Re: operation take binky away....
Posted 7/11/2012 2:09:57 PM by maymama


Posted by JenandMikey


Posted by maymama


Posted by JenandMikey


Posted by maymama

can you take it away just during the day for now - let her have it for naps/night time and then later on transition and take it away all together?

my son is 26 months. at about 18 months, we cut him off outside of the crib - cold turkey. i have no problem with him keeping it for naps/sleep until HE is ready but, he has no speech issues.

Chat Icon



see i took the binky away during the day for both my girls very early so they both actually only had a problem for naps and bedtime.....and like you i did the cold turkey for during the day....now its the naps and bedtime ....and also like you i have absolutely no problem with her having it until i could reason more with her like i did with my first dd but my first dd was speaking in sentences at 18mos old with no problems so this is definitely different and i feel like i need to listen to the speech therapist and pediatrician if they are both saying that the binky could be the reason for the tongue placement problem....im really upset about having to do this bc I'm a firm believer in whatever comforts a child shouldn't be taken away until they are readyChat Icon



how could the paci be interferring is she is only using it while sleeping? she isnt talking while sleeping? did the therapist and doc say it can interfere even if only used for sleep?



yesChat Icon apparently no matter when they use them even if when sleeping they can interfere because of how the tongue is positioned while sucking on it....that positioning can lead to tongue thrusting which can lead to lisps and annunciation problems with certain words....i actually started looking it up when the speech therapist brought it up, and there is evidence that it is possible and then when the pediatrician said it to me last night (before i even brought it up that the speech therapist told me to take it away)i realized that i guess its best even though i really don't want to and I'm so upset to do soChat Icon



makes sense Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window