Opionions on MIL situation

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3 4

MrsSunflwr29
LIF Adult

Member since 3/06

1093 total posts

Name:
M

Opionions on MIL situation

Just some background. Since our boys were born 3 years ago we never let anyone drive them around unless necessary (back and forth to school).

My MIL watches the 3 of them ( 3 under 3) 3 days a week while I work. 1 day I go the office the other 2 days I am at home.

Now that the boys are done with school I put the carry carseat away since there is no need for the kids to go in the car.

Yesterday I call home at lunch time just to check in and say hello. Well she tells me that everyone woke up etc and then goes into that she went looking for the carseat (which was in the back of the basement) and took the kids food shopping..Well I almost went through the roof. I kept my cool and said please do not take the kids out in the car in the future. She turned and completely got mad and me and fine I wont do anything. I said they can go for walks but there is no need for them to go in the car. There are stores in walking distance.

Now on the days I am in the office my mom comes after to work to relieve her. She goes on to tell my mom that I have a bad attitude. That she feels bad that my mom has a daughter that is so mean and that she isnt allowed to do anything with the kids. My mom turned around and said dont worry about our relationship (btw me and my mom are really close). Then she goes onto say I am just like her sister and have the same attiude (this is a sister she doenst deal with).

I am ****** on so many levels here and I am not sure what to do. 1st she went through my house looking for a carseat. 2nd she took my kids out of my house without my knowledge. Godforbid there was a car accident how would I ever find out. 3. She dragged my mom into this whole thing.

So where do I start do I leave it alone, do I say something....I think I am just going to leave it since it is known I dont want them in the car...but wondering how you all would handle this situation.

Posted 6/16/11 9:02 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Deeluvsvinny
DONE

Member since 10/08

4952 total posts

Name:
Whatever

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Well, first off (and please don't take this the wrong way)- if I trust someone to watch my child(ren) I trust them completely. So, I allow my mom and even our sitter to take DD in the car.

What your MIL said wasn't cool. I'd discuss THAT with her or your DH.

But, to be fair- you didn't tell her that since school is over there is no reason for her to take them in the car...right? I understand she had to use the car when they were in school, but if that's okay- why isn't a trip to the grocery store? Either way- they're all in the car, right?

Posted 6/16/11 9:08 AM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

well it depends on your relationship.. but I would get hubby involved.. and explain why you don't want her to drive them and that it's not for her to Understand why.. your kids..your rules.. and hubby needs to set her straight about talking sh*t about his wife ESPECIALLY to your mother!!Chat Icon

eta: just want to say that it's not for ANYONE to understand WHY you don't want you MIL driving them around..even if you had her drive them to school!!! You aren't comfortable and that's ALL THAT MATTERS!!!

Message edited 2011-06-16 09:11:43.147000.

Posted 6/16/11 9:10 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

She should not have talked about you, especially to your mother BUT I don't think it is fair that she has to stay home when she is watching them three days a week for you. Sorry, just being honest.

My parents watch DD for me and take her all over -- they have to shop and run errands too and it isn't fair to make them sit at home with DD if they are doing me a favor.

Posted 6/16/11 9:12 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

I may be in the minority here BUT here goes............I trust my family completely with my DD but I am still NOT a fan of ANYONE driving her around. For example, my dad is a terrible driver (I don't even feel safe in the car with him) so I wouldn't be comfortable having him drive DD around. I don't want to have to worry where she is, what store she's at, did something happen, etc. etc. I just don't really see the need for anyone to be driving my DD around at this age. (She's almost 3) I don't know, maybe I am a little crazy but I just feel better if it's just me or my DH that drives her around town.

Edit - I should also mention though that I don't rely no anyone for childcare which probably changes things a little. I am a SAHM so when my family does come to spend time we're either all together or on occasion DH and I will go out AFTER she's in bed for the night and my parents watch her. Perhaps if my mom was watching her all day long, 3 days a week I would have to change my tune but in my case, I don't really have a need for anyone to drive her around. KWIM?

Message edited 2011-06-16 09:17:09.483000.

Posted 6/16/11 9:14 AM
 

MrsSunflwr29
LIF Adult

Member since 3/06

1093 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

i do trust them I just feel there is no need for them to be in the car. God forbid there is an accident. If they were in daycare they wouldnt be in the car and around town. They are where you expect them to be. I have more then enough stuff in my home to keep them busy trust me. While I am at work I want the peice of mind that my kids are at home. Yesterday I thought my kids were wakling up having breakfast and watching tv instead within 2 hours they were dressed and out the door without me even knowing. What if there was an accident? How would I find out if something happened to my kids? I just want to know they are safe..

Posted 6/16/11 9:15 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Hofstra26

I may be in the minority here BUT here goes............I trust my family completely with my DD but I am still NOT a fan of ANYONE driving her around. For example, my dad is a terrible driver (I don't even feel safe in the car with him) so I wouldn't be comfortable having him drive DD around. I don't want to have to worry where she is, what store she's at, did something happen, etc. etc. I just don't really see the need for anyone to be driving my DD around at this age. (She's almost 3) I don't know, maybe I am a little crazy but I just feel better if it's just me or my DH that drives her around town.



But is your dad stuck at home with your children multiple times a week? How would he get anything done? Go food shopping? Pick up something from the dry cleaners?

No one is driving DD around for the heck of it, but they have to live their lives - they are not day care workers LOL

Posted 6/16/11 9:16 AM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

But she is the mother!! the MIL has a choice to not watch them if she doesn't like the arrangement.

I for one understand.. first time mom.. I dont want anyone driving my kid around...school is a necessity...shopping isnt'..

OP said there are stores in walking distance.. it's 3 days a week....I dont' think anyone should be questioning her decision at this point..it's not wht the post was about. KWIM.

Totall not being confrontational.. I just feel bad when everyone questions a mothers decision..kwim

Posted 6/16/11 9:16 AM
 

MrsSunflwr29
LIF Adult

Member since 3/06

1093 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Hofstra26

I may be in the minority here BUT here goes............I trust my family completely with my DD but I am still NOT a fan of ANYONE driving her around. For example, my dad is a terrible driver (I don't even feel safe in the car with him) so I wouldn't be comfortable having him drive DD around. I don't want to have to worry where she is, what store she's at, did something happen, etc. etc. I just don't really see the need for anyone to be driving my DD around at this age. (She's almost 3) I don't know, maybe I am a little crazy but I just feel better if it's just me or my DH that drives her around town.



I agree 100% with you...As for errands she is here from either 7-3 or 10 - 5 and she has plenty of time to do things on her own time. If I am watching someones kids that is what I should be doing and taking 3 little ones to the store isnt fun either.

Posted 6/16/11 9:17 AM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Tilde

Posted by Hofstra26

I may be in the minority here BUT here goes............I trust my family completely with my DD but I am still NOT a fan of ANYONE driving her around. For example, my dad is a terrible driver (I don't even feel safe in the car with him) so I wouldn't be comfortable having him drive DD around. I don't want to have to worry where she is, what store she's at, did something happen, etc. etc. I just don't really see the need for anyone to be driving my DD around at this age. (She's almost 3) I don't know, maybe I am a little crazy but I just feel better if it's just me or my DH that drives her around town.



But is your dad stuck at home with your children multiple times a week? How would he get anything done? Go food shopping? Pick up something from the dry cleaners?

No one is driving DD around for the heck of it, but they have to live their lives - they are not day care workers LOL




You say "stuck" like he is being forced to be there though.. it's htere choice!!

Posted 6/16/11 9:17 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Tilde

Posted by Hofstra26

I may be in the minority here BUT here goes............I trust my family completely with my DD but I am still NOT a fan of ANYONE driving her around. For example, my dad is a terrible driver (I don't even feel safe in the car with him) so I wouldn't be comfortable having him drive DD around. I don't want to have to worry where she is, what store she's at, did something happen, etc. etc. I just don't really see the need for anyone to be driving my DD around at this age. (She's almost 3) I don't know, maybe I am a little crazy but I just feel better if it's just me or my DH that drives her around town.



But is your dad stuck at home with your children multiple times a week? How would he get anything done? Go food shopping? Pick up something from the dry cleaners?

No one is driving DD around for the heck of it, but they have to live their lives - they are not day care workers LOL



I hear ya, I edited my post to mention that I am a SAHM and don't rely on anyone for childcare so that changes things a little in my case. See my original post. Chat Icon

Posted 6/16/11 9:18 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Linda1003

But she is the mother!! the MIL has a choice to not watch them if she doesn't like the arrangement.

I for one understand.. first time mom.. I dont want anyone driving my kid around...school is a necessity...shopping isnt'..

OP said there are stores in walking distance.. it's 3 days a week....I dont' think anyone should be questioning her decision at this point..it's not wht the post was about. KWIM.

Totall not being confrontational.. I just feel bad when everyone questions a mothers decision..kwim




I understand. The mom can make any decision she wants and she should be made aware of where her kids are at all times - i definitely agree with that!

But, I just don't think it is fair to the grandparents either. and the post asked for opinions Chat Icon

Posted 6/16/11 9:18 AM
 

MrsSunflwr29
LIF Adult

Member since 3/06

1093 total posts

Name:
M

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Tilde

Posted by Hofstra26

I may be in the minority here BUT here goes............I trust my family completely with my DD but I am still NOT a fan of ANYONE driving her around. For example, my dad is a terrible driver (I don't even feel safe in the car with him) so I wouldn't be comfortable having him drive DD around. I don't want to have to worry where she is, what store she's at, did something happen, etc. etc. I just don't really see the need for anyone to be driving my DD around at this age. (She's almost 3) I don't know, maybe I am a little crazy but I just feel better if it's just me or my DH that drives her around town.



But is your dad stuck at home with your children multiple times a week? How would he get anything done? Go food shopping? Pick up something from the dry cleaners?

No one is driving DD around for the heck of it, but they have to live their lives - they are not day care workers LOL



I look at it like a "job". they took on the responsiblity and knew what it was about. When I am work if I have to get things done I do it on my own time kwim.

Posted 6/16/11 9:19 AM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Tilde

Posted by Linda1003

But she is the mother!! the MIL has a choice to not watch them if she doesn't like the arrangement.

I for one understand.. first time mom.. I dont want anyone driving my kid around...school is a necessity...shopping isnt'..

OP said there are stores in walking distance.. it's 3 days a week....I dont' think anyone should be questioning her decision at this point..it's not wht the post was about. KWIM.

Totall not being confrontational.. I just feel bad when everyone questions a mothers decision..kwim




I understand. The mom can make any decision she wants and she should be made aware of where her kids are at all times - i definitely agree with that!

But, I just don't think it is fair to the grandparents either. and the post asked for opinions Chat Icon



yes opinions on how to handle the situation..not on her decision to have the mil not driver her kids 3 days a weekChat Icon
eta: they have 4 other days off during the week.

Message edited 2011-06-16 09:20:55.203000.

Posted 6/16/11 9:20 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by MrsSunflwr29

Posted by Tilde

Posted by Hofstra26

I may be in the minority here BUT here goes............I trust my family completely with my DD but I am still NOT a fan of ANYONE driving her around. For example, my dad is a terrible driver (I don't even feel safe in the car with him) so I wouldn't be comfortable having him drive DD around. I don't want to have to worry where she is, what store she's at, did something happen, etc. etc. I just don't really see the need for anyone to be driving my DD around at this age. (She's almost 3) I don't know, maybe I am a little crazy but I just feel better if it's just me or my DH that drives her around town.



But is your dad stuck at home with your children multiple times a week? How would he get anything done? Go food shopping? Pick up something from the dry cleaners?

No one is driving DD around for the heck of it, but they have to live their lives - they are not day care workers LOL



I look at it like a "job". they took on the responsiblity and knew what it was about. When I am work if I have to get things done I do it on my own time kwim.




Are you paying her?

I dont know - my parents have DD today. They have to go to the supermarket, a jewelry store and the mall. They have no restrictions on where they take her. They are watching my DD for free, I am not going to make their life harder by making them run their errands after I get home from work. JMO - if that is not the understanding that you have with her then I guess you have to make it clear to her and then it will be her choice if she wants to continue.

Posted 6/16/11 9:21 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by MrsSunflwr29

Posted by Tilde

Posted by Hofstra26

I may be in the minority here BUT here goes............I trust my family completely with my DD but I am still NOT a fan of ANYONE driving her around. For example, my dad is a terrible driver (I don't even feel safe in the car with him) so I wouldn't be comfortable having him drive DD around. I don't want to have to worry where she is, what store she's at, did something happen, etc. etc. I just don't really see the need for anyone to be driving my DD around at this age. (She's almost 3) I don't know, maybe I am a little crazy but I just feel better if it's just me or my DH that drives her around town.



But is your dad stuck at home with your children multiple times a week? How would he get anything done? Go food shopping? Pick up something from the dry cleaners?

No one is driving DD around for the heck of it, but they have to live their lives - they are not day care workers LOL



I look at it like a "job". they took on the responsiblity and knew what it was about. When I am work if I have to get things done I do it on my own time kwim.



I understand what you're saying and I would probably look at it the SAME EXACT way if I did need my parents to watch DD throughout the week. They have their own time to run errands, when they are watching my DD I would probably expect them to just be at my house with her too and just go for walks and stuff in the neighborhood but not run errands all day with her. Again, I'm sure most people don't agree with me on that but I can't help how I feel about things. I too always feel better knowing my DD is home and safe.

Posted 6/16/11 9:21 AM
 

pinkiegirl

Member since 7/07

2160 total posts

Name:
Dana

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Tilde

She should not have talked about you, especially to your mother BUT I don't think it is fair that she has to stay home when she is watching them three days a week for you. Sorry, just being honest.

My parents watch DD for me and take her all over -- they have to shop and run errands too and it isn't fair to make them sit at home with DD if they are doing me a favor.




This
She definitely should have talked to you first, but to expect her to sit home with them three days a week is not fair to her. If you're not paying her to watch your kids...then I don't think it's fair to her at all that she can't do other things like run errands etc
She's doing you a favor

Posted 6/16/11 9:21 AM
 

GioiaMia
Let's Go Rangers!

Member since 1/07

14818 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Linda1003

Posted by Tilde

Posted by Linda1003

But she is the mother!! the MIL has a choice to not watch them if she doesn't like the arrangement.

I for one understand.. first time mom.. I dont want anyone driving my kid around...school is a necessity...shopping isnt'..

OP said there are stores in walking distance.. it's 3 days a week....I dont' think anyone should be questioning her decision at this point..it's not wht the post was about. KWIM.

Totall not being confrontational.. I just feel bad when everyone questions a mothers decision..kwim




I understand. The mom can make any decision she wants and she should be made aware of where her kids are at all times - i definitely agree with that!

But, I just don't think it is fair to the grandparents either. and the post asked for opinions Chat Icon



yes opinions on how to handle the situation..not on her decision to have the mil not driver her kids 3 days a weekChat Icon
eta: they have 4 other days off during the week.



blah sorry i gave my opinion on teh wrong thing

should i put myself in a corner or something sheesh! Chat Icon

Posted 6/16/11 9:21 AM
 

Linda1003
love my 2 boys

Member since 8/08

10923 total posts

Name:
Linda

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Tilde

Posted by Linda1003

Posted by Tilde

Posted by Linda1003

But she is the mother!! the MIL has a choice to not watch them if she doesn't like the arrangement.

I for one understand.. first time mom.. I dont want anyone driving my kid around...school is a necessity...shopping isnt'..

OP said there are stores in walking distance.. it's 3 days a week....I dont' think anyone should be questioning her decision at this point..it's not wht the post was about. KWIM.

Totall not being confrontational.. I just feel bad when everyone questions a mothers decision..kwim




I understand. The mom can make any decision she wants and she should be made aware of where her kids are at all times - i definitely agree with that!

But, I just don't think it is fair to the grandparents either. and the post asked for opinions Chat Icon



yes opinions on how to handle the situation..not on her decision to have the mil not driver her kids 3 days a weekChat Icon
eta: they have 4 other days off during the week.



blah sorry i gave my opinion on teh wrong thing

should i put myself in a corner or something sheesh! Chat Icon



Chat Icon not confrontational..just stating a fact..never said anything snarky at all...not sure why it was taken that way...sorry.

Posted 6/16/11 9:23 AM
 

Tina1117
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1447 total posts

Name:
Tina

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

I think because it's your MIL you have a different opinion on the situation. If this was your mother would you be so upset about it.

I agree with a PP that if you didn't discuss this with your MIL then how would she know that she can not take them out.

I do not see anything wrong with her going through your house looking for a car seat. She wasn't snooping.

I do not agree with her talking badly about you to your mother. That definitely could've been handled differently OR not at all.

I think you should be grateful that you have a MIL who is willing to watch your children 3 days a week. You have someone who you can trust (?), someone who loves your children dearly and will give them undivided attention.

Communication is key and I think you should sit down with your MIL and tell her how you feel. I'm sure she will understand.

BTW...everyone is entitled to a bad day
Chat Icon

Posted 6/16/11 9:25 AM
 

jteach
2 and through

Member since 9/07

3939 total posts

Name:
Jess

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Tilde

Posted by Linda1003

But she is the mother!! the MIL has a choice to not watch them if she doesn't like the arrangement.

I for one understand.. first time mom.. I dont want anyone driving my kid around...school is a necessity...shopping isnt'..

OP said there are stores in walking distance.. it's 3 days a week....I dont' think anyone should be questioning her decision at this point..it's not wht the post was about. KWIM.

Totall not being confrontational.. I just feel bad when everyone questions a mothers decision..kwim




I understand. The mom can make any decision she wants and she should be made aware of where her kids are at all times - i definitely agree with that!

But, I just don't think it is fair to the grandparents either. and the post asked for opinions Chat Icon




Sorry, but I have to agree with Tilde. If any family member is helping me out by watching my child 3 days a week then I think its unfair to expect them never to have to take my child out. I don't like the idea of dd being out and about in the car without me but I can't imagine telling my aunt (who watches dd 2 times a week) that she CANNOT leave the house during that time.

You have the right to feel however you want about the situation and if you are dead set against it then you will have to either have a discussion with mil and try and get her to understand how you feel or get a babysitter that will not take them in the car.

Posted 6/16/11 9:25 AM
 

Deeluvsvinny
DONE

Member since 10/08

4952 total posts

Name:
Whatever

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

OK, since we gave our opinions on the wrong thing Chat Icon then I guess I would say: talk to her. Let her know your expectations and rules and let her decide if she still wants to watch them 3 days a week. Whether or not you pay her, it's her decision on if she' wants to do it knowing that those 3 days she can't use the car with them in it.
I'd also talk to her about how you were hurt/upset that she spoke to your mother, since you're an adul and she has an issue with you- she should have spoken to you. I did agree in my first post that what she did was wrong..and I do think you should say something so it doesn't become a bigger issue.

Posted 6/16/11 9:27 AM
 

4PsInaPod
My Loves <3

Member since 7/07

10079 total posts

Name:
D

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

She's aware she's not allowed to take them in the car or no?

Posted 6/16/11 9:28 AM
 

bluekat16
My boys :-)

Member since 3/09

6659 total posts

Name:
Kathy

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

I totally agree with you that she shouldn't have said anything to your mom about you. Your relationship with each of them is individual and one really has nothing to do with the other. I would speak to her about it and try to clarify your position regarding the driving also.

I'll be honest I would say there are mixed messages as far as the driving your 3 kids go. It's ok to school but not anywhere else. I think the fact that she can drive them to school but not anywhere is confusing her.

I'm not questioning your decision or authoirity as a mom...everyone has different comfort levels. However, anything can happen anywhere, and anytime...whether they're being driven, walking, at the park, in your own home and not only with your MIL or mom but with you and DH.

Message edited 2011-06-16 09:31:47.383000.

Posted 6/16/11 9:30 AM
 

Tina1117
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1447 total posts

Name:
Tina

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by MrsSunflwr29

i do trust them I just feel there is no need for them to be in the car. God forbid there is an accident. If they were in daycare they wouldnt be in the car and around town. They are where you expect them to be. I have more then enough stuff in my home to keep them busy trust me. While I am at work I want the peice of mind that my kids are at home. Yesterday I thought my kids were wakling up having breakfast and watching tv instead within 2 hours they were dressed and out the door without me even knowing. What if there was an accident? How would I find out if something happened to my kids? I just want to know they are safe..



IMO I think you are being a little harsh on your MIL.

I do not like my children out driving around either BUT it was a trip to the market. She wasn't out joy riding.

Yes if your children were in daycare they would most definitely be put all day but then you'd be worrying about other things.

From what you write it seems that your MIL comes to your house...this is a blessing.

We all worry about our children no matter what the situation is...I think just a little talk with your MIL may help both of you understand what you expect of each other.

Posted 6/16/11 9:30 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3 4
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
How would you react to this situation(MIL vent) babyquestion 5/26/11 16 Parenting
Need advice on how to handle a MIL situation katiebug 4/28/10 14 Parenting
Napping location suggestions for MIL-tricky situation neener1211 8/24/09 13 Parenting
MIL situation (kinda long) pinkandblue 2/5/07 12 Parenting