Question about "year round schooling".

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3]

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by zuzuspetals
edited for space



I agree with this except for the part about not pullng your child out because of a teacher. I do believe a lot of self confidence can be developed by dealing with difficult people on a regular basis - particularly for pre-teen & teens. However for younger kids (thinking of the kindergartener that was ridiculed in front of her class by her new teacher), I think parents do need to step in if necessary.

Message edited 2010-09-09 22:16:04.367000.

Posted 9/9/10 10:15 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

zuzuspetals
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/07

812 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by zuzuspetals
edited for space



I agree with this except for the part about not pullng your child out because of a teacher. I do believe a lot of self confidence can be developed by dealing with difficult people on a regular basis - particularly for pre-teen & teens. However for younger kids (thinking of the kindergartener that was ridiculed in front of her class by her new teacher), I think parents do need to step in if necessary.




Of course, I agree with that! No child should be torment, ridiculed, by anyone (especially a teacher). That is infuriating! I am talking about parents who take their child out of a class for much more trivial reasons. This has never happened to me as a teacher but I see kids pulled out frequently.

Posted 9/9/10 10:46 PM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by MikesWife

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by MikesWife

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by MikesWife

It's a good question Tricia!!

Yes, percentage wise these countries do produce more engineers, scientists, and programmers, but what about educators, social workers, writers, artists, musicians........?

The math and sciences are great and are instrumental to global advancement, but I just do not understand why it seems like those are the only measures that matter......





A social worker with an advanced degree makes less than an engineer coming right out of college. If we want our kids to be able to support themselves and afford to live here on LI we probably would prefer they go into a booming profession versus one that is always subject to budget cuts.




Making more $$$ does not equate to being a smarter adult. It just means you picked a different profession.

I also venture to guess that these countries we are referring to are not educating these kids based on their ability to sustain a more desirable living.

Plus, if we all came out with the same degree would there not be an oversaturation of that profession?




If more American students graduated with the skills needed we wouldn't see tech firms demand the government up the number of HB1 visas each year.

I would say that generally smarter adults end up being in demand and that with demand comes higher pay. This is why doctors and engineers make more than art history majors or social workers. Or why kids from Harvard and MIT make more than kids graduating from Dowling or Hofstra.

I would think Korea's emphasis on math and science is because they recognize this is what will make their people competitive in the global markets.




I get what you are saying, but my point is that just because these countries are producing young adults who excel in one or two areas, it does not make them smarter adults. I personally would consider someone who is well versed in many areas and/or interests a more intelligent individual than someone who can solely write programs.
Ask that person to hold a conversation with you about anything non binary.

I'm just saying that the measure of intelligence goes well beyond excellence in one or two categories.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I agree

Posted 9/10/10 8:11 AM
 

BaroqueMama
Chase is one!

Member since 5/05

27530 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by zuzuspetals

Greetings! Teacher here! Chat Icon

I do believe that in some other countries the children are getting a better education in many ways. However, I do NOT believe it is based on how many days they are in school. If we kept the system the way it is and increased the school year, I doubt we would see real progress. However, if the system was revamped then that would be a different story.

I feel that the children here are not held to the highest standards. Generally, the children I see are not disciplined, they do not want to work, they want to do the bare minimum. Even the children in the honors classes do not seem to have the same work ethic as they did years ago. Teachers have ZERO power. We can hardly discipline. We can't use red ink (it's bad for the self esteem). We cannot raise our voice, it's corporal punishment. Honestly, we have little control over the students who are disruptive and disrespectful. Parents fight for the kids ... Fight tooth and nail and I cannot fault them for that. I know they love their children and their intentions are good. But, kids are savvy, know how to manipulate.

I would never pull my kid out of a class because of the teacher. Every child will have different chemistry with different teachers. I KNOW bad teachers exist, but a really good lesson exists when a child has to overcome a less than ideal teaching style. A student will learn to overcome a challenge. If my child comes home and says, "I'm not doing well in this class because my teacher (insert excuse here) I would say, "well, you have to work extra hard then. One day you are going to have to work for a boss that you may not like but that's the way the cookie crumbles." LOL Something along those lines. Kids today are catered to in every sense of the word. Again, no ones fault, intentions are good but I don't think we are doing them any favors.

I can say that what the kids are learning in sixth grade, they should be learning in fourth. These state tests are ruining education. Parents are lied to everyday based on results of these tests. Even the curves on the regents exams are ridiculous. A child who earns a 82 actually earned a 64. Passing on many of these exams, is a 37%! With the curve, its 65! It is absurd! We are lowering expectations and it's showing.

I hope things change but I am afraid they are going to get worse. So much fluff in the curriculum. Kids want entertainment, want good grades for decent work.

*I want to add:
My husband and I are both teachers and despite all of the politics, mumbo jumbo, regulations we do not agree with ... we LIVE for our jobs. I am in love with my profession and I would never trade it for all of the money in the world. The joy I get from teaching is incredible. The relationships I form with my students are undeniable. I try and teach them real world lessons each day I am in the classroom. And every year, I cry like a baby when I have to let them go.





I totally agree with you. This is why I have chosen to teach in an independent school and send my daughter to an independent school. I truly feel our public schools are flawed in terms of teaching to the test and the curriculum not being challenging enough.

Posted 9/10/10 10:27 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by Sheena

One reason you cannot compare our scores to those scores from other countries is because our scores are from ALL students in a grade. In other countries, the students in a grade may only be their best and brightest.

In America we educate everyone. In many other countries only the best are able to go to specialized schools for engineering, math, and sciences. They track their students into these program, so we're comparing the math scores of all, let's say, 10th-grade math students--including the below level students, whether it be due to language, or special education--to the 10th-grade math students who are the brightest students in their nation.



This is an excellent point.

Posted 9/10/10 10:38 AM
 

Palebride
I am an amazing bakist

Member since 5/05

13673 total posts

Name:
Lori

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

I might be the exception here...and perhaps it's just the school I teach in, but I disagree that ALL students are just being taught to the test, and that ALL students aren't being challenged.
I teach 8th grade English, and we work to align our curriculum with the AP standards. We challenge our students on a daily basis, and try to show them how to think, how to analyze, and how to be independent. We also try to foster a love for reading and writing.
And...even though our main concentration for the year is not the ELA exam.....our students had the #1 scores in Nassau County.

I don't agree with year round schooling because I DO think kids deserve a break. Life is about more than just school. Life is about more than being the smartest. And, as a teacher, I think *I* benefit from the break as well! This was the first year since I started teaching that I took the whole summer off, and I came back refreshed and excited to start the new year.

Posted 9/10/10 10:39 AM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by MrsProfessor

On more than one occasion I've read about Finland and how their system is so much better than ours. There are a couple of interesting things: 1) They don't start formal reading instruction till kids are SEVEN. (I read this in one of my reading journals a while back, can't recall specifics) 2) Apparently they spend fewer hours in classrooms than the rest of the developed world. (mentioned in the piece below)

BBC Piece




I'm jumping in late, but I immediately thought about Finland too (and found the same article before I got down to your response). I also found that they go to school from the middle of August to the beginning of June (just like most of the US).

Finland came to mind b/c Jim Trelease (a reading expert) maintains that Finnish people are the best readers. But he attributes this to television! Since 50+% of their TV is not in FInnish, they watch with closed captioning turned on.


So screw year round school - let's watch more television; muted with CC turned on! Chat Icon

Posted 9/10/10 1:22 PM
 

MissJones
I need a nap!

Member since 5/05

22152 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by Erica



So screw year round school - let's watch more television; muted with CC turned on! Chat Icon



Don't laugh, when I have kids, I plan to have the tv with have CC on!


As for the original topic, I don't think a longer year is the answer. There are SO many factors that play a role in educational success.

1-the teachers-they need to be quality teachers
2-the parents-parents can't depend SOLELY on school to educate their children. Parents also can't blame teachers if their children are not succeeding
3-curriculum-it can't all be about a test. Children in other countries are learning other languages. Here, we don't start until 7th grade!
4-funding-the states are barely able to fund schools now.
5-the children-you can make the year as long as you want. You can make the day as long as you want. It will mean nothing if the kids do not want to be there.

People forget that we're dealing with kids. They have the attention span of a small puppy. Their biggest desire is to play! Making a school day or year longer might actually *defeat* the purpose. It's about what goes INTO the day or year that matters. If the children didn't need to be assessed and prepped for so many tests, then a whole lot more would be taught.

I will be the first to say that I wish I had more time in the day to get to all of the things I'd love to do with them. But the truth is that the kids really do need a break.

Message edited 2010-09-10 14:02:02.690000.

Posted 9/10/10 1:46 PM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

I haven't read all the posts here but my son is four and a half, and he starts all day (what is called) Reception this week. He was at a school last year, where he did half days. This is called the EYFS (Early Years Foundation Stage)

You can choose to do this first EYFS either at a school, or at a nursery (daycare centre) the government gives all children who are (I think, don't quote me on this) 3 years up 15 hours of free childcare a week. So you can either get it for free at a local school, or get money back from your daycare provider.

The school admissions systems is beyond crazy, however school typically runs from the 1/2nd September until the 23rd July...which leaves only about 5 weeks for the summer holidays. However, we don't get any summer here in England. As a working parent, this is brilliant as the scramble for childcare only leaves 5 weeks, rather than the 12 or so you get in the states. The kid do have several two week holidays throughout the school year, but summer break is short.

I don't really understand what happens past primary school here yet, but I am trying to learn quickly!!!

Posted 9/10/10 2:55 PM
 

dpli
Daylight savings :)

Member since 5/05

13973 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

I am an engineer. I just read an article recently in one of my professional magazines comparing US students to those in other countries and some of the information was very interesting.

First, they found that one thing that occurs in curriculums here in the US is that we try to teach too many topics and concepts, where in other countries, students study a smaller number of concepts, but in far more depth during an academic year. The persons conducting the study thought that this led to better problem solving skills and creative thinking in math and science, instead of just teaching kids how to do well on standardized tests. Also, in the US, school curriculums vary from state to state, where in other countries there is a national set of standards and curriculum.

Another thing that I found very interesting is that when they compared scores of students from higher income areas in the US, they saw scores much closer to the highest scoring countries. When they looked at scores from low income areas in the US, they were far below our national average. I didn't find this shocking, since I do believe there is an inequity in education in this country, but I thought it was interesting that many of our students are getting as good an education as those in high performing countries. I am not sure the issue is sitting in the classroom for more days, but more that the teachers and students who need the resources most are not getting them.

As for this comment:

Posted by annoyedTTCer

As for MS, every year they ask the govenment to increase the number of HB1 visas so they can bring in talent, that is a fact.



My DH is a programmer. Companies bring in more HB1 visas because they will work a lot more hours for a lot less money. Period. It is not about talent, it's about economics.

Posted 9/10/10 3:38 PM
 

TheDivineMrsM
2 girls 4 me!

Member since 8/08

7878 total posts

Name:
Mama mama mama....

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

No country in the world has year round schooling, but some school years are quite a bit longer than others. Japan, which has one of the longest school years, also has the highest adolescent suicide rate in the developed world. It would appear that they can't take the constant pressure. Children, especially in the younger grades, need time to be children. Play is an important part of learning, as is socialization. It's how they learn their role in the world.

That said... as a HS counselor, I can see the benefit of an extended school year, especially for the lowest and highest achievers. Students would get the help or stimulation they need to stay focused. It would give teachers a chance to go into real depth in a specific topic instead of being forced to rush through the state curricula. Subjects like Chemistry are studied for years in the Carribean; we give our kids a measly year.

We need to look at WHAT we're teaching in addition to the length of the school year. Countries that do well in math and science go into more depth, but actually touch on fewer topics than we do here. Students in India spend a year examining all aspects of a triangle. This is one topic in a sea of chapters for math students in the US.

Schools would have to make sure their environments are conducive to learning in the summertime. My building is brutally hot all through the summer, and it's impossible for a kid (or teacher) to focus when a classroom is 110 degrees.

I think day camps, restaurants, retailers, internship programs, etc would have a collective cow if we extended the school year though. More time in school = less money and/or fewer workers for them.

edited for spelling

Message edited 2010-09-10 16:06:29.240000.

Posted 9/10/10 4:01 PM
 

MissJones
I need a nap!

Member since 5/05

22152 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by TheDivineMrsM

No country in the world has year round schooling, but some school years are quite a bit longer than others. Japan, which has one of the longest school years, also has the highest adolescent suicide rate in the developed world. It would appear that they can't take the constant pressure. Children, especially in the younger grades, need time to be children. Play is an important part of learning, as is socialization. It's how they learn their role in the world.

That said... as a HS counselor, I can see the benefit of an extended school year, especially for the lowest and highest achievers. Students would get the help or stimulation they need to stay focused. It would give teachers a chance to go into real depth in a specific topic instead of being forced to rush through the state curricula. Subjects like Chemistry are studied for years in the Carribean; we give our kids a measly year.

We need to look at WHAT we're teaching in addition to the length of the school year. Countries that do well in math and science go into more depth, but actually touch on fewer topics than we do here. Students in India spend a year examining all aspects of a triangle. This is one topic in a sea of chapters for math students in the US.

Schools would have to make sure their environments are conducive to learning in the summertime. My building is brutally hot all through the summer, and it's impossible for a kid (or teacher) to focus when a classroom is 110 degrees.

I think day camps, restaurants, retailers, internship programs, etc would have a collective cow if we extended the school year though. More time in school = less money and/or fewer workers for them.

edited for spelling



I agree with all parts!

Posted 9/10/10 4:16 PM
 

LisaI
Momma's Little Beans

Member since 1/06

3923 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by maybeamommy

I'm not sure how it would work here, but I can tell you how it was in San Diego...

Year round school still had the SAME amount of days as traditional calendar schools.

The only different was WHEN the breaks were.

Year round has longer vacations during the year (think 3 weeks for Easter) and then they run until the end of July and still have off for August.



This is pretty much us here in GA. We have what's called year round schooling but it's not 12months. Still get summer break and more vacation throughout the year. 9 weeks on 1 week off. The county here did change it this school year so that the students have less time off.

Posted 9/10/10 4:58 PM
 

Erica
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

11767 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by dpli

Another thing that I found very interesting is that when they compared scores of students from higher income areas in the US, they saw scores much closer to the highest scoring countries. When they looked at scores from low income areas in the US, they were far below our national average. I didn't find this shocking, since I do believe there is an inequity in education in this country, but I thought it was interesting that many of our students are getting as good an education as those in high performing countries. I am not sure the issue is sitting in the classroom for more days, but more that the teachers and students who need the resources most are not getting them.



Stephen Krashen maintains that well-funded, up to date public and school libraries with certified librarians has a direct correlation to reading achievement. Wealthy communities tend to have this. Poorer communities do not.

Here is a synopsis of his work, but if you have time, he is a great speaker too (part 2, 3 and 4 are on the sidebar)


the video on comprehensible input is a quick, cool and unrelated video, but it's what turned me onto Stephen Krashen.

Posted 9/10/10 11:09 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spanish Immersion Workshop or Spanish all year round? vegalady 6/22/10 1 Parenting
Anyone use their grill year-round? rileysmama 6/3/10 13 Dining In or Out
Looking for year round rental in East Hampton Holly 10/29/09 4 Home
2009 Times Square ball to stay up year-round GoldenRod 11/11/08 20 Families Helping Families ™
So has anyone heard about the possiblility of a year round school year? beautyq115 10/19/07 18 Teachers
1 Year Wedding Anniversary Cake-Question LuvMy2Girls 9/15/05 5 Families Helping Families ™