Re: Pope Benedict Resigning.
Posted 2/11/2013 5:59:13 PM by JennP
Posted by eroxgirl
Posted by JAAMS
Posted by rojerono
Posted by JAAMS
I understand the church isn't a perfect institution (I don't think any man made one is, to be honest), but...
If the church doesn't change the way it does things, it's bad because it never changes.
If the church does change the way it does things, it's bad because it changed.
I just don't get it.
I don't know what there is to get.. and I'm not trying to be snarky at all.
This is not unique to the Catholic Church. Many religious organizations are skewered relentlessly by folks who are not a part of them. Scientology, Jehovah's, Muslims .. do they have it 'easier'? How about our government? If they are trying to do things differently there are people who will scream that they have forgotten their roots. If they look to be traditional people will scream that they aren't progressive enough. Same thing with other countries governments and unions and businesses and political parties and lobbying groups.
If you stand outside and apart from a group you see the cracks and the flaws a little more glaringly than you do from the 'inside'.
eta: I still don't see anyone saying or implying that there is something BAD necessarily. It's unusual and given the history of the church and it's disdain for things that make anyone go 'hmmm'.. I don't think it's weird to wonder what else might be happening.
I'm talking about the nature of the criticism itself. I'm not quire sure how to explain it other than how I did, so I think I am just going to leave it be.
I meant to respond to this post earlier. This isn't a case of damned if you do damned if you don't. It is true that the catholic church has lost a lot of followers for being rigid and refusing to change with the times.
But this isn't an example of the church trying to make that sort of change... and its not as if this action chanjges things for catholic people significantly.
This is a complete reversal of personality, unprecedented action taken by a pope who has always proven to be resistant to change regardless of public opinion. That's what makes it suspicious.
This is what I was going to write in response to the PPs who replied to me so thank you for getting into my head and typing it out, probably better than I would have.
|