Re: Spin-off to Verdict
Posted 7/5/2011 5:30:31 PM by DancinBarefoot
Posted by Kidsaplenty
I'm sorry, but did the whole motive thing in a murder suddenly become unimportant? Who do you think had the motive? Anyway, essentially what you are saying is that short of catching her on tape or her giving a full confession, there is no real "proof" that she killed Caylee. So then how did they do it before DNA evidence was available? Don't the circumstances surrounding a crime indicate anything?
1- Why would someone who just throws a body in a swamp care if the mandible was in place during decomp? Why would it matter to them? That kind of doubt is not reasonable I think. 2-That was the last day she was seen by ANYONE. And she was with her mother. The people her mother was with never saw little Caylee. Her parents didn't have her. The kidnapping story was bogus. (ps, that kid wouldnt have lasted more than a couple hours if she was left in the trunk during the summer in Florida) 3- The searches are indicative of the intent to commit a crime, on that point you agree. But once that crime is actually carried out, with one of the items being searched used as the 'weapon", well isn't that proof that the person researching it DID decide to commit that crime?
I'm sorry, but IMO the doubts you are laying out aren't logical and require a huge leap of faith and speculation to even be considered
As to your first question regarding motive - umm, actually, the reason a person kills another person is not an element of the crime. Is it helpful? Sure. Does it help jurors wrap their head around something horrible? Sure. But, at the end of the day, the reasons a crime is committed are not a consideration in determining a verdict.
And before DNA the standards used to get convictions were different because the science was different. In 2011 with CSI and other shows like that all over the networks, juries want physical evidence. They have come to expect it. The only physical evidence connecting Casey was the "special" duct tape - and frankly, that tape connected the entire Anthony family. As the State Attorney said in his statement to the media after the verdict - they didn't find the body in time to recover evidence to be able to prove beyond a reasonable doubt how she died.
|