Overweight People on TV?
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 | |
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Now I GET IT!!!! Message edited 2010-10-27 15:08:24.630000. |
|
Posted 10/27/10 3:08 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by Ayne11 Posted by BrinaEsq Posted by annoyedTTCer If obese people were as concerened with ther weight as they are with what some blogger wrote we could probably get rid of our obestity problems in less than a year. Wow. I think that is pretty harsh. I agree.... it's saddens me people on this site have such disdain for overweight people. You are right!! I guess we can all spew out HATE for whomever we please on here or a blog. |
|
Posted 10/27/10 3:08 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by MrsPJB2007 Posted by Ayne11 True, I'm quickly learning . Thank god I'm not a drag queen in the Navy...then i'd really be up poo creek w/o a paddle But what a FAAAAAAABULOUS paddle you would have. That's no joke! But I'd only have it in secret. You won't ask and I wont tell
|
|
Posted 10/27/10 3:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by Otherme Posted by NinaLemon Substitute Black/Jew/Homosexual/Handicap for fat/obese and she could be arrested. exactly! Ok, I know I may get flamed for this, and I'm fully prepared, but I'm going to play the devil's advocate here. While much of what she said, and the way she said it, was deplorable, she DOES make some valid points that I agree with - mainly, that society, TV and mass media seems to be headed in the direction of normalizing obesity, instead of treating it as the VERY serious health risk that it really is. I don't think it's fair to equate this to insulting someone on the basis of their race, religion, national origin, etc. Granted, I find it deplorable for ANYONE to be disgusted merely by the sight of a person who is obese kissing another obese person. But, obesity is a much different category than black, white, jewish, etc., because, unlike those categories, obesity represents a true, significant health risk and has many larger implications, such as the impact on our healthcare system and longevity. Personally, I think a large part of the problem is that we have become too sensitive to the emotional aspect of obesity, instead of focusing on it as a real health issue, like smoking. There seems to be no restriction on speaking out about the detrimental impact of smoking, but because there is such an emotional interconnection with obesity, there's too much silence, and normalization, about the issue. So I see her point when she says that it is just as crazy to implicitly promote obesity because aside from any aesthetic consideration, it is simply unhealthy. My two cents... I agree with all of this! Every year our populations gets larger. Small children are now being diagnosed with high cholesterol - it is a national epidemic that should not be normalized. However, in all of this there should be no room for cruelty. |
|
Posted 10/27/10 3:11 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? I think if "Maura Kelly" has had her own issues battling anorexia, then she should be a little sensitive towards other people who might have their own demons regarding weight. |
|
Posted 10/27/10 3:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by HeathKernandez I think if "Maura Kelly" has had her own issues battling anorexia, then she should be a little sensitive towards other people who might have their own demons regarding weight. I also think it goes with the territory of having anorexia of self-hate, and thus it gets projected onto others. Still no excuse. They should at least take down the damn article. |
|
Posted 10/27/10 3:20 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by kokopelia Your generalizing that all obese people are unhealthy. This is simply not true. I know this is a sensitive issue, I get it, particularly because I've struggled with weight issues all my life. But, I think it's a stretch to say that obesity doesn't implicate deeper health issues. Even if someone is obese and they exercise and/or eat healthy, the very fact that they are obese and their BMI is 30+ means that they are carrying extra weight that necessarily takes a toll on their bodily functions. What I'm talking about is the definition of obese - I hardly think that a size 12 woman would be considered obese - depending on her height, overweight maybe, but not obese. I agree that the portrayal of someone as obese as aesthetically displeasing is WRONG, plain and simple. But I do think that this raises some deeper issues that are intertwined with obesity and the growing rates, particularly with children, in this country, and the deeper implication for us as a result, as a society. Somehow we have to figure out a way to disentangle the emotional connection so that we can really address this issue, because it's really becoming a fast growing problem. |
|
Posted 10/27/10 3:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by stickydust Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by Otherme Posted by NinaLemon Substitute Black/Jew/Homosexual/Handicap for fat/obese and she could be arrested. exactly! Ok, I know I may get flamed for this, and I'm fully prepared, but I'm going to play the devil's advocate here. While much of what she said, and the way she said it, was deplorable, she DOES make some valid points that I agree with - mainly, that society, TV and mass media seems to be headed in the direction of normalizing obesity, instead of treating it as the VERY serious health risk that it really is. I don't think it's fair to equate this to insulting someone on the basis of their race, religion, national origin, etc. Granted, I find it deplorable for ANYONE to be disgusted merely by the sight of a person who is obese kissing another obese person. But, obesity is a much different category than black, white, jewish, etc., because, unlike those categories, obesity represents a true, significant health risk and has many larger implications, such as the impact on our healthcare system and longevity. Personally, I think a large part of the problem is that we have become too sensitive to the emotional aspect of obesity, instead of focusing on it as a real health issue, like smoking. There seems to be no restriction on speaking out about the detrimental impact of smoking, but because there is such an emotional interconnection with obesity, there's too much silence, and normalization, about the issue. So I see her point when she says that it is just as crazy to implicitly promote obesity because aside from any aesthetic consideration, it is simply unhealthy. My two cents... I agree with all of this! Every year our populations gets larger. Small children are now being diagnosed with high cholesterol - it is a national epidemic that should not be normalized. However, in all of this there should be no room for cruelty. I think bullying is just as big a problem as obesity - and just as dangerous as we've seen in recent months. If this blogger is really so concerned about "normalizing" obesity in this country, then maybe she should dedicate her time to institutions and actions that promote health, not obnoxious articles that can help destroy self-esteem and body image. There are a lot of studies out that showing that people who accept their bodies and love them are more likey to lose the weight than people who constantly feel horrible about their bodies. I fail to see how something like this does any good whatsoever. |
|
Posted 10/27/10 3:24 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by kokopelia Your generalizing that all obese people are unhealthy. This is simply not true. I know this is a sensitive issue, I get it, particularly because I've struggled with weight issues all my life. But, I think it's a stretch to say that obesity doesn't implicate deeper health issues. Even if someone is obese and they exercise and/or eat healthy, the very fact that they are obese and their BMI is 30+ means that they are carrying extra weight that necessarily takes a toll on their bodily functions. What I'm talking about is the definition of obese - I hardly think that a size 12 woman would be considered obese - depending on her height, overweight maybe, but not obese. I agree that the portrayal of someone as obese as aesthetically displeasing is WRONG, plain and simple. But I do think that this raises some deeper issues that are intertwined with obesity and the growing rates, particularly with children, in this country, and the deeper implication for us as a result, as a society. Somehow we have to figure out a way to disentangle the emotional connection so that we can really address this issue, because it's really becoming a fast growing problem. But you can be a size 6-8 AND be considered medically obese. While being "bigger" usually means obesity, it can happen with skinny people too. I also don't think she is really concerned for the well being part of it. She is just disgusted with the sight of someone fat even walking in the street. She wanted to "Shock". She did! Unfortunatelly, a lot of OBESE people do read MC. I hope it comes and bite MC in the butt. You don't attack half of your customers. Not only is she attemting to be a controversial writter but she is neither good at it or legit. Attack fat people for health, medical fall down, etc.. but not because it disgusts you to see them on TV. Seeing fat people on TV does not promote obesity or make people fat, seeing Jewish people on TV does not make people convert religion, seeing gay partners on TV does not make people gay. You don't like... just don't watch it! |
|
Posted 10/27/10 3:56 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Am I the only one who thinks that this was clearly an attempt for attention and publicity ? I can't believe that the blogger was stupid enough to not realize that this was would cause tremendous contreversy and offend lots of people! |
|
Posted 10/27/10 4:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? her artical was very very poorly worded. It lacked research. Sure, there are people who are obese and don't do anything about it. But she is completly disregarding those who are obese from genetics. Some people work really hard to lose weight and have a harder time than others because of their genetics. And for the lucky few in that category, they can get gastric bypass surury. but most of them probably can't afford it. To come out and write an unreasearched artical like that was pretty dumb on her part. To categorize all obese people into one category is dumb. She made a comment on how some very thing people are naturally really thin. Well, same goes for overweight and obese people. I don't think obesity should be glamorized. it is unhealthy and people need to take responsibility for their own health. I have not seen the show she refers to. But I also think its rude of her to generalize and not take different circumstances of inheritting certain health characteristics into consideration. Message edited 2010-10-27 17:02:48.390000. |
|
Posted 10/27/10 4:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by MrsA1012 Am I the only one who thinks that this was clearly an attempt for attention and publicity ? I can't believe that the blogger was stupid enough to not realize that this was would cause tremendous contreversy and offend lots of people! good point. |
|
Posted 10/27/10 4:59 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by stickydust Posted by Bxgell2 Posted by Otherme Posted by NinaLemon Substitute Black/Jew/Homosexual/Handicap for fat/obese and she could be arrested. exactly! Ok, I know I may get flamed for this, and I'm fully prepared, but I'm going to play the devil's advocate here. While much of what she said, and the way she said it, was deplorable, she DOES make some valid points that I agree with - mainly, that society, TV and mass media seems to be headed in the direction of normalizing obesity, instead of treating it as the VERY serious health risk that it really is. I don't think it's fair to equate this to insulting someone on the basis of their race, religion, national origin, etc. Granted, I find it deplorable for ANYONE to be disgusted merely by the sight of a person who is obese kissing another obese person. But, obesity is a much different category than black, white, jewish, etc., because, unlike those categories, obesity represents a true, significant health risk and has many larger implications, such as the impact on our healthcare system and longevity. Personally, I think a large part of the problem is that we have become too sensitive to the emotional aspect of obesity, instead of focusing on it as a real health issue, like smoking. There seems to be no restriction on speaking out about the detrimental impact of smoking, but because there is such an emotional interconnection with obesity, there's too much silence, and normalization, about the issue. So I see her point when she says that it is just as crazy to implicitly promote obesity because aside from any aesthetic consideration, it is simply unhealthy. My two cents... I agree with all of this! Every year our populations gets larger. Small children are now being diagnosed with high cholesterol - it is a national epidemic that should not be normalized. However, in all of this there should be no room for cruelty. I also think there are very valid points made in this post here. It is very well written and explained well. But yes, there is no need for teh cruelty. But being healthy is very important. |
|
Posted 10/27/10 5:22 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Wow....I don't even have words to......ugh |
|
Posted 10/27/10 5:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by kimbalina Posted by Ayne11 Posted by BrinaEsq Posted by annoyedTTCer If obese people were as concerened with ther weight as they are with what some blogger wrote we could probably get rid of our obestity problems in less than a year. Wow. I think that is pretty harsh. I agree.... it's saddens me people on this site have such disdain for overweight people. You are right!! I guess we can all spew out HATE for whomever we please on here or a blog. It is not harsh nor hate but rather an observation that obese people get bent out of shape every time anyone says they are anything but wonderful. It is sad that we actually have a fat acceptance movement here in the states when we see diabetes rates going through the roof. What kind of future are we shaping for our children? There is evena Fat Rights organization, really the right to gorge your self while others in the world are dying from starvation? Do you really want to applaud that mindset? What's next, don't pick on drug addicts and pedophiles or we'll hurt their feelings? |
|
Posted 10/27/10 5:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by annoyedTTCer Posted by kimbalina Posted by Ayne11 Posted by BrinaEsq Posted by annoyedTTCer If obese people were as concerened with ther weight as they are with what some blogger wrote we could probably get rid of our obestity problems in less than a year. Wow. I think that is pretty harsh. I agree.... it's saddens me people on this site have such disdain for overweight people. You are right!! I guess we can all spew out HATE for whomever we please on here or a blog. It is not harsh nor hate but rather an observation that obese people get bent out of shape every time anyone says they are anything but wonderful. It is sad that we actually have a fat acceptance movement here in the states when we see diabetes rates going through the roof. What kind of future are we shaping for our children? There is evena Fat Rights organization, really the right to gorge your self while others in the world are dying from starvation? Do you really want to applaud that mindset? What's next, don't pick on drug addicts and pedophiles or we'll hurt their feelings? I wasn't aware that "picking" on pedophiles and drug addicts leads to changing them. And you are really comparing overweight people with PEDOPHILES? And drug addiction is a DISEASE -- as are obesity and food addiction. Taunting overweight people and talking about how "disgusting" they are does notihng more to change the obesity problem than taunting drug addicts and pedophiles makes them want to change. I really don't understand why people think picking on ANYONE does GOOD. If you want to promote health, promote health. Don't tell overweight people how horrible and disgusting they are. That just makes you look like an *******. (NOT the person I quoted -- the general "you" who think talking about how disgusting fat people look is acceptable.) ETA --(removed) - I'm not even going to dignify this discussion with my story. Message edited 2010-10-27 18:07:09.813000. |
|
Posted 10/27/10 5:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by annoyedTTCer It is not harsh nor hate but rather an observation that obese people get bent out of shape every time anyone says they are anything but wonderful. It is sad that we actually have a fat acceptance movement here in the states when we see diabetes rates going through the roof. What kind of future are we shaping for our children? There is evena Fat Rights organization, really the right to gorge your self while others in the world are dying from starvation? Do you really want to applaud that mindset? What's next, don't pick on drug addicts and pedophiles or we'll hurt their feelings? Good God.. you really believe this tripe don't you? I am fat. I don't get 'bent out of shape' when someone says I am less than wonderful.. but I would prefer to be judged on who I am rather than what I look like. The fact is that the point of the blog was to make fun of fat people. To point out how they are gross and disgusting and repulsive to the author. She's 100% entitled to her feelings. I am under no delusions that she's alone in her opinion. I do think that her opinion could have been stated with more tact. I do think her opinion could have been done in a less derogatory manner. I do think that she put herself out there as an idiot who makes sweeping judgments about people based only on appearance. Now you can scoff at the idea of comparing those generalizations to historical prejudices against blacks, gays, etc.. but there is one big common thread there - these prejudices are all based on superficial bs. You can NOT tell who a person is, what they have been through, their capacity for love, their intellect or really ANYTHING based on their religion, their color, their sexual preference OR their weight. To think you can makes you completely ignorant. What she wrote was mean. Pure and simple. It's not unusual. It's not wrong for her to state her feelings. It's not going to change anyone's life for the better.. but it's mean and it's kind of repugnant that a national magazine would allow that kind of stuff to go out under their aegis. Plus.. the article is dopey. The whole point of it was "I don't like looking at fat people." It wasn't about the show or about seeing overweight folks being romantic.. it was an editorial about her negative feelings for fat people disguised as a commentary on a tv show. I also want to point out that a good portion of the folks who are incensed by this blog are NOT obese or even overweight! So it's not a case of us fatties getting rattled because someone had the audacity to say we aren't their favorite thing to look at. Message edited 2010-10-27 18:37:24.603000. |
|
Posted 10/27/10 6:34 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by annoyedTTCer Posted by kimbalina Posted by Ayne11 Posted by BrinaEsq Posted by annoyedTTCer If obese people were as concerened with ther weight as they are with what some blogger wrote we could probably get rid of our obestity problems in less than a year. Wow. I think that is pretty harsh. I agree.... it's saddens me people on this site have such disdain for overweight people. You are right!! I guess we can all spew out HATE for whomever we please on here or a blog. It is not harsh nor hate but rather an observation that obese people get bent out of shape every time anyone says they are anything but wonderful. It is sad that we actually have a fat acceptance movement here in the states when we see diabetes rates going through the roof. What kind of future are we shaping for our children? There is evena Fat Rights organization, really the right to gorge your self while others in the world are dying from starvation? Do you really want to applaud that mindset? What's next, don't pick on drug addicts and pedophiles or we'll hurt their feelings? You are gross. You are just as bad as the rest of them. |
|
Posted 10/27/10 6:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by annoyedTTCer Dipped? we already ate a whole bag of peanut butter cups
|
|
Posted 10/27/10 6:50 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by colette Posted by annoyedTTCer Dipped? we already ate a whole bag of peanut butter cups I was waiting for her post on the parent board to be broad up. Awesome!! |
|
Posted 10/27/10 7:02 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by rojerono Posted by annoyedTTCer It is not harsh nor hate but rather an observation that obese people get bent out of shape every time anyone says they are anything but wonderful. It is sad that we actually have a fat acceptance movement here in the states when we see diabetes rates going through the roof. What kind of future are we shaping for our children? There is evena Fat Rights organization, really the right to gorge your self while others in the world are dying from starvation? Do you really want to applaud that mindset? What's next, don't pick on drug addicts and pedophiles or we'll hurt their feelings? Good God.. you really believe this tripe don't you? I am fat. I don't get 'bent out of shape' when someone says I am less than wonderful.. but I would prefer to be judged on who I am rather than what I look like. The fact is that the point of the blog was to make fun of fat people. To point out how they are gross and disgusting and repulsive to the author. She's 100% entitled to her feelings. I am under no delusions that she's alone in her opinion. I do think that her opinion could have been stated with more tact. I do think her opinion could have been done in a less derogatory manner. I do think that she put herself out there as an idiot who makes sweeping judgments about people based only on appearance. Now you can scoff at the idea of comparing those generalizations to historical prejudices against blacks, gays, etc.. but there is one big common thread there - these prejudices are all based on superficial bs. You can NOT tell who a person is, what they have been through, their capacity for love, their intellect or really ANYTHING based on their religion, their color, their sexual preference OR their weight. To think you can makes you completely ignorant. What she wrote was mean. Pure and simple. It's not unusual. It's not wrong for her to state her feelings. It's not going to change anyone's life for the better.. but it's mean and it's kind of repugnant that a national magazine would allow that kind of stuff to go out under their aegis. Plus.. the article is dopey. The whole point of it was "I don't like looking at fat people." It wasn't about the show or about seeing overweight folks being romantic.. it was an editorial about her negative feelings for fat people disguised as a commentary on a tv show. I also want to point out that a good portion of the folks who are incensed by this blog are NOT obese or even overweight! So it's not a case of us fatties getting rattled because someone had the audacity to say we aren't their favorite thing to look at.
|
|
Posted 10/27/10 7:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? I commented earlier but seeing the turn this thread has taken I have to say - some people are being overly sensitive about this... |
|
Posted 10/27/10 7:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV?
|
|
Posted 10/27/10 9:27 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? I will say what I always say on topics like this: |
|
Posted 10/27/10 10:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Overweight People on TV? Posted by rojerono You can NOT tell who a person is, what they have been through, their capacity for love, their intellect or really ANYTHING based on their religion, their color, their sexual preference OR their weight. To think you can makes you completely ignorant. Exactly. Hopefully one day people will begin to understand this simple concept.
|
|
Posted 10/27/10 10:16 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 2 3 [4] 5 | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Do you believe that all overweight people have emotional/psychological issues? (Oprah-related) | melbalalala | 1/8/09 | 18 | Diet & Fitness |
| If you are overweight when do people of "our" body type start showing? | BabyLove08 | 2/26/08 | 5 | Pregnancy |
| Make me feel better- some people are so strange | sunny | 5/13/05 | 15 | Pregnancy |
| Since some people were asking | PrincessRose | 5/13/05 | 21 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Most annoying AND/OR Most Stupid things people say to me while TTC | DebG | 5/12/05 | 31 | TTC |
| do you get along with people who are? | TAD | 5/12/05 | 32 | Families Helping Families ™ |

















