Re: Overweight People on TV?
Posted 10/27/2010 2:58:25 PM by rojerono


Posted by MRsFaTThead

how is this being a bully? she is saying what grosses her out.

so know everytime someone thinks something is gross they are dicriminating and being a bully?



She's using her 'stage' to express an opinion that is hurtful to a fair number of people. Her words are so barbed that it does seem like she is trying to use them to intimidate folks who are 'fat'. I think that's why people are saying she's a bully.

Personally, I think 'bully' is an inaccurate word for what she is.

I do think she's ignorant - her words speak that fact for themselves.

I do think she's shallow - again, just read her own words.

I do think she lacks talent - I went back and have read several of her blogs and they are poorly written. I can think of 10 bloggers off the top of my head who can do more with that space than she has.

I do think that there is a time and a space for 'freedom of speech'. You are at home having a glass of wine with your BFF and you want to spew hateful shite.. go right ahead.

You are publishing a blog for a major magazine with an international audience that is designed to make many of the readers feel belittled? Not so cool.

I will GUARANTEE that the majority of fat people in this world are well aware that people like Maura Kelly exist with their narrow minded opinions and prejudiced outlooks.. but seeing it laid out for worldwide consumption is still somewhat hurtful.

The magazine allowed that post and further has defended the post. They are losing subscribers who find the viewpoint tasteless and are being inundated with commentary. Freedom of speech cuts both ways.

ETA: All that said.. I still am not 'shocked' by any sense of the word. I do think that obesity is a health risk. And I do think that she has the right to her opinion. I just think her vehicle for expressing that opinion was poorly chosen. Also - it is possible to express that opinion without being hateful.
Print Post      Close Window