Pope Benedict Resigning.
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |
|
Pope Benedict Resigning. HBO just released a documentary on the pedophilia scandal in the Catholic church and the role the Vadican played. It specifically mentions Pope Benedict and the role he played. After seeing that last week and now hearing this I am definitely feeling suspicious. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 9:52 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by MarsB HBO just released a documentary on the pedophilia scandal in the Catholic church and the role the Vadican played. It specifically mentions Pope Benedict and the role he played. After seeing that last week and now hearing this I am definitely feeling suspicious. I saw the documentary too. Honestly, the information in it about Cardinal Ratzinger (now Pope Benedict XVI) and his role in the sex abuse scandals isn't new. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 10:00 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by MrsPJB2007 My first thought was he might have some sort of illness like Alzheimer's or dementia. Same |
|
Posted 2/11/13 10:00 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. I do find that he has an illness, and to take down the position of Pope must have been a hard task for him. What a great honor to lead the Vatican, the Churches and the Catholics. It was and still is an honor to be selected to be Pope. I think it would right to honor his request and respect his choice without thinking the worst. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 10:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. I followed the death of John Paul II and the conclave and election that followed very closely. I'm Catholic and I'm a sucker for tradition and ceremony. I remember one of the big stories when he became Pope was that he was to be a transitional Pope and didn't t have the desire to stay on for life. In fact, he took the role in a time in which he was anticipating retiring from being a Cardinal. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 10:08 AM
|
|
|
Pope Benedict Resigning. I definitely think he must be suffering some form of dementia. . .and his advisors probably feel like he cannot hide it anymore. . . this is a man who publicly speaks DAILY and in several languages. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 10:08 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by teachermom I followed the death of John Paul II and the conclave and election that followed very closely. I'm Catholic and I'm a sucker for tradition and ceremony. I remember one of the big stories when he became Pope was that he was to be a transitional Pope and didn't t have the desire to stay on for life. In fact, he took the role in a time in which he was anticipating retiring from being a Cardinal. So, sorry to say to the Church-hating conspiracy theorists, this isn't really that surprising. I love the ceremony and tradition as well, I am a sucker for a good conclave that is the one exciting thing to me here is all the shows that will be on about it!
|
|
Posted 2/11/13 10:16 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by rojerono I am prone to suspicion when it comes to the Church because it is such a powerful and often corrupt entity. Given the fact that nobody resigns - despite age or infirmity - I can't help but question his decision. it simply doesn't happen.. it hasn't happened since the Middle Ages and the Great Western Schism! And we all know THIS Pope is hardline.. he's known for his traditional views and is not one to look to break new ground. But maybe it is innocent. Maybe they want a new Pope in place for Easter. Or maybe it's nothing. I don't fault anyone or think anyone is naive for seeing nothing odd about his decision.. but I also see nothing crazy about thinking that there might be something more that isn't seen considering the Church loves secrets.. This exactly! |
|
Posted 2/11/13 10:16 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by Kitten1929 I see nothing suspicious. 85 years old is no spring chicken, and the pressures and responsibilities mst be taking is toll. If anything I see it as the prudent thing to do. I'm not really skeptic so I don't think there's an ulterior motive. I agree. Maybe he realizes he won't be effective at his age, and would rather have someoe who CAN do the job there. rather than him being less effective. Hopefully they can get someone progressive enough to meet the REAL challenges of today. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 10:21 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by rojerono This is a HUGE deal. Pope's don't resign, given the Power of the Keys they are the final authority and THE human Word according to Catholics. That was my first thought when I read the title. That's crazy. I mean I remember how big of a deal it was when the last Pope died. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 10:22 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by GioiaMia I definitely think he must be suffering some form of dementia. . .and his advisors probably feel like he cannot hide it anymore. . . this is a man who publicly speaks DAILY and in several languages. It is so disheartening though that every source that I have turned to be it news, or social media, I have to weed through Catholics and non Catholics alike using this time to bash the Church. But I guess at this point, practicing Catholics are used to it and we shouldn't be surprised by anything anymore. Exactly this! |
|
Posted 2/11/13 10:23 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by donegal419 I am in shock. This is unprecedented in modern times. That Said however, in one way I commend him. Archbishop Dolan was just on the news and made a good point. Perhaps it is because of his love for the Church that he is stepping down and that he is humble enough to know that he cannot continue to best serve it. Interestingly, when Benedict was chosen, it was with the idea that we needed a pope to lead the transitional period between JPII and another younger pope who would have a longer tenure. I think the time is now to pick someone young and energetic to lead the Church through today's turbulent times. I personally think Archbishop Dolan would be an amazing choice. Exactly. I also think that Benedict had a more modern way of thinking and handling issues as opposed to traditionalists. Even though centuries of popes have not retired (even though maybe they should have), he has the sense to quit while he is ahead and before he can not carry out his duties properly. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 11:01 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by MrsA714 Posted by GioiaMia I definitely think he must be suffering some form of dementia. . .and his advisors probably feel like he cannot hide it anymore. . . this is a man who publicly speaks DAILY and in several languages. It is so disheartening though that every source that I have turned to be it news, or social media, I have to weed through Catholics and non Catholics alike using this time to bash the Church. But I guess at this point, practicing Catholics are used to it and we shouldn't be surprised by anything anymore. Exactly this! Exactly. My mother takes care of my 83 year old grandmother who has Alzheimers. She is not of sound mind to pick out her socks, let alone be the head of the Catholic Church. Message edited 2013-02-11 12:02:01.983000. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 11:06 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by Kitten1929 Posted by MrsA714 Posted by GioiaMia I definitely think he must be suffering some form of dementia. . .and his advisors probably feel like he cannot hide it anymore. . . this is a man who publicly speaks DAILY and in several languages. It is so disheartening though that every source that I have turned to be it news, or social media, I have to weed through Catholics and non Catholics alike using this time to bash the Church. But I guess at this point, practicing Catholics are used to it and we shouldn't be surprised by anything anymore. Exactly this! Exactly. My mother takes care of my 83 year old grandmother who has Alzhemimers. She is not of sound mind to pick out her socks, let alone run be the head of the Catholic Church. I agree. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 11:08 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. It's completely suspicious to me. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 11:27 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. I understand the church isn't a perfect institution (I don't think any man made one is, to be honest), but... |
|
Posted 2/11/13 11:47 AM
|
|
|
Pope Benedict Resigning. Normally it wouldnt have be very suspicous to me...but with Ash wednesday 2 days away and lent and easter right around the corner, i think it came at a very odd time which leds me to think there is more to the story than him being 85 and tired. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 11:50 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by GioiaMia It is so disheartening though that every source that I have turned to be it news, or social media, I have to weed through Catholics and non Catholics alike using this time to bash the Church. But I guess at this point, practicing Catholics are used to it and we shouldn't be surprised by anything anymore. I love the Church. I no longer identify as Catholic for a variety of reasons.. but that does not in anyway mean that I don't have a deep affection and respect for the religion that I was raised in and that formed my identity as a person. But this IS news. It is not something that happens often at all. The election of a new Pope is news, the death of any Pope is news and the RESIGNATION of a Pope is a very big deal. I pray that the Pope is healed of whatever affliction of mind or body that might trouble him - but questioning and piqued interest in the light of something that is so very unusual is NOT the same as bashing. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 11:51 AM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by MarsB HBO just released a documentary on the pedophilia scandal in the Catholic church and the role the Vadican played. It specifically mentions Pope Benedict and the role he played. After seeing that last week and now hearing this I am definitely feeling suspicious. Yep! I find it very suspicious. Especially during the holiest time of the year.
|
|
Posted 2/11/13 12:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by JAAMS I understand the church isn't a perfect institution (I don't think any man made one is, to be honest), but... If the church doesn't change the way it does things, it's bad because it never changes. If the church does change the way it does things, it's bad because it changed. I just don't get it. Can you explain where this comes from, especially the second part? Are you equating the Pope stepping down with "change?" Just trying to understand.
|
|
Posted 2/11/13 12:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. I immediately thought scandal. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 12:14 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by JAAMS I understand the church isn't a perfect institution (I don't think any man made one is, to be honest), but... If the church doesn't change the way it does things, it's bad because it never changes. If the church does change the way it does things, it's bad because it changed. I just don't get it. I don't know what there is to get.. and I'm not trying to be snarky at all. This is not unique to the Catholic Church. Many religious organizations are skewered relentlessly by folks who are not a part of them. Scientology, Jehovah's, Muslims .. do they have it 'easier'? How about our government? If they are trying to do things differently there are people who will scream that they have forgotten their roots. If they look to be traditional people will scream that they aren't progressive enough. Same thing with other countries governments and unions and businesses and political parties and lobbying groups. If you stand outside and apart from a group you see the cracks and the flaws a little more glaringly than you do from the 'inside'. eta: I still don't see anyone saying or implying that there is something BAD necessarily. It's unusual and given the history of the church and it's disdain for things that make anyone go 'hmmm'.. I don't think it's weird to wonder what else might be happening. Message edited 2013-02-11 12:34:44.153000. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 12:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by JennP Posted by JAAMS I understand the church isn't a perfect institution (I don't think any man made one is, to be honest), but... If the church doesn't change the way it does things, it's bad because it never changes. If the church does change the way it does things, it's bad because it changed. I just don't get it. Can you explain where this comes from, especially the second part? Are you equating the Pope stepping down with "change?" Just trying to understand. I *think* she meant that people are saying this must be a scandal (a bad thing) because it is something that hasn't been done in several hundred years (something that hasn't changed). So his "stepping down" is a "change" in that sense. That's how I read it, anyway! |
|
Posted 2/11/13 12:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. Posted by Bearcat Posted by JennP Posted by JAAMS I understand the church isn't a perfect institution (I don't think any man made one is, to be honest), but... If the church doesn't change the way it does things, it's bad because it never changes. If the church does change the way it does things, it's bad because it changed. I just don't get it. Can you explain where this comes from, especially the second part? Are you equating the Pope stepping down with "change?" Just trying to understand. I *think* she meant that people are saying this must be a scandal (a bad thing) because it is something that hasn't been done in several hundred years (something that hasn't changed). So his "stepping down" is a "change" in that sense. That's how I read it, anyway! Thats the way I read it too, damned if you damned if you don't. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 12:26 PM
|
|
|
Re: Pope Benedict Resigning. On NBC they said he gave an interview very early on in his Papacy where he mentions that the Pope could resign for health reasons. I think it is for health reasons. The job has taken its toll on him. I don't think it was a scandal. Please correct me if I am wrong, but I thought he changed some of the verbiage of the mass to some older version. I think he has an old school thought process, and when I say old school it is more like 1500s than 1900s. So based on his past decisions frankly this did not surprise me at all. He is in his mid 80s. He said that he did not want to be remembered like JP at the end. I think he is retiring to die peacefully. But if I had to guess - I think he has Cancer or some other disease where daily activity will be impeded. |
|
Posted 2/11/13 12:29 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] 3 | |






that is the one exciting thing to me here is all the shows that will be on about it!











