Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MsMBV

Posted by DMcK

There's a huge difference between Hitler and other people being mentioned on this thread. You cannot even compare. Sure, someone may get offended by an FDR quote but let's be reasonable. Hitler stands in a category of his own.

I am asking this out of curiosity for people who are free speech advocates and think it is okay in schools, where do you draw the line in schools? Can students curse at one another or teachers? What can you do at your job? Could you quote Hitler openly at a meeting?



Please do not take this the wrong way, but to someone here there may be a a huge difference between Hitler & FDR, Truman, Naopleon...etc. But to someone else I am not so sure. The beauty of free speech is that it has nothing to do with reaction or response. TFree speech is what is says, Free. People absolutely have the right to be offended, and if students or parents do not want to pay thier money to see those quotes listed in their yearbook, then it is their right.

And as far as teachers cursing or mentioning these quotes at a meeting at work, I think that most people would do what is socially acceptable, as there is a job involved. It is not the same type of forum, IMO.



I don't oppose free speech, I guess the big difference is that I don't see this as a free speech argument.

As for people not seeing the difference between Hitler and FDRChat Icon

Posted 6/13/06 11:08 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Shroggie
Don't Worry...Be Happy

Member since 5/06

6261 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

I agree with the above 2 posts.

Posted 6/13/06 11:08 AM
 

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MrsS2005

Posted by MsMBV

Posted by DMcK

There's a huge difference between Hitler and other people being mentioned on this thread. You cannot even compare. Sure, someone may get offended by an FDR quote but let's be reasonable. Hitler stands in a category of his own.

I am asking this out of curiosity for people who are free speech advocates and think it is okay in schools, where do you draw the line in schools? Can students curse at one another or teachers? What can you do at your job? Could you quote Hitler openly at a meeting?



Please do not take this the wrong way, but to someone here there may be a a huge difference between Hitler & FDR, Truman, Naopleon...etc. But to someone else I am not so sure. The beauty of free speech is that it has nothing to do with reaction or response. TFree speech is what is says, Free. People absolutely have the right to be offended, and if students or parents do not want to pay thier money to see those quotes listed in their yearbook, then it is their right.

And as far as teachers cursing or mentioning these quotes at a meeting at work, I think that most people would do what is socially acceptable, as there is a job involved. It is not the same type of forum, IMO.


Free speech is not absolute. There are limitations, especially in a school setting. Just as you cannot yell "fire" in a crowded building, the school has a right to censor its publications including newspapers and yearbooks.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 6/13/06 11:09 AM
 

Jesaroo
is not the girl you knew

Member since 5/05

14266 total posts

Name:
Jes

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

i dont think they should have to tkae it out.

its not their right to.

there was nothing offensive to the quote they had chosen. it wasnt "zeig hal" or anything like that.

let the student express themself the way they want to.

of course there has to be censorship somewhere i.e. no cursign, etc but i feel that if they take it out the line will be/would have been crossed.

do you have to agree wiht their quote? absolutely not. but whast the point of letting them have quotes if they wont let them quote what they want to???

i personally dont find their quote distasteful.

the PERSON quoted yes, but i feel it is totally different

Posted 6/13/06 11:14 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

The school does have the right to censor their own publication (and obviously should've taken more care in providing guidelines).

Many rights we have do not apply to minors. For example, they have the right to search a student, lockers, bags, etc. Last time I checked, they can't search ME without probable cause. (of course, who knows what applies nowChat Icon )

Posted 6/13/06 11:27 AM
 

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

It would be interesting to see how teachers vs. non teacher feels about this.

Posted 6/13/06 11:28 AM
 

stickydust
Now a mommy of 2!!!

Member since 4/06

3164 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

The Supreme Court has held on more than one occasion that freedom of speech is not an absolute right in a school setting. The schools can monitor dress, speech, assembly etc. It has been pretty clear on this point so I believe this and any school is well within their constitutional right to censor this type of speech.

Posted 6/13/06 11:29 AM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by Lolita4Life

i dont think they should have to tkae it out.

its not their right to.

there was nothing offensive to the quote they had chosen. it wasnt "zeig hal" or anything like that.

let the student express themself the way they want to.

of course there has to be censorship somewhere i.e. no cursign, etc but i feel that if they take it out the line will be/would have been crossed.

do you have to agree wiht their quote? absolutely not. but whast the point of letting them have quotes if they wont let them quote what they want to???

i personally dont find their quote distasteful.

the PERSON quoted yes, but i feel it is totally different


The school has the right to censor its publications. The Supreme Court has ruled on this with school newspapers. I don't see any difference between newspapers and yearbooks.

Posted 6/13/06 11:30 AM
 

Jesaroo
is not the girl you knew

Member since 5/05

14266 total posts

Name:
Jes

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

of course schools censor. i just feel like they are censoring TOO much now.

Posted 6/13/06 11:31 AM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Free Speech IS an absolute, it has to be otherwise it is censorship, in one way or another. Sorry but IMO it is a freedom of Speech and freedom of expression issue 100%. If it happens in a school, or on a TV show, it is still the 1st ammendment of our US Constitution to be able to express an opinion. That is is. It does not say, but you cannot in school, or you cannot in a year book...it simply states freedom, no limitation.

So my question to you is, who sets these "limits" on freedom, who decides how far is too far...who writes the legislation to determine proper punishment? Not us, that is for sure. The frightening thing is that popular opinon can attempt to produce some of the most unjust and unequitable legislation.

Posted 6/13/06 11:37 AM
 

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MsMBV

Free Speech IS an absolute, it has to be otherwise it is censorship, in one way or another. Sorry but IMO it is a freedom of Speech and freedom of expression issue 100%. If it happens in a school, or on a TV show, it is still the 1st ammendment of our US Constitution to be able to express an opinion. That is is. It does not say, but you cannot in school, or you cannot in a year book...it simply states freedom, no limitation.

So my question to you is, who sets these "limits" on freedom, who decides how far is too far...who writes the legislation to determine proper punishment? Not us, that is for sure. The frightening thing is that popular opinon can attempt to produce some of the most unjust and unequitable legislation.



There ARE legal limits to the First Am. It is a fact. You cannot scream "Fire" in a crowded building, there are laws against discrimination, etc.

Posted 6/13/06 11:38 AM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by Lolita4Life

of course schools censor. i just feel like they are censoring TOO much now.


I agree. I think it is a load. I understand that schools contain minors who do not have the rights as minors, however I think to teach that editorialized censorship is very harmful, in that it just gets people *used* to limits and to censorship later in life. Chat Icon

Posted 6/13/06 11:39 AM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MsMBV

Free Speech IS an absolute, it has to be otherwise it is censorship, in one way or another. Sorry but IMO it is a freedom of Speech and freedom of expression issue 100%. If it happens in a school, or on a TV show, it is still the 1st ammendment of our US Constitution to be able to express an opinion. That is is. It does not say, but you cannot in school, or you cannot in a year book...it simply states freedom, no limitation.

So my question to you is, who sets these "limits" on freedom, who decides how far is too far...who writes the legislation to determine proper punishment? Not us, that is for sure. The frightening thing is that popular opinon can attempt to produce some of the most unjust and unequitable legislation.


Free speech is not absolute. As the above poster menitoned, you cannot yell "fire" in a crowded building. There are limitations in the school setting. The Supreme Court Justices, who are the ones interpreting the Constitution, have ruled on this.

Posted 6/13/06 11:41 AM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by DMcK

Posted by MsMBV

Free Speech IS an absolute, it has to be otherwise it is censorship, in one way or another. Sorry but IMO it is a freedom of Speech and freedom of expression issue 100%. If it happens in a school, or on a TV show, it is still the 1st ammendment of our US Constitution to be able to express an opinion. That is is. It does not say, but you cannot in school, or you cannot in a year book...it simply states freedom, no limitation.

So my question to you is, who sets these "limits" on freedom, who decides how far is too far...who writes the legislation to determine proper punishment? Not us, that is for sure. The frightening thing is that popular opinon can attempt to produce some of the most unjust and unequitable legislation.



There ARE legal limits to the First Am. It is a fact. You cannot scream "Fire" in a crowded building, there are laws against discrimination, etc.


Yes, but that is not what we are talking about. And screaming fire in a building is more of a danger/neglect/intent to do harm or incite riot issue than it is a speech issue.

What laws against discrimination are you referring to in regards to the 1st Am?

Posted 6/13/06 11:42 AM
 

stickydust
Now a mommy of 2!!!

Member since 4/06

3164 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Freedom of speech is not an absolute for instance obscenity is not protected and your speech has to actually deliver some sort of political, scientifice etc. message.

Whether or not something is protected under the first amendment falls under the courts jurisidction (this is also proscribed in our constitution)

I could sit here and provide a lesson on the tests that are used to decide whetehr or not something is protected but I am afraid you would all fall asleep Chat Icon

Posted 6/13/06 11:46 AM
 

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by stickydust

Freedom of speech is not an absolute for instance obscenity is not protected and your speech has to actually deliver some sort of political, scientifice etc. message.

Whether or not something is protected under the first amendment falls under the courts jurisidction (this is also proscribed in our constitution)

I could sit here and provide a lesson on the tests that are used to decide whetehr or not something is protected but I am afraid you would all fall asleep Chat Icon



Actually, I think it would be interesting!

Posted 6/13/06 11:48 AM
 

stickydust
Now a mommy of 2!!!

Member since 4/06

3164 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Oh and discrimination is not covered under the first amendment - it came in a much later amendment. Originally, there was no amendment and the courts used the commerce clause of the consitutio. Then an amendment was created. That concluded the legal history lesson for todayChat Icon

Posted 6/13/06 11:48 AM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by DMcK

As for people not seeing the difference between Hitler and FDRChat Icon



All I stated was that YOUR OPINION of their similarity or difference may not be someone else's. NO SINGLE PERSON'S OPINION IS UNIVERSAL. That is what should be so great about this country, we can disagree and still co-exist.

Posted 6/13/06 11:49 AM
 

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MsMBV

Posted by DMcK

As for people not seeing the difference between Hitler and FDRChat Icon



All I stated was that YOUR OPINION of their similarity or difference may not be someone else's. NO SINGLE PERSON'S OPINION IS UNIVERSAL. That is what should be so great about this country, we can disagree and still co-exist.



I agree. Like I said earlier, to me, this is not a free speech issue.

Posted 6/13/06 11:50 AM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by stickydust

Freedom of speech is not an absolute for instance obscenity is not protected and your speech has to actually deliver some sort of political, scientifice etc. message.

Whether or not something is protected under the first amendment falls under the courts jurisidction (this is also proscribed in our constitution)

I could sit here and provide a lesson on the tests that are used to decide whetehr or not something is protected but I am afraid you would all fall asleep Chat Icon


Well I'd love it......but I think we might have to start a new thread. Chat Icon

And I do think, if you remove the stigma of the author, that those quotes could very well apply to our current political and global situation. JMHO

Posted 6/13/06 11:51 AM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by stickydust

Oh and discrimination is not covered under the first amendment - it came in a much later amendment. Originally, there was no amendment and the courts used the commerce clause of the consitutio. Then an amendment was created. That concluded the legal history lesson for todayChat Icon



I recall vaguely that one of the earlier cases regarding the posting or distribution of bills was overturned becuase of the message on one side was political, therefore finding a loophole for the advertisement on the other side....if I remember correctly.....Chat Icon

Posted 6/13/06 11:53 AM
 

stickydust
Now a mommy of 2!!!

Member since 4/06

3164 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MsMBV

Posted by stickydust

Oh and discrimination is not covered under the first amendment - it came in a much later amendment. Originally, there was no amendment and the courts used the commerce clause of the consitutio. Then an amendment was created. That concluded the legal history lesson for todayChat Icon



I recall vaguely that one of the earlier cases regarding the posting or distribution of bills was overturned becuase of the message on one side was political, therefore finding a loophole for the advertisement on the other side....if I remember correctly.....Chat Icon



That's correct an advertisement can be protected only if it delivers some sort of political message and is not purely advertising.

Posted 6/13/06 11:55 AM
 

Maathy317
Grammie's Little Man

Member since 2/06

3235 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by JenniferEver

I think the school should absolutely take it out.

Freedom of speech does not extend to yearbook quotes. You can't use foul language or hate speech, and imo you shouldn't be able to quote hitler either.



Freedom of Speech is unconditional. It extends to all aspect of society, even if the majority of citizens find it offensive. That's the beauty of it and the rest of the freedoms we have. Anyone can quote anyone. If people find this quote offensive, then black it out. While I am, certainly, not a fan of Adolf Hitler, I can guarantee that if that quote was not followed by his name, no one would have known who it was from. I think there are far more important things in this world to be upset about than a quote in a yearbook.

Posted 6/13/06 3:11 PM
 

LadyMaravilla
Fall Is Here

Member since 5/05

12023 total posts

Name:
Sonia

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by dpli

On the one hand, I can see the argument for free speech and if you are foolish enough to be known for all time as the guy with the Hitler quote under your senior photo, that is your perogative. However, the school is actually the one publishing the yearbook and it is a representation of their school so I think they do get the final veto on what is published in it.



I agree.

Posted 6/13/06 3:18 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MsMBV

And I do think, if you remove the stigma of the author, that those quotes could very well apply to our current political and global situation. JMHO



As a former HS teacher, I would feel safe in betting that the author of the quote is one of the reasons the quote was chosen in the first place - to push the limits and see if it would "get through."

Posted 6/13/06 3:22 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
YUMMY WW 2 PT SNACK ALERT!! Repost..cause I posted on the wrong board... Cookiegobbler 1/23/06 10 Diet & Fitness
OK, I need honest opinions. Am I wrong? (VERY long) Scotty-CassidysMom 1/8/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
Am I feeding Kevin Wrong? Veggies? Maximum amount of formula per day? MM2004 12/6/05 1 Parenting
I have a number that is a wrong number but it is restricted how can i call this person back luvsbob4603 11/15/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
i knw i am sensitive b/c i just had a DNc but this is whast so wrong with twh worlkd sometimes... 04bride 11/9/05 11 Pregnancy
i want ask you all something and let me know if you agree or am i wrong luvsbob4603 8/24/05 8 Families Helping Families ™