Spin-off to Verdict
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by ItsTime2011 What do we consider a reasonable doubt? What is reasonable for me might not be reasonable for someone else. Its all very lukewarm and cloudy, this justice system that we have but I couldn't come up with a better way to do it. YES, exactly! ETA: From what I have heard in that court room, I don't think there is ANY other reasonable explanation as to why or how she died... So no matter what she confesses or says now, she can never be tried for her daughters murder?
Message edited 2011-07-05 16:59:26.260000. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:55 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by DancinBarefoot Posted by Kidsaplenty Posted by DancinBarefoot Posted by Kidsaplenty See, but just because we don't know how she died it means that you cannot prove a murder? Duct tape over mouth/nose, body thrown in a swamp, left to decompose and be fed on by animals. a mother than not only doesn't report her child missing, but goes out and parties hard and never mentions to ANYONE that the kid is missing. Computer searches for various ways to kill someone, that only the mother could have done. And the motive, to have all her responsibilities gone. Why not look at all the circumstances surrounding the death? Prove the duct tape was put on before death - you can't, and neither could the prosecution. Casey wasn't charged with failing to report her child missing. I don't even know if there is such a crime. It makes her a bad mother, maybe, but a murderer - no. Partying and drinking by themselves also don't make someone a murderer. Again, maybe a bad mother, but not a murderer. As for the searches - how many people following this trial have now googled cloroform?? Does it make any of them a murderer? I think common sense was lacking in this trial. Why would she need to put duct tape over her mouth after death? I can tell you, that "leaking decomposition fluids" would have leaked from every pore, every open orifice of her body. If it was really the issue of decomp fluids, she would have had to taped the kid's privates too. So what is the logical alternative for duct tape being only over the mouth? I'm talking LOGIC, not the most out there explanation you could possibly think of. The searches weren't just for chloroform. There were also searches for neck breaking, house hold weapons, ruptured spleen, etc. They found searches for the ingredients of chloroform AND how to make it!. Isn't that indicative of someone planning on committing a crime? If a serial rapist who was accused of drugging his victims with GHB during his crime was also found to have searches of how to make GHB and the ingredients on his computer, would you say it wasn't relevant? What other REASONABLE explanation is there for her not reporting the child missing? The partying and drinking is indicative of CELEBRATING, hello! Your kid is "missing" but she was out partying like something amazing just happened to her. And again, the partying and drinking can't be viewed as a separate issue, all the issues tie into each other no? That would be like me saying my husband walked into a knife, but leaving out the part about me arguing with him while I was holding a knife. You are starting with the assumption that Casey put the duct tape on Caylee. What if she didn't? There were no fingerprints on the duct tape, so in addition to no proof it was put on prior to death, there is no proof Casey put it on at all. Logical conclusion for duct tape? I don't know about logical, but alternative conclusion - to hold the jaw in place during decomposition. The searches may in fact be indicitive of the intent to commit a crime - but at any time before a person commits a crime, they can change their mind. Prove she didn't change her mind. Prove she made those searches to kill Caylee and not her mother, or father, or brother, or boyfriend or anyone else in her life. As for the partying and failure to report her missing etc, you can't convict her of murder because she's a bad mother. Maybe she didn't report her missing because she wasn't. Maybe she was in the trunk of the car for weeks and died of heat exhaustion in the trunk. The last day she was seen doesn't necessarily equate with the day she died. That's another thing the prosecution didn't prove - date of death. I'm sorry, but did the whole motive thing in a murder suddenly become unimportant? Who do you think had the motive? Anyway, essentially what you are saying is that short of catching her on tape or her giving a full confession, there is no real "proof" that she killed Caylee. So then how did they do it before DNA evidence was available? Don't the circumstances surrounding a crime indicate anything? 1- Why would someone who just throws a body in a swamp care if the mandible was in place during decomp? Why would it matter to them? That kind of doubt is not reasonable I think. 2-That was the last day she was seen by ANYONE. And she was with her mother. The people her mother was with never saw little Caylee. Her parents didn't have her. The kidnapping story was bogus. (ps, that kid wouldnt have lasted more than a couple hours if she was left in the trunk during the summer in Florida) 3- The searches are indicative of the intent to commit a crime, on that point you agree. But once that crime is actually carried out, with one of the items being searched used as the 'weapon", well isn't that proof that the person researching it DID decide to commit that crime? I'm sorry, but IMO the doubts you are laying out aren't logical and require a huge leap of faith and speculation to even be considered |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by Kidsaplenty Posted by DancinBarefoot Posted by Kidsaplenty Posted by DancinBarefoot Posted by Kidsaplenty See, but just because we don't know how she died it means that you cannot prove a murder? Duct tape over mouth/nose, body thrown in a swamp, left to decompose and be fed on by animals. a mother than not only doesn't report her child missing, but goes out and parties hard and never mentions to ANYONE that the kid is missing. Computer searches for various ways to kill someone, that only the mother could have done. And the motive, to have all her responsibilities gone. Why not look at all the circumstances surrounding the death? Prove the duct tape was put on before death - you can't, and neither could the prosecution. Casey wasn't charged with failing to report her child missing. I don't even know if there is such a crime. It makes her a bad mother, maybe, but a murderer - no. Partying and drinking by themselves also don't make someone a murderer. Again, maybe a bad mother, but not a murderer. As for the searches - how many people following this trial have now googled cloroform?? Does it make any of them a murderer? I think common sense was lacking in this trial. Why would she need to put duct tape over her mouth after death? I can tell you, that "leaking decomposition fluids" would have leaked from every pore, every open orifice of her body. If it was really the issue of decomp fluids, she would have had to taped the kid's privates too. So what is the logical alternative for duct tape being only over the mouth? I'm talking LOGIC, not the most out there explanation you could possibly think of. The searches weren't just for chloroform. There were also searches for neck breaking, house hold weapons, ruptured spleen, etc. They found searches for the ingredients of chloroform AND how to make it!. Isn't that indicative of someone planning on committing a crime? If a serial rapist who was accused of drugging his victims with GHB during his crime was also found to have searches of how to make GHB and the ingredients on his computer, would you say it wasn't relevant? What other REASONABLE explanation is there for her not reporting the child missing? The partying and drinking is indicative of CELEBRATING, hello! Your kid is "missing" but she was out partying like something amazing just happened to her. And again, the partying and drinking can't be viewed as a separate issue, all the issues tie into each other no? That would be like me saying my husband walked into a knife, but leaving out the part about me arguing with him while I was holding a knife. You are starting with the assumption that Casey put the duct tape on Caylee. What if she didn't? There were no fingerprints on the duct tape, so in addition to no proof it was put on prior to death, there is no proof Casey put it on at all. Logical conclusion for duct tape? I don't know about logical, but alternative conclusion - to hold the jaw in place during decomposition. The searches may in fact be indicitive of the intent to commit a crime - but at any time before a person commits a crime, they can change their mind. Prove she didn't change her mind. Prove she made those searches to kill Caylee and not her mother, or father, or brother, or boyfriend or anyone else in her life. As for the partying and failure to report her missing etc, you can't convict her of murder because she's a bad mother. Maybe she didn't report her missing because she wasn't. Maybe she was in the trunk of the car for weeks and died of heat exhaustion in the trunk. The last day she was seen doesn't necessarily equate with the day she died. That's another thing the prosecution didn't prove - date of death. I'm sorry, but did the whole motive thing in a murder suddenly become unimportant? Who do you think had the motive? Anyway, essentially what you are saying is that short of catching her on tape or her giving a full confession, there is no real "proof" that she killed Caylee. So then how did they do it before DNA evidence was available? Don't the circumstances surrounding a crime indicate anything? 1- Why would someone who just throws a body in a swamp care if the mandible was in place during decomp? Why would it matter to them? That kind of doubt is not reasonable I think. 2-That was the last day she was seen by ANYONE. And she was with her mother. The people her mother was with never saw little Caylee. Her parents didn't have her. The kidnapping story was bogus. (ps, that kid wouldnt have lasted more than a couple hours if she was left in the trunk during the summer in Florida) 3- The searches are indicative of the intent to commit a crime, on that point you agree. But once that crime is actually carried out, with one of the items being searched used as the 'weapon", well isn't that proof that the person researching it DID decide to commit that crime? I'm sorry, but IMO the doubts you are laying out aren't logical and require a huge leap of faith and speculation to even be considered I completely agree with you. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by brownie Posted by ItsTime2011 What do we consider a reasonable doubt? What is reasonable for me might not be reasonable for someone else. Its all very lukewarm and cloudy, this justice system that we have but I couldn't come up with a better way to do it. YES, exactly! I agree but honestly 12 different people and not one of them saw the motive, connection, nothing and decide to let her walk free FOREVER?? COME ON...we all know that you cannot try someone for the same thing twice..Double jeopardy so not one juror disagreed to at the VERY least get a hung jury. I did sit on a trial once for a crime far far far less heinous than this one and we ended up in a hung jury because we could not agree. All 12 jurors in the CA case agreed she was not guilty??? Are they dumb, blind, sleeping, brain dead. Come on. The searches for cholorform, the smell of DEATH in her car, the fact that she dumped her child like a piece of garbage with duct tape from HER house and Cayless blanket from the house..who else could have done this? Not some random stranger. Then she partied like it was 1999 living the good life she didn't have a care in the world..didn't report her daughter "missing" etc, lied to EVERYONE over and over and over and shows no remorse. That is motive...her partying. At the VERY least she should have been found guilty of Child Endangerement at the VERY LEAST....and IMO at least manslaughter. Message edited 2011-07-05 17:09:55.210000. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 5:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by Kidsaplenty I'm sorry, but did the whole motive thing in a murder suddenly become unimportant? Who do you think had the motive? Anyway, essentially what you are saying is that short of catching her on tape or her giving a full confession, there is no real "proof" that she killed Caylee. So then how did they do it before DNA evidence was available? Don't the circumstances surrounding a crime indicate anything? 1- Why would someone who just throws a body in a swamp care if the mandible was in place during decomp? Why would it matter to them? That kind of doubt is not reasonable I think. 2-That was the last day she was seen by ANYONE. And she was with her mother. The people her mother was with never saw little Caylee. Her parents didn't have her. The kidnapping story was bogus. (ps, that kid wouldnt have lasted more than a couple hours if she was left in the trunk during the summer in Florida) 3- The searches are indicative of the intent to commit a crime, on that point you agree. But once that crime is actually carried out, with one of the items being searched used as the 'weapon", well isn't that proof that the person researching it DID decide to commit that crime? I'm sorry, but IMO the doubts you are laying out aren't logical and require a huge leap of faith and speculation to even be considered As to your first question regarding motive - umm, actually, the reason a person kills another person is not an element of the crime. Is it helpful? Sure. Does it help jurors wrap their head around something horrible? Sure. But, at the end of the day, the reasons a crime is committed are not a consideration in determining a verdict. And before DNA the standards used to get convictions were different because the science was different. In 2011 with CSI and other shows like that all over the networks, juries want physical evidence. They have come to expect it. The only physical evidence connecting Casey was the "special" duct tape - and frankly, that tape connected the entire Anthony family. As the State Attorney said in his statement to the media after the verdict - they didn't find the body in time to recover evidence to be able to prove beyond a reasonable doubt how she died. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 5:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict ITA with OP |
|
Posted 7/5/11 5:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by Erica ITA with OP If we look at other countries, I'm thinking Amanda Knox in Italy, that have guilty until proven innocent, it makes me shudder. I would trust a jury of my peers over any judge that is elected (where are campaign finances coming from?) This just shows how important the voir dire is. Many people who are upset with the verdict today, came to the trial with prejudices about the case. Exactly the type of people you are supposed to eliminate during voir dire. I was on a jury for a far far less crime and in the first round only 3/16 of us were chosen. yes, it's the same thing in France too. You are guilty until found innocent. Yet, just because you are innocent until proven guilty DOES NOT mean that circumstancials cases are not strong enough to convict anyone. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 6:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict I think what it comes down to is that without enough information there is speculation that someone else culd have done it and casey covered for them. Maybe she put "medicine" in a bottle and asked a friend to feed her and she accidentally died, and then tried to make it look like murder. Or something crazy like that. I definitely think she is guilty, but I could see the jury not being to sleep at night of they convicted someone when there's even a Slight chance they could be innocent. I think it's sad but I wouldn't say the verdict is appalling or disgusting or anything like that. This is why the judicial system is the way it is |
|
Posted 7/5/11 6:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict How does the jury sleep at night after this? I cannot believe 12 grown adults made this decision in 10 hours time, without asking for any read backs of anything.. They went into deliberations and just wanted out of there. GA and CA are now receiving death threats, yes they were not the best people but why the death threats against them. Baez better have body guards for Casey when she gets out. She is on probation for other things, so she cannot leave FL is what I heard. I still cannot wrap my head around this whole case, watched for 6 weeks so I could make educated opinions, i think she should have been convicted of manslaughter, she placed herself at the pool, so why is she going free. Message edited 2011-07-05 22:18:52.257000. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 7:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict I agree with the OP. We have to remember the difference between thinking someone is guilty and being able to prove it beyond a reasonable doubt. I think she was very likely guilty, but I also think there was reasonable doubt based on the evidence presented. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 9:47 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by NervousNell Posted by DancinBarefoot Posted by Kidsaplenty See, but just because we don't know how she died it means that you cannot prove a murder? Duct tape over mouth/nose, body thrown in a swamp, left to decompose and be fed on by animals. a mother than not only doesn't report her child missing, but goes out and parties hard and never mentions to ANYONE that the kid is missing. Computer searches for various ways to kill someone, that only the mother could have done. And the motive, to have all her responsibilities gone. Why not look at all the circumstances surrounding the death? Prove the duct tape was put on before death - you can't, and neither could the prosecution. Casey wasn't charged with failing to report her child missing. I don't even know if there is such a crime. It makes her a bad mother, maybe, but a murderer - no. Partying and drinking by themselves also don't make someone a murderer. Again, maybe a bad mother, but not a murderer. As for the searches - how many people following this trial have now googled cloroform?? Does it make any of them a murderer? My question is- why would you put duct tape over the mouth of a dead body? Doesn't make much sense to me. Just because they can't prove when it was put on, does that mean common sense also needs to go out the window in the jury box? Like you have to put your common sense aside? I'm just curious about something like that... I may be mistaken but I dont think it was ever proven that the duct tape was over her mouth. It was found NEAR her mouth, attached to hair. It was only a possibility that it was over her mouth. Also, Roy Kronk admitted to moving the skull. In one story, the skull rolled out of the bag, in another he moved the skull with his meter stick. Either way, the skull was moved. because of this, who can say where the duct tape was originally? maybe it was on the bag, in the bag....we dont really know. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 11:30 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bachelor Party Spin | Redhead | 8/11/05 | 40 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| wedding gift spin off | rose825 | 7/30/05 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Spin off kinda-double dose of fear... | dm24angel | 7/25/05 | 10 | Infertility |
| Spin-off: TV couples you Hated | neenie | 6/10/05 | 40 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| spin off... have you had someone arrested | janet | 5/16/05 | 1 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Spin Off: Favorite Cold Stone Flavor and Item's add in | HarleyGirlFLA | 5/11/05 | 29 | Families Helping Families ™ |








