Re: Torn in 2
Posted 1/12/2007 12:38:40 PM by BabyAvocado
Posted by JD02
First of all the actual study NEVER says panic disorder, and in regards to PTSD only states that "one implication is that cultures that train for independence, and therefore self-responsibility, risk having more PTSD later in life." Such a blanket statement. I dont think that having your baby cry for 10 minutes to fall asleep is training it for independence. Your getting most of your information from the article after the actual study. Read the study again. It also says that American mothers talk to their babies a lot, and our children therefore spend more time in "excited states" where other cultures find this bizarre because babies don't understand. Should we stop talking to our babies because it excites them as well?
If you do a search, you can find about 100 other studies commending the use of CIO because it allows babies to sleep better, being better rested and more emotionally stable.
I am not even a big fan of CIO, but I would NEVER judge and tell another mother that their child is going to suffer from PTSD or have panic disorders because she is doing what she thinks is best to have them sleep well and thrive emotionally.
Thank you.
Also I think that comparing American mothers to mothers in Kenya (like they did in that study), a third world country with a poor infant mortality rate, is very misleading. If I bore a child in the conditions of a third world country rife with disease, I would probably jump everytime the baby made a peep too and NEVER consider CIO.
Also, the study says that these mothers are much harsher on older children than American mothers are. I'm sure that can be psychologically damaging too.
I personally would not base my opinion on CIO on this particular study.
|