Torn in 2
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
|
Re: Torn in 2 Posted by greeneyes361708 Posted by CheeChee Posted by greeneyes361708 Posted by CheeChee Posted by greeneyes361708 There isn't anything right about letting your dc cry for hours without a parent being there for them. Harvard did a study that said CIO can cause psychological problems for children. Please...Well if Harvard wants to come to my house at all hours of the night and rock my son back to sleep until he is in high school, that will be just fine with me!!!! But if not, then please inform Harvard that I will do what I see fit when it comes to my child. And if my son winds up on a psychiatrists couch in 20 years with his only issue being me letting him CIO when he was a baby, i'll consider myself lucky and a fantastic parent! Ah, the "its my kid and I'll do what I want with it" logic. Nice. Good to know one of the top unviersities in the world have no bearing on your parental decisions, no matter what the emotional consequences for your child. oh puhlease!....No they really dont have any bearing on how I parent.. sorry if that upsets you. Last time i checked it wasnt Harvard's sperm and egg that created my child. But I promise to keep you posted on his emotional status. As of right now he's sleeping so I'm gonna say he's A-ok! And that makes my emotional status EVEN BETTER!! You do what works for you, and us terrible mom's who let our kids CIO will do what works for us!! Okie dokie. I hope the screaming himself to sleep for an hour and a half doesn't bother YOU as much as it does HIM. Actually, he wasnt screaming for an hour and half straight, it was off and on. phew.. right??? How horrible of a mom would I have been then right?? That would def have warranted a call to CPS...But anyhoo, like i said, it worked.. and if you can believe this, he slept the entire night which he hadnt done in a year AND woke up smiling the next morning!!! Look out South Oaks... here cooomes Jacob! But I do appreciate your concern, and hey listen any more Harvard research studies come your way regarding parenting.. pass em this way!!!
|
|
Posted 1/11/07 11:49 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Torn in 2 Message edited 2010-02-28 19:29:07.763000. |
|
Posted 1/11/07 11:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 OMG I am going to show this to my mother, she didn't let me CIO, but I have plenty of psychological damage! I co-slept, wore my baby for 8 months until he could crawl, and I let my baby CIO quite a few times. Believe you me, he will have plenty of psychological damage, but not from CIO. Probably from. oh lets see, me going back to work, having no family around, being the product of a meek Brit and a loud jew, OH, being in daycare, being circumsized... I could go on... Message edited 2007-01-12 04:24:44.377000. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 4:17 AM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Posted by racheeeee OMG I am going to show this to my mother, she didn't let me CIO, but I have plenty of psychological damage! I co-slept, wore my baby for 8 months until he could crawl, and I let my baby CIO quite a few times. Believe you me, he will have plenty of psychological damage, but not from CIO. Probably from. oh lets see, me going back to work, having no family around, being the product of a meek Brit and a loud jew, OH, being in daycare, being circumsized... I could go on... I'm with you on that Racheeeeeeeee!!!!!
|
|
Posted 1/12/07 6:42 AM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Where is the study? Do you have another link? This seems to be the opinion of 2 people without any scientific back-up or actual data to look at. I googled it too and could not find the actual study, or any other publication quoting the *study*, well except for a post on another site quoting the original article in the gazette posted by a user "Stephanie." |
|
Posted 1/12/07 7:13 AM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Posted by Shelly Usually we let her cry for 10 minutes. 90% of the time she is asleep by the end of it. If not, we usually take her out. Once she woke up in the middle of the night and we let her cry it out for almost an hour. She sleeps in our room- and it was SO hard! But she went back to sleep, and didn't wake up at night again for another month!! I don't know what it was- but letting her CIO taught her to put herself back to sleep. We do the ten minute wait also. However, if it goes on longer than that, I am so torn up I have to go into her room just to see if she is OK. As stated above, 90% of the time she will go back to sleep on her own. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 7:15 AM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Message edited 2010-02-28 19:29:29.953000. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 9:19 AM
|
|
|
FelAndJon Member since 6/05 10212 total posts Name: |
Re: Torn in 2 disregard, I was able to fix it myself Message edited 2007-01-12 09:35:51.393000. |
Posted 1/12/07 9:34 AM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Posted by greeneyes361708 Posted by JD02 Where is the study? Do you have another link? This seems to be the opinion of 2 people without any scientific back-up or actual data to look at. I googled it too and could not find the actual study, or any other publication quoting the *study*, well except for a post on another site quoting the original article in the gazette posted by a user "Stephanie." Wow, this was just SO hard to find. Harvard greeneyes, why are you the end all be all in how someone chooses to parent their child? Plenty of people have success with CIO and just b/c YOU choose not to do it does not mean that you should berate someone else who does. I have let my child cry for a long time on certain nights and it happens to work, I honestly don't think she will be psychologically damaged for the rest of her life b/c of it. So get off your soap box about CIO. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 9:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Message edited 2010-02-28 19:29:52.080000. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 9:58 AM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Posted by greeneyes361708 Posted by ckdk greeneyes, why are you the end all be all in how someone chooses to parent their child? Plenty of people have success with CIO and just b/c YOU choose not to do it does not mean that you should berate someone else who does. I have let my child cry for a long time on certain nights and it happens to work, I honestly don't think she will be psychologically damaged for the rest of her life b/c of it. So get off your soap box about CIO. I'm not. I just think when there is proof that it does damage then perhaps you should listen? Doesn't matter to me what you do with your kids I certainly won't have to deal with their panic disorders and post traumatic stresss disorder There is a hell of a lot of proof that smoking, drinking, leaving your house you might get hit by a bus, working, eating, etc etc will cause long term damage to the human body and mind...but we still do them! I think you should do what you want with your children by all means, but don't be criticising other people for their decisions about their children. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 10:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Posted by greeneyes361708 Posted by ckdk greeneyes, why are you the end all be all in how someone chooses to parent their child? Plenty of people have success with CIO and just b/c YOU choose not to do it does not mean that you should berate someone else who does. I have let my child cry for a long time on certain nights and it happens to work, I honestly don't think she will be psychologically damaged for the rest of her life b/c of it. So get off your soap box about CIO. I'm not. I just think when there is proof that it does damage then perhaps you should listen? Doesn't matter to me what you do with your kids I certainly won't have to deal with their panic disorders and post traumatic stresss disorder I honestly couldn't be bothered with reading 15 pages of gibberish from that study but I wouldn't consider that study to be true for ALL infants anyway. Plenty of parents use some form of CIO and yeah, I'm sure some kids may have problems later in life but I doubt it's from CIO when they were 8 months old! So, have fun rocking your child to sleep for the next 5 years! |
|
Posted 1/12/07 10:05 AM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 I am sure everyone knows I am a fan of CIO. It worked amazing for Talia. It changed her whole personality for the better. When I have more time I will post a link to info about babies sleep and the link to learning disorders. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 10:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 I know I am going to get flamed for this and stomped on with all kinds of feet, but, I have read a number of posts regarding CIO and I have to say I don't understand why it gets to this point. Children are not born knowing what to do, they learn what they live. I don't understand why parents don't start their lives by making it easier for them. Why not just put them in their crib and in their room from the very beginning? Unless a child has medical complications, I don't understand why it is necessary to keep transitioning them from one sleep setting to another. Why is it necessary to put them in a bassinett in the parents' bedroom or in a co-sleeper or in the parents' bed when it is so much easier for them to get used to one thing and to stay that way? I know it's easier on the parents when it's feeding time in the middle of the night to have them that close, but, how does it make it easier for the child to have to keep relearning new ways to sleep? I know that some feel it's important for them to bond this way, but, in all honesty, how much bonding is being done when you are asleep, or trying to? It seems that both parents and children appear to be exhausted from this when there is no need to be. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 10:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Posted by greeneyes361708 You all do know that Dr. Ferber says you need to go back and check on them, right? From some of the posts it seems a few people are walking out and letting their dc cry for hours. First of all, NO ONE said they were letting their child cry for hours on end. There is a HUGE difference between CIO and neglect, which is what you are implying. Second, who the hell are you to judge how someone chooses to parent? Just because YOU are 100% against CIO, and you have ONE Harvard study in support of not allowing CIO, doesn't mean you get to judge everyone else who chooses to use this method. There is plenty of real life proof that it does work and does not cause psychological problems. Besides, I am sure that you make parenting choices that I do not agree with - I would never presume to know that what you are doing is wrong and tell you so because I read some study. Third, yes children need their parents - they also need their SLEEP! They need it for brain development, as well as psychological and emotional well-being. And teaching them to fall asleep on their own is one of the best things you can do for your child. Anyway, needless to say, I am a fan of CIO. However, I have never felt the need to judge a parent who decides NOT to use CIO nor do I think they are "wrong" for not doing it. I don't push MY parenting principles on anyone else and neither do most of the mothers and fathers on this board. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 10:36 AM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Posted by Maathy317 I know I am going to get flamed for this and stomped on with all kinds of feet, but, I have read a number of posts regarding CIO and I have to say I don't understand why it gets to this point. Children are not born knowing what to do, they learn what they live. I don't understand why parents don't start their lives by making it easier for them. Why not just put them in their crib and in their room from the very beginning? Unless a child has medical complications, I don't understand why it is necessary to keep transitioning them from one sleep setting to another. Why is it necessary to put them in a bassinett in the parents' bedroom or in a co-sleeper or in the parents' bed when it is so much easier for them to get used to one thing and to stay that way? I know it's easier on the parents when it's feeding time in the middle of the night to have them that close, but, how does it make it easier for the child to have to keep relearning new ways to sleep? I know that some feel it's important for them to bond this way, but, in all honesty, how much bonding is being done when you are asleep, or trying to? It seems that both parents and children appear to be exhausted from this when there is no need to be. Both my girls went in their cribs and their rooms from the very beginning. They slept throught the night by the time they were one month old. I didn't have baby monitors or video monitors (which I think are a great idea) and managed to hear every sound. They got the rest they needed and so did we and they never had to learn a different way. I'm not saying they didn't wake up occasionally or that their sleep patterns didn't change, but, they were still never brought into our room to sleep through the night. If I needed to, I went in there, got them back to sleep and left. When they got older and needed to be comforted by coming into our room and being with us, that was fine, but, they never stayed long, only until they calmed down and left when they decided to. They never needed to sleep with a light on or their door open for comfort. They are both adults now and my oldest daughter has done the same with her son and has never had any problems. I know all children are different and not all situtations are the same. Some children have medical problems and some people may live in small apartments and not have the accommodations for an extra bedroom. It just seems to me from all the posts regarding this issue that this is one problem for the general population on this board that does not need to exist. I guess I am just old-fashioned and out-of-touch because I just don't see the benefit to putting children through this. If this is what you choose for your child, then I guess there must be some benefit to it. I just don't understand it. You sound *just* like my mother. I have no kids, so I can't comment from my own experience, but from what my mom tells me she did CIO before there was such a term. And I can assure you all that I don't suffer from post-traumatic stress from it. In fact, as a child I could sleep anywhere in nearly any conditions - lights on, tv on, people talking - because that's how I was trained. I understand that every child is different, but I don't think it's fair to lay such guilt trips on the moms who are successful with CIO. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 10:40 AM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Posted by greeneyes361708 Posted by ckdk greeneyes, why are you the end all be all in how someone chooses to parent their child? Plenty of people have success with CIO and just b/c YOU choose not to do it does not mean that you should berate someone else who does. I have let my child cry for a long time on certain nights and it happens to work, I honestly don't think she will be psychologically damaged for the rest of her life b/c of it. So get off your soap box about CIO. I'm not. I just think when there is proof that it does damage then perhaps you should listen? Doesn't matter to me what you do with your kids I certainly won't have to deal with their panic disorders and post traumatic stresss disorder First of all the actual study NEVER says panic disorder, and in regards to PTSD only states that "one implication is that cultures that train for independence, and therefore self-responsibility, risk having more PTSD later in life." Such a blanket statement. I dont think that having your baby cry for 10 minutes to fall asleep is training it for independence. Your getting most of your information from the article after the actual study. Read the study again. It also says that American mothers talk to their babies a lot, and our children therefore spend more time in "excited states" where other cultures find this bizarre because babies don't understand. Should we stop talking to our babies because it excites them as well? If you do a search, you can find about 100 other studies commending the use of CIO because it allows babies to sleep better, being better rested and more emotionally stable. I am not even a big fan of CIO, but I would NEVER judge and tell another mother that their child is going to suffer from PTSD or have panic disorders because she is doing what she thinks is best to have them sleep well and thrive emotionally. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 11:55 AM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Posted by JD02 First of all the actual study NEVER says panic disorder, and in regards to PTSD only states that "one implication is that cultures that train for independence, and therefore self-responsibility, risk having more PTSD later in life." Such a blanket statement. I dont think that having your baby cry for 10 minutes to fall asleep is training it for independence. Your getting most of your information from the article after the actual study. Read the study again. It also says that American mothers talk to their babies a lot, and our children therefore spend more time in "excited states" where other cultures find this bizarre because babies don't understand. Should we stop talking to our babies because it excites them as well? If you do a search, you can find about 100 other studies commending the use of CIO because it allows babies to sleep better, being better rested and more emotionally stable. I am not even a big fan of CIO, but I would NEVER judge and tell another mother that their child is going to suffer from PTSD or have panic disorders because she is doing what she thinks is best to have them sleep well and thrive emotionally. Thank you. Also I think that comparing American mothers to mothers in Kenya (like they did in that study), a third world country with a poor infant mortality rate, is very misleading. If I bore a child in the conditions of a third world country rife with disease, I would probably jump everytime the baby made a peep too and NEVER consider CIO. Also, the study says that these mothers are much harsher on older children than American mothers are. I'm sure that can be psychologically damaging too. I personally would not base my opinion on CIO on this particular study. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 12:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Posted by BabyAvocado Posted by greeneyes361708 You all do know that Dr. Ferber says you need to go back and check on them, right? From some of the posts it seems a few people are walking out and letting their dc cry for hours. First of all, NO ONE said they were letting their child cry for hours on end. There is a HUGE difference between CIO and neglect, which is what you are implying. Second, who the hell are you to judge how someone chooses to parent? Just because YOU are 100% against CIO, and you have ONE Harvard study in support of not allowing CIO, doesn't mean you get to judge everyone else who chooses to use this method. There is plenty of real life proof that it does work and does not cause psychological problems. Besides, I am sure that you make parenting choices that I do not agree with - I would never presume to know that what you are doing is wrong and tell you so because I read some study. Third, yes children need their parents - they also need their SLEEP! They need it for brain development, as well as psychological and emotional well-being. And teaching them to fall asleep on their own is one of the best things you can do for your child. Anyway, needless to say, I am a fan of CIO. However, I have never felt the need to judge a parent who decides NOT to use CIO nor do I think they are "wrong" for not doing it. I don't push MY parenting principles on anyone else and neither do most of the mothers and fathers on this board. I think greeneyes was prob referring to my post about letting Jacob CIO for an hour and a half.. maybe i should have been more clear but he was NOT screaming for an hour and half straight.. he cried for 5-10 min.. stopped, sat down...looked around, stood up, cried for another few min.. stopped, sat down.etc.. So therefore the whole process took an hour and a half but I did NOT go in in that timeframe and he eventually fell asleep. Believe me, I have never been one to use CIO because he would always throw up, but him not sleeping was getting out of hand at one year old. No one in my house was getting the sleep they needed. Thankfully i have had much luck with it the past week and with no throwing up. But to be told that I am traumatizing him is just totally uncalled for....
|
|
Posted 1/12/07 12:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Posted by CheeChee I think greeneyes was prob referring to my post about letting Jacob CIO for an hour and a half.. maybe i should have been more clear but he was NOT screaming for an hour and half straight.. he cried for 5-10 min.. stopped, sat down...looked around, stood up, cried for another few min.. stopped, sat down.etc.. So therefore the whole process took an hour and a half but I did NOT go in in that timeframe and he eventually fell asleep. Believe me, I have never been one to use CIO because he would always throw up, but him not sleeping was getting out of hand at one year old. No one in my house was getting the sleep they needed. Thankfully i have had much luck with it the past week and with no throwing up. But to be told that I am traumatizing him is just totally uncalled for.... Noreen - you don't need to explain yourself She has no right to judge you and she did say hourS (plural) - an hour and a half is not hours. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 1:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Posted by greeneyes361708 Posted by JD02 Where is the study? Do you have another link? This seems to be the opinion of 2 people without any scientific back-up or actual data to look at. I googled it too and could not find the actual study, or any other publication quoting the *study*, well except for a post on another site quoting the original article in the gazette posted by a user "Stephanie." Wow, this was just SO hard to find. Harvard Not a mom, just lurking. Just wanted to say this isn't a study. This is a paper. It's also not about CIO per se, it's about how child rearing practices differ cross-culturally. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 2:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 As someone who was 100% failure at CIO with #1 and a success with #2, I can volunteer that #2 sleeps much better. She's also better behaved. Message edited 2007-01-12 14:43:27.963000. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 2:43 PM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Posted by greeneyes361708 There isn't anything right about letting your dc cry for hours without a parent being there for them. Harvard did a study that said CIO can cause psychological problems for children. You're kidding right? I think most mommies would agree that one of the first things we learn as a mom is to THROW OUT everything we read. You do realize that psychologists and the American Pediatric Society have changed their perspective on literally EVERY aspect of raising your child almost every decade, right? The point being, you go with your instincts and what works for you and your family. For some, CIO doesn't work, for others, it does (in my case, it works like a charm). My daughter is loved and doted upon at all waking hours, and I truly believe that allowing her to CIO teaches her one of the most invaluable lessons for a child - how to soothe herself. And you know what? I guarantee more than half of us were allowed to CIO as children, and were we pyschologically impaired as a result? Doubtful. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 3:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Wow! You guys must have jinxed me. I had such a problem with Jordana last night. She is getting a cold and is all stuffed up. She sleeps in a crib in our room (we have 1 br). She went to sleep at 8- like she usually does and woke up at 10 as she usually does. I fed her at 10, but she wouldn't go back to sleep. I put her in the crib. She started to cry. I brought her in the bed. For an hour it was OK- she was still awake, but not crying. Then she started crying. She kepts startign and stoppign crying. The pacifier wasn't calming her down. The cycle kept going. I didn't know what to do. I used saline drops on her nose. Try to suck out some boogers. I held her and hugged her- she was in bed with me. After 3 hours i just didn't know what to do. I put her back in the crib and she cried. She kept crying and stopping. Crying and stopping. I went to sleep on the couch while DH was in the room. Message edited 2007-01-12 15:12:35.487000. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 3:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Torn in 2 Posted by SAMMIYY What is your opinion on letting your DC CIO? I tried it last night but after the second time up and crying I couldn't let her continue crying. I get nervous what if....she's hungry, something hurts, her teeth are bothering her, etc. Help! Getting back to the original post here...how old is your DD? If you are not comfortable letting her CIO then don't! I rocked DS to sleep even for naps until 8 months old, most times I wanted to. Now that he knows more about whats going on we do it different, I didn't read any books or anything, just trial and error and what works for us. What works for us is when DS is tired we put him in the crib with his music playing and leave, he sometimes whimpers or crys but we leave him for a few minutes and he usually stops and falls asleep. If he doesn't I'll go in for a second and rub his back and leave again, I've never had to do this more than a few times. He doesn't get hysterical though, I'm not sure if I could handle that. I have also found the key is to get them into the crib as soon as they are tired to avoid the overtired crying. I believe babies release their feelings through crying, sometimes after a long day I want to whimper and cry myself to sleep!! Even though I always rocked DS, from day one my house has always been noisy, I drag him out with me all the time and he will nap in the car or stroller, on a friends floor, couch etc. and some people think I'm crazy for that stuff but it works for us. |
|
Posted 1/12/07 3:16 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| so torn what shouls i get.. stroller related..LONG | 04bride | 7/16/06 | 11 | Parenting |
| CNN Breaking News - New Orleans mayor issues forced removal of people and also SUperdome being torn down | MrsJ | 9/6/05 | 13 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| What would you do? Job/Parent/PG related. I am so confused and torn...LONG..NEED Help | LuvMy2Girls | 1/8/07 | 20 | Parenting |
| I am so torn | mommy2Alex | 3/20/06 | 11 | TTC |
| I am very torn about stopping BFing | monkeybride | 3/9/06 | 12 | Parenting |
| I feel torn | 05mommy09 | 1/16/06 | 20 | Families Helping Families ™ |

















