Question about "year round schooling".

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by sfp0701

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by sfp0701

Posted by zuzuspetals

Greetings! Teacher here! Chat Icon

I do believe that in some other countries the children are getting a better education in many ways. However, I do NOT believe it is based on how many days they are in school. If we kept the system the way it is and increased the school year, I doubt we would see real progress. However, if the system was revamped then that would be a different story.

I feel that the children here are not held to the highest standards. Generally, the children I see are not disciplined, they do not want to work, they want to do the bare minimum. Even the children in the honors classes do not seem to have the same work ethic as they did years ago. Teachers have ZERO power. We can hardly discipline. We can't use red ink (it's bad for the self esteem). We cannot raise our voice, it's corporal punishment. Honestly, we have little control over the students who are disruptive and disrespectful. Parents fight for the kids ... Fight tooth and nail and I cannot fault them for that. I know they love their children and their intentions are good. But, kids are savvy, know how to manipulate.

I would never pull my kid out of a class because of the teacher. Every child will have different chemistry with different teachers. I KNOW bad teachers exist, but a really good lesson exists when a child has to overcome a less than ideal teaching style. A student will learn to overcome a challenge. If my child comes home and says, "I'm not doing well in this class because my teacher (insert excuse here) I would say, "well, you have to work extra hard then. One day you are going to have to work for a boss that you may not like but that's the way the cookie crumbles." LOL Something along those lines. Kids today are catered to in every sense of the word. Again, no ones fault, intentions are good but I don't think we are doing them any favors.

I can say that what the kids are learning in sixth grade, they should be learning in fourth. These state tests are ruining education. Parents are lied to everyday based on results of these tests. Even the curves on the regents exams are ridiculous. A child who earns a 82 actually earned a 64. Passing on many of these exams, is a 37%! With the curve, its 65! It is absurd! We are lowering expectations and it's showing.

I hope things change but I am afraid they are going to get worse. So much fluff in the curriculum. Kids want entertainment, want good grades for decent work.

*I want to add:
My husband and I are both teachers and despite all of the politics, mumbo jumbo, regulations we do not agree with ... we LIVE for our jobs. I am in love with my profession and I would never trade it for all of the money in the world. The joy I get from teaching is incredible. The relationships I form with my students are undeniable. I try and teach them real world lessons each day I am in the classroom. And every year, I cry like a baby when I have to let them go.




I agree with all of that. I am just so tired of hearing that a 12 month school year is the answer without any proof that it actually changes the outcome of the "adult" in the end. I get that when tested as STUDENTS they may out preform American's.. but, what about the end product? Is it any different or do we eventually catch up?



Do you think it’s a coincidence that nations with more days of schooling outperform US students?

And that these nations produce more engineers, computer programers and scientists than we do?




What I was asking is.. where is the proof? I was asking if anyone knew of a study that PROVED that the ADULTS ( i never said students.. as in when they were kids) were more intelligent or could score better than our adults... That's all. And do they produce more of those engineers etc. because of population or has it been adujsted? As in the percentage of people that graduate college are engineers, etc. Honestly, I was just wondering if it was ever proven? I really don't know. Maybe there is proof. I honestly don't know and was wondering if there was. But, so far.. no one has shown me a stat ever that said that at the end of schooling, the other students performed better.



Honestly not sure if a long term study exists but I would accept as proof the fact Microsoft has to import engineers because they can't find qaulified ones here while Apple makes all their products overseas because that is where the talent is.




apple, as do a million other companies, make their products in China bc the labor and parts are cheaper which equals a higher profit margin for them.



Not totally true.

Apple also designs and engineers their products in Asia with suppliers because that's where the talent is. Concepts are created in the USA but execution happens in Asia in conjunction with vendors.

Nearly every improvement to Apple products is the result of vendors working to improve their goods. These improvements don't come from people making a $1 an hour in some dark room.








are you talking about design or production of goods? You said apple MAKES their products overseas, not designs.

I still dont see how one companies business practices are concrete proof that year round schooling makes them smarter as adults, just that it may lead to a labor force more skilled at certain jobs. They however, are not the ONLY jobs.

Posted 9/9/10 3:07 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by MikesWife

It's a good question Tricia!!

Yes, percentage wise these countries do produce more engineers, scientists, and programmers, but what about educators, social workers, writers, artists, musicians........?

The math and sciences are great and are instrumental to global advancement, but I just do not understand why it seems like those are the only measures that matter......



A social worker with an advanced degree makes less than an engineer coming right out of college. If we want our kids to be able to support themselves and afford to live here on LI we probably would prefer they go into a booming profession versus one that is always subject to budget cuts.

Posted 9/9/10 3:09 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by sfp0701

Posted by annoyedTTCer


What I was asking is.. where is the proof?




your question was perfectly clear, dont worry Chat Icon

As for producing more engineers, chemists, programmers, etc - is there proof, aside from the population that it is bc of the # of days in the school year, as opposed the the curriculum itself?



If they score better in math, science at nearly every grade level wouldn't that lead to more entering those fields?

The fact remains we don't score well versus the rest of the world for the areas of math and science and these are probably the two most important subjects these days.

I can't see how there is any debate as to if you would learn more sitting in class 180 days versus 280 days. More time should equal better and deeper coverage of subjects.




i just think its a blanket statement, she is asking for proof, unless you are going to compare apples to apples, there is no way to know what they are being taught and it still doesnt answer her question as to whether or not they are smarter as adults....not which career field is more prominent based in the education system.



Something has to account for us testing behind MANY other contries, do we want to say then that our curriculum sucks?




ok, but the question was AS ADULTS, not how they test while they are students.

And to answer your question, it doesnt have to mean that our curriculum sucks, why couldnt it just be different?

Message edited 2010-09-09 15:09:35.490000.

Posted 9/9/10 3:09 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by sfp0701

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by sfp0701

Posted by zuzuspetals

Greetings! Teacher here! Chat Icon

I do believe that in some other countries the children are getting a better education in many ways. However, I do NOT believe it is based on how many days they are in school. If we kept the system the way it is and increased the school year, I doubt we would see real progress. However, if the system was revamped then that would be a different story.

I feel that the children here are not held to the highest standards. Generally, the children I see are not disciplined, they do not want to work, they want to do the bare minimum. Even the children in the honors classes do not seem to have the same work ethic as they did years ago. Teachers have ZERO power. We can hardly discipline. We can't use red ink (it's bad for the self esteem). We cannot raise our voice, it's corporal punishment. Honestly, we have little control over the students who are disruptive and disrespectful. Parents fight for the kids ... Fight tooth and nail and I cannot fault them for that. I know they love their children and their intentions are good. But, kids are savvy, know how to manipulate.

I would never pull my kid out of a class because of the teacher. Every child will have different chemistry with different teachers. I KNOW bad teachers exist, but a really good lesson exists when a child has to overcome a less than ideal teaching style. A student will learn to overcome a challenge. If my child comes home and says, "I'm not doing well in this class because my teacher (insert excuse here) I would say, "well, you have to work extra hard then. One day you are going to have to work for a boss that you may not like but that's the way the cookie crumbles." LOL Something along those lines. Kids today are catered to in every sense of the word. Again, no ones fault, intentions are good but I don't think we are doing them any favors.

I can say that what the kids are learning in sixth grade, they should be learning in fourth. These state tests are ruining education. Parents are lied to everyday based on results of these tests. Even the curves on the regents exams are ridiculous. A child who earns a 82 actually earned a 64. Passing on many of these exams, is a 37%! With the curve, its 65! It is absurd! We are lowering expectations and it's showing.

I hope things change but I am afraid they are going to get worse. So much fluff in the curriculum. Kids want entertainment, want good grades for decent work.

*I want to add:
My husband and I are both teachers and despite all of the politics, mumbo jumbo, regulations we do not agree with ... we LIVE for our jobs. I am in love with my profession and I would never trade it for all of the money in the world. The joy I get from teaching is incredible. The relationships I form with my students are undeniable. I try and teach them real world lessons each day I am in the classroom. And every year, I cry like a baby when I have to let them go.




I agree with all of that. I am just so tired of hearing that a 12 month school year is the answer without any proof that it actually changes the outcome of the "adult" in the end. I get that when tested as STUDENTS they may out preform American's.. but, what about the end product? Is it any different or do we eventually catch up?



Do you think it’s a coincidence that nations with more days of schooling outperform US students?

And that these nations produce more engineers, computer programers and scientists than we do?




What I was asking is.. where is the proof? I was asking if anyone knew of a study that PROVED that the ADULTS ( i never said students.. as in when they were kids) were more intelligent or could score better than our adults... That's all. And do they produce more of those engineers etc. because of population or has it been adujsted? As in the percentage of people that graduate college are engineers, etc. Honestly, I was just wondering if it was ever proven? I really don't know. Maybe there is proof. I honestly don't know and was wondering if there was. But, so far.. no one has shown me a stat ever that said that at the end of schooling, the other students performed better.



Honestly not sure if a long term study exists but I would accept as proof the fact Microsoft has to import engineers because they can't find qaulified ones here while Apple makes all their products overseas because that is where the talent is.




apple, as do a million other companies, make their products in China bc the labor and parts are cheaper which equals a higher profit margin for them.



Not totally true.

Apple also designs and engineers their products in Asia with suppliers because that's where the talent is. Concepts are created in the USA but execution happens in Asia in conjunction with vendors.

Nearly every improvement to Apple products is the result of vendors working to improve their goods. These improvements don't come from people making a $1 an hour in some dark room.








are you talking about design or production of goods? You said apple MAKES their products overseas, not designs.

I still dont see how one companies business practices are concrete proof that year round schooling makes them smarter as adults, just that it may lead to a labor force more skilled at certain jobs. They however, are not the ONLY jobs.



Apple makes AND designs many of their products overseas. All those concept leaks we see, they are coming from the vendors R&D departments.

You are right, lets ignore engineering and computer science fields that are growing by leaps and bounds and instead look at booming fields like .....



Posted 9/9/10 3:11 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by MikesWife

It's a good question Tricia!!

Yes, percentage wise these countries do produce more engineers, scientists, and programmers, but what about educators, social workers, writers, artists, musicians........?

The math and sciences are great and are instrumental to global advancement, but I just do not understand why it seems like those are the only measures that matter......



A social worker with an advanced degree makes less than an engineer coming right out of college. If we want our kids to be able to support themselves and afford to live here on LI we probably would prefer they go into a booming profession versus one that is always subject to budget cuts.




again, does not pertain AT all to how smart they are as adults. She was asking why engineers and technical professions are the only careers by which you would consider adults smart. There is no reason educators, social workers etc, are not equally as smart, but that their interests lie elsewhere.

Posted 9/9/10 3:11 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by annoyedTTCer



Honestly not sure if a long term study exists but I would accept as proof the fact Microsoft has to import engineers because they can't find qaulified ones here while Apple makes all their products overseas because that is where the talent is.




apple, as do a million other companies, make their products in China bc the labor and parts are cheaper which equals a higher profit margin for them.

Not totally true.

Apple also designs and engineers their products in Asia with suppliers because that's where the talent is. Concepts are created in the USA but execution happens in Asia in conjunction with vendors.

Nearly every improvement to Apple products is the result of vendors working to improve their goods. These improvements don't come from people making a $1 an hour in some dark room.







are you talking about design or production of goods? You said apple MAKES their products overseas, not designs.

I still dont see how one companies business practices are concrete proof that year round schooling makes them smarter as adults, just that it may lead to a labor force more skilled at certain jobs. They however, are not the ONLY jobs.

Apple makes AND designs many of their products overseas. All those concept leaks we see, they are coming from the vendors R&D departments.

You are right, lets ignore engineering and computer science fields that are growing by leaps and bounds and instead look at booming fields like .....





what are you talking about? You are just arguing to for the sake of it now.....it still doesnt answer the OP question.

Message edited 2010-09-09 15:12:52.787000.

Posted 9/9/10 3:12 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by sfp0701

Posted by annoyedTTCer


What I was asking is.. where is the proof?




your question was perfectly clear, dont worry Chat Icon

As for producing more engineers, chemists, programmers, etc - is there proof, aside from the population that it is bc of the # of days in the school year, as opposed the the curriculum itself?



If they score better in math, science at nearly every grade level wouldn't that lead to more entering those fields?

The fact remains we don't score well versus the rest of the world for the areas of math and science and these are probably the two most important subjects these days.

I can't see how there is any debate as to if you would learn more sitting in class 180 days versus 280 days. More time should equal better and deeper coverage of subjects.




i just think its a blanket statement, she is asking for proof, unless you are going to compare apples to apples, there is no way to know what they are being taught and it still doesnt answer her question as to whether or not they are smarter as adults....not which career field is more prominent based in the education system.



Something has to account for us testing behind MANY other contries, do we want to say then that our curriculum sucks?




ok, but the question was AS ADULTS, not how they test while they are students.

And to answer your question, it doesnt have to mean that our curriculum sucks, why couldnt it just be different?



OK What do YOU think is the reason other nations outperform us in math and science tests?

If our students and great and our curriculum perfect wouldn't we be on top?

As for adults, I already said very clearly that I wasn't aware of any long-term studies in that field.


Posted 9/9/10 3:12 PM
 

MikesWife
Wanting...........

Member since 1/06

6887 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by MikesWife

It's a good question Tricia!!

Yes, percentage wise these countries do produce more engineers, scientists, and programmers, but what about educators, social workers, writers, artists, musicians........?

The math and sciences are great and are instrumental to global advancement, but I just do not understand why it seems like those are the only measures that matter......



A social worker with an advanced degree makes less than an engineer coming right out of college. If we want our kids to be able to support themselves and afford to live here on LI we probably would prefer they go into a booming profession versus one that is always subject to budget cuts.




Making more $$$ does not equate to being a smarter adult. It just means you picked a different profession.

I also venture to guess that these countries we are referring to are not educating these kids based on their ability to sustain a more desirable living.

Plus, if we all came out with the same degree would there not be an oversaturation of that profession?

Posted 9/9/10 3:14 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by sfp0701

Posted by annoyedTTCer


What I was asking is.. where is the proof?




your question was perfectly clear, dont worry Chat Icon

As for producing more engineers, chemists, programmers, etc - is there proof, aside from the population that it is bc of the # of days in the school year, as opposed the the curriculum itself?



If they score better in math, science at nearly every grade level wouldn't that lead to more entering those fields?

The fact remains we don't score well versus the rest of the world for the areas of math and science and these are probably the two most important subjects these days.

I can't see how there is any debate as to if you would learn more sitting in class 180 days versus 280 days. More time should equal better and deeper coverage of subjects.




i just think its a blanket statement, she is asking for proof, unless you are going to compare apples to apples, there is no way to know what they are being taught and it still doesnt answer her question as to whether or not they are smarter as adults....not which career field is more prominent based in the education system.



Something has to account for us testing behind MANY other contries, do we want to say then that our curriculum sucks?




ok, but the question was AS ADULTS, not how they test while they are students.

And to answer your question, it doesnt have to mean that our curriculum sucks, why couldnt it just be different?



OK What do YOU think is the reason other nations outperform us in math and science tests?

If our students and great and our curriculum perfect wouldn't we be on top?

As for adults, I already said very clearly that I wasn't aware of any long-term studies in that field.



I dont care bc that wasnt the question.

Yes, you did, but you also said you would take as proof.....

which is how the rest of the conversation started.

Posted 9/9/10 3:14 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by MikesWife

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by MikesWife

It's a good question Tricia!!

Yes, percentage wise these countries do produce more engineers, scientists, and programmers, but what about educators, social workers, writers, artists, musicians........?

The math and sciences are great and are instrumental to global advancement, but I just do not understand why it seems like those are the only measures that matter......



A social worker with an advanced degree makes less than an engineer coming right out of college. If we want our kids to be able to support themselves and afford to live here on LI we probably would prefer they go into a booming profession versus one that is always subject to budget cuts.




Making more $$$ does not equate to being a smarter adult. It just means you picked a different profession.

I also venture to guess that these countries we are referring to are not educating these kids based on their ability to sustain a more desirable living.

Plus, if we all came out with the same degree would there not be an oversaturation of that profession?




If more American students graduated with the skills needed we wouldn't see tech firms demand the government up the number of HB1 visas each year.

I would say that generally smarter adults end up being in demand and that with demand comes higher pay. This is why doctors and engineers make more than art history majors or social workers. Or why kids from Harvard and MIT make more than kids graduating from Dowling or Hofstra.

I would think Korea's emphasis on math and science is because they recognize this is what will make their people competitive in the global markets.

Posted 9/9/10 3:18 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by sfp0701

Posted by annoyedTTCer


What I was asking is.. where is the proof?




your question was perfectly clear, dont worry Chat Icon

As for producing more engineers, chemists, programmers, etc - is there proof, aside from the population that it is bc of the # of days in the school year, as opposed the the curriculum itself?



If they score better in math, science at nearly every grade level wouldn't that lead to more entering those fields?

The fact remains we don't score well versus the rest of the world for the areas of math and science and these are probably the two most important subjects these days.

I can't see how there is any debate as to if you would learn more sitting in class 180 days versus 280 days. More time should equal better and deeper coverage of subjects.




i just think its a blanket statement, she is asking for proof, unless you are going to compare apples to apples, there is no way to know what they are being taught and it still doesnt answer her question as to whether or not they are smarter as adults....not which career field is more prominent based in the education system.



Something has to account for us testing behind MANY other contries, do we want to say then that our curriculum sucks?




ok, but the question was AS ADULTS, not how they test while they are students.

And to answer your question, it doesnt have to mean that our curriculum sucks, why couldnt it just be different?



OK What do YOU think is the reason other nations outperform us in math and science tests?

If our students and great and our curriculum perfect wouldn't we be on top?

As for adults, I already said very clearly that I wasn't aware of any long-term studies in that field.



I dont care bc that wasnt the question.

Yes, you did, but you also said you would take as proof.....

which is how the rest of the conversation started.



Correct I said I would accept is as proof as in that's they way I see things. Emphasis on I!

As for the original question, yes it was does year round school make them smarter adults to which I said I wasn't aware of long-tern studies in that space.

"I dont care bc that wasnt the question" so take you ball and go home if you can't be bothered to answer a very simple question.




Posted 9/9/10 3:21 PM
 

MikesWife
Wanting...........

Member since 1/06

6887 total posts

Name:
Karen

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by MikesWife

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by MikesWife

It's a good question Tricia!!

Yes, percentage wise these countries do produce more engineers, scientists, and programmers, but what about educators, social workers, writers, artists, musicians........?

The math and sciences are great and are instrumental to global advancement, but I just do not understand why it seems like those are the only measures that matter......



A social worker with an advanced degree makes less than an engineer coming right out of college. If we want our kids to be able to support themselves and afford to live here on LI we probably would prefer they go into a booming profession versus one that is always subject to budget cuts.




Making more $$$ does not equate to being a smarter adult. It just means you picked a different profession.

I also venture to guess that these countries we are referring to are not educating these kids based on their ability to sustain a more desirable living.

Plus, if we all came out with the same degree would there not be an oversaturation of that profession?




If more American students graduated with the skills needed we wouldn't see tech firms demand the government up the number of HB1 visas each year.

I would say that generally smarter adults end up being in demand and that with demand comes higher pay. This is why doctors and engineers make more than art history majors or social workers. Or why kids from Harvard and MIT make more than kids graduating from Dowling or Hofstra.

I would think Korea's emphasis on math and science is because they recognize this is what will make their people competitive in the global markets.




I get what you are saying, but my point is that just because these countries are producing young adults who excel in one or two areas, it does not make them smarter adults. I personally would consider someone who is well versed in many areas and/or interests a more intelligent individual than someone who can solely write programs.
Ask that person to hold a conversation with you about anything non binary.

I'm just saying that the measure of intelligence goes well beyond excellence in one or two categories.

Posted 9/9/10 3:30 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Aren't those kids who go to school all year coming to America for higher education (college)? I was always curious about that. If their systems were so great why don't we have their colleges on the tip of our tongues when we think of elite education?

I guess I would say that the only real 'test' of this theory can be done only on the students and not as adults. Once they have control over their own decisions, actions and reactions, wouldn't their basic nature who itself? Lazy, procastinator, etc.

Still I, for one, would have loved all year school. I hated summers. I mean sure it was fun here and there but with my household, school WAS my escape. I signed up for as many free summer school type programs as I could. My parents couldn't afford 'camp' etc and wouldn't have let me go 'away' but they were ok with me finding and signing up for any educational or sport like 'school' environment for the summer.

Now as a parent, I wish my child could have year long school. But I agree they need to be pushed more and parents as well as teachers need to be given more freedom for discipline. I was never allowed to mouth off to a teacher without fear I'd get it if my father found out. I certainly didn't tell me father to 'leave me alone' or "i hate you".



Posted 9/9/10 3:32 PM
 

TheDivaBrideandTeddyFrog
Leah's here!

Member since 9/07

5404 total posts

Name:
Sabrina

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

There are many, many factors at stake on how our children are turning out...of course, one of the many facets are schools...but lest we lately have been discounting parenting, resources (of which people either don't take advantage of or don't have, etc.-not arguing about that) and change in character regarding education and our futures overall...

People's attitudes have changed-for some reason (one of many), we have become an instant gratification nation and working hard in school or staying the course and focusing on a long term goal do not fit into that attitude. Our school administrators, policymakers, and boards of education subscribe to the same philosophy and don't work PROactively as they do REactively, not looking far past their noses...we can't think about how they are going to be as adults (a VERY valid and fascinating question by the OP, honestly..I'd join that study!) because we have to think about this year/month's bottom line. This does not contribute to our future success, no matter how many days the kids are in school...

We don't value education..it's true..not when you can be the next Tiger Woods, Lindsey Lohan, etc...why would one hit the books?

Our curriculum and (some) teachers (being one myself, I will say this for sure) are not equipped for the modern world. When I can't get tissues for my kids to wipe their noses or soap for their hands, how the heck are we creating the next world moguls? Maslow's basic needs! I try to relate life experiences and reasons for lessons to the students, but that can only go so far..practical curriculum is invaluable. If we don't have the money to work on good curriculum, we don't have the money to run schools for more days a year..more days of what we have now simply will not cut it...

Posted 9/9/10 3:37 PM
 

eddiesmommy
best buds!

Member since 5/09

11524 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by eddiesmommy

Posted by sfp0701

Posted by annoyedTTCer


What I was asking is.. where is the proof?




your question was perfectly clear, dont worry Chat Icon

As for producing more engineers, chemists, programmers, etc - is there proof, aside from the population that it is bc of the # of days in the school year, as opposed the the curriculum itself?



If they score better in math, science at nearly every grade level wouldn't that lead to more entering those fields?

The fact remains we don't score well versus the rest of the world for the areas of math and science and these are probably the two most important subjects these days.

I can't see how there is any debate as to if you would learn more sitting in class 180 days versus 280 days. More time should equal better and deeper coverage of subjects.




i just think its a blanket statement, she is asking for proof, unless you are going to compare apples to apples, there is no way to know what they are being taught and it still doesnt answer her question as to whether or not they are smarter as adults....not which career field is more prominent based in the education system.



Something has to account for us testing behind MANY other contries, do we want to say then that our curriculum sucks?




ok, but the question was AS ADULTS, not how they test while they are students.

And to answer your question, it doesnt have to mean that our curriculum sucks, why couldnt it just be different?



OK What do YOU think is the reason other nations outperform us in math and science tests?

If our students and great and our curriculum perfect wouldn't we be on top?

As for adults, I already said very clearly that I wasn't aware of any long-term studies in that field.



I dont care bc that wasnt the question.

Yes, you did, but you also said you would take as proof.....

which is how the rest of the conversation started.



Correct I said I would accept is as proof as in that's they way I see things. Emphasis on I!

As for the original question, yes it was does year round school make them smarter adults to which I said I wasn't aware of long-tern studies in that space.

"I dont care bc that wasnt the question" so take you ball and go home if you can't be bothered to answer a very simple question.






what is your problem? talk about being childish.....you seriously get catty when your viewpoints are challenged.

As for the "i dont care" I meant I dont care to discuss it bc its irrelevant to the OP question.

There is no reason to further this conversation as it is clearly not headed any place productive.Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-09-09 15:43:04.260000.

Posted 9/9/10 3:40 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

On more than one occasion I've read about Finland and how their system is so much better than ours. There are a couple of interesting things: 1) They don't start formal reading instruction till kids are SEVEN. (I read this in one of my reading journals a while back, can't recall specifics) 2) Apparently they spend fewer hours in classrooms than the rest of the developed world. (mentioned in the piece below)

BBC Piece

My observation- we just don't value education in our society. I will never forget the episode of Oprah (I know this sounds like it's going to be a joke Chat Icon ) where she announced plans for her school. The kids who were chosed went wild- jumping up and down, screaming with joy. Would we ever see a reaction like that here? I doubt it.

Posted 9/9/10 3:56 PM
 

klingklang77
kraftwerk!

Member since 7/06

11489 total posts

Name:
Völlig losgelöst

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by MrsProfessor

On more than one occasion I've read about Finland and how their system is so much better than ours. There are a couple of interesting things: 1) They don't start formal reading instruction till kids are SEVEN. (I read this in one of my reading journals a while back, can't recall specifics) 2) Apparently they spend fewer hours in classrooms than the rest of the developed world. (mentioned in the piece below)



Germany is a bit similar. They don't have to start school until they are 6-7. They go to school until they are 18-19. It is year round, but with breaks in summer, for Easter etc. The breaks are spaced out sort of evenly, there is no two month off break for summer. However, the school day finishes at around 1PM. The schools are not better than the US and there was PISA scores which showed they performed worse than the the US. The universities are not that good either, but the are practically free.

What they learn is much more in depth than what is learned in the US. Based on what I've seen comparing text books from both countries is that the US seems to learn a general overview, while in Germany it is a lot more detail. I think that may also be a cultural difference.

I'd love to see evidence about how eduction in different countries has an effect after school/university is finished.

Message edited 2010-09-09 16:39:20.753000.

Posted 9/9/10 4:38 PM
 

Christine
2nd verse same as the 1st

Member since 5/05

15287 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by MrsProfessor

On more than one occasion I've read about Finland and how their system is so much better than ours. There are a couple of interesting things: 1) They don't start formal reading instruction till kids are SEVEN. (I read this in one of my reading journals a while back, can't recall specifics) 2) Apparently they spend fewer hours in classrooms than the rest of the developed world. (mentioned in the piece below)

BBC Piece

My observation- we just don't value education in our society. I will never forget the episode of Oprah (I know this sounds like it's going to be a joke Chat Icon ) where she announced plans for her school. The kids who were chosed went wild- jumping up and down, screaming with joy. Would we ever see a reaction like that here? I doubt it.



I agree with your last statement. There was a story on the news the other day where groups of parents were encouraging all parents to keep their kids home from school on Wednesday. They thought it was a waste to go for one day when the schools were closed on Thurs & Fri.

Posted 9/9/10 5:09 PM
 

DiamondGirl
You are my I love you

Member since 7/09

18802 total posts

Name:
DiamondMama

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

All school, all the time may lead to academically strong children, but it also leaves little room for social development.

My DH who works in finance got his job bc of his skills, but he gets promoted and is asked to networking events bc of his robust personality.

He suceeds on his job bc he is a good communicator, he has a way with people.

These are not things that math and science class teach.

We want, well I know I do anyway, a society of well rounded people. Smart, well educated, but also people who have personalities.

School is one the most important aspects of a persons life, but it should not be the only thing a person has.

This is America and the things I mentioned count here. It is one of the reasons why we are successful as a nation.

Ask any successful attorney, real estate agent, CEO etc.

Ask them if the score on their SAT's got them where they are today. I bet not. MIT will get you a degree, but the guy who talks golf with the boss gets the invite to the outing, which leads to a repore which leads to keeping him in mind for a promotion.

It is the way it works around here.

People hiring from other nations do so to save money, usually.

Hope this does not sound snarky but as a guidance counselor I work hard to encourage the parents of my students (I speak mainly of my immigrant parents here) to allow their kids to have a social life, join a sports team or a club. Many of these parents feel they should be in school from dusk till dawn, everyday, all year. You know what? The majority of these kids are unhappy. They feel as though they have no outlet, no place to be creative, to be a kid.

IMO it is not healthy. Sure there are some personalities that it will work for, but not the majority.

Message edited 2010-09-09 17:58:08.070000.

Posted 9/9/10 5:54 PM
 

Octobermom
LIF Adult

Member since 1/09

972 total posts

Name:
Anna Maria

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

This question is really all about politics. Most nations in the world do not offer universal education. They also tend to gear students early on into areas where they feel they will have the most success -- including the trades and vocational areas. Most countries do not compel students to until the age of 18 and then label the school a failure when their young adults choose to not complete their educations.


Posted 9/9/10 7:06 PM
 

springsandra
Baby girl has a baby brother!

Member since 11/09

7155 total posts

Name:
Sandra

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

There's year round schooling tracks around here where I live now in NC. They track-out a few weeks here and there during the year and I believe they have the same amount of "total" time off as traditional students do.

So at least where I live, I don't think it makes much of a difference at all having year-round schooling verses traditional. Except their summers aren't really long enough to get full-time jobs. But that doesn't really apply until near the end of H.S. anyway.

Posted 9/9/10 7:17 PM
 

Dani
Life is about choices.

Member since 5/05

6532 total posts

Name:
Dani

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by zuzuspetals

Greetings! Teacher here! Chat Icon

I do believe that in some other countries the children are getting a better education in many ways. However, I do NOT believe it is based on how many days they are in school. If we kept the system the way it is and increased the school year, I doubt we would see real progress. However, if the system was revamped then that would be a different story.

I feel that the children here are not held to the highest standards. Generally, the children I see are not disciplined, they do not want to work, they want to do the bare minimum. Even the children in the honors classes do not seem to have the same work ethic as they did years ago. Teachers have ZERO power. We can hardly discipline. We can't use red ink (it's bad for the self esteem). We cannot raise our voice, it's corporal punishment. Honestly, we have little control over the students who are disruptive and disrespectful. Parents fight for the kids ... Fight tooth and nail and I cannot fault them for that. I know they love their children and their intentions are good. But, kids are savvy, know how to manipulate.

I would never pull my kid out of a class because of the teacher. Every child will have different chemistry with different teachers. I KNOW bad teachers exist, but a really good lesson exists when a child has to overcome a less than ideal teaching style. A student will learn to overcome a challenge. If my child comes home and says, "I'm not doing well in this class because my teacher (insert excuse here) I would say, "well, you have to work extra hard then. One day you are going to have to work for a boss that you may not like but that's the way the cookie crumbles." LOL Something along those lines. Kids today are catered to in every sense of the word. Again, no ones fault, intentions are good but I don't think we are doing them any favors.

I can say that what the kids are learning in sixth grade, they should be learning in fourth. These state tests are ruining education. Parents are lied to everyday based on results of these tests. Even the curves on the regents exams are ridiculous. A child who earns a 82 actually earned a 64. Passing on many of these exams, is a 37%! With the curve, its 65! It is absurd! We are lowering expectations and it's showing.

I hope things change but I am afraid they are going to get worse. So much fluff in the curriculum. Kids want entertainment, want good grades for decent work.






ITA

Posted 9/9/10 7:34 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Posted by DiamondGirl

Hope this does not sound snarky but as a guidance counselor I work hard to encourage the parents of my students (I speak mainly of my immigrant parents here) to allow their kids to have a social life, join a sports team or a club. Many of these parents feel they should be in school from dusk till dawn, everyday, all year. You know what? The majority of these kids are unhappy. They feel as though they have no outlet, no place to be creative, to be a kid.

IMO it is not healthy. Sure there are some personalities that it will work for, but not the majority.



Not snarky at all- I agree with you. Childhood is short- as a parent, I would not want my child in school any longer than she will be. I was summers/breaks for family time, for traveling, for pursuing interests.

Charter schools have a significantly longer day and year- and I know that though those kids do better generally compared to kids from different socioecomic backgrounds. But they also have higher teacher turnover and they also lose many of their kids (some schools lose up to 30% of their kids- either by the parent/kid's choice or the school's) so I don't think that's strong evidence for a longer day/year either. It simply isn't sustainable.

Posted 9/9/10 7:59 PM
 

TaraHutch
True beauty

Member since 10/07

9888 total posts

Name:
Tara

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

Can I be an example?Chat Icon It wouldn't matter how many damn days I went to school in a year...I would NEVER have been good at math or science.

I don't know if we can always blame it on the school system...everyone learns differently. Everyone has strengths and weaknesses. It didn't matter if I went to summer school to pass the damn Math regents exam because my Mom insisted I had to have a Regents diploma- I still couldn't hack it. And I TRIED.

Yet I aced the Spanish regents.Chat Icon I was strong in the languages and arts. And guess what? I walked away without a Regents diploma and lived to tell about it. Chat Icon

Now I teach music, which some could say is expendable....but I see the worth when I have parents come to me saying their children with learning difficulties live for my class because it's the only time of day they can feel good about themselves.

We all learn differently. Gardner's Multiple Intelligence Theory, anyone? We're not all meant to be engineers and geniuses. I think we're a product of our culture. I don't see how adding more days to the school year could change that. The more you study the media in America, I think it's clear why we don't score as high as other countries. The image of an engineer isn't so 'popular' - just a thought.

Though I will admit, I don't do well with a long break!Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-09-09 21:01:13.760000.

Posted 9/9/10 8:58 PM
 

Sheena
LIF Infant

Member since 3/07

264 total posts

Name:
queen of the jungle

Re: Question about "year round schooling".

One reason you cannot compare our scores to those scores from other countries is because our scores are from ALL students in a grade. In other countries, the students in a grade may only be their best and brightest.

In America we educate everyone. In many other countries only the best are able to go to specialized schools for engineering, math, and sciences. They track their students into these program, so we're comparing the math scores of all, let's say, 10th-grade math students--including the below level students, whether it be due to language, or special education--to the 10th-grade math students who are the brightest students in their nation.

Posted 9/9/10 9:10 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Spanish Immersion Workshop or Spanish all year round? vegalady 6/22/10 1 Parenting
Anyone use their grill year-round? rileysmama 6/3/10 13 Dining In or Out
Looking for year round rental in East Hampton Holly 10/29/09 4 Home
2009 Times Square ball to stay up year-round GoldenRod 11/11/08 20 Families Helping Families ™
So has anyone heard about the possiblility of a year round school year? beautyq115 10/19/07 18 Teachers
1 Year Wedding Anniversary Cake-Question LuvMy2Girls 9/15/05 5 Families Helping Families ™