Question about "year round schooling".
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: [1] 2 3 | |
|
Question about "year round schooling". This is a real question. I am not trying to start anything... I am really looking for an answer. Message edited 2010-09-09 16:20:10.967000. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 12:47 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". thats a good question. Message edited 2010-09-09 13:32:21.737000. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 12:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". I'm not sure how it would work here, but I can tell you how it was in San Diego... |
|
Posted 9/9/10 12:58 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Greetings! Teacher here! Message edited 2010-09-09 13:16:52.667000. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 1:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". By the way, I know that many exceptions exist to my statements. I do NOT mean ALL parents, ALL schools, ALL teachers, ALL students. In my experience, this is what I have encountered. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 1:10 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". The only reason kids have the summer off is because many many many years ago their help was needed on the farm so school was in session during what general are cooler months. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 1:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Very well said, zuzuspetals. I think the issues that exist go beyond the amount of time that our kids are in school. I do believe that kids need downtime, and to "rest" their brains. Message edited 2010-09-09 13:21:16.680000. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 1:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Posted by zuzuspetals Greetings! Teacher here! I do believe that in some other countries the children are getting a better education in many ways. However, I do NOT believe it is based on how many days they are in school. If we kept the system the way it is and increased the school year, I doubt we would see real progress. However, if the system was revamped then that would be a different story. I feel that the children here are not held to the highest standards. Generally, the children I see are not disciplined, they do not want to work, they want to do the bare minimum. Even the children in the honors classes do not seem to have the same work ethic as they did years ago. Teachers have ZERO power. We can hardly discipline. We can't use red ink (it's bad for the self esteem). We cannot raise our voice, it's corporal punishment. Honestly, we have little control over the students who are disruptive and disrespectful. Parents fight for the kids ... Fight tooth and nail and I cannot fault them for that. I know they love their children and their intentions are good. But, kids are savvy, know how to manipulate. I would never pull my kid out of a class because of the teacher. Every child will have different chemistry with different teachers. I KNOW bad teachers exist, but a really good lesson exists when a child has to overcome a less than ideal teaching style. A student will learn to overcome a challenge. If my child comes home and says, "I'm not doing well in this class because my teacher (insert excuse here) I would say, "well, you have to work extra hard then. One day you are going to have to work for a boss that you may not like but that's the way the cookie crumbles." LOL Something along those lines. Kids today are catered to in every sense of the word. Again, no ones fault, intentions are good but I don't think we are doing them any favors. I can say that what the kids are learning in sixth grade, they should be learning in fourth. These state tests are ruining education. Parents are lied to everyday based on results of these tests. Even the curves on the regents exams are ridiculous. A child who earns a 82 actually earned a 64. Passing on many of these exams, is a 37%! With the curve, its 65! It is absurd! We are lowering expectations and it's showing. I am not a teacher but I couldnt agree more with this. I dont think the important of education is stressed as strongly here as it is in other countries. I dont think we expect enough of our children. I think unfortunately some parents send their kids to school and think they are the school's problem where education should be considered just as important in the home. We also are a very selfish society and think things should just be handed out as opposed to working for hard. I've said it before bu for the most part all the state tests are a waste. Teachers spend all year prepping their students for tests that like the above poster mentioned are all graded on a curve and are not necessarily a true representation of the child academically. Message edited 2010-09-09 13:23:25.400000. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 1:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". when i had the summers off i had difficulty coming back and remember anything that i had learned in difficult subjects for me. Back when I went to school there was really no "programs" geared for children with difficulties in the summer as much as they do now. Also the expense of these programs can be crippling to most. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 1:39 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Posted by zuzuspetals Greetings! Teacher here! I do believe that in some other countries the children are getting a better education in many ways. However, I do NOT believe it is based on how many days they are in school. If we kept the system the way it is and increased the school year, I doubt we would see real progress. However, if the system was revamped then that would be a different story. I feel that the children here are not held to the highest standards. Generally, the children I see are not disciplined, they do not want to work, they want to do the bare minimum. Even the children in the honors classes do not seem to have the same work ethic as they did years ago. Teachers have ZERO power. We can hardly discipline. We can't use red ink (it's bad for the self esteem). We cannot raise our voice, it's corporal punishment. Honestly, we have little control over the students who are disruptive and disrespectful. Parents fight for the kids ... Fight tooth and nail and I cannot fault them for that. I know they love their children and their intentions are good. But, kids are savvy, know how to manipulate. I would never pull my kid out of a class because of the teacher. Every child will have different chemistry with different teachers. I KNOW bad teachers exist, but a really good lesson exists when a child has to overcome a less than ideal teaching style. A student will learn to overcome a challenge. If my child comes home and says, "I'm not doing well in this class because my teacher (insert excuse here) I would say, "well, you have to work extra hard then. One day you are going to have to work for a boss that you may not like but that's the way the cookie crumbles." LOL Something along those lines. Kids today are catered to in every sense of the word. Again, no ones fault, intentions are good but I don't think we are doing them any favors. I can say that what the kids are learning in sixth grade, they should be learning in fourth. These state tests are ruining education. Parents are lied to everyday based on results of these tests. Even the curves on the regents exams are ridiculous. A child who earns a 82 actually earned a 64. Passing on many of these exams, is a 37%! With the curve, its 65! It is absurd! We are lowering expectations and it's showing. I hope things change but I am afraid they are going to get worse. So much fluff in the curriculum. Kids want entertainment, want good grades for decent work. *I want to add: My husband and I are both teachers and despite all of the politics, mumbo jumbo, regulations we do not agree with ... we LIVE for our jobs. I am in love with my profession and I would never trade it for all of the money in the world. The joy I get from teaching is incredible. The relationships I form with my students are undeniable. I try and teach them real world lessons each day I am in the classroom. And every year, I cry like a baby when I have to let them go. both dh and i are teachers as well and couldn't agree more with this ! well said! |
|
Posted 9/9/10 1:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Having been in schools that were year round and those that were traditional summers off, it was easier to get back into the class routine after breaks in the year round model than when I had the whole summer off. But I don't think that I learned more in those schools than the traditional model. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 1:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Posted by Nifheim when i had the summers off i had difficulty coming back and remember anything that i had learned in difficult subjects for me. Back when I went to school there was really no "programs" geared for children with difficulties in the summer as much as they do now. Also the expense of these programs can be crippling to most. I am not a educator, i only teach adults but I can only reflect what I recall from my school days and really feeling all year round school with some extra time off built in monthly would of been best for me. I am sure there are many students as well that would benefit from it as well. As far as the challenges in a classroom with the restrictive nature of teachers now, i think we truly have taken away most rights as adults to enforce rules on children. My kindergarten teacher put me in the corner when i ate glue, she hit my hand when i had taken a toy away from another child, i wasn't allowed to participate in recess if my grades were not good - it did hurt but you know what stuff like that builds character and a great foundation of what is good and what is bad behavior and in no one way did i feel or even my mom ever felt it was wrong of my teacher to discipline me. This is a big reason why schools implemented reading several books over the summer and then testing the students when they got back. I hated those books so much! |
|
Posted 9/9/10 1:53 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Posted by Nifheim when i had the summers off i had difficulty coming back and remember anything that i had learned in difficult subjects for me. Back when I went to school there was really no "programs" geared for children with difficulties in the summer as much as they do now. Also the expense of these programs can be crippling to most. I am not a educator, i only teach adults but I can only reflect what I recall from my school days and really feeling all year round school with some extra time off built in monthly would of been best for me. I am sure there are many students as well that would benefit from it as well. As far as the challenges in a classroom with the restrictive nature of teachers now, i think we truly have taken away most rights as adults to enforce rules on children. My kindergarten teacher put me in the corner when i ate glue, she hit my hand when i had taken a toy away from another child, i wasn't allowed to participate in recess if my grades were not good - it did hurt but you know what stuff like that builds character and a great foundation of what is good and what is bad behavior and in no one way did i feel or even my mom ever felt it was wrong of my teacher to discipline me. I work in special ed and our summer school is to prevent "substansial regression". If a student is deemed to be someone who would regress each summer. They come to summer school. They aren't taught new material but, review everything they learned in order to prevent the September regression. But, that is special ed. Not regular ed. Maybe a program like that would help the situation you talked about if it was created for a reg. ed. environment. Message edited 2010-09-09 14:30:56.353000. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 2:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Posted by zuzuspetals Greetings! Teacher here! I do believe that in some other countries the children are getting a better education in many ways. However, I do NOT believe it is based on how many days they are in school. If we kept the system the way it is and increased the school year, I doubt we would see real progress. However, if the system was revamped then that would be a different story. I feel that the children here are not held to the highest standards. Generally, the children I see are not disciplined, they do not want to work, they want to do the bare minimum. Even the children in the honors classes do not seem to have the same work ethic as they did years ago. Teachers have ZERO power. We can hardly discipline. We can't use red ink (it's bad for the self esteem). We cannot raise our voice, it's corporal punishment. Honestly, we have little control over the students who are disruptive and disrespectful. Parents fight for the kids ... Fight tooth and nail and I cannot fault them for that. I know they love their children and their intentions are good. But, kids are savvy, know how to manipulate. I would never pull my kid out of a class because of the teacher. Every child will have different chemistry with different teachers. I KNOW bad teachers exist, but a really good lesson exists when a child has to overcome a less than ideal teaching style. A student will learn to overcome a challenge. If my child comes home and says, "I'm not doing well in this class because my teacher (insert excuse here) I would say, "well, you have to work extra hard then. One day you are going to have to work for a boss that you may not like but that's the way the cookie crumbles." LOL Something along those lines. Kids today are catered to in every sense of the word. Again, no ones fault, intentions are good but I don't think we are doing them any favors. I can say that what the kids are learning in sixth grade, they should be learning in fourth. These state tests are ruining education. Parents are lied to everyday based on results of these tests. Even the curves on the regents exams are ridiculous. A child who earns a 82 actually earned a 64. Passing on many of these exams, is a 37%! With the curve, its 65! It is absurd! We are lowering expectations and it's showing. I hope things change but I am afraid they are going to get worse. So much fluff in the curriculum. Kids want entertainment, want good grades for decent work. *I want to add: My husband and I are both teachers and despite all of the politics, mumbo jumbo, regulations we do not agree with ... we LIVE for our jobs. I am in love with my profession and I would never trade it for all of the money in the world. The joy I get from teaching is incredible. The relationships I form with my students are undeniable. I try and teach them real world lessons each day I am in the classroom. And every year, I cry like a baby when I have to let them go. I agree with all of that. I am just so tired of hearing that a 12 month school year is the answer without any proof that it actually changes the outcome of the "adult" in the end. I get that when tested as STUDENTS they may out preform American's.. but, what about the end product? Is it any different or do we eventually catch up? |
|
Posted 9/9/10 2:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Posted by sfp0701 Posted by zuzuspetals Greetings! Teacher here! I do believe that in some other countries the children are getting a better education in many ways. However, I do NOT believe it is based on how many days they are in school. If we kept the system the way it is and increased the school year, I doubt we would see real progress. However, if the system was revamped then that would be a different story. I feel that the children here are not held to the highest standards. Generally, the children I see are not disciplined, they do not want to work, they want to do the bare minimum. Even the children in the honors classes do not seem to have the same work ethic as they did years ago. Teachers have ZERO power. We can hardly discipline. We can't use red ink (it's bad for the self esteem). We cannot raise our voice, it's corporal punishment. Honestly, we have little control over the students who are disruptive and disrespectful. Parents fight for the kids ... Fight tooth and nail and I cannot fault them for that. I know they love their children and their intentions are good. But, kids are savvy, know how to manipulate. I would never pull my kid out of a class because of the teacher. Every child will have different chemistry with different teachers. I KNOW bad teachers exist, but a really good lesson exists when a child has to overcome a less than ideal teaching style. A student will learn to overcome a challenge. If my child comes home and says, "I'm not doing well in this class because my teacher (insert excuse here) I would say, "well, you have to work extra hard then. One day you are going to have to work for a boss that you may not like but that's the way the cookie crumbles." LOL Something along those lines. Kids today are catered to in every sense of the word. Again, no ones fault, intentions are good but I don't think we are doing them any favors. I can say that what the kids are learning in sixth grade, they should be learning in fourth. These state tests are ruining education. Parents are lied to everyday based on results of these tests. Even the curves on the regents exams are ridiculous. A child who earns a 82 actually earned a 64. Passing on many of these exams, is a 37%! With the curve, its 65! It is absurd! We are lowering expectations and it's showing. I hope things change but I am afraid they are going to get worse. So much fluff in the curriculum. Kids want entertainment, want good grades for decent work. *I want to add: My husband and I are both teachers and despite all of the politics, mumbo jumbo, regulations we do not agree with ... we LIVE for our jobs. I am in love with my profession and I would never trade it for all of the money in the world. The joy I get from teaching is incredible. The relationships I form with my students are undeniable. I try and teach them real world lessons each day I am in the classroom. And every year, I cry like a baby when I have to let them go. I agree with all of that. I am just so tired of hearing that a 12 month school year is the answer without any proof that it actually changes the outcome of the "adult" in the end. I get that when tested as STUDENTS they may out preform American's.. but, what about the end product? Is it any different or do we eventually catch up? Do you think it’s a coincidence that nations with more days of schooling outperform US students? And that these nations produce more engineers, computer programers and scientists than we do? |
|
Posted 9/9/10 2:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Posted by annoyedTTCer Posted by sfp0701 Posted by zuzuspetals Greetings! Teacher here! I do believe that in some other countries the children are getting a better education in many ways. However, I do NOT believe it is based on how many days they are in school. If we kept the system the way it is and increased the school year, I doubt we would see real progress. However, if the system was revamped then that would be a different story. I feel that the children here are not held to the highest standards. Generally, the children I see are not disciplined, they do not want to work, they want to do the bare minimum. Even the children in the honors classes do not seem to have the same work ethic as they did years ago. Teachers have ZERO power. We can hardly discipline. We can't use red ink (it's bad for the self esteem). We cannot raise our voice, it's corporal punishment. Honestly, we have little control over the students who are disruptive and disrespectful. Parents fight for the kids ... Fight tooth and nail and I cannot fault them for that. I know they love their children and their intentions are good. But, kids are savvy, know how to manipulate. I would never pull my kid out of a class because of the teacher. Every child will have different chemistry with different teachers. I KNOW bad teachers exist, but a really good lesson exists when a child has to overcome a less than ideal teaching style. A student will learn to overcome a challenge. If my child comes home and says, "I'm not doing well in this class because my teacher (insert excuse here) I would say, "well, you have to work extra hard then. One day you are going to have to work for a boss that you may not like but that's the way the cookie crumbles." LOL Something along those lines. Kids today are catered to in every sense of the word. Again, no ones fault, intentions are good but I don't think we are doing them any favors. I can say that what the kids are learning in sixth grade, they should be learning in fourth. These state tests are ruining education. Parents are lied to everyday based on results of these tests. Even the curves on the regents exams are ridiculous. A child who earns a 82 actually earned a 64. Passing on many of these exams, is a 37%! With the curve, its 65! It is absurd! We are lowering expectations and it's showing. I hope things change but I am afraid they are going to get worse. So much fluff in the curriculum. Kids want entertainment, want good grades for decent work. *I want to add: My husband and I are both teachers and despite all of the politics, mumbo jumbo, regulations we do not agree with ... we LIVE for our jobs. I am in love with my profession and I would never trade it for all of the money in the world. The joy I get from teaching is incredible. The relationships I form with my students are undeniable. I try and teach them real world lessons each day I am in the classroom. And every year, I cry like a baby when I have to let them go. I agree with all of that. I am just so tired of hearing that a 12 month school year is the answer without any proof that it actually changes the outcome of the "adult" in the end. I get that when tested as STUDENTS they may out preform American's.. but, what about the end product? Is it any different or do we eventually catch up? Do you think it’s a coincidence that nations with more days of schooling outperform US students? And that these nations produce more engineers, computer programers and scientists than we do? What I was asking is.. where is the proof? I was asking if anyone knew of a study that PROVED that the ADULTS ( i never said students.. as in when they were kids) were more intelligent or could score better than our adults... That's all. And do they produce more of those engineers etc. because of population or has it been adujsted? As in the percentage of people that graduate college are engineers, etc. Honestly, I was just wondering if it was ever proven? I really don't know. Maybe there is proof. I honestly don't know and was wondering if there was. But, so far.. no one has shown me a stat ever that said that at the end of schooling, the other students performed better. Message edited 2010-09-09 14:42:39.773000. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 2:42 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Posted by sfp0701 Posted by annoyedTTCer What I was asking is.. where is the proof? your question was perfectly clear, dont worry As for producing more engineers, chemists, programmers, etc - is there proof, aside from the population that it is bc of the # of days in the school year, as opposed the the curriculum itself? Message edited 2010-09-09 14:55:37.853000. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 2:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Posted by sfp0701 Posted by annoyedTTCer Posted by sfp0701 Posted by zuzuspetals Greetings! Teacher here! I do believe that in some other countries the children are getting a better education in many ways. However, I do NOT believe it is based on how many days they are in school. If we kept the system the way it is and increased the school year, I doubt we would see real progress. However, if the system was revamped then that would be a different story. I feel that the children here are not held to the highest standards. Generally, the children I see are not disciplined, they do not want to work, they want to do the bare minimum. Even the children in the honors classes do not seem to have the same work ethic as they did years ago. Teachers have ZERO power. We can hardly discipline. We can't use red ink (it's bad for the self esteem). We cannot raise our voice, it's corporal punishment. Honestly, we have little control over the students who are disruptive and disrespectful. Parents fight for the kids ... Fight tooth and nail and I cannot fault them for that. I know they love their children and their intentions are good. But, kids are savvy, know how to manipulate. I would never pull my kid out of a class because of the teacher. Every child will have different chemistry with different teachers. I KNOW bad teachers exist, but a really good lesson exists when a child has to overcome a less than ideal teaching style. A student will learn to overcome a challenge. If my child comes home and says, "I'm not doing well in this class because my teacher (insert excuse here) I would say, "well, you have to work extra hard then. One day you are going to have to work for a boss that you may not like but that's the way the cookie crumbles." LOL Something along those lines. Kids today are catered to in every sense of the word. Again, no ones fault, intentions are good but I don't think we are doing them any favors. I can say that what the kids are learning in sixth grade, they should be learning in fourth. These state tests are ruining education. Parents are lied to everyday based on results of these tests. Even the curves on the regents exams are ridiculous. A child who earns a 82 actually earned a 64. Passing on many of these exams, is a 37%! With the curve, its 65! It is absurd! We are lowering expectations and it's showing. I hope things change but I am afraid they are going to get worse. So much fluff in the curriculum. Kids want entertainment, want good grades for decent work. *I want to add: My husband and I are both teachers and despite all of the politics, mumbo jumbo, regulations we do not agree with ... we LIVE for our jobs. I am in love with my profession and I would never trade it for all of the money in the world. The joy I get from teaching is incredible. The relationships I form with my students are undeniable. I try and teach them real world lessons each day I am in the classroom. And every year, I cry like a baby when I have to let them go. I agree with all of that. I am just so tired of hearing that a 12 month school year is the answer without any proof that it actually changes the outcome of the "adult" in the end. I get that when tested as STUDENTS they may out preform American's.. but, what about the end product? Is it any different or do we eventually catch up? Do you think it’s a coincidence that nations with more days of schooling outperform US students? And that these nations produce more engineers, computer programers and scientists than we do? What I was asking is.. where is the proof? I was asking if anyone knew of a study that PROVED that the ADULTS ( i never said students.. as in when they were kids) were more intelligent or could score better than our adults... That's all. And do they produce more of those engineers etc. because of population or has it been adujsted? As in the percentage of people that graduate college are engineers, etc. Honestly, I was just wondering if it was ever proven? I really don't know. Maybe there is proof. I honestly don't know and was wondering if there was. But, so far.. no one has shown me a stat ever that said that at the end of schooling, the other students performed better. Honestly not sure if a long term study exists but I would accept as proof the fact Microsoft has to import engineers because they can't find qaulified ones here while Apple makes all their products overseas because that is where the talent is. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 2:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Posted by annoyedTTCer Posted by sfp0701 Posted by annoyedTTCer Posted by sfp0701 Posted by zuzuspetals Greetings! Teacher here! I do believe that in some other countries the children are getting a better education in many ways. However, I do NOT believe it is based on how many days they are in school. If we kept the system the way it is and increased the school year, I doubt we would see real progress. However, if the system was revamped then that would be a different story. I feel that the children here are not held to the highest standards. Generally, the children I see are not disciplined, they do not want to work, they want to do the bare minimum. Even the children in the honors classes do not seem to have the same work ethic as they did years ago. Teachers have ZERO power. We can hardly discipline. We can't use red ink (it's bad for the self esteem). We cannot raise our voice, it's corporal punishment. Honestly, we have little control over the students who are disruptive and disrespectful. Parents fight for the kids ... Fight tooth and nail and I cannot fault them for that. I know they love their children and their intentions are good. But, kids are savvy, know how to manipulate. I would never pull my kid out of a class because of the teacher. Every child will have different chemistry with different teachers. I KNOW bad teachers exist, but a really good lesson exists when a child has to overcome a less than ideal teaching style. A student will learn to overcome a challenge. If my child comes home and says, "I'm not doing well in this class because my teacher (insert excuse here) I would say, "well, you have to work extra hard then. One day you are going to have to work for a boss that you may not like but that's the way the cookie crumbles." LOL Something along those lines. Kids today are catered to in every sense of the word. Again, no ones fault, intentions are good but I don't think we are doing them any favors. I can say that what the kids are learning in sixth grade, they should be learning in fourth. These state tests are ruining education. Parents are lied to everyday based on results of these tests. Even the curves on the regents exams are ridiculous. A child who earns a 82 actually earned a 64. Passing on many of these exams, is a 37%! With the curve, its 65! It is absurd! We are lowering expectations and it's showing. I hope things change but I am afraid they are going to get worse. So much fluff in the curriculum. Kids want entertainment, want good grades for decent work. *I want to add: My husband and I are both teachers and despite all of the politics, mumbo jumbo, regulations we do not agree with ... we LIVE for our jobs. I am in love with my profession and I would never trade it for all of the money in the world. The joy I get from teaching is incredible. The relationships I form with my students are undeniable. I try and teach them real world lessons each day I am in the classroom. And every year, I cry like a baby when I have to let them go. I agree with all of that. I am just so tired of hearing that a 12 month school year is the answer without any proof that it actually changes the outcome of the "adult" in the end. I get that when tested as STUDENTS they may out preform American's.. but, what about the end product? Is it any different or do we eventually catch up? Do you think it’s a coincidence that nations with more days of schooling outperform US students? And that these nations produce more engineers, computer programers and scientists than we do? What I was asking is.. where is the proof? I was asking if anyone knew of a study that PROVED that the ADULTS ( i never said students.. as in when they were kids) were more intelligent or could score better than our adults... That's all. And do they produce more of those engineers etc. because of population or has it been adujsted? As in the percentage of people that graduate college are engineers, etc. Honestly, I was just wondering if it was ever proven? I really don't know. Maybe there is proof. I honestly don't know and was wondering if there was. But, so far.. no one has shown me a stat ever that said that at the end of schooling, the other students performed better. Honestly not sure if a long term study exists but I would accept as proof the fact Microsoft has to import engineers because they can't find qaulified ones here while Apple makes all their products overseas because that is where the talent is. apple, as do a million other companies, make their products in China bc the labor and parts are cheaper which equals a higher profit margin for them. Also, is the statistics of one company "proof"? CA do not import, and as a matter of fact I know THREE people alone who were schooled here in public schools and are engineers and programmers at Microsoft. Message edited 2010-09-09 15:01:08.270000. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 2:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by sfp0701 Posted by annoyedTTCer What I was asking is.. where is the proof? your question was perfectly clear, dont worry As for producing more engineers, chemists, programmers, etc - is there proof, aside from the population that it is bc of the # of days in the school year, as opposed the the curriculum itself? If they score better in math, science at nearly every grade level wouldn't that lead to more entering those fields? The fact remains we don't score well versus the rest of the world for the areas of math and science and these are probably the two most important subjects these days. I can't see how there is any debate as to if you would learn more sitting in class 180 days versus 280 days. More time should equal better and deeper coverage of subjects. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 2:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". It's a good question Tricia!! |
|
Posted 9/9/10 3:01 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by annoyedTTCer Posted by sfp0701 Posted by annoyedTTCer Posted by sfp0701 Posted by zuzuspetals Greetings! Teacher here! I do believe that in some other countries the children are getting a better education in many ways. However, I do NOT believe it is based on how many days they are in school. If we kept the system the way it is and increased the school year, I doubt we would see real progress. However, if the system was revamped then that would be a different story. I feel that the children here are not held to the highest standards. Generally, the children I see are not disciplined, they do not want to work, they want to do the bare minimum. Even the children in the honors classes do not seem to have the same work ethic as they did years ago. Teachers have ZERO power. We can hardly discipline. We can't use red ink (it's bad for the self esteem). We cannot raise our voice, it's corporal punishment. Honestly, we have little control over the students who are disruptive and disrespectful. Parents fight for the kids ... Fight tooth and nail and I cannot fault them for that. I know they love their children and their intentions are good. But, kids are savvy, know how to manipulate. I would never pull my kid out of a class because of the teacher. Every child will have different chemistry with different teachers. I KNOW bad teachers exist, but a really good lesson exists when a child has to overcome a less than ideal teaching style. A student will learn to overcome a challenge. If my child comes home and says, "I'm not doing well in this class because my teacher (insert excuse here) I would say, "well, you have to work extra hard then. One day you are going to have to work for a boss that you may not like but that's the way the cookie crumbles." LOL Something along those lines. Kids today are catered to in every sense of the word. Again, no ones fault, intentions are good but I don't think we are doing them any favors. I can say that what the kids are learning in sixth grade, they should be learning in fourth. These state tests are ruining education. Parents are lied to everyday based on results of these tests. Even the curves on the regents exams are ridiculous. A child who earns a 82 actually earned a 64. Passing on many of these exams, is a 37%! With the curve, its 65! It is absurd! We are lowering expectations and it's showing. I hope things change but I am afraid they are going to get worse. So much fluff in the curriculum. Kids want entertainment, want good grades for decent work. *I want to add: My husband and I are both teachers and despite all of the politics, mumbo jumbo, regulations we do not agree with ... we LIVE for our jobs. I am in love with my profession and I would never trade it for all of the money in the world. The joy I get from teaching is incredible. The relationships I form with my students are undeniable. I try and teach them real world lessons each day I am in the classroom. And every year, I cry like a baby when I have to let them go. I agree with all of that. I am just so tired of hearing that a 12 month school year is the answer without any proof that it actually changes the outcome of the "adult" in the end. I get that when tested as STUDENTS they may out preform American's.. but, what about the end product? Is it any different or do we eventually catch up? Do you think it’s a coincidence that nations with more days of schooling outperform US students? And that these nations produce more engineers, computer programers and scientists than we do? What I was asking is.. where is the proof? I was asking if anyone knew of a study that PROVED that the ADULTS ( i never said students.. as in when they were kids) were more intelligent or could score better than our adults... That's all. And do they produce more of those engineers etc. because of population or has it been adujsted? As in the percentage of people that graduate college are engineers, etc. Honestly, I was just wondering if it was ever proven? I really don't know. Maybe there is proof. I honestly don't know and was wondering if there was. But, so far.. no one has shown me a stat ever that said that at the end of schooling, the other students performed better. Honestly not sure if a long term study exists but I would accept as proof the fact Microsoft has to import engineers because they can't find qaulified ones here while Apple makes all their products overseas because that is where the talent is. apple, as do a million other companies, make their products in China bc the labor and parts are cheaper which equals a higher profit margin for them. Not totally true. Apple also designs and engineers their products in Asia with suppliers because that's where the talent is. Concepts are created in the USA but execution happens in Asia in conjunction with vendors. Nearly every improvement to Apple products is the result of vendors working to improve their goods. These improvements don't come from people making a $1 an hour in some dark room. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 3:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Posted by annoyedTTCer Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by sfp0701 Posted by annoyedTTCer What I was asking is.. where is the proof? your question was perfectly clear, dont worry As for producing more engineers, chemists, programmers, etc - is there proof, aside from the population that it is bc of the # of days in the school year, as opposed the the curriculum itself? If they score better in math, science at nearly every grade level wouldn't that lead to more entering those fields? The fact remains we don't score well versus the rest of the world for the areas of math and science and these are probably the two most important subjects these days. I can't see how there is any debate as to if you would learn more sitting in class 180 days versus 280 days. More time should equal better and deeper coverage of subjects. i just think its a blanket statement, she is asking for proof, unless you are going to compare apples to apples, there is no way to know what they are being taught and it still doesnt answer her question as to whether or not they are smarter as adults....not which career field is more prominent based in the education system. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 3:04 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by annoyedTTCer Posted by sfp0701 Posted by annoyedTTCer Posted by sfp0701 Posted by zuzuspetals Greetings! Teacher here! I do believe that in some other countries the children are getting a better education in many ways. However, I do NOT believe it is based on how many days they are in school. If we kept the system the way it is and increased the school year, I doubt we would see real progress. However, if the system was revamped then that would be a different story. I feel that the children here are not held to the highest standards. Generally, the children I see are not disciplined, they do not want to work, they want to do the bare minimum. Even the children in the honors classes do not seem to have the same work ethic as they did years ago. Teachers have ZERO power. We can hardly discipline. We can't use red ink (it's bad for the self esteem). We cannot raise our voice, it's corporal punishment. Honestly, we have little control over the students who are disruptive and disrespectful. Parents fight for the kids ... Fight tooth and nail and I cannot fault them for that. I know they love their children and their intentions are good. But, kids are savvy, know how to manipulate. I would never pull my kid out of a class because of the teacher. Every child will have different chemistry with different teachers. I KNOW bad teachers exist, but a really good lesson exists when a child has to overcome a less than ideal teaching style. A student will learn to overcome a challenge. If my child comes home and says, "I'm not doing well in this class because my teacher (insert excuse here) I would say, "well, you have to work extra hard then. One day you are going to have to work for a boss that you may not like but that's the way the cookie crumbles." LOL Something along those lines. Kids today are catered to in every sense of the word. Again, no ones fault, intentions are good but I don't think we are doing them any favors. I can say that what the kids are learning in sixth grade, they should be learning in fourth. These state tests are ruining education. Parents are lied to everyday based on results of these tests. Even the curves on the regents exams are ridiculous. A child who earns a 82 actually earned a 64. Passing on many of these exams, is a 37%! With the curve, its 65! It is absurd! We are lowering expectations and it's showing. I hope things change but I am afraid they are going to get worse. So much fluff in the curriculum. Kids want entertainment, want good grades for decent work. *I want to add: My husband and I are both teachers and despite all of the politics, mumbo jumbo, regulations we do not agree with ... we LIVE for our jobs. I am in love with my profession and I would never trade it for all of the money in the world. The joy I get from teaching is incredible. The relationships I form with my students are undeniable. I try and teach them real world lessons each day I am in the classroom. And every year, I cry like a baby when I have to let them go. I agree with all of that. I am just so tired of hearing that a 12 month school year is the answer without any proof that it actually changes the outcome of the "adult" in the end. I get that when tested as STUDENTS they may out preform American's.. but, what about the end product? Is it any different or do we eventually catch up? Do you think it’s a coincidence that nations with more days of schooling outperform US students? And that these nations produce more engineers, computer programers and scientists than we do? What I was asking is.. where is the proof? I was asking if anyone knew of a study that PROVED that the ADULTS ( i never said students.. as in when they were kids) were more intelligent or could score better than our adults... That's all. And do they produce more of those engineers etc. because of population or has it been adujsted? As in the percentage of people that graduate college are engineers, etc. Honestly, I was just wondering if it was ever proven? I really don't know. Maybe there is proof. I honestly don't know and was wondering if there was. But, so far.. no one has shown me a stat ever that said that at the end of schooling, the other students performed better. Honestly not sure if a long term study exists but I would accept as proof the fact Microsoft has to import engineers because they can't find qaulified ones here while Apple makes all their products overseas because that is where the talent is. apple, as do a million other companies, make their products in China bc the labor and parts are cheaper which equals a higher profit margin for them. Also, is the statistics of one company "proof"? CA do not import, and as a matter of fact I know THREE people alone who were schooled here in public schools and are engineers and programmers at Microsoft. Sorry Apple and MS are only two of the most successful US firms. Add in Google and the same is true and any other high tech firm. CA, I assume you mean Computer Associates. They use Indian talent all the time, have you visited their HQ lately? I'll be there in October, I bet I spot a ton of imported talent. As for MS, every year they ask the govenment to increase the number of HB1 visas so they can bring in talent, that is a fact. |
|
Posted 9/9/10 3:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: Question about "year round schooling". Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by annoyedTTCer Posted by eddiesmommy Posted by sfp0701 Posted by annoyedTTCer What I was asking is.. where is the proof? your question was perfectly clear, dont worry As for producing more engineers, chemists, programmers, etc - is there proof, aside from the population that it is bc of the # of days in the school year, as opposed the the curriculum itself? If they score better in math, science at nearly every grade level wouldn't that lead to more entering those fields? The fact remains we don't score well versus the rest of the world for the areas of math and science and these are probably the two most important subjects these days. I can't see how there is any debate as to if you would learn more sitting in class 180 days versus 280 days. More time should equal better and deeper coverage of subjects. i just think its a blanket statement, she is asking for proof, unless you are going to compare apples to apples, there is no way to know what they are being taught and it still doesnt answer her question as to whether or not they are smarter as adults....not which career field is more prominent based in the education system. Something has to account for us testing behind MANY other contries, do we want to say then that our curriculum sucks? |
|
Posted 9/9/10 3:07 PM
|
|
| Pages: [1] 2 3 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spanish Immersion Workshop or Spanish all year round? | vegalady | 6/22/10 | 1 | Parenting |
| Anyone use their grill year-round? | rileysmama | 6/3/10 | 13 | Dining In or Out |
| Looking for year round rental in East Hampton | Holly | 10/29/09 | 4 | Home |
| 2009 Times Square ball to stay up year-round | GoldenRod | 11/11/08 | 20 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| So has anyone heard about the possiblility of a year round school year? | beautyq115 | 10/19/07 | 18 | Teachers |
| 1 Year Wedding Anniversary Cake-Question | LuvMy2Girls | 9/15/05 | 5 | Families Helping Families ™ |










