Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?
Posted 6/13/2006 11:09:28 AM by Shanti


Posted by MrsS2005


Posted by MsMBV


Posted by DMcK

There's a huge difference between Hitler and other people being mentioned on this thread. You cannot even compare. Sure, someone may get offended by an FDR quote but let's be reasonable. Hitler stands in a category of his own.

I am asking this out of curiosity for people who are free speech advocates and think it is okay in schools, where do you draw the line in schools? Can students curse at one another or teachers? What can you do at your job? Could you quote Hitler openly at a meeting?



Please do not take this the wrong way, but to someone here there may be a a huge difference between Hitler & FDR, Truman, Naopleon...etc. But to someone else I am not so sure. The beauty of free speech is that it has nothing to do with reaction or response. TFree speech is what is says, Free. People absolutely have the right to be offended, and if students or parents do not want to pay thier money to see those quotes listed in their yearbook, then it is their right.

And as far as teachers cursing or mentioning these quotes at a meeting at work, I think that most people would do what is socially acceptable, as there is a job involved. It is not the same type of forum, IMO.


Free speech is not absolute. There are limitations, especially in a school setting. Just as you cannot yell "fire" in a crowded building, the school has a right to censor its publications including newspapers and yearbooks.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window