Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2]

stinger
LIF Adult

Member since 11/11

4971 total posts

Name:

Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I went to a district with high ratings on LI. Many graduates went on to good colleges. Many came from families with money. However, we had our fair share of deaths during and after high school due to drugs.

Posted 11/30/14 7:30 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I went to NYC public elementary and middle schools, I live in the best district in NYC and the education was superb as was the exposure to other cultures, races, kids from other socioeconomic backgrounds. I went to catholic HS in LI and while it was a lot of fun I don't think I got the best education there, I was not challenged whereas as an honors student in my NYC middle school I had to work my ass off to keep up. I went to a private college and I think I received an incredible education. So I guess it depends on the school but ultimately the most important factor in any child's academic success or failure is what is going on in their home, period.

Message edited 2014-11-30 19:49:29.717000.

Posted 11/30/14 7:48 PM
 

CunningOne
***

Member since 5/05

26975 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by Millie3

Posted by MrsA1012

I went to private school from grade 1 through 12. Yes, it shaped me in many, many ways both personally and academically.



Same here. I completely agree.



same here

Posted 11/30/14 8:20 PM
 

TheDivineMrsM
2 girls 4 me!

Member since 8/08

7878 total posts

Name:
Mama mama mama....

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by DiamondGirl
So I guess it depends on the school but ultimately the most important factor in any child's academic success or failure is what is going on in their home, period.



Agreed! I went to an "average" school district growing up. I was a top kid, and hung out with my fellow nerds. I went to a good college. Now, I am an educator myself.

I've work in one of the best schools in the state, but I've worked in average and "bad" schools too - including a school that was doing so poorly that NYC shut their doors. I know the family's attitude towards education is the best predictor of how the child will ultimately do.

On Long Island, I think almost all the districts provide a solid education.

Posted 11/30/14 8:26 PM
 

jerrysgirl
I love my hot dog!!

Member since 6/06

5357 total posts

Name:
E & J

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by CunningOne

Posted by Millie3

Posted by MrsA1012

I went to private school from grade 1 through 12. Yes, it shaped me in many, many ways both personally and academically.



Same here. I completely agree.



same here



same, except i went from pre k to 12. it definitely shaped me. i went to an all girls private high school so that played a huge role in my life. everyone in my class went to college. i think one person went to a community college.

Posted 11/30/14 8:26 PM
 

drpepper318
MIR MIR MIR!

Member since 6/07

8274 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by DiamondGirl
ultimately the most important factor in any child's academic success or failure is what is going on in their home, period.


100% agree with this. My opinion... I went to a variety of schools... Catholic elementary, public nyc junior high, Catholic high school... none of which were spectacular but I did reasonably well because my family made education a priority.

Posted 11/30/14 8:27 PM
 

jerrysgirl
I love my hot dog!!

Member since 6/06

5357 total posts

Name:
E & J

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by drpepper318

Posted by DiamondGirl
ultimately the most important factor in any child's academic success or failure is what is going on in their home, period.


100% agree with this. My opinion... I went to a variety of schools... Catholic elementary, public nyc junior high, Catholic high school... none of which were spectacular but I did reasonably well because my family made education a priority.



i also agree with this. i had someone at home always encouraging me about school. i saw the importance of college with much older brothers and sisters. i have a family member who barely made it out of high school as reading and school work were not instilled in their difficult home life.

Posted 11/30/14 8:31 PM
 

Eunyboo
<3

Member since 7/12

4376 total posts

Name:
E

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by justbeachy

I was in a very rough school district on LI. But I had a great experience because I was tracked and offered AP courses, etc. very diverse district that shaped who I am, absolutely.

But would I send my child there? Since I've graduated, it's gone even more downhill. I'm friendly with the principal of the high school (my former teacher!), and some of my former retired teachers. Even THEY comment about the decline of the district. So, no, I wouldn't send my kids there now. Ever.

Eta: The thing that does make me sad is that people like me, who did have a great experience, are not returning to the school district. My fellow graduates are amazing, wonderful people, and very few will send their kids there. The decline of safety and major disciplinary issues at the school are causing people to leave. So, inherently, the district will get worse. Chat Icon It's cyclical.




Pretty much.. Word for word. I graduated from Brentwood, still live in the district but refuse to buy here. I live near the high school.. I was blessed but it is getting worse and worse.

Posted 11/30/14 9:01 PM
 

Chatham-Chick
*********************

Member since 5/05

10312 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I graduated from Sachem and had a positive experience. I loved the fact that it was such a large school. At the time when I was there, we seemed to be on top when it came to sports and there was no shortage of courses, clubs and other activities. They seemed to fit a lot of needs.

From a bullying perspective, I felt that there was a clique for everyone. I had my fair of issues with bullies, but I was grateful that the school was big enough that the whole school wasn't in on it and I had plenty of people to fall back on for friendships and support.


I don't know much about the district or area now. We needed to be close to airports and NYC, so our district was pretty much as far east as we'd consider. However, I do get concerned about the size of our current district. It's a bit too small for my liking.

My DH and his brothers went to catholic schools for their entire education (K up to and including college), with his high school being an all boys catholic HS and I feel their education was exemplary and they all seem to have very fond memories of their education.

Posted 11/30/14 9:36 PM
 

MrsA1012
love my little girl !

Member since 9/10

5777 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by jerrysgirl

Posted by CunningOne

Posted by Millie3

Posted by MrsA1012

I went to private school from grade 1 through 12. Yes, it shaped me in many, many ways both personally and academically.



Same here. I completely agree.



same here



same, except i went from pre k to 12. it definitely shaped me. i went to an all girls private high school so that played a huge role in my life. everyone in my class went to college. i think one person went to a community college. [/QUOTE Same at my school. 100 percent graduation rate, everyone Attended college,several ivies/ top ranked schools. Only difference was mine wasn't all girls, just a regular prep school.

Posted 11/30/14 9:49 PM
 

Kerie-is-so-very
versatile!

Member since 5/05

13535 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Yes. My school district played a role. I had some great teachers. I had many who were tough on us, telling us that we had to be ready for college, then when I got to college at Stony Brook, the professors were not as tough as those teachers. In high school it was a given that almost all of us of us were going to college. For better or for worse, discussion of going straight to work after graduation was very rare. I had some friends who did but I am sure that it was not without a lengthy discussion with guidance counselors. That said, I am sure that my parents would have pushed me very hard no matter where I was. The district I was in was rated highly back then but I don't remember it being #1 or 2 in the county and now in many rankings it is #1 or 2. I think I would have liked a larger district but that's more about personal preference. I liked being at a large university.

Posted 12/1/14 12:10 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by jerrysgirl

Posted by drpepper318

Posted by DiamondGirl
ultimately the most important factor in any child's academic success or failure is what is going on in their home, period.


100% agree with this. My opinion... I went to a variety of schools... Catholic elementary, public nyc junior high, Catholic high school... none of which were spectacular but I did reasonably well because my family made education a priority.



i also agree with this. i had someone at home always encouraging me about school. i saw the importance of college with much older brothers and sisters. i have a family member who barely made it out of high school as reading and school work were not instilled in their difficult home life.



Exactly. I have coworkers who went to very prestigious HSs in NYC, and prestigious colleges. They are making the same salary, doing the same job, sitting in cubicles right next to people who went to average HSs, and average colleges. The home environment for all of these people were much more important than the school itself.

Posted 12/1/14 8:53 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

ha! Yes and no.

Yes because I went to a rough school with no real hopes of being successful and they gave us Food Stamp apps to complete as 'practice' They had so little hope for us. They assumed I was a drug user, suicidal risk and a lost cause. So yeah They taught me that people suck and no one NO ONE is EVER going to expect you to be successful. YOU need to do that yourself. NO one is going to give you a hand up or support you if you don't show you want it yourself. You will fail, you will lose, they will look past you, over you and down on you because of where you went to school. So get used to it.

THAT actually HELPED me!

Plus even though I went to a crappy school district, I went to a small school behind two military bases where kids were mixed beyond belief. We had poor, middle class and the military elite. So they had to make up for the differences. I was able to go to a school with 10 Doctorates teaching. My Cal teacher had a Doctorate in Physics and was working on the Math.

So yes and no.

Posted 12/1/14 10:27 AM
 

FirstMate
My lil cowboy

Member since 10/10

7790 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I went to an average district I guess. I'm not really sure how it rates today. It had some diversity and is a blue collar town.

I did very well there. I was pushed by my parents and by my teachers. I was able to take all advanced courses and entered college as a sophomore. I have no complaints about the education I received there. I graduated in the top 10% of my class and went to a very good college. But I will say that if it wasn't for the support, or really the force at home, I could have easily gone the other way. It's not one of those districts that instills competition between its pupils to have the highest grades. I think it you were an average kid, you would have fallen through the cracks.

Posted 12/1/14 11:27 AM
 

buttercup
St. Jude pray for us...

Member since 1/11

2951 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I grew up in the city (suburbs) and I went to one of the best highschools in the country (according US Reports Chat Icon ) but I graduated from the "hood" middle school, there was a huge difference in the teachers and just the aura, but my commute was about an hour door to door. My brother on the other hand decided against this school and went to the honors program of our local highschool which is fabulous in every way but it was just different. I always got teased for going to a "nerd" school but it sure did open up lot more doors, and I think overall I had a better high school experience.. although things were lot of focused on education rather than other activities. A fight, or a drop out was unheard of.. suspension!??! what's that..kwim. I think because of where I went to highschool, my parents didn't have a lot of gray when I graduated Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/1/14 1:17 PM
 

LovesMike
LIF Adult

Member since 8/10

978 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I can honestly say that mine did. Valley Stream Central HS. Had an outstanding English program when I was there and it really stayed with me through college, where I double majored in English and Art History. My overall HS experience there was great, wouldn't change a thing. My DH teaches there now and I believe that it is still a great school, although there are detractors, of course. And the ratings, of course, but according to DH, the kids are great, the best part of his job, and the teachers are as well.

Funny story - in college, I had a roommate from suburban MD who had, of course, gone to private school her whole life. I overheard her on the phone with her mother one day saying she had read a paper I wrote for one of my English courses and that I was "actually a really good writer" and that she was surprised because I went to public school. haha.

Posted 12/1/14 1:23 PM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I went to public elementary in NYC, Catholic Middle School in NYC, and 1 year of Catholic HighSchool. Then we moved to an excellent small school district in Suffolk County.

I think the highest standards were held by the Catholic schools I went to. (Example, they wanted you to pass the regents with an 85.)

The excellent high school in Suffolk I went to seemed to care more about their rankings than about their actual students. Guidance counselors pushed everyone toward 4 year colleges-and honors grades were inflated, etc. I did very well in highschool, I was ranked 12 out of nearly 300 in my graduating class. But I only lived in the district for 3 1/2 years.

So essentially, I think success depends much more on an individual's intelligence, drive, and discipline than on what district they live in.

Posted 12/1/14 1:23 PM
 

Christine Braun - Signature Premier Properties
LIFamilies Business

Member since 2/11

3992 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I think my educational experiences shaped me, as they do everyone. But I don't think that the ranking of my school district had a significant impact on my personal success.

I went to Seaford High - solid, good school, but not the highest ranked school or in the top tier of LI districts. I graduated at the top of my class, had a college scholarship and went to an Ivy League law school.

I think I had a lot of advantages to start me off on the right path that had nothing to do with the ranking of my school. My parents encouraged my education and expected me to put effort into my school work - they were supportive and involved. I think another factor in my own academic success is that it came fairly easy to me and that I was also motivated to succeed.

My school -- while not top-ranked -- offered honors track classes, lots of AP classes, extracurricular activities (like sports, drama, community service), a great music program -- and kids took advantage of them and were involved in school. I had good teachers and mentors, and the school administration at the time ran a tight ship. They cared about the school and community, and encouraged the students to have pride in themselves and the community. I think all of those things are important to having a good school experience and giving every opportunity to succeed. And if they are present, then I consider that a "good" school regardless of the rankings.

My school was not SUPER competitive with academics (although of course there was some natural competition among top students). It was not the type of school where people took private SAT prep courses or crumbled under academic pressure. Most of us had after school jobs. There were certainly people who didn't go to college or who went to a community college, as well as people who went to top colleges and Ivy League schools.

If I had gone to a school where academics was more of the sole focus, or that was ranked in the top 5 schools on LI, I don't think I would have turned out any differently! : )

So I guess I would say -- while it's unrealistic to say that the school you attend has no impact on a student whatsoever (because it definitely shapes your experiences, attitudes, etc.), I don't think the ranking of a HIGH school will make or break anyone or really dictate their success.

I also think that the prestige of a college or grad school is much more important than a high school because that is where alumni connections and job recruiting and all of that can come into play. When I went on interviews for law jobs at top firms, doors definitely opened because I went to a top law school. But I don't think PUBLIC high school rankings have that kind of influence (or any, really!).

Posted 12/1/14 6:18 PM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by Chatham-Chick

I graduated from Sachem and had a positive experience. I loved the fact that it was such a large school. At the time when I was there, we seemed to be on top when it came to sports and there was no shortage of courses, clubs and other activities. They seemed to fit a lot of needs.

From a bullying perspective, I felt that there was a clique for everyone. I had my fair of issues with bullies, but I was grateful that the school was big enough that the whole school wasn't in on it and I had plenty of people to fall back on for friendships and support.


I don't know much about the district or area now. We needed to be close to airports and NYC, so our district was pretty much as far east as we'd consider. However, I do get concerned about the size of our current district. It's a bit too small for my liking.

My DH and his brothers went to catholic schools for their entire education (K up to and including college), with his high school being an all boys catholic HS and I feel their education was exemplary and they all seem to have very fond memories of their education.



I had no idea you were a Sachem graduate. A 1000 unit rental complex is going up behind us and in combination with their tanking scores, we are pretty concerned ... Chat Icon

Message edited 2014-12-17 15:16:20.790000.

Posted 12/17/14 5:13 AM
 

Faithx2
All good things in 2016!!

Member since 8/05

20181 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by DaniRella

Hell yes.

My scholastic experience was superb.

My parents arranged it that way too - that's why they moved us to this district.

I always receive compliments on how I write. I personally don't get it Chat Icon but, I always credit it to my HS education. The english department at my school was phenomenal.



Where did you go, if you don't mind me asking?

Message edited 2014-12-17 15:12:48.483000.

Posted 12/17/14 9:02 AM
 

sunnyflies
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1757 total posts

Name:

Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

What interests me, aside from the thoughtful points of views, is the level of writing in this thread. Some is excellent, most is good, and a few pieces have several major grammatical errors that are clearly habitual. Food for thought in a discussion about education. Now, I will run for cover!

Message edited 2014-12-17 13:04:01.037000.

Posted 12/17/14 1:02 PM
 

Ian&EmmesMommy23
My family is complete!

Member since 11/08

12970 total posts

Name:
Diana

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

i grew up in the NYC schools in Canarsie, Brooklyn. No it did not shape me Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/17/14 1:04 PM
 

JRsMaMa
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

2044 total posts

Name:
Jake's Mama

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Absolutely not. I grew up in Queens in a very working middle class district. We had children from other areas bussed in to take advantage of "all we had to offer" which wasn't much.

There were fights and gangs (I'm sure) more so when I was HS age but by then I went to catholic school.

I made the most out of my education. I worked hard. We all followed the same curriculum. I firmly believe it's the student that makes the most of their education not what district they are taught in.

Posted 12/17/14 1:31 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
which school in oceanside school district do you think is best? 04bride 10/4/10 6 Home
School district boundaries capricorn75 6/9/05 2 Home
What school district is ... emc 6/6/05 7 Home
Anyone know about the Herricks school district? 04bride 5/31/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
Sayville school district? dandj 5/18/05 0 Career
School District dawn0717 5/11/05 15 Parenting