone because that is whole other debate in itself. Do some real research , besides looking across the street, and I'm sure you will find that it's the union workers that Pave your roads, keep clean water running to your faucets,building your skyscrapers,educating your children, cleaning your parks, delivering petroleum to your local gas station, and even manufacturing the F-16's that protect your Freedom. A freedom that you use to bash the UNIONS THAT BUILT AMERICA.
|
|
Posted 6/8/12 9:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by Teachergal I will preface this by saying I'm a teacher, so obviously I am pro-union. I believe in the right to picket. However, some questions are going unanswered here: 1. Why *should* the picket workers be allowed to use bully tactics while picketing simply because they are in a union? 2. What are the people who *need* jobs to support their family supposed to do when they can't get into a union because there is no room? I am asking honestly if anyone knows or has any answers. 1. Why *should* the picket workers be allowed to use bully tactics while picketing simply because they are in a union? They are not allowed to use intimidation or bullying tactics. If you witness this or any other questionable behavior call the police and have them handle it. 2. What are the people who *need* jobs to support their family supposed to do when they can't get into a union because there is no room? I have never heard of there being "no room" in a union. As far as I know they are always looking for new members. Maybe some one else has a better answer to this question. |
|
Posted 6/8/12 9:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing The idea that people should not take non union jobs even if they need to support their family is that they are standing in solidarity as one strong group to stand up to management (when they have infringed on workers' rights), who often is more powerful than one lone worker. So the whole group if workers can support their families. All for one, one for all isn't a radical idea. |
|
Posted 6/8/12 11:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by Erica Since slurpee has voiced his own perceptions, may I add my own? I'm sure this is wrong, but I just can't get out if my head that you have like a 90 handicap. I know you say you are good at your job, so I'm sure I'm in wrong, but your usual negativity gives me that perception. Perceptions aren't always correct. You just remind me of the crabby old men on the golf course. Stand strong my sisters and brothers! You are right, I do have 'like a 90 handicap.' I go out and play and shoot 160 every time I play. That may be the best one I heard all day! Hahahahahaha. |
|
Posted 6/9/12 5:16 AM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by KCCL 1. Why *should* the picket workers be allowed to use bully tactics while picketing simply because they are in a union? They are not allowed to use intimidation or bullying tactics. If you witness this or any other questionable behavior call the police and have them handle it. 2. What are the people who *need* jobs to support their family supposed to do when they can't get into a union because there is no room? I have never heard of there being "no room" in a union. As far as I know they are always looking for new members. Maybe some one else has a better answer to this question. I agree with these answers. I also haven't heard that there is no room. There are times where there are wait lists to get into a union & you do have to pass a test to qualify. Unions exist for collective bargaining. I haven't heard of a union protesting the lack of a yacht or European vacation yet. It's for pensions, health benefits, livable wages, safety issues. I've searched for what union is protesting the Wyndham & what they're protesting for but haven't find out any info. If anyone knows, I'd appreciate finding out more info. Message edited 2012-06-09 07:31:30.490000. |
|
Posted 6/9/12 7:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by SlurpeeDad You are right, I do have 'like a 90 handicap.' I go out and play and shoot 160 every time I play. That may be the best one I heard all day! Hahahahahaha. This answer is why I have that perception of you - but maybe I'll change crabby to obnoxious. |
|
Posted 6/9/12 8:10 AM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing My husband was offered a non-union job as an electrician. |
|
Posted 6/9/12 9:26 AM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by rojerono My husband was offered a non-union job as an electrician. The pay was ridiculously low for the expertise, training and skill set required. He would have needed to provide all of his own safety equipment.. or just forego it. At least 2 of the guys he would be supervising had ZERO training as electricians, no safety training and no certifications of any kind. This is why I support unions in construction!!!! I can't speak of any others because I am just not familiar with them. Unions in construction have high safety standards. They protect the well being of their members. They make sure all the members are trained in what they do. I said it before and I will always stand behind this....NON-UNION CONSTRUCTION IS SCARY!!!!! I have worked with them so I have first hand knowledge. They do not have safety plans in place and many of the employees are not trained. I could do a better job than many of the non union contractors I have worked with. Why sacrifice safety just to save a few bucks!!! |
|
Posted 6/9/12 9:48 AM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by SlurpeeDad After watching this for two days, I could never imagine hiring a union worker to do anything. Win jobs with your work, not by bullying people into hiring you. Enough is enough. SlurpeeDad, no one is saying that the behavior you described is acceptable. While I can only speak for myself, what probably p*sses most of the people on this thread off is that you are generalizing. If you are going to paint all union workers with the same brush, people are going to take issue with that. But you know what? If you want to generalize, I can too. So here goes: I've had two careers - private sector, non union (managed an analytical department at a direct mail company) and public (NYC teacher, where I am now.) I can tell you with 100% certainty that my private sector, non union job was much, much safer than this one. Accountability the teaching field is HUGE and everyone is on their toes all the time. My principal would not tolerate incompetency for any real length of time because it is on HIS asss if test scores or quality review show any problems within the school. I am not just talking about my view since I'm, admittedly, untenured. My long tenured coworker, with 18 years in the system, is at work, right now, on a Saturday, in the classroom next to me because of a phrase HE has coined - everything is "voluntary mandatory." If the principal wants you to do something, you do it. This works fine if your principal is a reasonable human being. (I'm going to stop right there because I don't want to get into whether mine is or isn't.) BTW, if you have tenure, they CAN STILL FIRE YOU. Yes, it takes longer. But it can happen and has happened because I've seen it with my own eyes. My old job, however - a private, non union company - was a notorious safehouse for dead wood. My husband (who still works there and is part of the live wood -lol) and I have had many conversations about who is just taking up space and who produces. Management does not wish to be bothered going through firing, hiring, and training because there is always a learning curve and it means that they might actually have to pick up some slack until the new person is up to speed. Now, does every private sector job protect the weak like my old job? Of course not. Is every union as defenseless against the power of a principal to give a bad review? Of course not. Now, if I were to generalize like you did, see what type of conclusions I would come up with? |
|
Posted 6/9/12 9:56 AM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by SlurpeeDad I forgot that every typo gets picked up here. Maybe my union teacher packed it in years prior, and just half assed her way through the latter part of her career. I'm sure she would say it was my fault and not hers though. That's how it works, right? If I had not made a mistake, all credit goes to my union teacher. Since I made a mistake, I must not have been paying attention. You are arrogant, close-minded and incredibly obnoxious. Shame on every one of your teachers K- university, union or not. |
|
Posted 6/9/12 10:08 AM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by DiamondGirl Posted by SlurpeeDad I forgot that every typo gets picked up here. Maybe my union teacher packed it in years prior, and just half assed her way through the latter part of her career. I'm sure she would say it was my fault and not hers though. That's how it works, right? If I had not made a mistake, all credit goes to my union teacher. Since I made a mistake, I must not have been paying attention. You are arrogant, close-minded and incredibly obnoxious. Shame on every one of your teachers K- university, union or not. That is bull shit and you know it. My responses have been right in line with every other "arrogant, close-minded and incredibly obnoxious" person on here. You are fantastic. |
|
Posted 6/9/12 12:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing JennP...maybe I am generalizing, but that is now my perception of what is going on. First impressions last a long time. |
|
Posted 6/9/12 12:46 PM
|
|
|
Re: Unions Picketing Posted by Erica Posted by SlurpeeDad You are right, I do have 'like a 90 handicap.' I go out and play and shoot 160 every time I play. That may be the best one I heard all day! Hahahahahaha. This answer is why I have that perception of you - but maybe I'll change crabby to obnoxious. What should my response have been? If I told you the truth you would call me full of myself. It was a no win situation. I guess I could have ignored it, but I don't usually ignore things well. |
|
Posted 6/9/12 12:50 PM
|
|
| Pages: << 2 3 4 [5] 6 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Local 3 people or anyone that knows about unions.. | NS1976 | 4/12/11 | 4 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| wisconsin, unions, hitler... please connect the dots for me | MarathonKnitter | 3/10/11 | 65 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| I have what I think is a fairly general question about unions and contract negotiations. | Ophelia | 2/25/11 | 9 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Spinoff to Broadway Shows - How do you feel about unions? | SweetestOfPeas | 11/20/07 | 24 | Families Helping Families ™ |















