Opionions on MIL situation

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 3 [4]

Tina1117
LIF Adult

Member since 11/07

1447 total posts

Name:
Tina

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by NextStopBabytown


QUOTE]

I totally agree with Linda

The issue isn't 'should she allow MIL to take the kids out?' The issue is she said 'no taking the kids in the car!' MIL took the kids in the car AND didn't tell the PARENT of these kids where/when she was going. Not OK by me Chat Icon Chat Icon

I too feel sad for the OP but I truly believe she is right in this situation



I think she told MIL 'no' after she took the kids out in the car. I don't think it was prior to taking them out Chat Icon

Posted 6/16/11 2:00 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

casey31
Mommy of 3!

Member since 5/05

2967 total posts

Name:
Mommy to two boys and a girl

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by nrthshgrl

Posted by Irishgrl13

Let me ask you a question then....if you don't mind.... Do you pay her? or is she doing this to help you guys out?

If she is being paid...like a job...then yes, you have every right to say "no car except for school"...

If she is helping you out, you still have every right to say "no car"...but I would just think it is a little harsh considering she is doing you a favor...



I agree with this to some extent.
I do think that your MIL should follow your wishes while watching your kids regardless of being paid or not. BUT if she is doing you the favor & not following your wishes (which I'm not even sure you specified to her), then YOU have the option of getting another caregiver. Or if you were to spell out "you cannot take the kids in the car", she has the option of saying, I can't do it. But as you've stated, she will say one thing & do the other.

Given her history of not listening to you, I suggest you find another caregiver. You cannot control her but you can control what you do.

If you decide to stick with her because of finances (3 kids in daycare is Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon ), then you need to go into it knowing that you have someone who does not respect your wishes while watching your kids.

I do think you should be made aware of where she is taking your kids (the park, the store, etc) but I also think expecting someone who isn't paid to stay home for 3 days with 3 kids & not go out just for some change of pace is tough on everyone. Even daycares change their curriculum to alleviate boredom.



I totally agree with this. My mom was watching my 2 for a while and now she is sick and my FIL is watching them 2 days a week. Of course they do things differently than we would do but it is such a HUGE favor and we are SO grateful that its not even worth addressing.

Message edited 2011-06-16 14:32:16.700000.

Posted 6/16/11 2:30 PM
 

summertime
LIF Adolescent

Member since 9/10

852 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by Tina1117

Posted by MrsSunflwr29

i do trust them I just feel there is no need for them to be in the car. God forbid there is an accident. If they were in daycare they wouldnt be in the car and around town. They are where you expect them to be. I have more then enough stuff in my home to keep them busy trust me. While I am at work I want the peice of mind that my kids are at home. Yesterday I thought my kids were wakling up having breakfast and watching tv instead within 2 hours they were dressed and out the door without me even knowing. What if there was an accident? How would I find out if something happened to my kids? I just want to know they are safe..



IMO I think you are being a little harsh on your MIL.

I do not like my children out driving around either BUT it was a trip to the market. She wasn't out joy riding.

Yes if your children were in daycare they would most definitely be put all day but then you'd be worrying about other things.

From what you write it seems that your MIL comes to your house...this is a blessing.

We all worry about our children no matter what the situation is...I think just a little talk with your MIL may help both of you understand what you expect of each other.



Totally agree. On another note god bless her if she wants to go food shopping with 3 kids under 3. I have 3 and food shopping is a nightmare!

Posted 6/16/11 2:37 PM
 

Bops
My 3 wishes

Member since 12/07

13625 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

My MIL occasionallly watches my children.....

She is a terrible driver, so I myself would not drive with her, let alone have her drive around with my 3 precious cargo in tow....She also smokes like a chimney with the windows rolled up, so her car smells like an ashtray...

Just because I trust her to watch my kids in my home , does not mean I feel comfortable with her driving them around...Difference being- my home is a controlled environment that "she" is IMO capable of watching them safely in...Her home is also not child friendly and I feel the same about her watching them there, therefore she does not...

She is aware of this (of-course I do not hurt her feelings by telling her what a terrible driver I think she is Chat Icon )...
If she had a problem with this, there would be no hard feelings, we would just find someone else to care for them.

I do feel that OP's mil was wrong in speaking about her the way she did...not cool
It seems like the biggest issue is that the MIL just assumed it was okay to take them...Things like this do kind of need to be discussed in advance I think...

Posted 6/16/11 2:41 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

1. Going on a limb here...but the troublemaker is your mom. no disrespect...but why would she tell you that your mil said those things??? fueling an unnecessary fire.

2. SAHMs function in different ways. Some find it easiest to stay home and play in their yard. Others must pass the day away being out and about. I go out all the time for nonsense. The getting kids ready, getting them in car, driving somewhere while they are strapped in-it is a mental break for me. so i can see why mil went.

3. It must be so hard to not have control over the situation. I sincerely can't imagine being at work and not knowing what my kids are doing...but, if your MIL is giving your kids awesome days...I would really try to go with it.

Chat Icon

Posted 6/16/11 3:46 PM
 

Janice
Sweet Jessie Quinn

Member since 5/05

27567 total posts

Name:
Janice

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

wanted to add-trust my sister to watch kids, drive, take them out places with her...but pool is off limits.

i don't know why but i just have a weird feeling about it. she understands...so i can see if driving was my hangup rather then swimming...it would drive me insane if i knew she had my kids at a pool while i was working

Posted 6/16/11 3:48 PM
 

stickydust
Now a mommy of 2!!!

Member since 4/06

3164 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

Posted by itsbabytime

I don't let anyone drive my kids around or take them on errands unless it is a necessary situation. That said, it is b/c there is no one that I trust enough to do it AND, I stay home with them 24/7 so no one has to.

So, that said, I am going to be totally honest with you b/c you asked for opinions. I do think you are being very unfair and unreasonable. You expect your MIL to watch your kids - 3 of them under 3 which is ALOT to ask of an older person - 3 days a week for no money or anything and, then, you are going to restrict her that she can't leave the house unless she walks with them which, might not be the easiest in the summer heat for an older person juggling 3 little kids. My feeling is this - if you have these concerns - you are very entitled to them but, if you want what you say to go then I feel you should hire a nanny or put them in day care. I think your MIL was understandably frustrated as she is doingyou a HUGE HUGE favor!



I agree with this 100%!!

eta: except I do let both my ILs and my mom drive my kids. They are all safe drivers and I would go insane if I worried about all the what ifs.

Message edited 2011-06-16 16:29:29.453000.

Posted 6/16/11 4:27 PM
 

KT2004
LIF Zygote

Member since 11/08

40 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

After having my first child, I went back to work & my MIL watched my daughter twice a week. She would drive to our house & spend the entire day there. There were many times that she took my daughter out to either a store or a friends house (with my car that had the carseat base) & I didn't mind at all......she was doing us such a huge favor & I was so grateful. As long as she's taking the kids out with carseats & she's a cautious driver, I don't see what the big deal is....Chat Icon

Posted 6/16/11 8:45 PM
 

twicethefun
Loving life

Member since 7/06

4088 total posts

Name:

Re: Opionions on MIL situation

So you expect your MIL to stay at home with your boys all day? Except maybe a walk. What if she needs to go to the post office or something she is not allowed? Or if she wants to take them to the library, park or museum? That sounds painful for both the kids and the MIL.

JMHO

Posted 6/16/11 9:35 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 3 [4]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
How would you react to this situation(MIL vent) babyquestion 5/26/11 16 Parenting
Need advice on how to handle a MIL situation katiebug 4/28/10 14 Parenting
Napping location suggestions for MIL-tricky situation neener1211 8/24/09 13 Parenting
MIL situation (kinda long) pinkandblue 2/5/07 12 Parenting