Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

LastLightGlow
Mystic.

Member since 4/07

2665 total posts

Name:

Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Do you think your own personal successes or shortcomings in life were influenced by your childhood school district?

ETA: Was your school district perceived to be desirable by those from other areas?

Message edited 2014-11-29 21:50:50.217000.

Posted 11/29/14 8:29 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsA1012
love my little girl !

Member since 9/10

5777 total posts

Name:
Me

Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I went to private school from grade 1 through 12. Yes, it shaped me in many, many ways both personally and academically.

Posted 11/29/14 8:32 PM
 

DaniJude
You're My Home <3

Member since 11/06

14815 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Hell yes.

My scholastic experience was superb.

My parents arranged it that way too - that's why they moved us to this district.

I always receive compliments on how I write. I personally don't get it Chat Icon but, I always credit it to my HS education. The english department at my school was phenomenal.

Posted 11/29/14 8:59 PM
 

Millie3
LIF Adult

Member since 7/13

1280 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by MrsA1012

I went to private school from grade 1 through 12. Yes, it shaped me in many, many ways both personally and academically.



Same here. I completely agree.

Posted 11/29/14 9:06 PM
 

kahlua716
3 Girls for Me!

Member since 8/07

12475 total posts

Name:
Keri

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

No. I did very well in school- I was among the top of my class and was very involved.

I know people who were the complete opposite.

School is what you make of it.

Posted 11/29/14 9:14 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I think what district you're in makes a huge difference. I'm all for giving your child the best education you can, it's why DH and I bought a smaller house in a really good school district over a bigger house in a lesser one.

My parents moved us when I was ten, we lived in Copiague, and back when we moved in 1985 the area and school was changing a lot, and not in a good way. The friends I left behind didn't do great in school, many were left back, some didn't graduate, and a lot of them didn't go on to college. I think my life would've been VERY different had I stayed in that district. I'm thankful my parents moved me and my siblings to a nicer area and into better schools.

I think the schools you attend have a big impact on your future success. When I was teaching in the city (I wasn't in good areas) I use to tell my DH I felt bad for many of the bright kids I came across because if they had the opportunity to attend better schools they would excel so much more but I felt they were hindered by the district they were in and the many behavioral issues within the classrooms/school as a whole.

There is nothing wrong with wanting to try and give your kids the best education and opportunities possible, I'm glad that was a priority for my parents and it's a priority for me as well.

Message edited 2014-11-29 21:24:02.930000.

Posted 11/29/14 9:23 PM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Yes, I think it did. I felt there was a big push for academics for those that were strong and they had a terrific program for those students that struggled. I was in the former category; my sisters were in the latter.

Posted 11/29/14 9:46 PM
 

shadows
LIF Adult

Member since 1/10

4694 total posts

Name:

Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Yes, I believe it did.

Message edited 2014-11-29 22:05:57.137000.

Posted 11/29/14 9:56 PM
 

LSP2005
Bunny kisses are so cute!

Member since 5/05

19461 total posts

Name:
L

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Absolutely. We moved to a better district for our children and want from top 15 to 7 and I can see the difference between the two schools at this level too. I do think where you go to school, the people you meet, and the contacts you make have an enormous impact upon your success. Of course, it is what you make of it, but, you will have a much easier path to success if you are already starting out in a successful position.

Posted 11/29/14 10:04 PM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I'm not from LI and grew up in an area of NY with no diversity.

While I received a good education, there's a lot to be said for missing that piece.

I also think because I grew up with all white kids, it also hid a lot of other issues that I became more apparent of as I grew up. There was and still is a lot of poverty in that area, and a lot of ignorance too. I have to block a lot of my HS classmates come political time.

We are in the district another poster mentioned now and so far, have no issues with our son. He is in elementary school though.

It is definitely coming out of your comfort zone though when you walk in the school and are not used to being around black and Spanish people.

We have always said however that we will deal with issues as they occur. If we end up needing to move, or send DS to private school, we will deal with it then.

I know a lot of the newer grads (not people from 1985) and they are completely different from how Hofstra paints them.

Also many younger families are moving here to start out and are involved with the district.

At the same time, many people have lived here for generations and are super involved. People when they meet me know who I am because they know my neighbor across the street. Chat Icon

Lastly, you all know what I do for a living, so obviously that as well contributes to my experience in dealing with people, since those who are poor or a different race from me don't scare me.

I've worked with people who are middle and upper class on a professional level, and honestly, they are tougher to deal with because of their overall sense of entitlement.

ETA: we also looked in "better districts" but this is where we ended up based on our budget, and lack of inventory/bidding wars in other areas. Again, we are happy so far and the reason I get mad about the school district wars, is when people make blanket statements about a community, especially without being from that community, it is hard to NOT take that personally. You ARE talking about me and my family when you do that ;)

Message edited 2014-11-30 06:47:13.983000.

Posted 11/30/14 6:42 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

I'm not from LI and grew up in an area of NY with no diversity.

While I received a good education, there's a lot to be said for missing that piece.

I also think because I grew up with all white kids, it also hid a lot of other issues that I became more apparent of as I grew up. There was and still is a lot of poverty in that area, and a lot of ignorance too. I have to block a lot of my HS classmates come political time.

We are in the district another poster mentioned now and so far, have no issues with our son. He is in elementary school though.

It is definitely coming out of your comfort zone though when you walk in the school and are not used to being around black and Spanish people.

We have always said however that we will deal with issues as they occur. If we end up needing to move, or send DS to private school, we will deal with it then.

I know a lot of the newer grads (not people from 1985) and they are completely different from how Hofstra paints them.

Also many younger families are moving here to start out and are involved with the district.

At the same time, many people have lived here for generations and are super involved. People when they meet me know who I am because they know my neighbor across the street. Chat Icon

Lastly, you all know what I do for a living, so obviously that as well contributes to my experience in dealing with people, since those who are poor or a different race from me don't scare me.

I've worked with people who are middle and upper class on a professional level, and honestly, they are tougher to deal with because of their overall sense of entitlement.

ETA: we also looked in "better districts" but this is where we ended up based on our budget, and lack of inventory/bidding wars in other areas. Again, we are happy so far and the reason I get mad about the school district wars, is when people make blanket statements about a community, especially without being from that community, it is hard to NOT take that personally. You ARE talking about me and my family when you do that ;)



We all have different experiences and expectations when it comes to education. If you're happy in your district, that's all that matters. My parents were not happy for a variety of reasons in that district and that's why we moved...........that was MY experience. I wasn't making blanket statements, I was sharing my very real experience in that district and living in that town for years.

Posted 11/30/14 9:39 AM
 

oldtimerocknroll
LIF Adult

Member since 11/14

1657 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I went to Catholic school for preschool, elementary, and high school. I believe the curriculum and environment of a Catholic school has shaped me in positive ways. Yes, part of this experience, for me, was the religious and spiritual environment and the family bonds formed within the school; the other part is the fact that I selected the school myself, so clearly, I picked one that lined up with my wants.

I think schools can shape people, but I also think that family involvement is extremely important. Additionally, I think many factors must be considered when selecting a school. As another poster said, diversity is important. Yes, I know I said I went to Catholic school; however, we had all levels of beliefs, different religions, and, of course, students from all cultural and racial backgrounds.

The school district DH and I are in now is often shamed. Yet it receives rankings similar to school districts that are praised. I also have personal experience there, and I was very impressed by the quality of the education. To me, it seems clear that people do not always look at the full picture of a school.

Posted 11/30/14 9:51 AM
 

justbeachy
So close....

Member since 7/07

2900 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I was in a very rough school district on LI. But I had a great experience because I was tracked and offered AP courses, etc. very diverse district that shaped who I am, absolutely.

But would I send my child there? Since I've graduated, it's gone even more downhill. I'm friendly with the principal of the high school (my former teacher!), and some of my former retired teachers. Even THEY comment about the decline of the district. So, no, I wouldn't send my kids there now. Ever.

Eta: The thing that does make me sad is that people like me, who did have a great experience, are not returning to the school district. My fellow graduates are amazing, wonderful people, and very few will send their kids there. The decline of safety and major disciplinary issues at the school are causing people to leave. So, inherently, the district will get worse. Chat Icon It's cyclical.

Message edited 2014-11-30 10:24:19.840000.

Posted 11/30/14 10:20 AM
 

ANewDayHasCome
Love multiplies, not divides

Member since 11/12

14481 total posts

Name:
Me

Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Yes, I went to one of the top schools in the country. I came into college with a lot of college credits bc my hs offered Syracuse classes as well as the standard AP.

Posted 11/30/14 10:40 AM
 

MichLiz213
Life is Good!

Member since 7/07

7979 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Yes.

I went to a diverse school and received an outstanding education. I also took advantage of many extra-curricular opportunities. I was a bright student and received enrichment. On the flip side, one of my brothers has special needs and received an excellent education as well from the same district.

Posted 11/30/14 11:40 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

I'm not from LI and grew up in an area of NY with no diversity.

While I received a good education, there's a lot to be said for missing that piece.

I also think because I grew up with all white kids, it also hid a lot of other issues that I became more apparent of as I grew up. There was and still is a lot of poverty in that area, and a lot of ignorance too. I have to block a lot of my HS classmates come political time.

We are in the district another poster mentioned now and so far, have no issues with our son. He is in elementary school though.

It is definitely coming out of your comfort zone though when you walk in the school and are not used to being around black and Spanish people.

We have always said however that we will deal with issues as they occur. If we end up needing to move, or send DS to private school, we will deal with it then.

I know a lot of the newer grads (not people from 1985) and they are completely different from how Hofstra paints them.

Also many younger families are moving here to start out and are involved with the district.

At the same time, many people have lived here for generations and are super involved. People when they meet me know who I am because they know my neighbor across the street. Chat Icon

Lastly, you all know what I do for a living, so obviously that as well contributes to my experience in dealing with people, since those who are poor or a different race from me don't scare me.

I've worked with people who are middle and upper class on a professional level, and honestly, they are tougher to deal with because of their overall sense of entitlement.

ETA: we also looked in "better districts" but this is where we ended up based on our budget, and lack of inventory/bidding wars in other areas. Again, we are happy so far and the reason I get mad about the school district wars, is when people make blanket statements about a community, especially without being from that community, it is hard to NOT take that personally. You ARE talking about me and my family when you do that ;)



We all have different experiences and expectations when it comes to education. If you're happy in your district, that's all that matters. My parents were not happy for a variety of reasons in that district and that's why we moved...........that was MY experience. I wasn't making blanket statements, I was sharing my very real experience in that district and living in that town for years.




I truly mean no disrespect but you pretty much come across at this point as talking out of both sides of your face.

Posted 11/30/14 12:03 PM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

I'm not from LI and grew up in an area of NY with no diversity.

While I received a good education, there's a lot to be said for missing that piece.

I also think because I grew up with all white kids, it also hid a lot of other issues that I became more apparent of as I grew up. There was and still is a lot of poverty in that area, and a lot of ignorance too. I have to block a lot of my HS classmates come political time.

We are in the district another poster mentioned now and so far, have no issues with our son. He is in elementary school though.

It is definitely coming out of your comfort zone though when you walk in the school and are not used to being around black and Spanish people.

We have always said however that we will deal with issues as they occur. If we end up needing to move, or send DS to private school, we will deal with it then.

I know a lot of the newer grads (not people from 1985) and they are completely different from how Hofstra paints them.

Also many younger families are moving here to start out and are involved with the district.

At the same time, many people have lived here for generations and are super involved. People when they meet me know who I am because they know my neighbor across the street. Chat Icon

Lastly, you all know what I do for a living, so obviously that as well contributes to my experience in dealing with people, since those who are poor or a different race from me don't scare me.

I've worked with people who are middle and upper class on a professional level, and honestly, they are tougher to deal with because of their overall sense of entitlement.

ETA: we also looked in "better districts" but this is where we ended up based on our budget, and lack of inventory/bidding wars in other areas. Again, we are happy so far and the reason I get mad about the school district wars, is when people make blanket statements about a community, especially without being from that community, it is hard to NOT take that personally. You ARE talking about me and my family when you do that ;)



We all have different experiences and expectations when it comes to education. If you're happy in your district, that's all that matters. My parents were not happy for a variety of reasons in that district and that's why we moved...........that was MY experience. I wasn't making blanket statements, I was sharing my very real experience in that district and living in that town for years.




I truly mean no disrespect but you pretty much come across at this point as talking out of both sides of your face.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 11/30/14 12:51 PM
 

MrsA1012
love my little girl !

Member since 9/10

5777 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

Posted by Hofstra26

Posted by MorningCuppaCoffee

I'm not from LI and grew up in an area of NY with no diversity.

While I received a good education, there's a lot to be said for missing that piece.

I also think because I grew up with all white kids, it also hid a lot of other issues that I became more apparent of as I grew up. There was and still is a lot of poverty in that area, and a lot of ignorance too. I have to block a lot of my HS classmates come political time.

We are in the district another poster mentioned now and so far, have no issues with our son. He is in elementary school though.

It is definitely coming out of your comfort zone though when you walk in the school and are not used to being around black and Spanish people.

We have always said however that we will deal with issues as they occur. If we end up needing to move, or send DS to private school, we will deal with it then.

I know a lot of the newer grads (not people from 1985) and they are completely different from how Hofstra paints them.

Also many younger families are moving here to start out and are involved with the district.

At the same time, many people have lived here for generations and are super involved. People when they meet me know who I am because they know my neighbor across the street. Chat Icon

Lastly, you all know what I do for a living, so obviously that as well contributes to my experience in dealing with people, since those who are poor or a different race from me don't scare me.

I've worked with people who are middle and upper class on a professional level, and honestly, they are tougher to deal with because of their overall sense of entitlement.

ETA: we also looked in "better districts" but this is where we ended up based on our budget, and lack of inventory/bidding wars in other areas. Again, we are happy so far and the reason I get mad about the school district wars, is when people make blanket statements about a community, especially without being from that community, it is hard to NOT take that personally. You ARE talking about me and my family when you do that ;)



We all have different experiences and expectations when it comes to education. If you're happy in your district, that's all that matters. My parents were not happy for a variety of reasons in that district and that's why we moved...........that was MY experience. I wasn't making blanket statements, I was sharing my very real experience in that district and living in that town for years.




I truly mean no disrespect but you pretty much come across at this point as talking out of both sides of your face.

Why ? She is stating her experience and you are stating yours. Why can't you have a different perspective ?

Posted 11/30/14 1:03 PM
 

Kitten1929
LIF Adult

Member since 1/13

6040 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I lived in a very diverse district. I was involved in lots of extracurricular activities, and had a wonderful academic experience. I would love to live in the same district, but my husband's job keeps us too far east. I went to a good college and graduated with a BA and have a career I love. It was due to having caring and focused teachers and parents who were involved in my education. They could have afforded to move to "better" districts, but they loved our community as a whole and were happy with our district.

I hate the school district debate with a passion. There are just too many factors that play into where people can live and what district they fall into. You can live in the wealthiest area with the best district, but still have kids grow up to be failures because their parents weren't home or were too lax with discipline, and you can have the same in a middle class town and district.

Snobbery exists the way it does on LI because people all too often equate "the best" with monetary value. Am I a bad parent because I bought a house in a middle class neighborhood and district, as opposed to renting in an affluent one? I shouldn't have to live up to other people's standards. I didn't know there was anything "bad" about my district until I was in HS, and even then it was from nasty, prejudiced adults who made uninformed opinions.

And also - times have changed. "Bad" districts from 20 years ago still have a stigma because people can't get with the times and realize that every generation brings change to districts. Why is my district still being stigmatized and judged from shit that occurred in the 1980s? Unless you still live in that area or have firshand knowledge of these "bad" districts, all it is is a bunch of secondhand rhetoric.

Posted 11/30/14 1:16 PM
 

Seawolf
LIF Adult

Member since 3/14

1336 total posts

Name:
Scrumba

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I'm from (and still live in) East Islip. Great schools education-wise but wow what a cliquey school district to grow up in.

Posted 11/30/14 1:19 PM
 

Teach723
Have faith. Believe. Dream.

Member since 8/10

2356 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by Kitten1929

I lived in a very diverse district. I was involved in lots of extracurricular activities, and had a wonderful academic experience. I would love to live in the same district, but my husband's job keeps us too far east. I went to a good college and graduated with a BA and have a career I love. It was due to having caring and focused teachers and parents who were involved in my education. They could have afforded to move to "better" districts, but they loved our community as a whole and were happy with our district.

I hate the school district debate with a passion. There are just too many factors that play into where people can live and what district they fall into. You can live in the wealthiest area with the best district, but still have kids grow up to be failures because their parents weren't home or were too lax with discipline, and you can have the same in a middle class town and district.

Snobbery exists the way it does on LI because people all too often equate "the best" with monetary value. Am I a bad parent because I bought a house in a middle class neighborhood and district, as opposed to renting in an affluent one? I shouldn't have to live up to other people's standards. I didn't know there was anything "bad" about my district until I was in HS, and even then it was from nasty, prejudiced adults who made uninformed opinions.

And also - times have changed. "Bad" districts from 20 years ago still have a stigma because people can't get with the times and realize that every generation brings change to districts. Why is my district still being stigmatized and judged from shit that occurred in the 1980s? Unless you still live in that area or have firshand knowledge of these "bad" districts, all it is is a bunch of secondhand rhetoric.




Chat Icon Chat Icon
Very well said!

Posted 11/30/14 1:31 PM
 

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17796 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

Posted by kahlua716

No. I did very well in school- I was among the top of my class and was very involved.

I know people who were the complete opposite.

School is what you make of it.



Same.

Posted 11/30/14 5:33 PM
 

BaysideForever
LIF Adult

Member since 1/11

9976 total posts

Name:

Re: Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

yes yes and yes. for both dh and myself.

Posted 11/30/14 5:39 PM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I would have done well in any district. But that is due to my parents. My mom was a HS teacher and she always pushed me to do my best and both my mom and dad taught me what a good education could do. I get my work ethic from them.

Eta - my DH went to in of the worst districs in LI and he is one of the hardest working person I know. He is probably smarter than I am and he went to undergrad and law school. So I think your district means less than your famy life. A good support system ( and I don't mean financially) means the most IMO.

Message edited 2014-11-30 18:04:22.673000.

Posted 11/30/14 6:02 PM
 

LuckyStar
LIF Adult

Member since 7/14

7274 total posts

Name:

Spinoff-Did your own school district make a difference?

I went to Catholic school in Queens....where I grew up, that's just what you did. I am grateful for the education I received, but I don't think it was significantly different than what I would have gotten in public school. I went to a run of the mill college and now have a very good job, but I don't credit that to my education, I got where I am by working my butt off.

This school district obsession on LI is honestly kind of bizarre to me. I get not wanting to send your child to an unsafe school or one where the entire school is testing below average but it seems like a status symbol more than anything else. DH and I recently bought in what I understand is a good district. Not amazing, but good for what we can afford. It was important to me to find a district with a variety of programs and a solid special ed program. We don't have kids yet and while I'd love to have the next Einstein, I probably won't and should my hypothetical kid need extra help I want it available to them.

Honestly, even if I could afford to live in a super wealthy district I wouldn't want my kids in the schools. They have their own set of problems that are, IMO, no better or worse than the mediocre districts.

Posted 11/30/14 7:13 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
which school in oceanside school district do you think is best? 04bride 10/4/10 6 Home
School district boundaries capricorn75 6/9/05 2 Home
What school district is ... emc 6/6/05 7 Home
Anyone know about the Herricks school district? 04bride 5/31/05 4 Families Helping Families ™
Sayville school district? dandj 5/18/05 0 Career
School District dawn0717 5/11/05 15 Parenting