Overweight People on TV?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by MRsFaTThead

how is this being a bully? she is saying what grosses her out.

so know everytime someone thinks something is gross they are dicriminating and being a bully?



Well, it grosses out some of the masses if people return worn clothes to a store, and even though the person who committed the action is free to do such an act, it still may not sit well.

She opened her mouth and now she will get flack for what came out of it.

Posted 10/27/10 2:40 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

ndblovah
Be happy always

Member since 1/07

1880 total posts

Name:

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by speakthetruth

Posted by kokopelia

Good ole "freedom of speech"... sad but true. ..But then again she is smart, publicity is publicity right?



I Chat Icon freedom of speech, and then I also believe in being able to speak back to insanity, KWIM?

Her little "career" is d-o-n-e.

People are already canceling their subscriptions to Marie Claire.

In the publishing industry, where print journalism is ALREADY hit so hard and is disappearing - hell, the New York Times says in a few years they will be going out of print (to, perhaps, online format), this is the last thing a print magazine needs.




I agree. But she got people talking. Not everyone will agree with her but I am sure there will be some.... Think of it that way.
Sure print is going to be extinct in a few years (which I completely dislike, love to hold something and read it Chat Icon )... but she is a blogger right? She will still get hits on her blog.

Posted 10/27/10 2:41 PM
 

Ayne11
Yep

Member since 1/09

18021 total posts

Name:

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by speakthetruth

Posted by MRsFaTThead

how is this being a bully? she is saying what grosses her out.

so know everytime someone thinks something is gross they are dicriminating and being a bully?



Well, it grosses out some of the masses if people return worn clothes to a store, and even though the person who committed the action is free to do such an act, it still may not sit well.



Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/27/10 2:43 PM
 

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by kokopelia

Posted by speakthetruth

Posted by kokopelia

Good ole "freedom of speech"... sad but true. ..But then again she is smart, publicity is publicity right?



I Chat Icon freedom of speech, and then I also believe in being able to speak back to insanity, KWIM?

Her little "career" is d-o-n-e.

People are already canceling their subscriptions to Marie Claire.

In the publishing industry, where print journalism is ALREADY hit so hard and is disappearing - hell, the New York Times says in a few years they will be going out of print (to, perhaps, online format), this is the last thing a print magazine needs.




I agree. But she got people talking. Not everyone will agree with her but I am sure there will be some.... Think of it that way.
Sure print is going to be extinct in a few years (which I completely dislike, love to hold something and read it Chat Icon )... but she is a blogger right? She will still get hits on her blog.



I normally would agree that bad publicity is still publicity - but I don't know this time. I think with all the bullying headlines in the news of kids in schools , I just feel this will not go over well. I could be wrong, though of course. It will be interesting to see how it plays out. I think she really hurt a lot of people. I would imagine some women logged on this morning at work to marieclaire.com and probably had tears in their eyes. That kills me - really kills me. Her tone was off, so was the headline..everything. It was like she was only talking to a certain percentage of the population who were "plump" and lower. I think many people will be turned off. I don't even think this is "controversial" what she said - I think it was downright cruel....and I know what you mean...if I can't hold something and read it, I will cry. Chat Icon

Posted 10/27/10 2:46 PM
 

8ternity
<3

Member since 11/08

10586 total posts

Name:
Formally NYPD-Wife

Re: Overweight People on TV?

wow who hired her??? that was very rude and disgusting!

Posted 10/27/10 2:46 PM
 

ndblovah
Be happy always

Member since 1/07

1880 total posts

Name:

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by speakthetruth

Posted by kokopelia

Posted by speakthetruth

Posted by kokopelia

Good ole "freedom of speech"... sad but true. ..But then again she is smart, publicity is publicity right?



I Chat Icon freedom of speech, and then I also believe in being able to speak back to insanity, KWIM?

Her little "career" is d-o-n-e.

People are already canceling their subscriptions to Marie Claire.

In the publishing industry, where print journalism is ALREADY hit so hard and is disappearing - hell, the New York Times says in a few years they will be going out of print (to, perhaps, online format), this is the last thing a print magazine needs.




I agree. But she got people talking. Not everyone will agree with her but I am sure there will be some.... Think of it that way.
Sure print is going to be extinct in a few years (which I completely dislike, love to hold something and read it Chat Icon )... but she is a blogger right? She will still get hits on her blog.



I normally would agree that bad publicity is still publicity - but I don't know this time. I think with all the bullying headlines in the news of kids in schools , I just feel this will not go over well. I could be wrong, though of course. It will be interesting to see how it plays out. I think she really hurt a lot of people. I would imagine some women logged on this morning at work to marieclaire.com and probably had tears in their eyes. That kills me - really kills me. Her tone was off, so was the headline..everything. It was like she was only talking to a certain percentage of the population who were "plump" and lower. I think many people will be turned off. I don't even think this is "controversial" what she said - I think it was downright cruel....and I know what you mean...if I can't hold something and read it, I will cry. Chat Icon

Good point. I can't wait to see how it plays out too...
And the day Domino folded was the saddest day in my life !!!

Posted 10/27/10 2:48 PM
 

Sunday
In love with a boy named Luca

Member since 6/09

1799 total posts

Name:
`

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by NinaLemon

Posted by annoyedTTCer


If obese people were as concerened with ther weight as they are with what some blogger wrote we could probably get rid of our obestity problems in less than a year.




Wow. I think that is pretty harsh.




Message edited 2010-10-27 14:56:06.593000.

Posted 10/27/10 2:49 PM
 

Bxgell2
Perfection

Member since 5/05

16438 total posts

Name:
Beth

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by Otherme

Posted by NinaLemon

Substitute Black/Jew/Homosexual/Handicap for fat/obese and she could be arrested.



exactly!



Ok, I know I may get flamed for this, and I'm fully prepared, but I'm going to play the devil's advocate here.

While much of what she said, and the way she said it, was deplorable, she DOES make some valid points that I agree with - mainly, that society, TV and mass media seems to be headed in the direction of normalizing obesity, instead of treating it as the VERY serious health risk that it really is.

I don't think it's fair to equate this to insulting someone on the basis of their race, religion, national origin, etc. Granted, I find it deplorable for ANYONE to be disgusted merely by the sight of a person who is obese kissing another obese person. But, obesity is a much different category than black, white, jewish, etc., because, unlike those categories, obesity represents a true, significant health risk and has many larger implications, such as the impact on our healthcare system and longevity.

Personally, I think a large part of the problem is that we have become too sensitive to the emotional aspect of obesity, instead of focusing on it as a real health issue, like smoking. There seems to be no restriction on speaking out about the detrimental impact of smoking, but because there is such an emotional interconnection with obesity, there's too much silence, and normalization, about the issue. So I see her point when she says that it is just as crazy to implicitly promote obesity because aside from any aesthetic consideration, it is simply unhealthy.

My two cents...

Posted 10/27/10 2:50 PM
 

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Blog aside, let's just focus on this one freaking line she wrote, that had NOTHING to do with the television program itself, it had to do with real life.


"To be brutally honest, even in real life, I find it aesthetically displeasing to watch a very, very fat person simply walk across a room."


**and can someone spell out to me who that IS NOT an ignorant, cruel, bully-like statement? How is she NOT belittling an entire group of humans?**

Posted 10/27/10 2:51 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Overweight People on TV?

You do not have to be 100 Lbs to be called obese. I think she (or others) needs to check the definition of obese. You are obese depending on your body fat percentage. So a skinny person could be officially obese.

In our society we have created this image of perfection only in magazines and movies.

Truth be told, most of the people on magazines are photoshoped or had plastic surgery.

Is being overweight and extremelly overweight healthy? yes and no. Some skinny people smoke or drink a latte for the whole day. Sure there are more risk for cardiovascular desease, etc..

But let's be realistic. The average size of American is NOT a size 4. Actually I remember my skinnier days and finding a size 4 is actually not that easy. You have better selections in size 10 and 12. Unless you want to dress in the Junior section.

Let's look at who is walking on the streets and the stores, work, etc.. Not a bunch of supermodel. Most with extra weight.

So am I surprised to find an "overweight" couple on a show? While should I? That's more "reality" than "fantasy" to me.

Posted 10/27/10 2:52 PM
 

ndblovah
Be happy always

Member since 1/07

1880 total posts

Name:

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by Bxgell2

Posted by Otherme

Posted by NinaLemon

Substitute Black/Jew/Homosexual/Handicap for fat/obese and she could be arrested.



exactly!



Ok, I know I may get flamed for this, and I'm fully prepared, but I'm going to play the devil's advocate here.

While much of what she said, and the way she said it, was deplorable, she DOES make some valid points that I agree with - mainly, that society, TV and mass media seems to be headed in the direction of normalizing obesity, instead of treating it as the VERY serious health risk that it really is.

I don't think it's fair to equate this to insulting someone on the basis of their race, religion, national origin, etc. Granted, I find it deplorable for ANYONE to be disgusted merely by the sight of a person who is obese kissing another obese person. But, obesity is a much different category than black, white, jewish, etc., because, unlike those categories, obesity represents a true, significant health risk and has many larger implications, such as the impact on our healthcare system and longevity.

Personally, I think a large part of the problem is that we have become too sensitive to the emotional aspect of obesity, instead of focusing on it as a real health issue, like smoking. There seems to be no restriction on speaking out about the detrimental impact of smoking, but because there is such an emotional interconnection with obesity, there's too much silence, and normalization, about the issue. So I see her point when she says that it is just as crazy to implicitly promote obesity because aside from any aesthetic consideration, it is simply unhealthy.

My two cents...

Your generalizing that all obese people are unhealthy. This is simply not true.

Message edited 2010-10-27 14:53:30.230000.

Posted 10/27/10 2:53 PM
 

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Beth - I agree with you on some points, as I can see the other side. I just think she went about it completely in another direction.

Posted 10/27/10 2:53 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by Bxgell2

Posted by Otherme

Posted by NinaLemon

Substitute Black/Jew/Homosexual/Handicap for fat/obese and she could be arrested.



exactly!



Ok, I know I may get flamed for this, and I'm fully prepared, but I'm going to play the devil's advocate here.

While much of what she said, and the way she said it, was deplorable, she DOES make some valid points that I agree with - mainly, that society, TV and mass media seems to be headed in the direction of normalizing obesity, instead of treating it as the VERY serious health risk that it really is.

I don't think it's fair to equate this to insulting someone on the basis of their race, religion, national origin, etc. Granted, I find it deplorable for ANYONE to be disgusted merely by the sight of a person who is obese kissing another obese person. But, obesity is a much different category than black, white, jewish, etc., because, unlike those categories, obesity represents a true, significant health risk and has many larger implications, such as the impact on our healthcare system and longevity.

Personally, I think a large part of the problem is that we have become too sensitive to the emotional aspect of obesity, instead of focusing on it as a real health issue, like smoking. There seems to be no restriction on speaking out about the detrimental impact of smoking, but because there is such an emotional interconnection with obesity, there's too much silence, and normalization, about the issue. So I see her point when she says that it is just as crazy to implicitly promote obesity because aside from any aesthetic consideration, it is simply unhealthy.

My two cents...



But if the average size in the US is 12, how that is not the norm then?

Posted 10/27/10 2:55 PM
 

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by BrinaEsq

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by NinaLemon

Posted by annoyedTTCer


If obese people were as concerened with ther weight as they are with what some blogger wrote we could probably get rid of our obestity problems in less than a year.



Posted by BrinaEsq
Wow. I think that's pretty harsh.



there are some people around here, you will quickly learn, that are best to not even put stock in what they have to say - because it's never constructive and they always have to go against the grain - and it always seems intentional. Save your fingers some typing energy. Chat Icon



Message edited 2010-10-27 14:58:06.587000.

Posted 10/27/10 2:57 PM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by speakthetruth

Posted by MRsFaTThead

how is this being a bully? she is saying what grosses her out.

so know everytime someone thinks something is gross they are dicriminating and being a bully?



Well, it grosses out some of the masses if people return worn clothes to a store, and even though the person who committed the action is free to do such an act, it still may not sit well.

She opened her mouth and now she will get flack for what came out of it.




"Like" Chat Icon

How does this show "promote" obesity exactly??? Can someone explain this to me??? Isn't that like saying "2 and a half men" (imho the worst sitcom on tv) promotes promiscuity and STDs as a lifestyle choice, no?

Posted 10/27/10 2:57 PM
 

rojerono
Happiest.

Member since 8/06

13803 total posts

Name:
Jeannie

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by MRsFaTThead

how is this being a bully? she is saying what grosses her out.

so know everytime someone thinks something is gross they are dicriminating and being a bully?



She's using her 'stage' to express an opinion that is hurtful to a fair number of people. Her words are so barbed that it does seem like she is trying to use them to intimidate folks who are 'fat'. I think that's why people are saying she's a bully.

Personally, I think 'bully' is an inaccurate word for what she is.

I do think she's ignorant - her words speak that fact for themselves.

I do think she's shallow - again, just read her own words.

I do think she lacks talent - I went back and have read several of her blogs and they are poorly written. I can think of 10 bloggers off the top of my head who can do more with that space than she has.

I do think that there is a time and a space for 'freedom of speech'. You are at home having a glass of wine with your BFF and you want to spew hateful shite.. go right ahead.

You are publishing a blog for a major magazine with an international audience that is designed to make many of the readers feel belittled? Not so cool.

I will GUARANTEE that the majority of fat people in this world are well aware that people like Maura Kelly exist with their narrow minded opinions and prejudiced outlooks.. but seeing it laid out for worldwide consumption is still somewhat hurtful.

The magazine allowed that post and further has defended the post. They are losing subscribers who find the viewpoint tasteless and are being inundated with commentary. Freedom of speech cuts both ways.

ETA: All that said.. I still am not 'shocked' by any sense of the word. I do think that obesity is a health risk. And I do think that she has the right to her opinion. I just think her vehicle for expressing that opinion was poorly chosen. Also - it is possible to express that opinion without being hateful.

Message edited 2010-10-27 15:13:29.840000.

Posted 10/27/10 2:58 PM
 

Ayne11
Yep

Member since 1/09

18021 total posts

Name:

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by BrinaEsq

Posted by annoyedTTCer
If obese people were as concerened with ther weight as they are with what some blogger wrote we could probably get rid of our obestity problems in less than a year.



Wow. I think that is pretty harsh.





I agree.... it's saddens me people on this site have such disdain for overweight people.

Posted 10/27/10 3:01 PM
 

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by Ayne11

Posted by BrinaEsq

Posted by annoyedTTCer
If obese people were as concerened with ther weight as they are with what some blogger wrote we could probably get rid of our obestity problems in less than a year.



Wow. I think that is pretty harsh.





I agree.... it's saddens me people on this site have such disdain for overweight people.



there are some people around here, you will quickly learn, that are best to not even put stock in what they have to say - because it's never constructive and they always have to go against the grain - and it always seems intentional. Save your fingers some typing energy. Chat Icon

Posted 10/27/10 3:01 PM
 

Celt
~~~~~~~~~~

Member since 4/08

7758 total posts

Name:
colette

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by Ayne11

Posted by BrinaEsq

Posted by annoyedTTCer
If obese people were as concerened with ther weight as they are with what some blogger wrote we could probably get rid of our obestity problems in less than a year.



Wow. I think that is pretty harsh.





I agree.... it's saddens me people on this site have such disdain for overweight people.



Don't be upset, this one has disdain for eeeeerrrrrrrbody Chat Icon

Posted 10/27/10 3:03 PM
 

kimbalina
Bring on the glitter and bows!

Member since 6/08

15158 total posts

Name:
Kim

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by speakthetruth

Posted by MRsFaTThead

how is this being a bully? she is saying what grosses her out.

so know everytime someone thinks something is gross they are dicriminating and being a bully?



Well, it grosses out some of the masses if people return worn clothes to a store, and even though the person who committed the action is free to do such an act, it still may not sit well.

She opened her mouth and now she will get flack for what came out of it.




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon
Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 10/27/10 3:03 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by BrinaEsq


Posted by annoyedTTCer


If obese people were as concerened with ther weight as they are with what some blogger wrote we could probably get rid of our obestity problems in less than a year.



Wow. I think that is pretty harsh.





totally agreed.

I'm sure it's not as EASY as one might think...


Posted 10/27/10 3:03 PM
 

LadyBugN2Buggies
<3

Member since 5/10

6691 total posts

Name:

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Again, she titled her article "Should Fatties Get a Room? (even on TV?)"


how did this ever get the green-light? by a WOMEN'S publication????

I'm beyond shocked - and very little shocks me these days.

Posted 10/27/10 3:04 PM
 

Ayne11
Yep

Member since 1/09

18021 total posts

Name:

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by colette

Posted by Ayne11

Posted by BrinaEsq

Posted by annoyedTTCer
If obese people were as concerened with ther weight as they are with what some blogger wrote we could probably get rid of our obestity problems in less than a year.



Wow. I think that is pretty harsh.





I agree.... it's saddens me people on this site have such disdain for overweight people.



Don't be upset, this one has disdain for eeeeerrrrrrrbody Chat Icon



True, I'm quickly learning . Thank god I'm not a drag queen in the Navy...then i'd really be up poo creek w/o a paddle

Posted 10/27/10 3:05 PM
 

MrsPJB2007
MBA at your service!

Member since 7/06

12020 total posts

Name:
MJ

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by Ayne11

True, I'm quickly learning . Thank god I'm not a drag queen in the Navy...then i'd really be up poo creek w/o a paddle




But what a FAAAAAAABULOUS paddle you would have.

Posted 10/27/10 3:07 PM
 

HeathKernandez
Our Ron is an awesome Ron

Member since 4/07

9091 total posts

Name:
baby fish mouth

Re: Overweight People on TV?

Posted by colette

Posted by speakthetruth

Posted by MRsFaTThead

how is this being a bully? she is saying what grosses her out.

so know everytime someone thinks something is gross they are dicriminating and being a bully?



Well, it grosses out some of the masses if people return worn clothes to a store, and even though the person who committed the action is free to do such an act, it still may not sit well.

She opened her mouth and now she will get flack for what came out of it.




"Like" Chat Icon

How does this show "promote" obesity exactly??? Can someone explain this to me??? Isn't that like saying "2 and a half men" (imho the worst sitcom on tv) promotes promiscuity and STDs as a lifestyle choice, no?



Personally I find women who resemble "Morticia" and decorate their toddler's stroller according to season a little *gross*

but hey- that's JUST ME


Chat Icon

Posted 10/27/10 3:07 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Do you believe that all overweight people have emotional/psychological issues? (Oprah-related) melbalalala 1/8/09 18 Diet & Fitness
If you are overweight when do people of "our" body type start showing? BabyLove08 2/26/08 5 Pregnancy
Make me feel better- some people are so strange sunny 5/13/05 15 Pregnancy
Since some people were asking PrincessRose 5/13/05 21 Families Helping Families ™
Most annoying AND/OR Most Stupid things people say to me while TTC DebG 5/12/05 31 TTC
do you get along with people who are? TAD 5/12/05 32 Families Helping Families ™