ONLY CHILD ??

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2

chris605
.

Member since 5/05

3206 total posts

Name:

ONLY CHILD ??

So - DH and I were talking over the weekend about my DD being and only child - Do you think its cruel??? I am so torn about having another child - I want to give her the best life possible and obvioulsy the more child one has the less time and $$ you have - So I just thought I would ask you guys your opinions???

I also want to add this is just your opinion regardless of your answers..... Chat Icon

Posted 5/24/10 4:19 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsPowers
So blessed!

Member since 11/06

10348 total posts

Name:
Ivelysse

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

To answer your first question, no I do not think it is cruel to only have one child. I don't think people should have another child just for the sake of having one because it is more accepted to have more than one child or etc.... You need to do what is right for you and your family and if that means having just one child, then fine.

But then again, I am an only child and see nothing wrong with it. I also defend my being an only child all of the time to people. For example, the other day a co-worker said well as an only child it stinks because you are the only one around to take care of your parents when they get older. To which I replied, well I do have a husband and how is that different than people with multiple children and some children aren't as involved and don't care for the aging parents.

Anyway, if you have any other questions please feel free to ask me.

Posted 5/24/10 4:23 PM
 

twinkletoes807
Mommy's Girls! ♥

Member since 11/07

10116 total posts

Name:
Gabi

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I don't think it is cruel at all!! Personally, I loved having siblings and even though I'm not super close to them now, it is nice to reminisce with them about growing up, when I do see them. My DH grew up 1 of 5 and they are all very very close. I adore his family and am so happy to be a part of the craziness that goes along with having a big family.

I think whatever you and DH feel is best in your own hearts is what the correct choice is. Your DD will know boundless love whether you give her a sibling or not. Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/24/10 4:23 PM
 

MrsGmomof3
...

Member since 6/08

3290 total posts

Name:
Irrelevant

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I do not think its "cruel". Only you and your DH know what is right for your lives.

Personally, I could never have had just one baby. I have 3 children, my first 2 are just 19 months apart. I dealt with the guilt over not having time with DS# 1, the money stuff, but when it came down to it, we WANTED a big family. The money stuff works out, and the "guilt", well, there is nothing for me to feel guilty about. All 3 of my children are loved, all are BONDED to me, and they have the best relationship with each other. I would not have had it any other way.

Chat Icon

Whatever YOU and DH decide will be whats best for your family though!

Posted 5/24/10 4:25 PM
 

LML
Twins!

Member since 10/09

1320 total posts

Name:
Laura

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I'm an only child and I don't think that my parents were cruel to me. Would it have been nice to have a sibling? Yes. But I don't think that I got short-changed in life because of it. I think I was more social because I learned to play with other kids where ever I went.

My cat might not have been happy about it since he was my playdate when I was alone. (Picture the cat getting tied in to my Strawberry Shortcake stroller and being walked around the block. Chat Icon)

Posted 5/24/10 4:25 PM
 

Gatsbygirl
Please St. Therese....

Member since 10/07

8494 total posts

Name:

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I'm an only child and have two minds on this topic.

There are wonderful things about being an only. I have a close relationship with both of my parents and really enjoy spending time with them. I was never spoiled in terms of material items, but felt so lucky to have their time and attention.

Will your DD grow up with cousins and extended family? I did not and that made it lonely. Even now my family is my parents- I don't really have a support system and I envy those with close knit aunts/cousins/ siblings etc.

I felt a lot of pressure to suceed since I was all my parents had. I felt I had to live up to their expectations and that could be hard.

As an adult I wish I had a sibling I could talk to/ vent about my parents. I think a lot about my parents getting olderChat Icon and know it will all fall on my shoulders and get sad and stressed just thinking about it.

Having siblings can certainly be a mixed bag and is no guarantee of anything either, but I want to tell you the pros and consChat Icon

Posted 5/24/10 4:27 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I am an only child.

Growing up I always wanted a sister and brother like everyone else and remembering asking every Christmas for a little brother or sister. My mom couldnt have anymore kids after me and decided not to go the IVF route.

That being said, I have an amazing and close relationship with my parents. I never minded it being just me on family trips. I obviously got all of their attention and they were never torn on who's game or concert to go to as parents with more than one child sometimes are. Now as an adult with kids, my parents are extremely generous with my kids and baby-sit for me. If I had siblings and they had kids, my parents probably wouldnt be able to help out as much because they would have to spend time with their other grandkids as well.

Now that I have kids I again sometimes wish I had a sister or brother...an aunt and uncle for my kids. A sister who I could call up and say "hey can I drop off the kids so I can go food shopping?" I wish I had siblings so that my kids could have lots of cousins like I did growing up.

I personally did not want my first son to be an only child. I wanted him to have at least one sibling and he got a little brother and hopefully they will be best friends for the rest of their life.

Most people dont know I am an only child and are surprised when I say I am because I am not your typical only child (I dont fit the stereotypes)...my parents did not raise me that way.

I know alot of people these days are stopping at one because they want to be able to provide them with nice things in their life, but sometimes having family is more important than the things you could ever give them.

Message edited 2010-05-24 16:31:23.927000.

Posted 5/24/10 4:28 PM
 

Mommy2Boys
My Boys!!!!

Member since 6/06

14437 total posts

Name:
C

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

Posted by Gatsbygirl

I felt a lot of pressure to suceed since I was all my parents had. I felt I had to live up to their expectations and that could be hard.

As an adult I wish I had a sibling I could talk to/ vent about my parents. I think a lot about my parents getting olderChat Icon and know it will all fall on my shoulders and get sad and stressed just thinking about it.





this is how I felt too. I was all my parents had to focus on so the attention was always on me and only me. Had I had a sibling I might have been able to let some mis-doings fall through the seams Chat Icon

Posted 5/24/10 4:30 PM
 

Gatsbygirl
Please St. Therese....

Member since 10/07

8494 total posts

Name:

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

Posted by jellybean1420

Posted by Gatsbygirl

I felt a lot of pressure to suceed since I was all my parents had. I felt I had to live up to their expectations and that could be hard.

As an adult I wish I had a sibling I could talk to/ vent about my parents. I think a lot about my parents getting olderChat Icon and know it will all fall on my shoulders and get sad and stressed just thinking about it.





this is how I felt too. I was all my parents had to focus on so the attention was always on me and only me. Had I had a sibling I might have been able to let some mis-doings fall through the seams Chat Icon



Yup! Mine was the only report card on the table to be analyzedChat Icon They were also over proctective since I was their only, but now that I am a parent I can understand that much more.

Even in COLLEGE I felt that I had to make them proud etc.

Posted 5/24/10 4:41 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I don't think its cruel

Then again I'm super happy with just one and done.

Everyone seems to want siblings and that's great. I however am very aware of what I want to give my child and I can not see myself offering her all of that if I have to divide and conquer.

I think she will love us for the parents we are, for what we teach her, the love we give her and the life she can have.

I don't think its cruel to not give her a playmate. Hopefully she'll have life long good friends. I bought my house so that we'd not move until she was much older. To give her stability and community. No she has no cousins near her age, but she has a second cousin close in age.

I think public opinion is creating peer pressure to have more kids, but its just not something I see as 'healthy' right now for my child, my life.

I can't say never, cause really who knows, but I can say I'm not TRYING to, and I am actively trying to AVOID it.

Posted 5/24/10 4:53 PM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I hated being an only child.

Posted 5/24/10 4:56 PM
 

mommy2bella
Where does time go?

Member since 12/05

9747 total posts

Name:
Kelly

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

Ugh....these responses make me Chat Icon Chat Icon

I am SO on the fence about DD being an only child. I battle with it all the time and have for the past couple of years. Search me and you will see some of my previous posts about it.

I struggle every day with this choice...especially now that Bella is 5 and FAR from a baby anymore. Just yesterday I was ready to pop another one out, now I am unsure again Chat Icon

I am one of 6 children. It was hard growing up, but I love that I can be super annoyed at 1 or even 2 siblings and still have 4 to chat with Chat Icon

Now that my Dad is getting older and has health issues, it's good to know that at least one or two of my siblings can step up and help out.

I would hate for Bella to be all alone in that burden, especially with so many aunts and uncles.

Ugh

Posted 5/24/10 5:46 PM
 

DomesticDeeva
Tiebreaker on deck!!!

Member since 11/08

2088 total posts

Name:
Dee

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I don't think it's cruel, especially if there are valid reasons why you don't want/can't have another one.

But I will say, as an only child, it has benefits and disadvantages. It can get lonely and boring without another child to play with, but if you take your child to parks, playgroups, etc., then they make friends that way. It's great to be the only one vying (sp?) for your parents attention, but it also sux when you're in trouble and have no one else to blame. Chat Icon But even having a sibling doesn't guarantee you'll get along. My DH and his bro hardly even talk..growing up they always fought.

Overall, I liked being an only child, but there were times when I would have loved a bro or sis.

Posted 5/24/10 6:05 PM
 

july06bride
I'm a mom!

Member since 5/05

3966 total posts

Name:
Nicole

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I do not think it is "cruel" to have an only child- I am biased though, being an only child myself.

Yes, there were many times growing up where I asked for a brother or sister- I clearly remember it being on my Christmas list each year ...

There were many advantages to being an only child as well...many of which were already stated...I am very close to both of my parents and I was spoiled with love. Additionally, my parents were able to give me more opportunities because they only had me...private tutors, singing lessons, dance classes, camps, vacations..etc..I consider myself very lucky- but if I had a brother or sister I might not have had all of those same experiences.

As an adult, I do think about the future and taking care of my parents but I have a loving, supportive husband who loves my parents and will always be there for me and for them.

Posted 5/24/10 6:40 PM
 

butterfly20
Party of 5 - 2015

Member since 4/06

7390 total posts

Name:

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I dont think its cruel. I think that having one you can focus your energy and money on them.

when we got married we wanted 2. Then at one point i felt like i'd be very happy with 1. Then when ds was born i wanted more. Now, we both want 2 again, but if we ever came into a load of money would want a third.

Message edited 2010-05-24 19:38:10.627000.

Posted 5/24/10 7:29 PM
 

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I'm an only child and don't think it's cruel in anyway..I had all my the attention and love in the world, not to say that adding a sibling would have taken away from that...Was it a bit lonely growing up, definitely, we don't have a huge extended family and all my friends had siblings so it was a bit strange and lonely, but nothing that I scarred me for life Chat Icon My parents gave me everything they possibly could have and more and I have never felt slighted for not having a sibling...

Posted 5/24/10 7:37 PM
 

ladyofficer
LIF Adolescent

Member since 4/09

735 total posts

Name:

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

My DH was an only child, he wanted siblings, his parents were older when they had him- both are now deceased. It can be lonely.

Posted 5/24/10 7:54 PM
 

MrsProfessor
hi

Member since 5/05

14279 total posts

Name:

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

Siblings don't guanrantee anything. Both of my parents have one sibling each that they have feuded with even into adulthood, even now that they are in their 60s. My brothers were younger and never really wanted to hang out with me- so I'd say that I was lonely a lot as a kid.

My DD is an only and it's very likely she will remain that day. She is a very happy child. We will have to work harder to help her have friends, etc. as she gets older, especially since DH and I are introverted and homebodies.

I just really enjoy the life I have with my DH and our daughter- and I know she's happy too. Being an only's not bad, it's just different.

Posted 5/24/10 8:09 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I think it's totally unfair to call this "cruel". Many factors come into consideration when having more than 1 child.

Having kids just to have "companions" for other siblings does not guarantee anything.

I have 3 other siblings. 1 I don't talk to, 1 I talk to once in a while and 1 I really like.

It means NOTHING to have siblings if you don't have the same personality/likes.

You only grow apart later on.

I am closer to some of my friends than some of my siblings who I would never talk to if they were not.

Posted 5/24/10 8:15 PM
 

cjik
Welcome 2010!

Member since 2/06

8879 total posts

Name:

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I do not think it's cruel at all, especially if DH and you have decided this is what is best for your family.

DS is going to be an only child also, and yes sometimes I wonder if he'll miss having a sibling as he gets older, but this really is the best choice for our family and for him. We talked it over and decided we really couldn't handle more right now and given our ages, right now is all the time we have.

Honestly, it's up to DH and you and people will probably have opinions about it. But if you truly believe this is best, then it is and DD will be fine.

Posted 5/24/10 9:15 PM
 

beachgirl
LIF Adult

Member since 7/05

7967 total posts

Name:
sara

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I really think its a personal choice and you have to do what you and your DH are comfortable with. I will say though that the love that my DD has for my DS and vica versa is incomparable to anything I have ever experienced. She is 4 and he is 9 months and they are already in their own little world even when my husband and I are around.

Of course they may kill each other when they are olderChat Icon but for now "I" believe having our DS was the greatest gift we could have given our DD and to be honest it has made me want one more to add to the group.

I hope this doesn't make your decision harder I just wanted to share my experience with having two with you.

Lots of luck with your decision.Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 5/24/10 9:25 PM
 

chris605
.

Member since 5/05

3206 total posts

Name:

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I just wanted to THANK everyone who responded -

Posted 5/25/10 12:34 AM
 

pickles16
Real Estate Professional

Member since 11/07

17227 total posts

Name:
Jen

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

Posted by jellybean1420

I am an only child.

Growing up I always wanted a sister and brother like everyone else and remembering asking every Christmas for a little brother or sister. My mom couldnt have anymore kids after me and decided not to go the IVF route.

That being said, I have an amazing and close relationship with my parents. I never minded it being just me on family trips. I obviously got all of their attention and they were never torn on who's game or concert to go to as parents with more than one child sometimes are. Now as an adult with kids, my parents are extremely generous with my kids and baby-sit for me. If I had siblings and they had kids, my parents probably wouldnt be able to help out as much because they would have to spend time with their other grandkids as well.

Now that I have kids I again sometimes wish I had a sister or brother...an aunt and uncle for my kids. A sister who I could call up and say "hey can I drop off the kids so I can go food shopping?" I wish I had siblings so that my kids could have lots of cousins like I did growing up.

I personally did not want my first son to be an only child. I wanted him to have at least one sibling and he got a little brother and hopefully they will be best friends for the rest of their life.

Most people dont know I am an only child and are surprised when I say I am because I am not your typical only child (I dont fit the stereotypes)...my parents did not raise me that way.

I know alot of people these days are stopping at one because they want to be able to provide them with nice things in their life, but sometimes having family is more important than the things you could ever give them.




ITA with many points!!!!

Posted 5/25/10 6:31 AM
 

Hofstra26
Love to Bake!

Member since 7/06

27915 total posts

Name:

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I don't think it's cruel but I do think that children benefit from having siblings. I think having brothers and sisters teaches you sharing (both material things and peoples time), cooperation, conflict resolution, and more. It also just gives them another person close in age to play with and enjoy things with. There is NOTHING wrong at all with having one child but I do think that an only child may feel lonely at times. I spent SO many hours upon hours playing with my brother and sister growing up and it was great always having a playmate around and honestly, I'm sure it gave my mom a break too!! Chat Icon

Also, my parents have 3 siblings each and I just look at how now as adults what a benefit it is to have siblings. We celebrate holidays together, we have lots of cousins and aunts and uncles, they are all there for each other (especially when dealing with their own parents), etc. I want my DD to have people in her life as she gets older that she can lean on and rely on. KWIM?

Having multiple children is not for everyone and of course an only child can grow up happy and well adjusted just as a child with siblings but for me, I really want my DD to have a sibling(s) even if it means I have to split my time or maybe not take as many vacations or buy her as many toys. My DH and I really are excited to expand our family and I think it will be good for my DD. Chat Icon

Message edited 2010-05-25 08:30:10.203000.

Posted 5/25/10 8:27 AM
 

pinkandblue
Our family is complete, maybe

Member since 9/05

32436 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: ONLY CHILD ??

I would not say it is cruel but I would never want an only child....I loved having a sister to grow up with and I love watching my kids interact Chat Icon

Posted 5/25/10 8:32 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
Do you think it's ok for your child or any child to be allowed to stay on a school team (sports) if they are failing 2 classes? mitabtrfly 11/8/07 17 Parenting
How old would your child have to be to let them fly on an airplane alone? luvsun27 6/20/05 14 Families Helping Families ™
Anyone use there maiden name as a middle name for there child? NoStressMom 6/14/05 6 Pregnancy
for all of us who ever have a family memebr on a trip - child or adult, this is good to read... pschica 6/11/05 0 Families Helping Families ™
Could you adopt a child of below average intellect? DebG 5/27/05 20 Families Helping Families ™
security item what does or doesnt your child use? TAD 5/24/05 8 Parenting