Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

For me this is an example of freedom of speech. Granted, misguided speech but then that's my opinion too.


Northport reels from Hitler yearbook quotes
BY KARLA SCHUSTER
Newsday Staff Writer

June 13, 2006


Northport school officials will remove quotations from Adolf Hitler that were chosen by two seniors to appear under their high school yearbook pictures, saying they regret that the Nazi leader's words were published.

"It's our responsibility and we failed miserably," said principal Irene McLaughlin. "The fact that the book went out in the form it did was a grave mistake on our part."

Seniors at Northport High pick a quote to appear under their yearbook picture -- and the choices run the gamut from song lyrics and famous movie lines, to passages from a favorite book or the words of noted philosophers, political and historical figures.

Christopher Koulermos and Philip Compton, both 18, chose to quote Hitler -- sparking dozens of angry calls from parents who found the quotations offensive, school officials said. Both quotes were attributed to Hitler.

They come from Hitler's 1925 autobiographical manifesto "Mein Kampf." Koulermos chose "Strength lies not in defense but attack," while Compton picked "The great masses of people will more easily fall victims to a big lie than to a small one."

Neither student returned calls Monday. McLaughlin and superintendent William Brosnan said the yearbook's student staff, and its adviser, Robert Runyan, a teacher, saw the quotations before they were published.

The district has no formal policy for reviewing senior quotations, Brosnan said, but he said common sense dictated that the Hitler ones should have been run by administrators before publication.

Brosnan, who is retiring July 1, noted the text of the quotes themselves is not offensive. "It's the attribution to Hitler that's offensive," he said.

But Rabbi Ian Silverman of the East Northport Jewish Center said it is impossible to separate the words from the man. "Some things can't be taken out of context. They remain in context forever," he said.

School officials would not comment on whether they will discipline the two students or yearbook adviser.

McLaughlin said she does not think the yearbook staff or the two boys meant to offend. The district plans to send parents a written apology this week. Officials are also discussing with the publishing company either reprinting that section or offering a special white tape to those who want to cover the quotes.

"I don't think they understood the ramifications," McLaughlin said, who didn't know about the quotes until parents complained.

Next year, the school may use a committee of parents, teachers and students to review senior quotations. That, many students say, amounts to censorship. "I think it's been blown completely out of proportion," said senior Joanna Dickman, 17. "I don't believe they should censor your senior quote ... I mean, if that's what those guys want to be remembered by, that's up to them."

Posted 6/13/06 9:51 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

On the one hand, I can see the argument for free speech and if you are foolish enough to be known for all time as the guy with the Hitler quote under your senior photo, that is your perogative. However, the school is actually the one publishing the yearbook and it is a representation of their school so I think they do get the final veto on what is published in it.

Posted 6/13/06 9:54 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

I think the school should absolutely take it out.

Freedom of speech does not extend to yearbook quotes. You can't use foul language or hate speech, and imo you shouldn't be able to quote hitler either.

Posted 6/13/06 9:56 AM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

On one hand, yes, I agree with free speech and I think the students should be allowed to use the quotes they want.

But on the other hand, a school is not a democracy, so i think the quotes should be removed.

If they want to make t-shirts with the quotes on them and wear them around the mall - go for it!

Posted 6/13/06 9:56 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

And how would you feel if it was a quote by Charles Manson?

Posted 6/13/06 9:57 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

It would depend on the quote I guess. I dont think they should be quoting murderers. JMO.

I kept an open mind and waited to read what those quotes were from hitler, and to me there was no way to take them out of the context of the horrors of the holocaust

Posted 6/13/06 9:58 AM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by nrthshgrl

And how would you feel if it was a quote by Charles Manson?



I would feel the same way. Yearbook quotes are scrutinized by HS students and I don't think people who have murdered or promoted hatred of other people should be quoted in a yearbook.

Posted 6/13/06 9:59 AM
 

MsG
Should be working

Member since 5/05

2824 total posts

Name:
G

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by Palebride

On one hand, yes, I agree with free speech and I think the students should be allowed to use the quotes they want.

But on the other hand, a school is not a democracy, so i think the quotes should be removed.

If they want to make t-shirts with the quotes on them and wear them around the mall - go for it!



I agree.

Posted 6/13/06 10:00 AM
 

Ren
LIF Infant

Member since 11/05

203 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

I think the seniors were stupid to think that they would not receive some sort of critism about chosing quotes from Hitler. However I do believe in free speech, and if the 2 quotes were used ("Strength lies not in defense but attack," "The great masses of people will more easily fall victims to a big lie than to a small one.") without the authors name, how many of us would know who said it? If I saw those quotes, I would think of any number of people, or movies that it may have come from. I think the yearbook staff/school district should have been more careful with their editing.

Posted 6/13/06 10:05 AM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

School-sponsored speech such as school newspapers can be subject to censorship and control by school officials. I think a yearbook is similar and should also be monitored by the school. While freedom of speech exists in the school setting, there are limitations. I don't think it's appropriate to quote Hitler or serial killers in a yearbook.

Posted 6/13/06 10:06 AM
 

Summer05
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

2320 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by Ren

I think the seniors were stupid to think that they would not receive some sort of critism about chosing quotes from Hitler. However I do believe in free speech, and if the 2 quotes were used ("Strength lies not in defense but attack," "The great masses of people will more easily fall victims to a big lie than to a small one.") without the authors name, how many of us would know who said it? If I saw those quotes, I would think of any number of people, or movies that it may have come from. I think the yearbook staff/school district should have been more careful with their editing.



I agree!

Posted 6/13/06 10:11 AM
 

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

I am a strong believer in free speech but school is not the place to practive free speech. Schools have a responsibility to teach ethics and social responsibility. Certain things just do not belong in a school setting. The same way you can't tell a teacher to go f themselves, students should not be allowed to quote from the leader of one of the worst atrocities in human history.

Posted 6/13/06 10:14 AM
 

LFitzy79
can hardly wait

Member since 5/05

2650 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by JenniferEver

I think the school should absolutely take it out.

Freedom of speech does not extend to yearbook quotes. You can't use foul language or hate speech, and imo you shouldn't be able to quote hitler either.



Freedom of speech extends well beyond yearbook quotes. It's not something that can have limitations.
Hitler is a horrifying human being, and anyone that quotes him is a disgrace, however, I'm proud to live in a country where people can quote hitler, and other's can tell them they are disgusting for doing so....when you start censoring what/whom you can quote you take a step closer to being narrow minded, and burning books.
As you stated on another thread "only a sith sees things in black and white"

Message edited 2006-06-13 10:21:16.983000.

Posted 6/13/06 10:18 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

The point is that it's a school publication. They have a right to edit it. Just like you can't put like "F--K YOU Lincoln HS", you can't put hitler quotes. If they want to put it on their website, that's fine, but the school is responsible for the content of the yearbook, and as such, I don't feel it approprioate for a school publication

Posted 6/13/06 10:21 AM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by LFitzy79

Posted by JenniferEver

I think the school should absolutely take it out.

Freedom of speech does not extend to yearbook quotes. You can't use foul language or hate speech, and imo you shouldn't be able to quote hitler either.



Freedom of speech extends well beyond yearbook quotes. It's not something that can have limitations.
Hitler is a horrifying human being, and anyone that quotes him is a disgrace, however, I'm proud to live in a country where people can quote hitler, and other's can tell them they are disgusting for doing so....when you start censoring what/whom you can quote you take a step closer to being narrow minded, and burning books.
As you stated on another thread "only a sith sees things in black and white"



Freedom of speech is not absolute in a school setting. The school has a right to pull articles from a newspaper and should therefore have a right to pull yearbook quotes.

Posted 6/13/06 10:25 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by LFitzy79

Posted by JenniferEver

I think the school should absolutely take it out.

Freedom of speech does not extend to yearbook quotes. You can't use foul language or hate speech, and imo you shouldn't be able to quote hitler either.



Freedom of speech extends well beyond yearbook quotes. It's not something that can have limitations.
Hitler is a horrifying human being, and anyone that quotes him is a disgrace, however, I'm proud to live in a country where people can quote hitler, and other's can tell them they are disgusting for doing so....when you start censoring what/whom you can quote you take a step closer to being narrow minded, and burning books.
As you stated on another thread "only a sith sees things in black and white"




I agree

Posted 6/13/06 10:34 AM
 

MommyofG
just the girls

Member since 5/05

9461 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

I dont see anything wrong with it. There are all kinds of people in this world, I'd rather want to know upfront what is on someones mind than be left to wonder. Its no surprise there are haters out there and it is something that will probably never change. As far as the year book- its freedom of speech, if they want to take it out so what, its not going to change how these kids feel and the way they think. It will probably justify to them what they are thinking is right. Its not like they drew a swat sticker under their picture.
Look at some of these rock songs that "made" kids commit suicide- Ive seen lots of those lyrics from rock songs quoted in year books and in other school type banners/posters/papers. Its all freedom of speech. I think b/c its "Hitler" is why it became a problem, not the actual quotes themselves.

Posted 6/13/06 10:35 AM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by LFitzy79

Posted by JenniferEver

I think the school should absolutely take it out.

Freedom of speech does not extend to yearbook quotes. You can't use foul language or hate speech, and imo you shouldn't be able to quote hitler either.



Freedom of speech extends well beyond yearbook quotes. It's not something that can have limitations.
Hitler is a horrifying human being, and anyone that quotes him is a disgrace, however, I'm proud to live in a country where people can quote hitler, and other's can tell them they are disgusting for doing so....when you start censoring what/whom you can quote you take a step closer to being narrow minded, and burning books.
As you stated on another thread "only a sith sees things in black and white"



I agree. And in truth, many people who are quoted on a regular basis are considered "great," even if they also have killed....FDR for example...

I do think that people have the right to be offended or aggravated over it, but I am not fan of sensorship in ANY form...JMHO

Posted 6/13/06 10:37 AM
 

Ren
LIF Infant

Member since 11/05

203 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by girlygrl33

I dont see anything wrong with it. There are all kinds of people in this world, I'd rather want to know upfront what is on someones mind than be left to wonder. Its no surprise there are haters out there and it is something that will probably never change. As far as the year book- its freedom of speech, if they want to take it out so what, its not going to change how these kids feel and the way they think. It will probably justify to them what they are thinking is right. Its not like they drew a swat sticker under their picture.
Look at some of these rock songs that "made" kids commit suicide- Ive seen lots of those lyrics from rock songs quoted in year books and in other school type banners/posters/papers. Its all freedom of speech. I think b/c its "Hitler" is why it became a problem, not the actual quotes themselves.



I agree. While I see where people will get offended that a quote from Hitler was used, it's the name, not the quote that's in question. Tons of Christians were offened by John Lennon and The Beatles in the 60s when they said they werw bigger than Jesus. Yet I bet there are tons of Lennon/Beatle quotes in yearbooks (me included). I realize it's ridiculus to compare the 2, but like has been said, the quotes used were not offensive, just the name associated with it.

Posted 6/13/06 10:53 AM
 

Shanti
True love

Member since 6/05

12653 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

There's a huge difference between Hitler and other people being mentioned on this thread. You cannot even compare. Sure, someone may get offended by an FDR quote but let's be reasonable. Hitler stands in a category of his own.

I am asking this out of curiosity for people who are free speech advocates and think it is okay in schools, where do you draw the line in schools? Can students curse at one another or teachers? What can you do at your job? Could you quote Hitler openly at a meeting?

Posted 6/13/06 11:00 AM
 

SweetestOfPeas
J'taime Paris!

Member since 3/06

32345 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by dpli

On the one hand, I can see the argument for free speech and if you are foolish enough to be known for all time as the guy with the Hitler quote under your senior photo, that is your perogative. However, the school is actually the one publishing the yearbook and it is a representation of their school so I think they do get the final veto on what is published in it.

well said

Posted 6/13/06 11:04 AM
 

MsMBV
:P

Member since 5/05

28602 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by DMcK

There's a huge difference between Hitler and other people being mentioned on this thread. You cannot even compare. Sure, someone may get offended by an FDR quote but let's be reasonable. Hitler stands in a category of his own.

I am asking this out of curiosity for people who are free speech advocates and think it is okay in schools, where do you draw the line in schools? Can students curse at one another or teachers? What can you do at your job? Could you quote Hitler openly at a meeting?



Please do not take this the wrong way, but to someone here there may be a a huge difference between Hitler & FDR, Truman, Naopleon...etc. But to someone else I am not so sure. The beauty of free speech is that it has nothing to do with reaction or response. TFree speech is what is says, Free. People absolutely have the right to be offended, and if students or parents do not want to pay thier money to see those quotes listed in their yearbook, then it is their right.

And as far as teachers cursing or mentioning these quotes at a meeting at work, I think that most people would do what is socially acceptable, as there is a job involved. It is not the same type of forum, IMO.

Posted 6/13/06 11:04 AM
 

Summer05
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

2320 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by SweetestOfPeas

Posted by dpli

On the one hand, I can see the argument for free speech and if you are foolish enough to be known for all time as the guy with the Hitler quote under your senior photo, that is your perogative. However, the school is actually the one publishing the yearbook and it is a representation of their school so I think they do get the final veto on what is published in it.

well said



I agree 100%

Posted 6/13/06 11:05 AM
 

MrsS2005
Mom of 3

Member since 11/05

13118 total posts

Name:
B

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by MsMBV

Posted by DMcK

There's a huge difference between Hitler and other people being mentioned on this thread. You cannot even compare. Sure, someone may get offended by an FDR quote but let's be reasonable. Hitler stands in a category of his own.

I am asking this out of curiosity for people who are free speech advocates and think it is okay in schools, where do you draw the line in schools? Can students curse at one another or teachers? What can you do at your job? Could you quote Hitler openly at a meeting?



Please do not take this the wrong way, but to someone here there may be a a huge difference between Hitler & FDR, Truman, Naopleon...etc. But to someone else I am not so sure. The beauty of free speech is that it has nothing to do with reaction or response. TFree speech is what is says, Free. People absolutely have the right to be offended, and if students or parents do not want to pay thier money to see those quotes listed in their yearbook, then it is their right.

And as far as teachers cursing or mentioning these quotes at a meeting at work, I think that most people would do what is socially acceptable, as there is a job involved. It is not the same type of forum, IMO.


Free speech is not absolute. There are limitations, especially in a school setting. Just as you cannot yell "fire" in a crowded building, the school has a right to censor its publications including newspapers and yearbooks.

Posted 6/13/06 11:07 AM
 

MommyofG
just the girls

Member since 5/05

9461 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?

Posted by DMcK

There's a huge difference between Hitler and other people being mentioned on this thread. You cannot even compare. Sure, someone may get offended by an FDR quote but let's be reasonable. Hitler stands in a category of his own.

I am asking this out of curiosity for people who are free speech advocates and think it is okay in schools, where do you draw the line in schools? Can students curse at one another or teachers? What can you do at your job? Could you quote Hitler openly at a meeting?

I see no difference with other people being mentioned since its really ALL contorversy! Its all the same- someone doesnt like what someone says- killers or not, people feel offended by what people say. Again those quotes are not bad at all- its the source they came from that people are angry with. Curse words are purposely said to hurt someone to their face. Quoting someone is how someone may feel about that quote- doesnt necessarily mean they agree with what Hitler did or condoned him but those particular statements- ANYONE could have said! It depends on what is quoted at a meeting , I dont like Hitler or what he did, but not all of his statements are that far fetched from what a "good" person may say as well.

Posted 6/13/06 11:08 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
YUMMY WW 2 PT SNACK ALERT!! Repost..cause I posted on the wrong board... Cookiegobbler 1/23/06 10 Diet & Fitness
OK, I need honest opinions. Am I wrong? (VERY long) Scotty-CassidysMom 1/8/06 9 Families Helping Families ™
Am I feeding Kevin Wrong? Veggies? Maximum amount of formula per day? MM2004 12/6/05 1 Parenting
I have a number that is a wrong number but it is restricted how can i call this person back luvsbob4603 11/15/05 7 Families Helping Families ™
i knw i am sensitive b/c i just had a DNc but this is whast so wrong with twh worlkd sometimes... 04bride 11/9/05 11 Pregnancy
i want ask you all something and let me know if you agree or am i wrong luvsbob4603 8/24/05 8 Families Helping Families ™