Re: ONLY CHILD ??
Posted 5/25/2010 9:29:00 AM by Hofstra26


Posted by Xelindrya

hrm.. I wanted to add. I have a brother. We were very close growing up. He saved my life in so many ways. Made me who I am today.

We rarely EVER talk since I guess 91 or so. I still love him to death. If we call each other or catch one another at my father's house or on the phone its nice to have that kindred spirit.

I don't see him helping with Dad as he's getting older. I don't see him helping out with AJ or me. I have a nephew but I speak even less with him. Its like they are relatives of convenience.

I don't see the big deal. I love him and would put my life on the line for him. Love hanging out with him, laughing, talking, etc. But I don't see this 'need' for a sibling for AJ.

She won't be lonely, she'll have friends

She can learn socialization skills from school and cousins.

There are PLENTY of studies out there that show only children have advantages that those with siblings are delayed at.

There are also PLENTY of studies that show other advantages they lack but also catch up with.

So Skills-wise (social, academic, mental, etc) are all pretty even. I don't think there's any DISADVANTAGE to having one child nor is there any ADVANTAGE per say to it either.

Sometimes we have no choice.

Some can only ever have one child. There's no justification necessary, it is what it is. End of story. For those of us who can have another child, I don't feel we should feel pressured into it in ANY WAY AT ALL.

We all do what's best for ourselves and our children. But I can't see having another kid *JUST* to benefit our child. It does not compute in my head. If you say that's true then you'd have to say the opposite is also true... that having one child is HURTFUL to that child. That's just NOT POSSIBLE.

This is a difficult question to ask a group of mothers because those who have one child will always say its not like we're out to hurt our kids, our kids are happy, healthy, well adjusted. Those who have more than one child are rarely (if never) going to say "Having that second kid was the worse thing I ever did"

*shrug*

When it comes to children for me... JUST FOR ME... I believe its up to ME and MY LIFE! Children grow and have lives of their own. Heck AJ is already pretty much her own person now! Altho, yes my decision affects her, its not HERS to make. She shouldn't have a say in how I use my body, just as I wouldn't ask her to give me 5 grand kids.

Good Luck with your internal debate.



I do think that as you grow into adults any number of things can drive siblings apart including personality, distance, age gap, etc. But that being said, I still think having siblings as you grow up really is wonderful. I just look at my DD who is only 20 months and I see how excited she is when other kids are around and how much fun she has with them that I just know having a sibling would be the greatest gift to her. I truly believe that. Now for me I am not having more children just for her benefit, DH and I both want a bigger family than just the 3 of us, but I am excited to be able to give her a constant playmate and buddy throughout her childhood. Maybe it's because I am a SAHM mom too that makes me feel that siblings are even more important but I think (and I hope) that one day she will thank me for her little brother or sister.

It's a very personal choice and I see both sides of it and in the end, nobody can tell someone what to do one way or another. It's a choice that one needs to make on their own based on many, many factors. My siblings can drive me nuts now that we're older and even if we're not as close as I would like I still have great memories from childhood and so much of my childhood centered around the time spent with them. Chat Icon
Print Post      Close Window