Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3]

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by JennZ

I immediately thought scandal. Sorry. Nothing surprises me with the Catholic Church.



I thought the same.

Posted 2/11/13 12:55 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

gina409
TWINS!

Member since 12/09

27635 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by GioiaMia

I definitely think he must be suffering some form of dementia. . .and his advisors probably feel like he cannot hide it anymore. . . this is a man who publicly speaks DAILY and in several languages.

It is so disheartening though that every source that I have turned to be it news, or social media, I have to weed through Catholics and non Catholics alike using this time to bash the Church. But I guess at this point, practicing Catholics are used to it and we shouldn't be surprised by anything anymore.

.

Ita

Posted 2/11/13 12:57 PM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by JennP

Posted by JAAMS

I understand the church isn't a perfect institution (I don't think any man made one is, to be honest), but...

If the church doesn't change the way it does things, it's bad because it never changes.

If the church does change the way it does things, it's bad because it changed.

I just don't get it.



Can you explain where this comes from, especially the second part?

Are you equating the Pope stepping down with "change?"

Just trying to understand.Chat Icon



Sorry-I didn't want to quote a specific person, b/c I wasn't responding to a specific person...just a general idea.

By change I meant the fact that it hasn't happened in hundreds of years.

Posted 2/11/13 1:02 PM
 

peanutbutter2
Carpe diem!

Member since 11/10

5287 total posts

Name:

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by rojerono

Posted by JAAMS

I understand the church isn't a perfect institution (I don't think any man made one is, to be honest), but...

If the church doesn't change the way it does things, it's bad because it never changes.

If the church does change the way it does things, it's bad because it changed.

I just don't get it.



I don't know what there is to get.. and I'm not trying to be snarky at all.

This is not unique to the Catholic Church. Many religious organizations are skewered relentlessly by folks who are not a part of them. Scientology, Jehovah's, Muslims .. do they have it 'easier'? How about our government? If they are trying to do things differently there are people who will scream that they have forgotten their roots. If they look to be traditional people will scream that they aren't progressive enough. Same thing with other countries governments and unions and businesses and political parties and lobbying groups.

If you stand outside and apart from a group you see the cracks and the flaws a little more glaringly than you do from the 'inside'.

eta: I still don't see anyone saying or implying that there is something BAD necessarily. It's unusual and given the history of the church and it's disdain for things that make anyone go 'hmmm'.. I don't think it's weird to wonder what else might be happening.




I'm talking about the nature of the criticism itself. I'm not quire sure how to explain it other than how I did, so I think I am just going to leave it be.

Posted 2/11/13 1:06 PM
 

kimmaymb20
a year of surprise

Member since 7/09

1119 total posts

Name:
Kimberly

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by donegal419

I am in shock. This is unprecedented in modern times. That Said however, in one way I commend him. Archbishop Dolan was just on the news and made a good point. Perhaps it is because of his love for the Church that he is stepping down and that he is humble enough to know that he cannot continue to best serve it.

Interestingly, when Benedict was chosen, it was with the idea that we needed a pope to lead the transitional period between JPII and another younger pope who would have a longer tenure. I think the time is now to pick someone young and energetic to lead the Church through today's turbulent times. I personally think Archbishop Dolan would be an amazing choice.



I agree with this.

Father Jonathan Morris also stated how this is a very humble thing for any Pope to do.

I will be praying hard that Cardinal Dolan will be the next Pope Chat Icon

Posted 2/11/13 1:49 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by JAAMS

Posted by rojerono

Posted by JAAMS

I understand the church isn't a perfect institution (I don't think any man made one is, to be honest), but...

If the church doesn't change the way it does things, it's bad because it never changes.

If the church does change the way it does things, it's bad because it changed.

I just don't get it.



I don't know what there is to get.. and I'm not trying to be snarky at all.

This is not unique to the Catholic Church. Many religious organizations are skewered relentlessly by folks who are not a part of them. Scientology, Jehovah's, Muslims .. do they have it 'easier'? How about our government? If they are trying to do things differently there are people who will scream that they have forgotten their roots. If they look to be traditional people will scream that they aren't progressive enough. Same thing with other countries governments and unions and businesses and political parties and lobbying groups.

If you stand outside and apart from a group you see the cracks and the flaws a little more glaringly than you do from the 'inside'.

eta: I still don't see anyone saying or implying that there is something BAD necessarily. It's unusual and given the history of the church and it's disdain for things that make anyone go 'hmmm'.. I don't think it's weird to wonder what else might be happening.




I'm talking about the nature of the criticism itself. I'm not quire sure how to explain it other than how I did, so I think I am just going to leave it be.



I meant to respond to this post earlier. This isn't a case of damned if you do damned if you don't. It is true that the catholic church has lost a lot of followers for being rigid and refusing to change with the times.

But this isn't an example of the church trying to make that sort of change... and its not as if this action chanjges things for catholic people significantly.

This is a complete reversal of personality, unprecedented action taken by a pope who has always proven to be resistant to change regardless of public opinion. That's what makes it suspicious.

Posted 2/11/13 2:01 PM
 

Mrs213
????????

Member since 2/09

18986 total posts

Name:

Pope Benedict Resigning.

Maybe he was caught doing something inappropriate on twitter...

Posted 2/11/13 2:17 PM
 

teachermom
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/11

843 total posts

Name:

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by kimmaymb20

Posted by donegal419

I am in shock. This is unprecedented in modern times. That Said however, in one way I commend him. Archbishop Dolan was just on the news and made a good point. Perhaps it is because of his love for the Church that he is stepping down and that he is humble enough to know that he cannot continue to best serve it.

Interestingly, when Benedict was chosen, it was with the idea that we needed a pope to lead the transitional period between JPII and another younger pope who would have a longer tenure. I think the time is now to pick someone young and energetic to lead the Church through today's turbulent times. I personally think Archbishop Dolan would be an amazing choice.





I agree with this.

Father Jonathan Morris also stated how this is a very humble thing for any Pope to do.

I will be praying hard that Cardinal Dolan will be the next Pope Chat Icon


Just out of curiosity, what about Dolan makes you want to see him as the next Pope?

Posted 2/11/13 2:44 PM
 

ElizaRags35
My 2 Girls

Member since 2/09

20494 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by Mrs213

Maybe he was caught doing something inappropriate on twitter...



Chat Icon

Posted 2/11/13 2:58 PM
 

Paramount
Sweet!

Member since 7/12

4289 total posts

Name:

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by teachermom

I will be praying hard that Cardinal Dolan will be the next Pope Chat Icon


Just out of curiosity, what about Dolan makes you want to see him as the next Pope?




There will be no one elected as pope that will instill change for the modern world.

Not a fan of Dolan.

Message edited 2013-02-11 15:00:21.400000.

Posted 2/11/13 2:59 PM
 

METLove2008
LIF Adolescent

Member since 5/08

541 total posts

Name:
Ellie

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by MarsB

HBO just released a documentary on the pedophilia scandal in the Catholic church and the role the Vadican played. It specifically mentions Pope Benedict and the role he played. After seeing that last week and now hearing this I am definitely feeling suspicious.



I want to check out this documentary. Does anyone know if it's on demand? Has anyone seen it?

Posted 2/11/13 3:06 PM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

I am not directing this in anyone's way at all.

I am just thinking about how he is resigning and everyone is saying it's such a change from the past. .... From a pope so Old-school.

I look at it this way, (if we accept the theory that he is sick) he probably isn't the first pope to get sick in office. However, in the past, there wasn't 24/7 news and cameras. Pope's, kings, shahs, etc (anyone in power) could be sick and no one would know it. That doesn't make it right, but it happened. People would go to great lengths to hide any type of disability or illness of a beloved ruler (roosevelt had special tracks for his cars underground so he could get into his car without anyone seeing his wheelchair ..not the same of course, but you get my point). Everyone around them protected them. And without direct access and news media, it was easier.

So, in the past a pope may have stayed in office because no one (public) would know the better. And people didn't question authority for so many reasons..

So now, in our day, if he pope is up there ailing, losing his mind etc. people are going to question it. Because in all honesty the pope should be in right body, mind, spirit. He has an important job. Whether you agree with the church or not, he is the ruler (for lack of better word) of one of the largest religious organizaitons in the world.

I think he is doing a commendable thing.

Posted 2/11/13 4:51 PM
 

sfp0701
Liam's Mommy!

Member since 1/07

9764 total posts

Name:
Tricia

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by Paramount

Posted by teachermom

I will be praying hard that Cardinal Dolan will be the next Pope Chat Icon


Just out of curiosity, what about Dolan makes you want to see him as the next Pope?




There will be no one elected as pope that will instill change for the modern world.

Not a fan of Dolan.



I don't know much about dolan.

However, I will say you are right that no Pope will ever be elected that will institute the kind of change that you are probably referring to. The church is against birth control, abortion, death penalty and priests being married. No modern world perspective is going to change that. Agree with it or not (and I don't on some of those points, even though I am proud Catholic.) the church can't bend just because the modern world wants it to. The church believes these things are wrong.

Would I like to see a cool young Pope, sure. We have priests that love football, listen to modern music and are very funny.. but, no priest is going to change the church's stance on these key issues. They took a vow to uphold the teaching of the church.

AND as a side note... I can't believe I started a three page Lifamilies thread!!!! I have been on here forever and I have yet to start one.. much less one that has a touch of drama to it!!Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/11/13 4:57 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

I am chalking it up to his German work ethic. if you can't do the job and do it right, you shouldn't be doing the job.

I don't agree with him on every point, but I respect this decision very much.

Posted 2/11/13 4:58 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

600 years ago, pope's were boffing their servants and murdering rival cardinals. so there are things that have changed in the church.

scandals will abound anywhere. anywhere there is people.

the man did what he was elected to do and served his God. he wants to retire into peace before he stands at the pearly gates. I wish him well.

Posted 2/11/13 5:04 PM
 

JennP
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

3986 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by eroxgirl

Posted by JAAMS

Posted by rojerono

Posted by JAAMS

I understand the church isn't a perfect institution (I don't think any man made one is, to be honest), but...

If the church doesn't change the way it does things, it's bad because it never changes.

If the church does change the way it does things, it's bad because it changed.

I just don't get it.



I don't know what there is to get.. and I'm not trying to be snarky at all.

This is not unique to the Catholic Church. Many religious organizations are skewered relentlessly by folks who are not a part of them. Scientology, Jehovah's, Muslims .. do they have it 'easier'? How about our government? If they are trying to do things differently there are people who will scream that they have forgotten their roots. If they look to be traditional people will scream that they aren't progressive enough. Same thing with other countries governments and unions and businesses and political parties and lobbying groups.

If you stand outside and apart from a group you see the cracks and the flaws a little more glaringly than you do from the 'inside'.

eta: I still don't see anyone saying or implying that there is something BAD necessarily. It's unusual and given the history of the church and it's disdain for things that make anyone go 'hmmm'.. I don't think it's weird to wonder what else might be happening.




I'm talking about the nature of the criticism itself. I'm not quire sure how to explain it other than how I did, so I think I am just going to leave it be.



I meant to respond to this post earlier. This isn't a case of damned if you do damned if you don't. It is true that the catholic church has lost a lot of followers for being rigid and refusing to change with the times.

But this isn't an example of the church trying to make that sort of change... and its not as if this action chanjges things for catholic people significantly.

This is a complete reversal of personality, unprecedented action taken by a pope who has always proven to be resistant to change regardless of public opinion. That's what makes it suspicious.



This is what I was going to write in response to the PPs who replied to me so thank you for getting into my head and typing it out, probably better than I would have.Chat Icon

Posted 2/11/13 5:59 PM
 

StarsStripes
LIF Adult

Member since 12/12

1192 total posts

Name:

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by kimmaymb20

Posted by donegal419

I am in shock. This is unprecedented in modern times. That Said however, in one way I commend him. Archbishop Dolan was just on the news and made a good point. Perhaps it is because of his love for the Church that he is stepping down and that he is humble enough to know that he cannot continue to best serve it.

Interestingly, when Benedict was chosen, it was with the idea that we needed a pope to lead the transitional period between JPII and another younger pope who would have a longer tenure. I think the time is now to pick someone young and energetic to lead the Church through today's turbulent times. I personally think Archbishop Dolan would be an amazing choice.



I agree with this.

Father Jonathan Morris also stated how this is a very humble thing for any Pope to do.

I will be praying hard that Cardinal Dolan will be the next Pope Chat Icon



I completely agree. It is sad that people immediately think scandal...it just shows what little faith people have.

Posted 2/11/13 7:39 PM
 

teachermom
LIF Adolescent

Member since 8/11

843 total posts

Name:

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by Paramount

Posted by teachermom

I will be praying hard that Cardinal Dolan will be the next Pope Chat Icon


Just out of curiosity, what about Dolan makes you want to see him as the next Pope?




There will be no one elected as pope that will instill change for the modern world.

Not a fan of Dolan.



This quote looks like I said I was praying for Dolan and I did not say that.

Posted 2/11/13 9:05 PM
 

ME75

Member since 10/06

4563 total posts

Name:

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by Ophelia

600 years ago, pope's were boffing their servants and murdering rival cardinals. so there are things that have changed in the church.

scandals will abound anywhere. anywhere there is people.

the man did what he was elected to do and served his God. he wants to retire into peace before he stands at the pearly gates. I wish him well.



well said and ITA
there is no solid proof of him doing anything wrong to make this decision, so why even say it? i get that the church has had scandal but tell me ANY institiution that has not. for some reason it is always ok and easy for people to be openly negative and rude about the catholic church..if you don't agree with it or follow, then move on.

Posted 2/11/13 9:43 PM
 

donegal419
St. Gerard, pray for us.

Member since 7/07

7650 total posts

Name:
K

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by teachermom

Posted by kimmaymb20

Posted by donegal419

I am in shock. This is unprecedented in modern times. That Said however, in one way I commend him. Archbishop Dolan was just on the news and made a good point. Perhaps it is because of his love for the Church that he is stepping down and that he is humble enough to know that he cannot continue to best serve it.

Interestingly, when Benedict was chosen, it was with the idea that we needed a pope to lead the transitional period between JPII and another younger pope who would have a longer tenure. I think the time is now to pick someone young and energetic to lead the Church through today's turbulent times. I personally think Archbishop Dolan would be an amazing choice.





I agree with this.

Father Jonathan Morris also stated how this is a very humble thing for any Pope to do.

I will be praying hard that Cardinal Dolan will be the next Pope Chat Icon


Just out of curiosity, what about Dolan makes you want to see him as the next Pope?



I know the last comment is not directed at me, but I think that Dolan would be a great pope. Not only is he a great theologian, but he is so full of life. every time i hear him speak, i am inspired. he is wonderful with the youth and young adults and he is just a fun guy. I listen to the Catholic Channel a lot on Sirius and he is on a lot. He talks about things that everyone can relate to: enjoying a good beer or cigar, going to a baseball game, etc. but peppered with great faith and insight.

i don't think an American will be chosen as i think there is a lot to said for choosing a pope from the third world - South America, Africa or possibly Asia. The Church is exploding in those areas and they have never had a pope. the pope has always been a European.... JPII was the first pope that wasn't an Italian! However, that said, I think choosing an American pope would be great. Not because I am American, but because it is the Western World, namely Americans and Europeans are the ones that have most strayed from the Church. I think Dolan has a way of connecting with people that I think could bring back a lot of Catholics that have left the Church or for whatever reason no longer practice.

Posted 2/11/13 10:09 PM
 

DandN
Twins are here!

Member since 3/06

3597 total posts

Name:
Deirdre

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

I'm a fan of the Pope resigning. I can't think of any job that someone should have until he/she dies. Just because no one has resigned in 600 years doesn't make it the best course of action. I don't think it's a conspiracy. I believe him when he said that he doesn't feel physically capable of carrying on his duties.

I would love to see a South American Pope or an African Pope. We've had enough European Popes, and the majority of Catholics in the world are from South America.

I don't know enough about any of the cardinals mentioned as possibilities, but one of them is from Brazil.

I'd want a Brazilian Pope just for the possibility that he could samba.

Message edited 2013-02-12 10:19:21.870000.

Posted 2/11/13 10:53 PM
 

Daisy32
Mommy

Member since 2/08

8081 total posts

Name:

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

Posted by Ophelia

the man did what he was elected to do and served his God. he wants to retire into peace before he stands at the pearly gates. I wish him well.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 2/12/13 11:24 AM
 

JenniferEver
The Disney Lady

Member since 5/05

18163 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.

I'm way tardy to this party beause I was on vacation when this news broke, but since the announcement Anonymous and some others have claimed that his resignation may be the result of leaked documents pointing to large scale cover ups of sexual abuse (duh).

I cried when Pope John Paul II died, but I am kind of glad Pope benedict is resigning. He is definitey not the Pope I would have chosen for many reasons. His involvement in covering up abuse is one reason and his conservatism is another. I just hope we get a Pope who takes us inb a good direction. I read that one of the top condenders blamed gay priests for the sex abuse and i really hope we don't get someone like that in that position. I truly believe we need a pope for the 21st century.

has anyone else heard of all of these other stories? I haven't been following it too cosely

Posted 2/28/13 11:59 AM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3]