Torn in 2

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3]

neenie

Member since 5/05

22351 total posts

Name:

Re: Torn in 2

Posted by BabyAvocado

Posted by greeneyes361708

You all do know that Dr. Ferber says you need to go back and check on them, right? From some of the posts it seems a few people are walking out and letting their dc cry for hours.



First of all, NO ONE said they were letting their child cry for hours on end. There is a HUGE difference between CIO and neglect, which is what you are implying.

Second, who the hell are you to judge how someone chooses to parent? Just because YOU are 100% against CIO, and you have ONE Harvard study in support of not allowing CIO, doesn't mean you get to judge everyone else who chooses to use this method. There is plenty of real life proof that it does work and does not cause psychological problems. Besides, I am sure that you make parenting choices that I do not agree with - I would never presume to know that what you are doing is wrong and tell you so because I read some study.

Third, yes children need their parents - they also need their SLEEP! They need it for brain development, as well as psychological and emotional well-being. And teaching them to fall asleep on their own is one of the best things you can do for your child.

Anyway, needless to say, I am a fan of CIO. However, I have never felt the need to judge a parent who decides NOT to use CIO nor do I think they are "wrong" for not doing it. I don't push MY parenting principles on anyone else and neither do most of the mothers and fathers on this board.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/12/07 3:31 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LIMOMx2
...

Member since 5/05

24989 total posts

Name:

Re: Torn in 2

Posted by greeneyes361708

We are 100% against CIO. Young children need their parents. Making them cry themselves to sleep teaches them that you're only there when you want to be IMO. When they're little they don't know why you're not there, KWIM?



If you are so against why would you post this in another thread?Chat Icon Chat Icon

You shouldn't do CIO until they are at least 6 months.

Posted 1/12/07 3:43 PM
 

Little-J-Mommy
I'm a Big Brother

Member since 5/06

8041 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Torn in 2

When I started a thread about trying to get Jack to sleep in his crib, Greeneyes responded with:

"My son is only 2 days older than yours and there is no way he would be ready to sleep through the night without soothing or fall asleep without soothing. I think he is way too young to make him CIO"

I would NEVER attempt to try CIO at this age (3.5 mos) without some form of going in and soothing him. I didn't feel supported or encouraged by your words but rather they seemed sort of accusatory even though they didn't seem as harsh as your comments here. I let the comment go without taking offense.

So, why were you so mean on this thread to another frustrated mom who was just looking for some help and support?

Posted 1/12/07 4:03 PM
 

lipglossjunky73
My Everything!

Member since 11/05

35670 total posts

Name:
<3

Re: Torn in 2

I am still pregnant, but I am a firm believer in teaching babies how to self soothe and put themselves to sleep.... I will try the CIO method - I feel it is a fine method...

As someone who is bombarded with research articles on a daily basis, I would NEVER take any one study at face value and base what I do when it comes to living my life in any way....

not for nothing, greeneyes, but you have sent out horrific FMs to people about the traumas of circumsicion to women on the pregnancy board with disgusting bloody clips of infants being circumsized... discussing the trauma of circumcision....

You are very conecrned about not traumatizing your kids, which is commendable, but spreading the message that way and cutting people down on forums for expressing their opinions - especially in response to a study - is just unwarranted and not nice....No one here is out to traumatize their kids - and like one mom said - if Harvard wants to help her out, thats fine - but I have never heard of a mentally deranged person blaming his parents for letting him cry too long in his crib at night....

Posted 1/12/07 4:11 PM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Torn in 2

Posted by lipglossjunky73

not for nothing, greeneyes, but you have sent out horrific FMs to people about the traumas of circumsicion to women on the pregnancy board with disgusting bloody clips of infants being circumsized... discussing the trauma of circumcision....




thank you!!!
I completely forgot who sent me that FM....(my DH may be suffering PTSD as a result, after I showed him the first clip for a few seconds Chat Icon )...but now it all makes sense!

Different people use different parenting methods!
My mother was just telling me the other day that when we were younger, she used to put us in a baby carriage all bundled up and leave us outside to nap while she was inside cleaning...nothing ever happened to us and that sounds a lot worse than CIO!!!!

Posted 1/12/07 4:21 PM
 

05mommy09
Family of 5!

Member since 5/05

15364 total posts

Name:
<3 Mommy <3

Re: Torn in 2

Weird coincidence or not-

But the parenting style greeneyes' is trying to force upon everyone is attachment parenting (if you have figured it out yet)-

My mother didnt learn about attachment parenting until after I was born- therefore, out of the 3 of us, I was the only one who wasnt BF, wh didnt co-sleep, who did CIO... and you wanna know what.. out of the 3 of us, Im the only one w/o a drug/alcohol and emotional problems....

SO apparently her little study was nothing but backwards for my family!

Im all for BF and we still co-sleep, but on occasion I allow DS to CIO- it all works in perfect harmony for us...

TO EACH HIS OWN- something some posters need to learn to live by!

Posted 1/12/07 4:27 PM
 

SAMMIYY
LIF Infant

Member since 1/07

78 total posts

Name:
SAMANTHA

Re: Torn in 2

I didn't mean to start a verbal war. i think what it boils down to is that with every study there is another study to contradict it. Everyone has their own style of parenting and what works for one person may not work for someone else. These chats are not meant for arguments but for us parents to exchange different ideas and situations that we are going through. With any luck someone else has gone throughg it and can give us advice or just let us know that they were there once too. So, lets stop this arguing and just agree to disagree. I truly thank you all for your advice it was very helpful - I was able to take alittle bit of everyones methods and with any luck Livi will learn to self soothe. Thank you Chat Icon

Posted 1/12/07 4:42 PM
 

CookiePuss
Cake from Outer Space!

Member since 5/05

14021 total posts

Name:

Re: Torn in 2

If I remember correctly and correct me if I'm wrong but the NYT just reported about a month or so ago on a study that compared the various popular sleep methods in helping your baby develop good sleeping habits. What was found that it wasn't the method but the consistency that had an effect. So what works for one baby doesn't work for all but the parent should be consistent.

There are so many ways to parent and a lot of them are good, healthy ways. It isn't the place of any one of us to judge another.

Posted 1/12/07 4:45 PM
 

june262004
But I love the Snow!

Member since 5/05

15379 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: Torn in 2

Posted by greeneyes361708

Posted by ckdk


greeneyes, why are you the end all be all in how someone chooses to parent their child? Plenty of people have success with CIO and just b/c YOU choose not to do it does not mean that you should berate someone else who does.
I have let my child cry for a long time on certain nights and it happens to work, I honestly don't think she will be psychologically damaged for the rest of her life b/c of it.
So get off your soap box about CIO.



I'm not. I just think when there is proof that it does damage then perhaps you should listen? Doesn't matter to me what you do with your kids I certainly won't have to deal with their panic disorders and post traumatic stresss disorder Chat Icon




Chat Icon

Im sure my parents let me "cio" but I was an infant and I can't remember if I cried or not. I don't have panic disorder or post traumatic stress disorder. I also wasn't attached at my parents hip and didn't cry just to get attention Chat Icon

Posted 1/12/07 5:07 PM
 

ana6178
Praying for a miracle!

Member since 5/05

1536 total posts

Name:

Re: Torn in 2

Big fan of CIO!

ETA: I read Heathly Sleep Habits Healthy Child- by Dr. Marc Weissbluth and ever since I read it- we have nothing but GREAT nights. My DD wakes up in the best mood.

That book was great!



Message edited 2007-01-12 17:31:28.257000.

Posted 1/12/07 5:28 PM
 

annie
This is how I play basketball!

Member since 6/05

1980 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Torn in 2

Posted by Maathy317

I know I am going to get flamed for this and stomped on with all kinds of feet, but, I have read a number of posts regarding CIO and I have to say I don't understand why it gets to this point. Children are not born knowing what to do, they learn what they live. I don't understand why parents don't start their lives by making it easier for them. Why not just put them in their crib and in their room from the very beginning? Unless a child has medical complications, I don't understand why it is necessary to keep transitioning them from one sleep setting to another. Why is it necessary to put them in a bassinett in the parents' bedroom or in a co-sleeper or in the parents' bed when it is so much easier for them to get used to one thing and to stay that way? I know it's easier on the parents when it's feeding time in the middle of the night to have them that close, but, how does it make it easier for the child to have to keep relearning new ways to sleep? I know that some feel it's important for them to bond this way, but, in all honesty, how much bonding is being done when you are asleep, or trying to? It seems that both parents and children appear to be exhausted from this when there is no need to be.

Both my girls went in their cribs and their rooms from the very beginning. They slept throught the night by the time they were one month old. I didn't have baby monitors or video monitors (which I think are a great idea) and managed to hear every sound. They got the rest they needed and so did we and they never had to learn a different way. I'm not saying they didn't wake up occasionally or that their sleep patterns didn't change, but, they were still never brought into our room to sleep through the night. If I needed to, I went in there, got them back to sleep and left. When they got older and needed to be comforted by coming into our room and being with us, that was fine, but, they never stayed long, only until they calmed down and left when they decided to.
They never needed to sleep with a light on or their door open for comfort.
They are both adults now and my oldest daughter has done the same with her son and has never had any problems.

I know all children are different and not all situtations are the same. Some children have medical problems and some people may live in small apartments and not have the accommodations for an extra bedroom. It just seems to me from all the posts regarding this issue that this is one problem for the general population on this board that does not need to exist. I guess I am just old-fashioned and out-of-touch because I just don't see the benefit to putting children through this. If this is what you choose for your child, then I guess there must be some benefit to it. I just don't understand it.


Before my daughter was born, I was of the exact same opinion. However, after weeks of colic & no sleep, I quickly changed my motto to "whatever works!" and my DD started sleeping in the swing. She would sleep 12 hours straight at night in the swing but couldn't lay for 1 full minute in the crib. We tried everything to get her to sleep in the crib, but when it didn't work, we stuck with the swing for four months. By that time, we decided it was time to get her into the crib. Again, we tried everything. CIO did not work for us. DD would cry for hours. We'd go in & check, rock her, the works. Did not work at all. She simply was not ready for the crib. At 5 1/2 months, she is getting much better. She sleeps in the crib every night (I rock her to sleep) but wakes up several times.

I envy you. I wish DD was a great sleeper like your kids. But please understand that simply putting a baby to sleep from day 1 in the crib failed miserably for us, as it has for some others. Some babies just have a real hard time sleeping in a big crib without any movement.

To the original poster, good luck! I know how frustrating it is. Around 5 or 6 months, you may want to try a check & console technique for a few nights & see how it goes.

Message edited 2007-01-12 17:45:14.873000.

Posted 1/12/07 5:43 PM
 

monkeybride
My Everything

Member since 5/05

20541 total posts

Name:

Re: Torn in 2

Posted by Shelly

Usually we let her cry for 10 minutes. 90% of the time she is asleep by the end of it. If not, we usually take her out.




This is basically what we do but more like 5 minutes.

DD just doesn't like to go to sleep, period! She would skip naps and stay up until all hours of the night if we let her. What kind of parents would we be if we did that? I would be fine to let her sleep in bed with us if she would actually sleep but she doesn't, she thinks it play time.

While I am not a fan of CIO in extremes we have to let DD fuss in her crib for a few minutes without going to her because it's the only way she'll go to sleep. We've also learned her I'm tired and I'm going to go to sleep cry and the I am not tired enough to go to sleep get me out of here cry and when she cries like that for even 30 seconds we take her out, let her play about 10-15 minutes more and she then goes down without a fuss.

Greeneyes-I understand that you practice Attachment Parenting, and I think that's great. I try to follow a lot of the core ideal of AP myself (although I don't do it perfectly) but this is no an AP website and you cannot push your belief on other parents who choose to parent their children differently than you. Also being so judgemental and harsh is not going to open anyone's minds to the ideas of AP instead they're going to think you're a wacko with some far fetched parenting ideals.

Why not be gentle in your approach? Isn't that what AP teaches? You can't force people to do what you do and generally if people feel attacked they're going to fight back, not respond positively to anything you have to say.

Posted 1/12/07 6:41 PM
 

dandr10199
Grace is growing up too fast!

Member since 10/05

11561 total posts

Name:
Dina

Re: Torn in 2

Posted by monkeybride

Also being so judgemental and harsh is not going to open anyone's minds to the ideas of AP instead they're going to think you're a wacko with some far fetched parenting ideals.

Why not be gentle in your approach? Isn't that what AP teaches? You can't force people to do what you do and generally if people feel attacked they're going to fight back, not respond positively to anything you have to say.




WELL SAID! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 1/12/07 6:43 PM
 

beachgirl13
Mommy to 3 boys!

Member since 5/05

4114 total posts

Name:

Re: Torn in 2

I personally think it's much better to install good sleep habits on a child early on. Sleeping is a comfort, and if a child can't learn how to sleep well from early on, I think THAT is depriving them. So I'm all for CIO. That being said, I totally understand moms who don't let their kids CIO. But for someone to say that it causes psychological damage is ridiculous. It teaches children to go to bed on their own, that's it! (IMO Chat Icon )

Posted 1/12/07 6:49 PM
 

JavaJunkie
Someday, Somehow

Member since 6/05

5857 total posts

Name:
Lois

Re: Torn in 2

Posted by dandr10199

Posted by monkeybride

Also being so judgemental and harsh is not going to open anyone's minds to the ideas of AP instead they're going to think you're a wacko with some far fetched parenting ideals.

Why not be gentle in your approach? Isn't that what AP teaches? You can't force people to do what you do and generally if people feel attacked they're going to fight back, not respond positively to anything you have to say.




WELL SAID! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



Very well said!!

Posted 1/12/07 8:34 PM
 

anon
where's winter?

Member since 11/05

2209 total posts

Name:

xxxxxxx

Message edited 2007-02-09 21:30:02.617000.

Posted 1/12/07 8:41 PM
 

emilain
UNREAL!!!!!!!!

Member since 5/05

4457 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: Torn in 2

I say...do what is right for you, if you want your child to co-cleep well then co-sleep, if you want them to use the doddie (pacifier) , let them use it, if they want the bottle after 12 months- give it to them, DO WHAT IS RIGHT FOR YOU!!!!!
But... I have to say, my son who we made CIO at 6 months is a great sleeper VS. my 7 year old who was my 1st and I would NEVER imagine letting her CIO still wakes up during the nightChat Icon there is your evidence. But all in all, do what feels right for you, as long as it isn't harming the child (and NO WAY does CIO harm a child emotionally, long term memory does not go back that far) go with your motherly instinct and you can;t go wrongChat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Message edited 2007-01-12 20:57:55.783000.

Posted 1/12/07 8:57 PM
 

Maathy317
Grammie's Little Man

Member since 2/06

3235 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Torn in 2

Posted by annie

Posted by Maathy317

I know I am going to get flamed for this and stomped on with all kinds of feet, but, I have read a number of posts regarding CIO and I have to say I don't understand why it gets to this point. Children are not born knowing what to do, they learn what they live. I don't understand why parents don't start their lives by making it easier for them. Why not just put them in their crib and in their room from the very beginning? Unless a child has medical complications, I don't understand why it is necessary to keep transitioning them from one sleep setting to another. Why is it necessary to put them in a bassinett in the parents' bedroom or in a co-sleeper or in the parents' bed when it is so much easier for them to get used to one thing and to stay that way? I know it's easier on the parents when it's feeding time in the middle of the night to have them that close, but, how does it make it easier for the child to have to keep relearning new ways to sleep? I know that some feel it's important for them to bond this way, but, in all honesty, how much bonding is being done when you are asleep, or trying to? It seems that both parents and children appear to be exhausted from this when there is no need to be.

Both my girls went in their cribs and their rooms from the very beginning. They slept throught the night by the time they were one month old. I didn't have baby monitors or video monitors (which I think are a great idea) and managed to hear every sound. They got the rest they needed and so did we and they never had to learn a different way. I'm not saying they didn't wake up occasionally or that their sleep patterns didn't change, but, they were still never brought into our room to sleep through the night. If I needed to, I went in there, got them back to sleep and left. When they got older and needed to be comforted by coming into our room and being with us, that was fine, but, they never stayed long, only until they calmed down and left when they decided to.
They never needed to sleep with a light on or their door open for comfort.
They are both adults now and my oldest daughter has done the same with her son and has never had any problems.

I know all children are different and not all situtations are the same. Some children have medical problems and some people may live in small apartments and not have the accommodations for an extra bedroom. It just seems to me from all the posts regarding this issue that this is one problem for the general population on this board that does not need to exist. I guess I am just old-fashioned and out-of-touch because I just don't see the benefit to putting children through this. If this is what you choose for your child, then I guess there must be some benefit to it. I just don't understand it.


Before my daughter was born, I was of the exact same opinion. However, after weeks of colic & no sleep, I quickly changed my motto to "whatever works!" and my DD started sleeping in the swing. She would sleep 12 hours straight at night in the swing but couldn't lay for 1 full minute in the crib. We tried everything to get her to sleep in the crib, but when it didn't work, we stuck with the swing for four months. By that time, we decided it was time to get her into the crib. Again, we tried everything. CIO did not work for us. DD would cry for hours. We'd go in & check, rock her, the works. Did not work at all. She simply was not ready for the crib. At 5 1/2 months, she is getting much better. She sleeps in the crib every night (I rock her to sleep) but wakes up several times.

I envy you. I wish DD was a great sleeper like your kids. But please understand that simply putting a baby to sleep from day 1 in the crib failed miserably for us, as it has for some others. Some babies just have a real hard time sleeping in a big crib without any movement.

To the original poster, good luck! I know how frustrating it is. Around 5 or 6 months, you may want to try a check & console technique for a few nights & see how it goes.



Your situation was different. Your child had a medical condition that required you to do whatever was necessary to make her as comfortable as possible. I wasn't referring to that. You did what you had to do at the time and I think anyone would understand that and sympathize with you.

Posted 1/12/07 9:32 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
so torn what shouls i get.. stroller related..LONG 04bride 7/16/06 11 Parenting
CNN Breaking News - New Orleans mayor issues forced removal of people and also SUperdome being torn down MrsJ 9/6/05 13 Families Helping Families ™
What would you do? Job/Parent/PG related. I am so confused and torn...LONG..NEED Help LuvMy2Girls 1/8/07 20 Parenting
I am so torn mommy2Alex 3/20/06 11 TTC
I am very torn about stopping BFing monkeybride 3/9/06 12 Parenting
I feel torn 05mommy09 1/16/06 20 Families Helping Families ™