|
Spinoff to Do YOU see anything wrong with this?
Posted 6/13/2006 9:51:16 AM by nrthshgrl For me this is an example of freedom of speech. Granted, misguided speech but then that's my opinion too. Northport reels from Hitler yearbook quotes BY KARLA SCHUSTER Newsday Staff Writer June 13, 2006 Northport school officials will remove quotations from Adolf Hitler that were chosen by two seniors to appear under their high school yearbook pictures, saying they regret that the Nazi leader's words were published. "It's our responsibility and we failed miserably," said principal Irene McLaughlin. "The fact that the book went out in the form it did was a grave mistake on our part." Seniors at Northport High pick a quote to appear under their yearbook picture -- and the choices run the gamut from song lyrics and famous movie lines, to passages from a favorite book or the words of noted philosophers, political and historical figures. Christopher Koulermos and Philip Compton, both 18, chose to quote Hitler -- sparking dozens of angry calls from parents who found the quotations offensive, school officials said. Both quotes were attributed to Hitler. They come from Hitler's 1925 autobiographical manifesto "Mein Kampf." Koulermos chose "Strength lies not in defense but attack," while Compton picked "The great masses of people will more easily fall victims to a big lie than to a small one." Neither student returned calls Monday. McLaughlin and superintendent William Brosnan said the yearbook's student staff, and its adviser, Robert Runyan, a teacher, saw the quotations before they were published. The district has no formal policy for reviewing senior quotations, Brosnan said, but he said common sense dictated that the Hitler ones should have been run by administrators before publication. Brosnan, who is retiring July 1, noted the text of the quotes themselves is not offensive. "It's the attribution to Hitler that's offensive," he said. But Rabbi Ian Silverman of the East Northport Jewish Center said it is impossible to separate the words from the man. "Some things can't be taken out of context. They remain in context forever," he said. School officials would not comment on whether they will discipline the two students or yearbook adviser. McLaughlin said she does not think the yearbook staff or the two boys meant to offend. The district plans to send parents a written apology this week. Officials are also discussing with the publishing company either reprinting that section or offering a special white tape to those who want to cover the quotes. "I don't think they understood the ramifications," McLaughlin said, who didn't know about the quotes until parents complained. Next year, the school may use a committee of parents, teachers and students to review senior quotations. That, many students say, amounts to censorship. "I think it's been blown completely out of proportion," said senior Joanna Dickman, 17. "I don't believe they should censor your senior quote ... I mean, if that's what those guys want to be remembered by, that's up to them." |