ONLY CHILD ??
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
|
Re: ONLY CHILD ?? hrm.. I wanted to add. I have a brother. We were very close growing up. He saved my life in so many ways. Made me who I am today. |
|
Posted 5/25/10 8:55 AM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: ONLY CHILD ?? I was raised as an only child and it was very lonely. My friends weren't available all the time to play and many times I wished I had a companion. This is the biggest reason I wanted to have more than 1 baby. |
|
Posted 5/25/10 9:16 AM
|
|
|
Re: ONLY CHILD ?? Posted by Xelindrya hrm.. I wanted to add. I have a brother. We were very close growing up. He saved my life in so many ways. Made me who I am today. We rarely EVER talk since I guess 91 or so. I still love him to death. If we call each other or catch one another at my father's house or on the phone its nice to have that kindred spirit. I don't see him helping with Dad as he's getting older. I don't see him helping out with AJ or me. I have a nephew but I speak even less with him. Its like they are relatives of convenience. I don't see the big deal. I love him and would put my life on the line for him. Love hanging out with him, laughing, talking, etc. But I don't see this 'need' for a sibling for AJ. She won't be lonely, she'll have friends She can learn socialization skills from school and cousins. There are PLENTY of studies out there that show only children have advantages that those with siblings are delayed at. There are also PLENTY of studies that show other advantages they lack but also catch up with. So Skills-wise (social, academic, mental, etc) are all pretty even. I don't think there's any DISADVANTAGE to having one child nor is there any ADVANTAGE per say to it either. Sometimes we have no choice. Some can only ever have one child. There's no justification necessary, it is what it is. End of story. For those of us who can have another child, I don't feel we should feel pressured into it in ANY WAY AT ALL. We all do what's best for ourselves and our children. But I can't see having another kid *JUST* to benefit our child. It does not compute in my head. If you say that's true then you'd have to say the opposite is also true... that having one child is HURTFUL to that child. That's just NOT POSSIBLE. This is a difficult question to ask a group of mothers because those who have one child will always say its not like we're out to hurt our kids, our kids are happy, healthy, well adjusted. Those who have more than one child are rarely (if never) going to say "Having that second kid was the worse thing I ever did" *shrug* When it comes to children for me... JUST FOR ME... I believe its up to ME and MY LIFE! Children grow and have lives of their own. Heck AJ is already pretty much her own person now! Altho, yes my decision affects her, its not HERS to make. She shouldn't have a say in how I use my body, just as I wouldn't ask her to give me 5 grand kids. Good Luck with your internal debate. I do think that as you grow into adults any number of things can drive siblings apart including personality, distance, age gap, etc. But that being said, I still think having siblings as you grow up really is wonderful. I just look at my DD who is only 20 months and I see how excited she is when other kids are around and how much fun she has with them that I just know having a sibling would be the greatest gift to her. I truly believe that. Now for me I am not having more children just for her benefit, DH and I both want a bigger family than just the 3 of us, but I am excited to be able to give her a constant playmate and buddy throughout her childhood. Maybe it's because I am a SAHM mom too that makes me feel that siblings are even more important but I think (and I hope) that one day she will thank me for her little brother or sister. It's a very personal choice and I see both sides of it and in the end, nobody can tell someone what to do one way or another. It's a choice that one needs to make on their own based on many, many factors. My siblings can drive me nuts now that we're older and even if we're not as close as I would like I still have great memories from childhood and so much of my childhood centered around the time spent with them.
|
|
Posted 5/25/10 9:29 AM
|
|
|
Re: ONLY CHILD ?? This is a tough question...I grew up as one of 6 children and although it was hard, we all are very close and I am glad to have them all in my life. |
|
Posted 5/25/10 9:30 AM
|
|
|
Re: ONLY CHILD ?? I don't think it is cruel at all-have the family you want, not the family that everyone else tells you you should have. |
|
Posted 5/25/10 9:47 AM
|
|
|
Re: ONLY CHILD ?? Posted by mommy2bella Ugh....these responses make me I am SO on the fence about DD being an only child. I battle with it all the time and have for the past couple of years. Search me and you will see some of my previous posts about it. I struggle every day with this choice...especially now that Bella is 5 and FAR from a baby anymore. Just yesterday I was ready to pop another one out, now I am unsure again ![]() I am one of 6 children. It was hard growing up, but I love that I can be super annoyed at 1 or even 2 siblings and still have 4 to chat with ![]() Now that my Dad is getting older and has health issues, it's good to know that at least one or two of my siblings can step up and help out. I would hate for Bella to be all alone in that burden, especially with so many aunts and uncles. Ugh I'm feeling the same way. Before we got married DH and I agreed to one child, he has a son from a previous relationship but my SS is 12.5 years older than DS so I really feel as if DS will be growing up as an only child since SS will be 18 when DS starts kindergarten. Most days I am very happy with just one child, I love being able to give him so much attention and I really wonder how I could love another child as much, even though my mother swears you do! Then there are days when I think about my childhood, I am 1 of 7, I loved having a large family, I loved the insanity of holidays, especially the excitement of Christmas morning. I worry that those type of things won't have the same thrill that they did for me. I love having so many siblings to turn to, chat with and hang out with and I genuinely feel sad for DS that he won't have that. For me there was a small downside to having a large family, we always had someone to play with, which sounds great BUT none of us are great at making friends. I think it was because we did always have each other and never 'needed' someone to play with. We all tend to have a few long term friends. DS will have tons of aunts and uncles and already he has 10 cousins (although right now only 2 close in age) so I really hope he won't be lonely growing up
|
|
Posted 5/25/10 10:18 AM
|
|
|
Re: ONLY CHILD ?? I hope its okay that I am answering since I am not a parent yet. |
|
Posted 5/25/10 10:24 AM
|
|
|
Re: ONLY CHILD ?? Posted by Tilde I hope its okay that I am answering since I am not a parent yet. No, I don't think it is cruel AT ALL BUT for me, my siblings are my BEST FRIENDS. Unfortunately, as I have gotten older - I have lost most of my best friends except for two. Yes, even the "we have been friends since age 5, like a sister" friends. However, my bond with my brother and sister has only gotten stronger. They are 12 and 14 years older than me. I talk to them every day. We see eachother twice a week. I can't wait to raise my children with theirs. I am sorry if I am not supposed to say this but I feel bad for people who have never experienced having a brother or sister. For me, I am reminded about how grateful I am for them on a daily basis. Even yesterday, I had to go for some testing at the perinatologist and I found out when I got home that my brother and sister had already called AND emailed trying to find out how it went. My parents always say that their proudest moment was when my brother and I went against THEIR wishes, and supported my sister in her marriage. This is JMO of course and I know that I am blessed to have such a great relationship with my family. I am an only and I really feel that I missed out on that sort of relationship. I missed out on it as a child and if anything want it more now as an adult! |
|
Posted 5/25/10 10:30 AM
|
|
|
Re: ONLY CHILD ?? I wouldn't say cruel. |
|
Posted 5/25/10 10:31 AM
|
|
|
Re: ONLY CHILD ?? Posted by Tilde I hope its okay that I am answering since I am not a parent yet. No, I don't think it is cruel AT ALL BUT for me, my siblings are my BEST FRIENDS. Unfortunately, as I have gotten older - I have lost most of my best friends except for two. Yes, even the "we have been friends since age 5, like a sister" friends. However, my bond with my brother and sister has only gotten stronger. They are 12 and 14 years older than me. I talk to them every day. We see eachother twice a week. I can't wait to raise my children with theirs. I am sorry if I am not supposed to say this but I feel bad for people who have never experienced having a brother or sister. For me, I am reminded about how grateful I am for them on a daily basis. Even yesterday, I had to go for some testing at the perinatologist and I found out when I got home that my brother and sister had already called AND emailed trying to find out how it went. My parents always say that their proudest moment was when my brother and I went against THEIR wishes, and supported my sister in her marriage. This is JMO of course and I know that I am blessed to have such a great relationship with my family. wow! this is so nice. i have to say my mother is an only child and WISHES she had a sibling. she used to beg her parents for one, but fortunately she grew up in a 3 family home where her cousins were upstairs and to the left of her. |
|
Posted 5/25/10 6:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: ONLY CHILD ?? Posted by mommy2bella Ugh....these responses make me I am SO on the fence about DD being an only child. I battle with it all the time and have for the past couple of years. Search me and you will see some of my previous posts about it. I struggle every day with this choice...especially now that Bella is 5 and FAR from a baby anymore. Just yesterday I was ready to pop another one out, now I am unsure again ![]() I am one of 6 children. It was hard growing up, but I love that I can be super annoyed at 1 or even 2 siblings and still have 4 to chat with ![]() Now that my Dad is getting older and has health issues, it's good to know that at least one or two of my siblings can step up and help out. I would hate for Bella to be all alone in that burden, especially with so many aunts and uncles. Ugh I feel exactly like you do. I am SO torn. Sometimes I am for having another child and other times I feel like it's totally the right thing for me. To add to it, DH and all of my family constantly ask me when the next one is coming. To them, it's not if it's when. DD is just turning 3, but I really don't know if I want another one.... eta to add that I'm an only child and never missed having siblings Message edited 2010-05-25 18:22:53.047000. |
|
Posted 5/25/10 6:21 PM
|
|
|
Re: ONLY CHILD ?? I'm an only child as well and I think there are both positives and negatives. I've always wanted siblings and yes, sometimes I feel like I miss the bond that goes with having a shared childhood with someone. But, my parents and I are super close and my they were able to provide me with things I would have never gotten if I had siblings. I also think I developed closer friendships as a result of not having siblings. |
|
Posted 5/25/10 6:53 PM
|
|
| Pages: 1 [2] | |
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Do you think it's ok for your child or any child to be allowed to stay on a school team (sports) if they are failing 2 classes? | mitabtrfly | 11/8/07 | 17 | Parenting |
| How old would your child have to be to let them fly on an airplane alone? | luvsun27 | 6/20/05 | 14 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Anyone use there maiden name as a middle name for there child? | NoStressMom | 6/14/05 | 6 | Pregnancy |
| for all of us who ever have a family memebr on a trip - child or adult, this is good to read... | pschica | 6/11/05 | 0 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| Could you adopt a child of below average intellect? | DebG | 5/27/05 | 20 | Families Helping Families ™ |
| security item what does or doesnt your child use? | TAD | 5/24/05 | 8 | Parenting |













