Re: Question about "year round schooling".
Posted 9/10/2010 8:11:40 AM by sfp0701


Posted by MikesWife


Posted by annoyedTTCer


Posted by MikesWife


Posted by annoyedTTCer


Posted by MikesWife

It's a good question Tricia!!

Yes, percentage wise these countries do produce more engineers, scientists, and programmers, but what about educators, social workers, writers, artists, musicians........?

The math and sciences are great and are instrumental to global advancement, but I just do not understand why it seems like those are the only measures that matter......





A social worker with an advanced degree makes less than an engineer coming right out of college. If we want our kids to be able to support themselves and afford to live here on LI we probably would prefer they go into a booming profession versus one that is always subject to budget cuts.




Making more $$$ does not equate to being a smarter adult. It just means you picked a different profession.

I also venture to guess that these countries we are referring to are not educating these kids based on their ability to sustain a more desirable living.

Plus, if we all came out with the same degree would there not be an oversaturation of that profession?




If more American students graduated with the skills needed we wouldn't see tech firms demand the government up the number of HB1 visas each year.

I would say that generally smarter adults end up being in demand and that with demand comes higher pay. This is why doctors and engineers make more than art history majors or social workers. Or why kids from Harvard and MIT make more than kids graduating from Dowling or Hofstra.

I would think Korea's emphasis on math and science is because they recognize this is what will make their people competitive in the global markets.




I get what you are saying, but my point is that just because these countries are producing young adults who excel in one or two areas, it does not make them smarter adults. I personally would consider someone who is well versed in many areas and/or interests a more intelligent individual than someone who can solely write programs.
Ask that person to hold a conversation with you about anything non binary.

I'm just saying that the measure of intelligence goes well beyond excellence in one or two categories.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon I agree
Print Post      Close Window