Spin-off to Verdict
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
|
Spin-off to Verdict For everyone who is so shocked and appalled and upset over the not guilty verdict, I want to offer the following: |
|
Posted 7/5/11 3:47 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict agreed |
|
Posted 7/5/11 3:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Thank you for this. I understand that people are outraged because, in all likelihood, she is guilty of something worse than covering up an accident. But to say all of these hateful things against the jury, who was just doing their job, is atrocious. I am so grateful for a judicial system that is as fair to BOTH sides as possible. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 3:54 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict You are right, and you explained this in a very clear, logical way. I think that as things calm down people will realize the logic behind the verdict. I just think that common sense tells us that she is responsible for her daughter's death. But now, justice can never be served. And that is sad and frustrating. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 3:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict I still believe the jury was stupid...the jury are 12 random citizens... |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict I do understand what you'r saying. Posted by DancinBarefoot A finding of not guilty means only that the prosecution did not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt. It does not mean that the accused is actually innocent of the crime charged The thing that's so frustrating for me is that now that she was found not guilty, she can't be charged with the crime if new evidence was to come out. Even if she was to admit it. So in some sense it does seem like she is innocent of the crime. Hope that made sense. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict i am also an attorney and i agree witht he above poster - the prosecution did not meet the requirements for a jury to find guilty - in ways i thought the defense was helping the prosecution withtheir theory but it is the prosecution to present the evidence for guilty and it was just too circumstantial - while i agree she propbably mirdered - i don't think i could find her guilty either based on the jury instruction and the summary of the testimony and evidence i heard |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by MsSissy The thing that's so frustrating for me is that now that she was found not guilty, she can't be charged with the crime if new evidence was to come out. That is frustrating
|
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by snowprincess i am also an attorney and i agree witht he above poster - the prosecution did not meet the requirements for a jury to find guilty - in ways i thought the defense was helping the prosecution withtheir theory but it is the prosecution to present the evidence for guilty and it was just too circumstantial - while i agree she propbably mirdered - i don't think i could find her guilty either based on the jury instruction and the summary of the testimony and evidence i heard Yeah you are right... I guess I am not believing in our system |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict See, but just because we don't know how she died it means that you cannot prove a murder? |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by Kidsaplenty See, but just because we don't know how she died it means that you cannot prove a murder? Duct tape over mouth/nose, body thrown in a swamp, left to decompose and be fed on by animals. a mother than not only doesn't report her child missing, but goes out and parties hard and never mentions to ANYONE that the kid is missing. Computer searches for various ways to kill someone, that only the mother could have done. And the motive, to have all her responsibilities gone. Why not look at all the circumstances surrounding the death? yes.yes.yes....thank you! |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:17 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict I didn't really follow the case that closely, but a little bit. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by dpli I didn't really follow the case that closely, but a little bit. I would be interested to know how many of the people who are outraged by the verdict have sat on a jury. I have and it is not a Law and Order episode. You are given very specific instructions, including that the decision you will make should not be taken lightly and that you cannot discuss the case with anyone. I'm not trying to start drama, but I had a much different perspective from the jury box than I did from my couch watching it on TV. No, but I know that you don't HAVE to believe all the experts that testified...that ultimately YOU have the right to think what you think...regardless of what others tell you I really think none of them used their common sense |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by Kidsaplenty See, but just because we don't know how she died it means that you cannot prove a murder? Duct tape over mouth/nose, body thrown in a swamp, left to decompose and be fed on by animals. a mother than not only doesn't report her child missing, but goes out and parties hard and never mentions to ANYONE that the kid is missing. Computer searches for various ways to kill someone, that only the mother could have done. And the motive, to have all her responsibilities gone. Why not look at all the circumstances surrounding the death? Prove the duct tape was put on before death - you can't, and neither could the prosecution. Casey wasn't charged with failing to report her child missing. I don't even know if there is such a crime. It makes her a bad mother, maybe, but a murderer - no. Partying and drinking by themselves also don't make someone a murderer. Again, maybe a bad mother, but not a murderer. As for the searches - how many people following this trial have now googled cloroform?? Does it make any of them a murderer? |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict couldn't agree more. thank you. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict I haven't been following this so closely either, but from what I have heard, I agree with you. I think they did not manage to provide enough proof that she murdered her daughter, so I am sure the jury had doubts and therefore, chose a not guilty verdict. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict I happen to really think the jury system is completely ridiculous! |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict My immediate reaction was outrage and shock, but what you're saying is true. It's unfortunate. Maybe had the body been found sooner they would have gotten some concrete evidence. I think the evidence does add up to there is something VERY wrong with Casey Anthony and she probably did kill her daughter or have something to do with it, but that's not our justice system. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict I've never googled chloroform..or neck breaking..and if god forbid my child were missing, I would NOT be partying. But our system doesn't go on gut feelings. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:30 PM
|
|
|
NervousNell
Member since 11/09 54921 total posts Name: |
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by DancinBarefoot Posted by Kidsaplenty See, but just because we don't know how she died it means that you cannot prove a murder? Duct tape over mouth/nose, body thrown in a swamp, left to decompose and be fed on by animals. a mother than not only doesn't report her child missing, but goes out and parties hard and never mentions to ANYONE that the kid is missing. Computer searches for various ways to kill someone, that only the mother could have done. And the motive, to have all her responsibilities gone. Why not look at all the circumstances surrounding the death? Prove the duct tape was put on before death - you can't, and neither could the prosecution. Casey wasn't charged with failing to report her child missing. I don't even know if there is such a crime. It makes her a bad mother, maybe, but a murderer - no. Partying and drinking by themselves also don't make someone a murderer. Again, maybe a bad mother, but not a murderer. As for the searches - how many people following this trial have now googled cloroform?? Does it make any of them a murderer? My question is- why would you put duct tape over the mouth of a dead body? Doesn't make much sense to me. Just because they can't prove when it was put on, does that mean common sense also needs to go out the window in the jury box? Like you have to put your common sense aside? I'm just curious about something like that... |
Posted 7/5/11 4:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by DancinBarefoot Posted by Kidsaplenty See, but just because we don't know how she died it means that you cannot prove a murder? Duct tape over mouth/nose, body thrown in a swamp, left to decompose and be fed on by animals. a mother than not only doesn't report her child missing, but goes out and parties hard and never mentions to ANYONE that the kid is missing. Computer searches for various ways to kill someone, that only the mother could have done. And the motive, to have all her responsibilities gone. Why not look at all the circumstances surrounding the death? Prove the duct tape was put on before death - you can't, and neither could the prosecution. Casey wasn't charged with failing to report her child missing. I don't even know if there is such a crime. It makes her a bad mother, maybe, but a murderer - no. Partying and drinking by themselves also don't make someone a murderer. Again, maybe a bad mother, but not a murderer. As for the searches - how many people following this trial have now googled cloroform?? Does it make any of them a murderer? I think common sense was lacking in this trial. Why would she need to put duct tape over her mouth after death? I can tell you, that "leaking decomposition fluids" would have leaked from every pore, every open orifice of her body. If it was really the issue of decomp fluids, she would have had to taped the kid's privates too. So what is the logical alternative for duct tape being only over the mouth? I'm talking LOGIC, not the most out there explanation you could possibly think of. The searches weren't just for chloroform. There were also searches for neck breaking, house hold weapons, ruptured spleen, etc. They found searches for the ingredients of chloroform AND how to make it!. Isn't that indicative of someone planning on committing a crime? If a serial rapist who was accused of drugging his victims with GHB during his crime was also found to have searches of how to make GHB and the ingredients on his computer, would you say it wasn't relevant? What other REASONABLE explanation is there for her not reporting the child missing? The partying and drinking is indicative of CELEBRATING, hello! Your kid is "missing" but she was out partying like something amazing just happened to her. And again, the partying and drinking can't be viewed as a separate issue, all the issues tie into each other no? That would be like me saying my husband walked into a knife, but leaving out the part about me arguing with him while I was holding a knife. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by brownie Posted by Kidsaplenty See, but just because we don't know how she died it means that you cannot prove a murder? Duct tape over mouth/nose, body thrown in a swamp, left to decompose and be fed on by animals. a mother than not only doesn't report her child missing, but goes out and parties hard and never mentions to ANYONE that the kid is missing. Computer searches for various ways to kill someone, that only the mother could have done. And the motive, to have all her responsibilities gone. Why not look at all the circumstances surrounding the death? yes.yes.yes....thank you! ITA! I could see the not guilty on the 1st degree murder charge if you believed that she used to choloform to sedate her and put her in the trunk, but at the very least she caused her daughter's death (IMO) and should have been found guilty of manslaughter. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:36 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by Kidsaplenty Posted by DancinBarefoot Posted by Kidsaplenty See, but just because we don't know how she died it means that you cannot prove a murder? Duct tape over mouth/nose, body thrown in a swamp, left to decompose and be fed on by animals. a mother than not only doesn't report her child missing, but goes out and parties hard and never mentions to ANYONE that the kid is missing. Computer searches for various ways to kill someone, that only the mother could have done. And the motive, to have all her responsibilities gone. Why not look at all the circumstances surrounding the death? Prove the duct tape was put on before death - you can't, and neither could the prosecution. Casey wasn't charged with failing to report her child missing. I don't even know if there is such a crime. It makes her a bad mother, maybe, but a murderer - no. Partying and drinking by themselves also don't make someone a murderer. Again, maybe a bad mother, but not a murderer. As for the searches - how many people following this trial have now googled cloroform?? Does it make any of them a murderer? I think common sense was lacking in this trial. Why would she need to put duct tape over her mouth after death? I can tell you, that "leaking decomposition fluids" would have leaked from every pore, every open orifice of her body. If it was really the issue of decomp fluids, she would have had to taped the kid's privates too. So what is the logical alternative for duct tape being only over the mouth? I'm talking LOGIC, not the most out there explanation you could possibly think of. The searches weren't just for chloroform. There were also searches for neck breaking, house hold weapons, ruptured spleen, etc. They found searches for the ingredients of chloroform AND how to make it!. Isn't that indicative of someone planning on committing a crime? If a serial rapist who was accused of drugging his victims with GHB during his crime was also found to have searches of how to make GHB and the ingredients on his computer, would you say it wasn't relevant? What other REASONABLE explanation is there for her not reporting the child missing? The partying and drinking is indicative of CELEBRATING, hello! Your kid is "missing" but she was out partying like something amazing just happened to her. And again, the partying and drinking can't be viewed as a separate issue, all the issues tie into each other no? That would be like me saying my husband walked into a knife, but leaving out the part about me arguing with him while I was holding a knife. You are starting with the assumption that Casey put the duct tape on Caylee. What if she didn't? There were no fingerprints on the duct tape, so in addition to no proof it was put on prior to death, there is no proof Casey put it on at all. Logical conclusion for duct tape? I don't know about logical, but alternative conclusion - to hold the jaw in place during decomposition. The searches may in fact be indicitive of the intent to commit a crime - but at any time before a person commits a crime, they can change their mind. Prove she didn't change her mind. Prove she made those searches to kill Caylee and not her mother, or father, or brother, or boyfriend or anyone else in her life. As for the partying and failure to report her missing etc, you can't convict her of murder because she's a bad mother. Maybe she didn't report her missing because she wasn't. Maybe she was in the trunk of the car for weeks and died of heat exhaustion in the trunk. The last day she was seen doesn't necessarily equate with the day she died. That's another thing the prosecution didn't prove - date of death. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict Posted by JenniferEver My immediate reaction was outrage and shock, but what you're saying is true. It's unfortunate. Maybe had the body been found sooner they would have gotten some concrete evidence. I think the evidence does add up to there is something VERY wrong with Casey Anthony and she probably did kill her daughter or have something to do with it, but that's not our justice system. I was expecting a guilty verdict (i only loosely followed the trial, but what I heard seemed to all add up to me, but now reading more, I can see why it ended up the way it did), so I was actually wondering why the jurors looked sick when they came in to read the verdict. I was thinking, why would you look so upset and grieved to convict someone who killed a 2 year old. Now I see why they looked the way they did. I hope people don't do anything bad to them. They had a terrible decision to make. They probably "knew" as a gut feeling, like many of us do, that Casey deserves to be behind bars, but they had to follow the rules of the court. Watch the footage again. They all look like they've seen a ghost and/or are going to throw up. You took the words right out of my mouth. I once sat on a jury and because of the lack of evidence, we had to find the defendant NOT guilty. We knew there was more to the story b/c the lawyer kept objecting to something that was clearly part of a previous suit against the defendant, but we were told to disregard it. In deliberation, we all said we WISH we could consider this other information, but based on what we were given, we couldn't. Therefore, the defendant was NOT guilty, even though we all suspected he was. There was nothing more we could do. I assume this was the case with this jury. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:52 PM
|
|
|
Re: Spin-off to Verdict What do we consider a reasonable doubt? What is reasonable for me might not be reasonable for someone else. Its all very lukewarm and cloudy, this justice system that we have but I couldn't come up with a better way to do it. |
|
Posted 7/5/11 4:52 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bachelor Party Spin | Redhead | 8/11/05 | 40 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| wedding gift spin off | rose825 | 7/30/05 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Spin off kinda-double dose of fear... | dm24angel | 7/25/05 | 10 | Infertility |
| Spin-off: TV couples you Hated | neenie | 6/10/05 | 40 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| spin off... have you had someone arrested | janet | 5/16/05 | 1 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Spin Off: Favorite Cold Stone Flavor and Item's add in | HarleyGirlFLA | 5/11/05 | 29 | Families Helping Families ™ |












Then guilty people go free.



