Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3]

Jax430
Hi!

Member since 5/05

18919 total posts

Name:
Jackie

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

The yearbook is representative of the school, not just the students in it. If the school officials do not want their name on something that had quotations from Hitler, or anyone else who they may consider offensive, it is their prerogative to censor.

Posted 6/13/06 3:22 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

LadyMaravilla
Fall Is Here

Member since 5/05

12023 total posts

Name:
Sonia

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by Maathy317

Freedom of Speech is unconditional. It extends to all aspect of society, even if the majority of citizens find it offensive. That's the beauty of it and the rest of the freedoms we have. Anyone can quote anyone. If people find this quote offensive, then black it out. While I am, certainly, not a fan of Adolf Hitler, I can guarantee that if that quote was not followed by his name, no one would have known who it was from. I think there are far more important things in this world to be upset about than a quote in a yearbook.




I also agree that because the quote is linked with his name it's causing such hysteria. I on a personal level would not want to be associated with any quotes Hitler gave, but again freedom of speech is Exercised

Posted 6/13/06 3:24 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

when you quote someone, you have to cite the source. I don't think any school would want to associate themselves with Adolph Hitler Chat Icon

this whole thread is silly. IMO

you cannot compare the biggest genocidal murderer of our times to Truman or anyone else for that matter! Chat Icon

Comparing anyone to Hitler lessens the unspeakable genocide that he caused!

Message edited 2006-06-13 15:27:55.237000.

Posted 6/13/06 3:25 PM
 

LadyMaravilla
Fall Is Here

Member since 5/05

12023 total posts

Name:
Sonia

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

.oops found the comparions....Chat Icon

Message edited 2006-06-13 15:29:35.093000.

Posted 6/13/06 3:28 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by Maathy317

Posted by JenniferEver

I think the school should absolutely take it out.

Freedom of speech does not extend to yearbook quotes. You can't use foul language or hate speech, and imo you shouldn't be able to quote hitler either.



Freedom of Speech is unconditional. It extends to all aspect of society, even if the majority of citizens find it offensive. That's the beauty of it and the rest of the freedoms we have. Anyone can quote anyone. If people find this quote offensive, then black it out. While I am, certainly, not a fan of Adolf Hitler, I can guarantee that if that quote was not followed by his name, no one would have known who it was from. I think there are far more important things in this world to be upset about than a quote in a yearbook.


Freedom of speech is not unconditional. The Supreme Court has set several limitations on it. Freedom of speech extends beyond the school gates, but there are limitations. Students do not have the right to say vulgar or offensive things in the classroom. They are not protected by the First Amendment. Also, the school has the right to censor the yearbook and its school-run newspapers.

Posted 6/13/06 3:32 PM
 

MrsERod
Praying for Everyone.

Member since 5/05

26170 total posts

Name:
MrsERod™®

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by Jax430

The yearbook is representative of the school, not just the students in it. If the school officials do not want their name on something that had quotations from Hitler, or anyone else who they may consider offensive, it is their prerogative to censor.




i completely agree.

and i'm STILL at a loss as to WHY the school even had quotes from Hitler available for the students to choose from in the first place!!???? Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 6/13/06 3:32 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MrsERod

Posted by Jax430

The yearbook is representative of the school, not just the students in it. If the school officials do not want their name on something that had quotations from Hitler, or anyone else who they may consider offensive, it is their prerogative to censor.




i completely agree.

and i'm STILL at a loss as to WHY the school even had quotes from Hitler available for the students to choose from in the first place!!???? Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



They probably didn't; they most likely allowed the students to choose their own and the yearbook staff or moderator did a bad job of editing.

My class in HS was the first in many years that was not allowed to have quotes under our photos because of problems like this.

Posted 6/13/06 3:34 PM
 

LFitzy79
can hardly wait

Member since 5/05

2650 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MrsERod

Posted by Jax430

The yearbook is representative of the school, not just the students in it. If the school officials do not want their name on something that had quotations from Hitler, or anyone else who they may consider offensive, it is their prerogative to censor.




i completely agree.

and i'm STILL at a loss as to WHY the school even had quotes from Hitler available for the students to choose from in the first place!!???? Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon



the kids got to pick ANY quote they wanted, these two dopes choose to quote Mein Kempf, I'm sure the school library has a copy on file, along with the town library, barnes and noble, etc.

Posted 6/13/06 3:35 PM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MrsERod

Posted by Jax430

The yearbook is representative of the school, not just the students in it. If the school officials do not want their name on something that had quotations from Hitler, or anyone else who they may consider offensive, it is their prerogative to censor.




i completely agree.

and i'm STILL at a loss as to WHY the school even had quotes from Hitler available for the students to choose from in the first place!!???? Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon


I don't think the school gave the students a list of quotes to choose from. In our yearbook, the seniors were the only ones who could include a quote and we could choose anything we wanted (although I doubt someone would be allowed to quote Hitler). I'm surprised the issue wasn't raised before the books were published. I wonder if anyone noticed that these students quoted Hitler. In my high school, two of my friends were the yearbook editors and were supervised by a teacher who meticulously looked over everything.

Posted 6/13/06 3:37 PM
 

MrsERod
Praying for Everyone.

Member since 5/05

26170 total posts

Name:
MrsERod™®

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

right, but i thought i heard on the news that the school GAVE the students the list of quotes to choose from? Chat Icon

guess the media was incorrect AGAIN!! Chat Icon

Posted 6/13/06 3:41 PM
 

Ren
LIF Infant

Member since 11/05

203 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MrsERod

right, but i thought i heard on the news that the school GAVE the students the list of quotes to choose from? Chat Icon

guess the media was incorrect AGAIN!! Chat Icon



I thought I heard them say this on the news this morning (that they had the quotes to chose from a list). But everything I've read seems to indicate that it was just something the students chose themselves.

Found this in the Newsday article:
"McLaughlin and superintendent William Brosnan said the yearbook's student staff, and its adviser, Robert Runyan, a teacher, saw the quotations before they were published."

Posted 6/13/06 3:46 PM
 

karacg
Babygirl is 4!

Member since 5/05

17076 total posts

Name:
Kara®

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Well one thing for sure - Hitler was one of the greatest motivators to ever live...

Posted 6/13/06 3:48 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by Ren

Found this in the Newsday article:
"McLaughlin and superintendent William Brosnan said the yearbook's student staff, and its adviser, Robert Runyan, a teacher, saw the quotations before they were published."



I wouldn't want to be in that adviser's shoes right about now......

Posted 6/13/06 3:49 PM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by karacg

Well one thing for sure - Hitler was one of the greatest motivators to ever live...


I'm sorry, but I think giving him any credit whatsoever (aside from being a genocidal mad man) is BS.

do you know what the 1st thing he did after he was elecetd? he took away every German's citizens weapon.

motivation and fear are not the same thing.

Posted 6/13/06 3:51 PM
 

Goldi0218
My miracles!

Member since 12/05

23902 total posts

Name:
Leslie

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

There are kids (and adults) who do things for shock value. People don't quote Hitler unless they either truly believe in his words or are looking to stir up controversy such as is being done here.

I think these kids are sitting back and laughing their arses off saying "Look what we did!" THAT in and of itself is rather is more disturbing than the authorities who missed it. Maybe what SHOULD be addressed is not necessarily the "OOOOH its Hitler" factor, but the fact that they CHOSE him over equally influential (but POSITIVE) figures to quote. The administrators should be talking to the parents and digging a little bit deeper here. JMO.

Posted 6/13/06 4:41 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
YUMMY WW 2 PT SNACK ALERT!! Repost..cause I posted on the wrong board... Cookiegobbler 1/23/06 10 Diet & Fitness
OK, I need honest opinions. Am I wrong? (VERY long) Scotty-CassidysMom 1/8/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
Am I feeding Kevin Wrong? Veggies? Maximum amount of formula per day? MM2004 12/6/05 1 Parenting
I have a number that is a wrong number but it is restricted how can i call this person back luvsbob4603 11/15/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
i knw i am sensitive b/c i just had a DNc but this is whast so wrong with twh worlkd sometimes... 04bride 11/9/05 11 Pregnancy
i want ask you all something and let me know if you agree or am i wrong luvsbob4603 8/24/05 8 Families Helping Families ™