Opionions on MIL situation

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4

DmarieK
My loves!!

Member since 1/06

9203 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

I think it was 100% wrong for MIL to take the kids out if she knew she was not supposed to. It doesn't sound like it was the first time either.

That said I would never expect a family member to watch my 3 kids and not be able to drive around. I HATE other people drving my boys around. I worry they won't strap them in correctly...I worry about an accident...so many things but I still let them take the boys if there's somewhere the need/want to go.

Posted 6/16/11 11:19 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

KrisT
Two Boys for Me!!

Member since 1/07

5213 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Tilde

She should not have talked about you, especially to your mother BUT I don't think it is fair that she has to stay home when she is watching them three days a week for you. Sorry, just being honest.

My parents watch DD for me and take her all over -- they have to shop and run errands too and it isn't fair to make them sit at home with DD if they are doing me a favor.




I agree with this! And honestly, I do think that because she is helping you out by watching the kids 3 days a week for free, that you may want to reconsider the driving issue.

Posted 6/16/11 11:23 AM
 

itsbabytime
LIF Adult

Member since 11/05

9644 total posts

Name:
Me

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

I don't let anyone drive my kids around or take them on errands unless it is a necessary situation. That said, it is b/c there is no one that I trust enough to do it AND, I stay home with them 24/7 so no one has to.

So, that said, I am going to be totally honest with you b/c you asked for opinions. I do think you are being very unfair and unreasonable. You expect your MIL to watch your kids - 3 of them under 3 which is ALOT to ask of an older person - 3 days a week for no money or anything and, then, you are going to restrict her that she can't leave the house unless she walks with them which, might not be the easiest in the summer heat for an older person juggling 3 little kids. My feeling is this - if you have these concerns - you are very entitled to them but, if you want what you say to go then I feel you should hire a nanny or put them in day care. I think your MIL was understandably frustrated as she is doingyou a HUGE HUGE favor!

Posted 6/16/11 11:57 AM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Deeluvsvinny

Well, first off (and please don't take this the wrong way)- if I trust someone to watch my child(ren) I trust them completely. So, I allow my mom and even our sitter to take DD in the car.

What your MIL said wasn't cool. I'd discuss THAT with her or your DH.

But, to be fair- you didn't tell her that since school is over there is no reason for her to take them in the car...right? I understand she had to use the car when they were in school, but if that's okay- why isn't a trip to the grocery store? Either way- they're all in the car, right?



I agree with all of this.

Posted 6/16/11 12:01 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Why would she want to take 3 kids food shopping if it wasn't necessary?
I would not let my MIL or my mom for that matter take all 3 of them anywhere by themselves. I am not even comfortable with the thought of them taking 1, let alone 3.
Most of you who answered you trust your relatives and let them take them all over seem to have 1 DC. It is very different taking out 3 young children vs. 1.There is no easy configuration to put them in, so why anyone would want to do this unnecessarily is beyond me.
Anyway, I think you should talk to MIL and tell her your feelings - that there are no non-essential trips alone in the car with the 3 kids. Also make sure your DH is on board and backs you up.

Posted 6/16/11 12:02 PM
 

MrsA714
Baby #2 is here!

Member since 8/07

8806 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Tilde

She should not have talked about you, especially to your mother BUT I don't think it is fair that she has to stay home when she is watching them three days a week for you. Sorry, just being honest.

My parents watch DD for me and take her all over -- they have to shop and run errands too and it isn't fair to make them sit at home with DD if they are doing me a favor.




I agree with Tilde on this. But if you already had an agreement with your MIL and she went against your wishes then I can completely understand you being upset. That being said, you and your DH should speak with her again and make clear what she can or cannot do. Depending on how that goes, you may want to reconsider your child care arrangement.

Posted 6/16/11 12:02 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by MrsSunflwr29

Posted by Tilde

Posted by Hofstra26

I may be in the minority here BUT here goes............I trust my family completely with my DD but I am still NOT a fan of ANYONE driving her around. For example, my dad is a terrible driver (I don't even feel safe in the car with him) so I wouldn't be comfortable having him drive DD around. I don't want to have to worry where she is, what store she's at, did something happen, etc. etc. I just don't really see the need for anyone to be driving my DD around at this age. (She's almost 3) I don't know, maybe I am a little crazy but I just feel better if it's just me or my DH that drives her around town.



But is your dad stuck at home with your children multiple times a week? How would he get anything done? Go food shopping? Pick up something from the dry cleaners?

No one is driving DD around for the heck of it, but they have to live their lives - they are not day care workers LOL



I look at it like a "job". they took on the responsiblity and knew what it was about. When I am work if I have to get things done I do it on my own time kwim.



Do you pay them?

If yes then I can see the request to not take them out.

If they are doing it for free to help you out then you need to cut them some slack or risk losing your free ride.


Posted 6/16/11 12:03 PM
 

MrsSunflwr29
LIF Adult

Member since 3/06

1093 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Again I am grateful that she watches them. She is only alone with them 1 day per week. On the other 2 days I work from home and she is only here from 7 hours. Between lunch naps etc...7 hours goes quick. This all happened on the 1 day that I was in the office and she is only here from 8-3 then my mom takes over until my DH comes home.

I know you think staying home with 3 kids would drive anyone crazy but to be honest it is the easiest place to be. Here they have all the toys in the yard and in the house. All 3 of my kids are on the go and being at home is the best place for them to play...I would think that would be easier then chasing 3 kids at a playground where they can run free, better then a store when they can take off....My kids are good and this never happens but you never know what can catch their eyes...never the less that is off topic.

She has walked them down to the corner to the food store, bagel store, etc and I have no issues..I just do not like the car and not knowing where my kids are.

Another situation was 2 weeks ago she said she was going for a walk...I said fine later that day my neighbors said oh your kids were so cute at the park and never once did she mention to me that she was there...I was taken back and I just dropped it. To me by not saying is hiding something..and if I give car permissions I may never know where they go..

Posted 6/16/11 12:06 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

My MIL lives overseas so she'll never be watching my son.

Will say with 100% certainty that if I told my mom she couldn't go anywhere with her grandson she'd tell me to piss off and go find myself some hired help.

Nothing wrong with asking her to not go out everyday but I see no problem with her running out now and again when needed.



Posted 6/16/11 12:11 PM
 

btrfly30
LIF Infant

Member since 3/06

161 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Tina1117

Posted by MrsSunflwr29

i do trust them I just feel there is no need for them to be in the car. God forbid there is an accident. If they were in daycare they wouldnt be in the car and around town. They are where you expect them to be. I have more then enough stuff in my home to keep them busy trust me. While I am at work I want the peice of mind that my kids are at home. Yesterday I thought my kids were wakling up having breakfast and watching tv instead within 2 hours they were dressed and out the door without me even knowing. What if there was an accident? How would I find out if something happened to my kids? I just want to know they are safe..



IMO I think you are being a little harsh on your MIL.

I do not like my children out driving around either BUT it was a trip to the market. She wasn't out joy riding.

Yes if your children were in daycare they would most definitely be put all day but then you'd be worrying about other things.

From what you write it seems that your MIL comes to your house...this is a blessing.

We all worry about our children no matter what the situation is...I think just a little talk with your MIL may help both of you understand what you expect of each other.




Is it more the fact that you thought they were in one place, when in fact they were somewhere else? That would upset me to no end.

If you didn't tell her that you didn't want her driving the kids, then you have to set some clear boundries. If you did and she didn't listen to you - that is a whole different story.

As for her talking about you to your mother - that is just plain wrong.

Posted 6/16/11 12:18 PM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by annoyedTTCer

My MIL lives overseas so she'll never be watching my son.

Will say with 100% certainty that if I told my mom she couldn't go anywhere with her grandson she'd tell me to piss off and go find myself some hired help.

Nothing wrong with asking her to not go out everyday but I see no problem with her running out now and again when needed.





But that's you...I feel really badly that everyone is saying...."I would let her..I would do this or that"..and that's great b/c we all do what is best for us....But the op.. is NOT comfortable with it...the constant posts of "i think you're wong" is just making me really sad for the op...

Ok : Im ready for the "it's a public forum and people can say blah blah blah" and the

" she asked for opinions" comments...

I can take it!!Chat Icon Chat Icon

eta: just to clarify...i agree the op needs to make her wishes clear...

Message edited 2011-06-16 12:20:01.173000.

Posted 6/16/11 12:18 PM
 

annoyedTTCer
LIF Adult

Member since 4/09

3272 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Linda1003

Posted by annoyedTTCer

My MIL lives overseas so she'll never be watching my son.

Will say with 100% certainty that if I told my mom she couldn't go anywhere with her grandson she'd tell me to piss off and go find myself some hired help.

Nothing wrong with asking her to not go out everyday but I see no problem with her running out now and again when needed.





But that's you...I feel really badly that everyone is saying...."I would let her..I would do this or that"..and that's great b/c we all do what is best for us....But the op.. is NOT comfortable with it...the constant posts of "i think you're wong" is just making me really sad for the op...

Ok : Im ready for the "it's a public forum and people can say blah blah blah" and the

" she asked for opinions" comments...

I can take it!!Chat Icon Chat Icon

eta: just to clarify...i agree the op needs to make her wishes clear...



A) Someone is doing her a favor for free
B) She allows her to drive to school

I think when someone does you a favor you treat them a little differently than as if they are hired help.

Posted 6/16/11 12:25 PM
 

Tina1117
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1447 total posts

Name:
Tina

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by MrsSunflwr29

Again I am grateful that she watches them. She is only alone with them 1 day per week. On the other 2 days I work from home and she is only here from 7 hours. Between lunch naps etc...7 hours goes quick. This all happened on the 1 day that I was in the office and she is only here from 8-3 then my mom takes over until my DH comes home.

I know you think staying home with 3 kids would drive anyone crazy but to be honest it is the easiest place to be. Here they have all the toys in the yard and in the house. All 3 of my kids are on the go and being at home is the best place for them to play...I would think that would be easier then chasing 3 kids at a playground where they can run free, better then a store when they can take off....My kids are good and this never happens but you never know what can catch their eyes...never the less that is off topic.

She has walked them down to the corner to the food store, bagel store, etc and I have no issues..I just do not like the car and not knowing where my kids are.

Another situation was 2 weeks ago she said she was going for a walk...I said fine later that day my neighbors said oh your kids were so cute at the park and never once did she mention to me that she was there...I was taken back and I just dropped it. To me by not saying is hiding something..and if I give car permissions I may never know where they go..



I think you need to pick and choose your battles. I do not think there is any harm in a MIL taking her grandchildren (yes your children) to the park. I don't think she's trying to be disrespectful but you really won't let her do anything. It's kind of like you are treating her like a child.

I get the car thing and driving because people just don't know how to drive but now you're talking about stopping at the park and she didn't tell you. I think if you backed off a little then you'd see that she just wants to enjoy her grandchildren and not be stuck to a 8-3 schedule in a house.

I'm sorry it's not what you want to hear but I think this situation is partly due to both of you.

Posted 6/16/11 12:29 PM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by annoyedTTCer

Posted by Linda1003

Posted by annoyedTTCer

My MIL lives overseas so she'll never be watching my son.

Will say with 100% certainty that if I told my mom she couldn't go anywhere with her grandson she'd tell me to piss off and go find myself some hired help.

Nothing wrong with asking her to not go out everyday but I see no problem with her running out now and again when needed.





But that's you...I feel really badly that everyone is saying...."I would let her..I would do this or that"..and that's great b/c we all do what is best for us....But the op.. is NOT comfortable with it...the constant posts of "i think you're wong" is just making me really sad for the op...

Ok : Im ready for the "it's a public forum and people can say blah blah blah" and the

" she asked for opinions" comments...

I can take it!!Chat Icon Chat Icon

eta: just to clarify...i agree the op needs to make her wishes clear...



A) Someone is doing her a favor for free
B) She allows her to drive to school

I think when someone does you a favor you treat them a little differently than as if they are hired help.




But she is the mother!! If my mother were here and she was watching my son.. for free... and she wants to pierce his ears.. I should let her b/c she's doing it for free and a favor!!!

Its' a FEAR that the mother has.. it has NOTHING to do with trust of the person.. I have the same fear..irrational as it may be.. I dont want people driving my son either..if the mother in law doesn't like it than she doesnt watch the child.. but just b/c she is doing it for free doesn't give the authority to do ANYTHING with the child without the parents wishes.

Posted 6/16/11 12:31 PM
 

neener1211
:-)

Member since 4/07

22952 total posts

Name:
J

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Linda1003
Its' a FEAR that the mother has.. it has NOTHING to do with trust of the person.. I have the same fear..irrational as it may be.. I dont want people driving my son either..if the mother in law doesn't like it than she doesnt watch the child.. but just b/c she is doing it for free doesn't give the authority to do ANYTHING with the child without the parents wishes.



I agree, again!

Posted 6/16/11 12:34 PM
 

Sparrow
LIF Adult

Member since 11/10

6826 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

I have never been a Grandma (DD is only 10 weeks lol) so I can't really understand what it feels like to be one . . . BUT I can say that when I've babysat kids (family and non) I'd never consider taking them out in the car without telling the parents first.

I 100% understand your feelings, I'd be livid if someone took DD out in the car without asking first! On top of that, I'm not sure what type of carseat you have but I know a lot of them are kinda difficult to install correctly and I'd be ****** that she put it in the car herself. I'd also be really annoyed about her tearing through your house looking for the car seat.

I also think it's perfectly normal that you want to be able to know that your kids are home, safe and sound while you're at work!

Posted 6/16/11 12:36 PM
 

Tina1117
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1447 total posts

Name:
Tina

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Linda1003


But that's you...I feel really badly that everyone is saying...."I would let her..I would do this or that"..and that's great b/c we all do what is best for us....But the op.. is NOT comfortable with it...the constant posts of "i think you're wong" is just making me really sad for the op...

Ok : Im ready for the "it's a public forum and people can say blah blah blah" and the

" she asked for opinions" comments...

I can take it!!Chat Icon Chat Icon

eta: just to clarify...i agree the op needs to make her wishes clear...

My MIL watches my children and I'm just trying to relate to this situation. I do not like MIL driving with my children BUT she does have carseats in her car in case there was ever an emergency. MIL also takes my children to the park but it is an enclosed park. Am I nervous? Every minute I am away from my children of course I am. I understand this mother's concern. BUT with that being said I think she needs to communicate her concerns to her MIL. Her MIL seems out of line and they should set up some ground rules. If she doesn't the end result will not be good. After all this is DHs mother and as much as we hate it they will stick up for their mothers. So to avoid that she really needs to express these concerns to her.

I don't think she's wrong in any way...I just think there's a lack of communication and if she wants it done right then she needs to do it (not DH or anyone else).

Message edited 2011-06-16 12:41:17.417000.

Posted 6/16/11 12:38 PM
 

mommyIam

Member since 7/09

9209 total posts

Name:
Shana

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Deeluvsvinny

Well, first off (and please don't take this the wrong way)- if I trust someone to watch my child(ren) I trust them completely. So, I allow my mom and even our sitter to take DD in the car.



I agree with this, when it comes to strangers, but when it comes to family I have a really hard time telling them "I don't trust you completely" ... especially when its my own mother!

So thank god MIL and FIL don't drive, but my crazy mom, who I trust, but not completely, decided it would be fine to let DS sit in the passenger seat of the car, while she re parked it on the other side of the street. OMG my blood boiled when she did this, she wasn't going to tell me, but I came earlier than expected and caught them.

She raised me, I'm still alive and fine, and she would have done the same many years ago. But I don't care, I went ballistic, I told her off, she called me a mean mom, tells me I have a bad attitude. Really no skin off my back I don't care. She has to know how ticked off I am and that I'm going to explode every times she tries something like this.

Honestly, be a mean mommy, and ignore everyone, you have a right to want to do the best you think for your children.

Posted 6/16/11 12:46 PM
 

ali120206
2 Boys

Member since 7/06

17796 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

I have no problem with ILs or parents taking DS somewhere when they watch him. Occasionally ILs have to run errands or take him to the mall to get out for a bit. My parents take him out occasionally too (if they have him overnight, they take him to visit my almost 98 year old grandfather who is homebound).

That being said:

1) She shouldn't have disrespected her wishes

2) She shouldn't have badmouthed you

3) Why you would want to take 3 kids to the supermarket is beyond me

The only thing I am thinking though, is based on the tone of the conversation she had with your mom - is there a chance she'd stop watching your kids if she is confronted about this? Are you able to find alternative arrangements?

Posted 6/16/11 12:50 PM
 

jgl
Love my little boys!!!

Member since 8/07

7060 total posts

Name:
g

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

I agree with Tilde. Your MIL is not being paid. She is doing it because she loves the kids and is helping you out. You say you do not see the need for her to take them in the car, well, as a SAHM right now I can tell you that if I was stuck in my house all day and only able to walk places (this gets old fast) I'd go nuts! She has 3 of your kids all day. That's a lot! This isn't daycare.

If you trust her and trust her driving I see no issue with having her drive them somewhere the store, the park, a museum on occasion. If she was a terrible driver, this is a different story. My MIL will never drive my son (unless it was an emergency), because her driving succks and gets lost going down the block (she doesnt know how to go 3 miles to my house) but she knows this as well and says she would never drive with him.

Of course we dont KNOW your MIL and maybe you have issues with her that we do not know about, but getting out of the house will be good for her sanity with your kids and for your kids. Just something to think about. Chat Icon

Posted 6/16/11 1:02 PM
 

jellybean78
:)

Member since 8/06

13103 total posts

Name:
Mommy

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Honestly...if I trust my parents/ILs to watch my kids I would not have a problem with them driving the kids around unless one of them is a horrible driver/has issues driving, etc. AND as long as the kids were ALWAYS in property secured car seats.
If your MIL is perfectly capable of driving and takes care of your kids for a significant amount of time every week I think its unfair to expect her to be stuck in the hosue with them all day. Yes some errands can be done on the weekends or after you come home but still maybe she wants to take that time to relax or do other stuff.

Are you paying her? I just ask because if you are not paying her and she is esentially doing you a favor by watching the kids then I really don't blame her for being upset. It's a lot to be home all the time with one kid I can't imagine being home all the time with 3 under 3. Yes they are your kids but sometimes when you have people doing favors for you there are certain things that you should just let go...obviously this IMO. I know others think differently.

Now if you're paying her and have expressed this before that is a different story and I DO agree that before her taking them out for a drive she should have let you know where they were going.

That said I think what your MIL said to your Mom was wrong and she should apologize to you.
Chat Icon

Posted 6/16/11 1:06 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

If you're not paying her, you need to be more reasonable with her wants and needs. If you don't, then you need to find some hired help.

Posted 6/16/11 1:11 PM
 

NextStopBabytown
TTC #2

Member since 11/08

3141 total posts

Name:
Lindsey

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Linda1003

Posted by annoyedTTCer

My MIL lives overseas so she'll never be watching my son.

Will say with 100% certainty that if I told my mom she couldn't go anywhere with her grandson she'd tell me to piss off and go find myself some hired help.

Nothing wrong with asking her to not go out everyday but I see no problem with her running out now and again when needed.





But that's you...I feel really badly that everyone is saying...."I would let her..I would do this or that"..and that's great b/c we all do what is best for us....But the op.. is NOT comfortable with it...the constant posts of "i think you're wong" is just making me really sad for the op...

Ok : Im ready for the "it's a public forum and people can say blah blah blah" and the

" she asked for opinions" comments...

I can take it!!Chat Icon Chat Icon

eta: just to clarify...i agree the op needs to make her wishes clear...



I totally agree with Linda

The issue isn't 'should she allow MIL to take the kids out?' The issue is she said 'no taking the kids in the car!' MIL took the kids in the car AND didn't tell the PARENT of these kids where/when she was going. Not OK by me Chat Icon Chat Icon

I too feel sad for the OP but I truly believe she is right in this situation

Posted 6/16/11 1:34 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

I'd be ticked off.

My aunt has AJ during the summer (right now) and I mean HAS her.. all day and all night, doesn't come home until the weekends. She'll be 3 in August.

When she was younger I posted several times how upset I was about her driving AJ around but I had to bite my tongue for a lot of it. Now she's older and its not exactly 'better'.

I still freak out. I want to know where she is at all times. I call a lot during the day no less. My aunt SAYS they won't go out but I find out later she does. It drives me absolutely crazy! What if there's a wreck and I won't even know they were out and about? It bothers me. Chat Icon

But in my situtation I can't expect her not to go out. So with that I have to be the same way with weekends during the school year. I can't hold her back.

Do I trust her, Yes
Do I love her, Yes
Does it bother me, Absolutely
Does it stop her, nope
Will I stop letting AJ stay over, nope

Like my dad said when I complained to him - if you don't like it, don't drop her off. Its the price you pay.

Chat Icon

The comments to your mom, totally uncalled for. Not notifying you they went out is rude in my opinion.

Posted 6/16/11 1:42 PM
 

yankinmanc
Happy Days!

Member since 8/05

18208 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by annoyedTTCer

My MIL lives overseas so she'll never be watching my son.

Will say with 100% certainty that if I told my mom she couldn't go anywhere with her grandson she'd tell me to piss off and go find myself some hired help.

Nothing wrong with asking her to not go out everyday but I see no problem with her running out now and again when needed.






OMG I Am agreeing with AnnoyedTTCer. Awesome sauce. And the bit about the fact that my mom would tell me to get some hired help, I agree with 100%. If I was your MIL I was not be happy.

Posted 6/16/11 1:48 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
How would you react to this situation(MIL vent) babyquestion 5/26/11 16 Parenting
Need advice on how to handle a MIL situation katiebug 4/28/10 14 Parenting
Napping location suggestions for MIL-tricky situation neener1211 8/24/09 13 Parenting
MIL situation (kinda long) pinkandblue 2/5/07 12 Parenting