operation take binky away....

Posted By Message

JenandMikey
life is good =)

Member since 5/07

4216 total posts

Name:
We're so blessed!

operation take binky away....

so I took dd#1's binky away when I could reason with her.....at about 33months old or so....i told her the binky fairy would come and take the binky for another little baby and leave a really cool present for the "big girl" and the binky fairy left the vetch mobigo....she asked a couple of times for the binky back but i told her that if the binky fairy has to come back she's taking the mobigo away, she wasn't having that so she got over the no binky thing after like two days .....so now I have dd#2....

honestly i'm a fan of keeping the binky until the kid is old enough to be reasoned with because it is so much easier to take it away....but she just turned 2 and has been in speech since 19mos old....she is having trouble with only words that use the movement of the tongue and the speech therapist along with her pediatrician feels that the binky is hindering her and making tongue placement when talking difficult so they want me to take it away....she is obsessed with the binky if she loses it in the middle of the night i have to go in there to find it and i got to the point where i put like 5 binkies in at a time so i wouldn't have to wake up so needless to say she is super attached....so after this longwinded story, my question is......

what do I do? how do I take this binky away? I heard about the cutting a small piece method until theres nothing left? does that work? any other suggestions, experiences? thank you in advance

Posted 7/11/12 7:25 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

cheryl28
LIF Adult

Member since 2/10

4657 total posts

Name:

Re: operation take binky away....

I did cold turkey when dd was 1 and I would not do that again. It was a nightmare. That was our BIG parenting mistake haha.

I would poke it with a pin and see if that helps first. She won't suck on it the same and then I would tll her it's broken and throw it away. I would do it to all of them.

If that doesn't work I would cut a little of it until there is nothing left.

Good Luck!

Posted 7/11/12 7:41 AM
 

Jan1975
.

Member since 8/09

3846 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Re: operation take binky away....

Here is what worked wonders for DD, she was about 21 months or so....

Elmo's song "Bye Bye Binky"

At first we would show her the video and then talk about it...we would show her everyday. Then we started taking away the binky in the car, then naps, then nightime. We would always sing the song and then subsitute DD's name for Elmo's. It may take a while, but she got it and we had no problems!!!Elmo's Bye Bye Binky Songs....

Posted 7/11/12 8:26 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: operation take binky away....

can you take it away just during the day for now - let her have it for naps/night time and then later on transition and take it away all together?

my son is 26 months. at about 18 months, we cut him off outside of the crib - cold turkey. i have no problem with him keeping it for naps/sleep until HE is ready but, he has no speech issues.

Chat Icon

Posted 7/11/12 9:06 AM
 

JenandMikey
life is good =)

Member since 5/07

4216 total posts

Name:
We're so blessed!

Re: operation take binky away....

Posted by maymama

can you take it away just during the day for now - let her have it for naps/night time and then later on transition and take it away all together?

my son is 26 months. at about 18 months, we cut him off outside of the crib - cold turkey. i have no problem with him keeping it for naps/sleep until HE is ready but, he has no speech issues.

Chat Icon



see i took the binky away during the day for both my girls very early so they both actually only had a problem for naps and bedtime.....and like you i did the cold turkey for during the day....now its the naps and bedtime ....and also like you i have absolutely no problem with her having it until i could reason more with her like i did with my first dd but my first dd was speaking in sentences at 18mos old with no problems so this is definitely different and i feel like i need to listen to the speech therapist and pediatrician if they are both saying that the binky could be the reason for the tongue placement problem....im really upset about having to do this bc I'm a firm believer in whatever comforts a child shouldn't be taken away until they are readyChat Icon

Posted 7/11/12 9:40 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: operation take binky away....

Posted by JenandMikey

Posted by maymama

can you take it away just during the day for now - let her have it for naps/night time and then later on transition and take it away all together?

my son is 26 months. at about 18 months, we cut him off outside of the crib - cold turkey. i have no problem with him keeping it for naps/sleep until HE is ready but, he has no speech issues.

Chat Icon



see i took the binky away during the day for both my girls very early so they both actually only had a problem for naps and bedtime.....and like you i did the cold turkey for during the day....now its the naps and bedtime ....and also like you i have absolutely no problem with her having it until i could reason more with her like i did with my first dd but my first dd was speaking in sentences at 18mos old with no problems so this is definitely different and i feel like i need to listen to the speech therapist and pediatrician if they are both saying that the binky could be the reason for the tongue placement problem....im really upset about having to do this bc I'm a firm believer in whatever comforts a child shouldn't be taken away until they are readyChat Icon



how could the paci be interferring is she is only using it while sleeping? she isnt talking while sleeping? did the therapist and doc say it can interfere even if only used for sleep?

Posted 7/11/12 9:45 AM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

operation take binky away....

Does she understand more than she can say? My first daughter never wanted a paci, so it was never an issue. My second was truly obsessed. About 2 months, or maybe a little less, before she turned 2, she was starting a new school and I wanted her to have a fresh start without it. So, I did the paci fairy spontaneously one day. She left it on the counter, and was doing something else. I hid it. She went back for it and looked confused. I made a big excited deal and said the paci fairy must have come to take it away so that the new babies would have them, and that means she is a big girl now. She definitely got it. It was a little hard at times, but I would remind her, and she would be ok. Then I ordered something from amazon with a note from the paci fairy saying how proud she was and how happy the new babies are. (It was a little lalaloopsy and a schoolbus). She thought lalaloopsy was paci fairy, and she still calls her paci fairy to this day. She then carried paci fairy around for awhile, along with her "shirts". (My old shirts that she carried and slept with from about 6 mths old). She still had other things to use as a source of comfort, so she did way better than I expected given how attached she was to it.

Posted 7/11/12 9:56 AM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: operation take binky away....

We got rid of the binky with our DD about a month before she turned 2. She had been teething and chewing on her pacis and I would find them with holes in the nipple down by where they connected to the rest of the paci.

As I would find broken ones, I would throw them out because I was afraid she would choke on it.

Finally, the last binky in the house had a hole in it. That night before bed, I showed it to her, showed her it was broken, ripped the nipple off. She repeated "paci broken?", got upset for about a minute, and was fine.

It's amazing sometimes how some kids are able to just move on. I think it all depends on your child. Some kids let go easily, others fight it. Good luck!

Posted 7/11/12 10:07 AM
 

Kissy331
My two miracles!

Member since 5/06

17826 total posts

Name:
Kristen

Re: operation take binky away....

Going through it now with my almost 2 yr old. He was addicted & would walk around 24/7. I had enough & slit holes in all the tops of the nipples. I give it to him only at night but since splitting the nipples he barely sucks it. He will chew it if he grabs it. I figure in another month I will completely take it away.

Posted 7/11/12 10:28 AM
 

JenandMikey
life is good =)

Member since 5/07

4216 total posts

Name:
We're so blessed!

Re: operation take binky away....

Posted by maymama

Posted by JenandMikey

Posted by maymama

can you take it away just during the day for now - let her have it for naps/night time and then later on transition and take it away all together?

my son is 26 months. at about 18 months, we cut him off outside of the crib - cold turkey. i have no problem with him keeping it for naps/sleep until HE is ready but, he has no speech issues.

Chat Icon



see i took the binky away during the day for both my girls very early so they both actually only had a problem for naps and bedtime.....and like you i did the cold turkey for during the day....now its the naps and bedtime ....and also like you i have absolutely no problem with her having it until i could reason more with her like i did with my first dd but my first dd was speaking in sentences at 18mos old with no problems so this is definitely different and i feel like i need to listen to the speech therapist and pediatrician if they are both saying that the binky could be the reason for the tongue placement problem....im really upset about having to do this bc I'm a firm believer in whatever comforts a child shouldn't be taken away until they are readyChat Icon



how could the paci be interferring is she is only using it while sleeping? she isnt talking while sleeping? did the therapist and doc say it can interfere even if only used for sleep?



yesChat Icon apparently no matter when they use them even if when sleeping they can interfere because of how the tongue is positioned while sucking on it....that positioning can lead to tongue thrusting which can lead to lisps and annunciation problems with certain words....i actually started looking it up when the speech therapist brought it up, and there is evidence that it is possible and then when the pediatrician said it to me last night (before i even brought it up that the speech therapist told me to take it away)i realized that i guess its best even though i really don't want to and I'm so upset to do soChat Icon

Posted 7/11/12 2:04 PM
 

JenandMikey
life is good =)

Member since 5/07

4216 total posts

Name:
We're so blessed!

Re: operation take binky away....

Posted by mamabear

Does she understand more than she can say? My first daughter never wanted a paci, so it was never an issue. My second was truly obsessed. About 2 months, or maybe a little less, before she turned 2, she was starting a new school and I wanted her to have a fresh start without it. So, I did the paci fairy spontaneously one day. She left it on the counter, and was doing something else. I hid it. She went back for it and looked confused. I made a big excited deal and said the paci fairy must have come to take it away so that the new babies would have them, and that means she is a big girl now. She definitely got it. It was a little hard at times, but I would remind her, and she would be ok. Then I ordered something from amazon with a note from the paci fairy saying how proud she was and how happy the new babies are. (It was a little lalaloopsy and a schoolbus). She thought lalaloopsy was paci fairy, and she still calls her paci fairy to this day. She then carried paci fairy around for awhile, along with her "shirts". (My old shirts that she carried and slept with from about 6 mths old). She still had other things to use as a source of comfort, so she did way better than I expected given how attached she was to it.



yes she can understand much more than what she can communicate verbally....and i did the binky fairy with my first daughter but i did that closer to when she turned 3....i really don't know if she would totally grasp it....i don't know what to do....i think i might try putting a pinhole in one and see how she does

Posted 7/11/12 2:06 PM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: operation take binky away....

Posted by JenandMikey

Posted by maymama

Posted by JenandMikey

Posted by maymama

can you take it away just during the day for now - let her have it for naps/night time and then later on transition and take it away all together?

my son is 26 months. at about 18 months, we cut him off outside of the crib - cold turkey. i have no problem with him keeping it for naps/sleep until HE is ready but, he has no speech issues.

Chat Icon



see i took the binky away during the day for both my girls very early so they both actually only had a problem for naps and bedtime.....and like you i did the cold turkey for during the day....now its the naps and bedtime ....and also like you i have absolutely no problem with her having it until i could reason more with her like i did with my first dd but my first dd was speaking in sentences at 18mos old with no problems so this is definitely different and i feel like i need to listen to the speech therapist and pediatrician if they are both saying that the binky could be the reason for the tongue placement problem....im really upset about having to do this bc I'm a firm believer in whatever comforts a child shouldn't be taken away until they are readyChat Icon



how could the paci be interferring is she is only using it while sleeping? she isnt talking while sleeping? did the therapist and doc say it can interfere even if only used for sleep?



yesChat Icon apparently no matter when they use them even if when sleeping they can interfere because of how the tongue is positioned while sucking on it....that positioning can lead to tongue thrusting which can lead to lisps and annunciation problems with certain words....i actually started looking it up when the speech therapist brought it up, and there is evidence that it is possible and then when the pediatrician said it to me last night (before i even brought it up that the speech therapist told me to take it away)i realized that i guess its best even though i really don't want to and I'm so upset to do soChat Icon



makes sense Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/11/12 2:09 PM
 

shiv
Twinsanity!!

Member since 5/07

4747 total posts

Name:
Shiv

Re: operation take binky away....

Good luck, if you find something that works let me know! We tried the hole and it didn't work. DS only has his at night and he's such a heavy sleeper that as soon as he wakes up and doesn't have it he will scream until he gets it back. I just couldn't do it to him because he had no sense of what was going on. He got that the paci was broken during the day but didn't comprehend it at night.

We'll try again closer to 3.

Posted 7/11/12 2:58 PM
 
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
anyone else's toys r us order cancled for buzz operation? Dee 11/16/11 4 Parenting
Operation "Stay Put Smurfs"!!!!! (a.k.a my day in L&D) PreshusSmurf 6/28/11 32 Pregnancy
operation no pacifier.... night 1... staceyd 2/16/10 8 Parenting
Operation No Paci - getting harder, not easier - BTDT moms, help! eddiesmommy 10/21/09 4 Parenting
2008..."Operation Slimdown" as I call it... EckoRed81504 12/30/07 31 Diet & Fitness
I hope this is it....two nights without the binky! Ambersmom 5/25/06 10 Parenting