|
Re: Unions Picketing
Posted 6/9/2012 9:56:40 AM by JennP
SlurpeeDad, no one is saying that the behavior you described is acceptable. While I can only speak for myself, what probably p*sses most of the people on this thread off is that you are generalizing. If you are going to paint all union workers with the same brush, people are going to take issue with that. But you know what? If you want to generalize, I can too. So here goes: I've had two careers - private sector, non union (managed an analytical department at a direct mail company) and public (NYC teacher, where I am now.) I can tell you with 100% certainty that my private sector, non union job was much, much safer than this one. Accountability the teaching field is HUGE and everyone is on their toes all the time. My principal would not tolerate incompetency for any real length of time because it is on HIS asss if test scores or quality review show any problems within the school. I am not just talking about my view since I'm, admittedly, untenured. My long tenured coworker, with 18 years in the system, is at work, right now, on a Saturday, in the classroom next to me because of a phrase HE has coined - everything is "voluntary mandatory." If the principal wants you to do something, you do it. This works fine if your principal is a reasonable human being. (I'm going to stop right there because I don't want to get into whether mine is or isn't.) BTW, if you have tenure, they CAN STILL FIRE YOU. Yes, it takes longer. But it can happen and has happened because I've seen it with my own eyes. My old job, however - a private, non union company - was a notorious safehouse for dead wood. My husband (who still works there and is part of the live wood -lol) and I have had many conversations about who is just taking up space and who produces. Management does not wish to be bothered going through firing, hiring, and training because there is always a learning curve and it means that they might actually have to pick up some slack until the new person is up to speed. Now, does every private sector job protect the weak like my old job? Of course not. Is every union as defenseless against the power of a principal to give a bad review? Of course not. Now, if I were to generalize like you did, see what type of conclusions I would come up with? |