Olympic Controversy

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

This is a game/sport. Not everyone wins every time. Do your best, finish on top and advance. Fair is fair, she was beat out by two of her own teamates! She should be celebrating their success while striving to achieve better next time. I understand she was ranked #4 overall but rules are rules. You win some, you lose some.

Posted 7/31/12 10:15 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

ALSO - weiber was only tenth's of a point from bumping teamate Aly Riseman out of the overall final!! Would we have been hearing about this if Weiber scored 1/10th higher on floor and Riseman was out of the final?

Posted 7/31/12 10:17 AM
 

BigB
C & J are 10!

Member since 6/05

5914 total posts

Name:
Stacey

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by maymama

ALSO - weiber was only tenth's of a point from bumping teamate Aly Riseman out of the overall final!! Would we have been hearing about this if Weiber scored 1/10th higher on floor and Riseman was out of the final?



No, because Riseman isn't the reigning World Champion.

Posted 7/31/12 10:23 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by BigB

Posted by maymama

ALSO - weiber was only tenth's of a point from bumping teamate Aly Riseman out of the overall final!! Would we have been hearing about this if Weiber scored 1/10th higher on floor and Riseman was out of the final?



No, because Riseman isn't the reigning World Champion.




bingo Chat Icon fair is fair!

Posted 7/31/12 10:25 AM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by BigB

Posted by maymama

ALSO - weiber was only tenth's of a point from bumping teamate Aly Riseman out of the overall final!! Would we have been hearing about this if Weiber scored 1/10th higher on floor and Riseman was out of the final?



No, because Riseman isn't the reigning World Champion.




But all that means is that Weiber *had* a great season. The Olympics are about what you can do right now. Michelle Kwan ( in figure skating) was a perfect example of that. She was a 5 time world champ but never won an Oylmpic gold medal. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

While kind of a bummer, I don't think it is a controversy, b/c the rule was followed correctly, but I am torn about whether I would prefer to see the absolute top 24 gymnasts or 24 of the best gymnasts from 12 or more countries.

Posted 7/31/12 10:32 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by tourist

Posted by BigB

Posted by maymama

ALSO - weiber was only tenth's of a point from bumping teamate Aly Riseman out of the overall final!! Would we have been hearing about this if Weiber scored 1/10th higher on floor and Riseman was out of the final?



No, because Riseman isn't the reigning World Champion.




But all that means is that Weiber *had* a great season. The Olympics are about what you can do right now. Michelle Kwan ( in figure skating) was a perfect example of that. She was a 5 time world champ but never won an Oylmpic gold medal. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

While kind of a bummer, I don't think it is a controversy, b/c the rule was followed correctly, but I am torn about whether I would prefer to see the absolute top 24 gymnasts or 24 of the best gymnasts from 12 or more countries.



entitlement at its best and this is what is wrong with the world. just because you are "world champion" one day doesnt mean you WILL win a medal the next.

Posted 7/31/12 10:34 AM
 

Blu-ize
Plan B is Now Plan A

Member since 7/05

32475 total posts

Name:
Susan

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by LeShellem

Posted by siren

The thing that really bothered me is not that she didn't make it, rules are rules - it's that they wouldn't let her go have her breakdown in peace and made her go to the press area.



I totally agree. I was watching her and telling DH how bad I feel for her. She couldn't even cry alone.



This was the worst. She wanted to run away and the gate keepers herded her to where they wanted her.

This is the culture for world class olympic athletes. You are pretty much owned and herded.

Posted 7/31/12 10:37 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by Blu-ize

Posted by LeShellem

Posted by siren

The thing that really bothered me is not that she didn't make it, rules are rules - it's that they wouldn't let her go have her breakdown in peace and made her go to the press area.



I totally agree. I was watching her and telling DH how bad I feel for her. She couldn't even cry alone.



This was the worst. She wanted to run away and the gate keepers herded her to where they wanted her.

This is the culture for world class olympic athletes. You are pretty much owned and herded.



i think it was more like they kept her from exiting through likely an unsupervised and unsecure exit. she had to follow her team. They DID give her time to calm down, did not interview her immediately.

Posted 7/31/12 10:38 AM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by maymama

Posted by tourist

Posted by BigB

Posted by maymama

ALSO - weiber was only tenth's of a point from bumping teamate Aly Riseman out of the overall final!! Would we have been hearing about this if Weiber scored 1/10th higher on floor and Riseman was out of the final?



No, because Riseman isn't the reigning World Champion.




But all that means is that Weiber *had* a great season. The Olympics are about what you can do right now. Michelle Kwan ( in figure skating) was a perfect example of that. She was a 5 time world champ but never won an Oylmpic gold medal. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

While kind of a bummer, I don't think it is a controversy, b/c the rule was followed correctly, but I am torn about whether I would prefer to see the absolute top 24 gymnasts or 24 of the best gymnasts from 12 or more countries.



entitlement at its best and this is what is wrong with the world. just because you are "world champion" one day doesnt mean you WILL win a medal the next.



I don't think she came off entitled, it's the press that is making this a thing. She is just a girl who is sad because she didn't get what she has been working for her whole life. That's not entitlemeent, it's just disappointment.

Same for Michelle Kwan. She was the most gracious competitor.

Posted 7/31/12 10:44 AM
 

mbg1007
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

1247 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

I just felt horrible for her, she's 17 and she couldnt even console herself in private. I think what make is so heartbreaking is the nature of gymnastics, by the time youre 18 youre over the hill and they arent allowed to compete in an olympics until they are 16 (whichwasnt implemented until 1997, Nadia was 14 when she scored her perfect ten). Most of these gymnasts only have one shot, unlike the other sports with lower age limits and a longer shelf life. Weiber is 17, so its extememtly unlikley that she will ever get the chance to go to another olympics and try again.

Posted 7/31/12 10:46 AM
 

JennP
LIF Adult

Member since 10/06

3986 total posts

Name:
Jenn

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by GoldenRod

Would Americans be so quick to repeal this rule if China happened to take all 24 spots themselves, and no other country was able to compete with them in the finals?



You have a valid point and a lot of people would probably be pissed.

However, I honestly think I would rather see that than this. I would take that as a sign that this is not our sport and we would need to improve our training practices as a nation if we wanted to bring our standing up. I realize this is easy to say since I'm not an elite athlete - that's my opinion as a layperson American.



Posted 7/31/12 11:21 AM
 

mbg1007
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

1247 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by JennP

Posted by GoldenRod

Would Americans be so quick to repeal this rule if China happened to take all 24 spots themselves, and no other country was able to compete with them in the finals?





But China cant take all 24 spots though bc there are only 5 girls per team so even if they took all 5 it woud still leave room for the very best athletes from all the other countries to compete, which is what the olympics should be and is supposed to be about, competing with the best. If America's gymnasts werent the best, then they shouldnt be competing with the best.




Message edited 2012-07-31 11:48:04.093000.

Posted 7/31/12 11:47 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by mbg1007

Posted by JennP

Posted by GoldenRod

Would Americans be so quick to repeal this rule if China happened to take all 24 spots themselves, and no other country was able to compete with them in the finals?




You have a valid point and a lot of people would probably be pissed.

However, I honestly think I would rather see that than this. I would take that as a sign that this is not our sport and we would need to improve our training practices as a nation if we wanted to bring our standing up. I realize this is easy to say since I'm not an elite athlete - that's my opinion as a layperson American.



But China cant take all 24 spots though bc there are only 5 girls per team so even if they took all 5 it woud still leave room for the very best athletes from all the other countries to compete, which is what the olympics should be and is supposed to be about, competing with the best. If America's gymnasts werent the best, then they shouldnt be competing with the best.





So, even without the rules, it's still theoretically not "the best in the world". If there are only 5 per team, but the truly top 24 in the world are all from China, then it's the same thing. It's just a matter of where the line in the sand is. It's either 5 per country, or 2 per country. Either way, it's not purely "the best 24".

Message edited 2012-07-31 12:03:09.773000.

Posted 7/31/12 12:02 PM
 

leesah85
LIF Infant

Member since 12/11

136 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by mzsocialworker1

I don't know. I guess this is part of the "excitement" of the Olympics for me.

Those that are considered "THE BEST" often don't make it to medal........and sometimes a newer athlete does, and especially someone the focus is not on.

While I am sure that most of these athletes don't feel this way, I think it's amazing that so many of them even make it as far as they do.

That alone is a huge accomplishment.

Look at the men yesterday. Weren't they originally considered definites and they ALL had horrible days and didn't qualify.




ITA with this.

this is the same for any sport for the most part (e.g. in baseball, just because a team has a great record - or even the best record - doesn't mean they win the world series if they lose 4 straight games)

similarly, in football, teams compete in different divisions therefore no two teams from the same division go to the superbowl

Posted 7/31/12 12:11 PM
 

Dulcinea
Weekend Warrior

Member since 3/08

2530 total posts

Name:
Dulcinea

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by mbg1007

I just felt horrible for her, she's 17 and she couldnt even console herself in private. I think what make is so heartbreaking is the nature of gymnastics, by the time youre 18 youre over the hill and they arent allowed to compete in an olympics until they are 16 (whichwasnt implemented until 1997, Nadia was 14 when she scored her perfect ten). Most of these gymnasts only have one shot, unlike the other sports with lower age limits and a longer shelf life. Weiber is 17, so its extememtly unlikley that she will ever get the chance to go to another olympics and try again.



ITA. That is true. Most of the best gymnasts are 16-18 yo. and are at their peak during that time so they really have only one shot for an Olympic medal. When you make it your goal in life to be an Olympic champion and can't even compete 'cus of some technicality like the 2 per country rule, it's devastating.

This rule reminds me of affirmative action and could be compared to inviting someone to a party but not letting them take part in it.

Besides, there is very little chance all 5 gymnasts from the same country would all medal in the all around final. Many gymnasts are only good at 1 or 2 of the apparatus, not all to make it through to the all around final.

The U.S. and many other countries are opposed to this rule when it was first implemented and I have a feeling this rule will change in the future to what it used to be - the 3 per country rule.



Message edited 2012-07-31 12:44:11.927000.

Posted 7/31/12 12:42 PM
 

blondiebabyZ
Ohhhh yeaaahh!!

Member since 6/10

1033 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by GoldenRod

Would Americans be so quick to repeal this rule if China happened to take all 24 spots themselves, and no other country was able to compete with them in the finals?



Exactly this...I think the rule is being fair. Its to give all countries a chance...because we all know if they didnt have the rule the olympics would end up just being 2-3 countries. And you know the US would dominate it. Maybe its just me but I dont think that's fair for something that is supposed to be a worldwide event.

Posted 7/31/12 1:18 PM
 

montimom
LIF Toddler

Member since 11/05

479 total posts

Name:
Misha

Re: Olympic Controversy

Does anyone know if the rule covers all sports or just gymnastics?

Posted 7/31/12 1:22 PM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by blondiebabyZ

Posted by GoldenRod

Would Americans be so quick to repeal this rule if China happened to take all 24 spots themselves, and no other country was able to compete with them in the finals?



Exactly this...I think the rule is being fair. Its to give all countries a chance...because we all know if they didnt have the rule the olympics would end up just being 2-3 countries. And you know the US would dominate it. Maybe its just me but I dont think that's fair for something that is supposed to be a worldwide event.



actually, no. in past, the US has not dominated women's gymnastics. Russia, Romania and China are ususally above the US.

Posted 7/31/12 1:30 PM
 

NorthCackalaky1013
LIF Infant

Member since 7/12

234 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by jerseypanda

Yes, it stinks for her, but like everyone else said, the rules are in place, she knew what they were and her teammates performed better than her.

It is just proof that with the 2 best performers from each country, you NEVER know who is going to take home gold. Whoever the #1 person is going into the finals, might just have a bad day and the person ranked last might have an amazing day and win. I think part of the Olympic games is being able to perform under pressure. Some will thrive because of it, others will fall and it makes it exciting that anyone has a chance to get gold!



Yes this exactly....it is a shame but now someone else, her teamate Aly Reisman (who no one ever thought could make the all around) has a chance to go for her dream.

Posted 7/31/12 1:51 PM
 

blondiebabyZ
Ohhhh yeaaahh!!

Member since 6/10

1033 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by maymama

Posted by blondiebabyZ

Posted by GoldenRod

Would Americans be so quick to repeal this rule if China happened to take all 24 spots themselves, and no other country was able to compete with them in the finals?



Exactly this...I think the rule is being fair. Its to give all countries a chance...because we all know if they didnt have the rule the olympics would end up just being 2-3 countries. And you know the US would dominate it. Maybe its just me but I dont think that's fair for something that is supposed to be a worldwide event.



actually, no. in past, the US has not dominated women's gymnastics. Russia, Romania and China are ususally above the US.



Actually, I am talking about US dominating sports in general. I mean I'd look at it as if what if those countries had taken up all 24 spots becuase they had the best of the best, I personally dont think that would be fair for the US? But thats just me.

Posted 7/31/12 2:08 PM
 

mbg1007
LIF Adult

Member since 3/09

1247 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by mbg1007

Posted by JennP

Posted by GoldenRod

Would Americans be so quick to repeal this rule if China happened to take all 24 spots themselves, and no other country was able to compete with them in the finals?




You have a valid point and a lot of people would probably be pissed.

However, I honestly think I would rather see that than this. I would take that as a sign that this is not our sport and we would need to improve our training practices as a nation if we wanted to bring our standing up. I realize this is easy to say since I'm not an elite athlete - that's my opinion as a layperson American.



But China cant take all 24 spots though bc there are only 5 girls per team so even if they took all 5 it woud still leave room for the very best athletes from all the other countries to compete, which is what the olympics should be and is supposed to be about, competing with the best. If America's gymnasts werent the best, then they shouldnt be competing with the best.





So, even without the rules, it's still theoretically not "the best in the world". If there are only 5 per team, but the truly top 24 in the world are all from China, then it's the same thing. It's just a matter of where the line in the sand is. It's either 5 per country, or 2 per country. Either way, it's not purely "the best 24".



How so? The 5 members of each team are the best of their countries. The all around should be the top 24 from those countries.

Posted 7/31/12 2:09 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by mbg1007

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by mbg1007

Posted by JennP

Posted by GoldenRod

Would Americans be so quick to repeal this rule if China happened to take all 24 spots themselves, and no other country was able to compete with them in the finals?




You have a valid point and a lot of people would probably be pissed.

However, I honestly think I would rather see that than this. I would take that as a sign that this is not our sport and we would need to improve our training practices as a nation if we wanted to bring our standing up. I realize this is easy to say since I'm not an elite athlete - that's my opinion as a layperson American.



But China cant take all 24 spots though bc there are only 5 girls per team so even if they took all 5 it woud still leave room for the very best athletes from all the other countries to compete, which is what the olympics should be and is supposed to be about, competing with the best. If America's gymnasts werent the best, then they shouldnt be competing with the best.





So, even without the rules, it's still theoretically not "the best in the world". If there are only 5 per team, but the truly top 24 in the world are all from China, then it's the same thing. It's just a matter of where the line in the sand is. It's either 5 per country, or 2 per country. Either way, it's not purely "the best 24".



How so? The 5 members of each team are the best of their countries. The all around should be the top 24 from those countries.



but, purely hypothetically, the 6th best person in the entire world may not be able to compete in the Olympics because they were cut off at their country's competition. Again, theoretically, the #1 American athlete may not be as good as the #6 Chinese athlete, but the American gets to compete, and not the #6 Chinese athlete.

It's still a cutoff number based on a maximum allowed per country. It's not the top 24 in the world, per-se. It usually works out that way, so nobody notices, but hypothetically, it could happen.

Posted 7/31/12 2:40 PM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by mbg1007

...

How so? The 5 members of each team are the best of their countries. The all around should be the top 24 from those countries.



Why is the top 5 from each country fair, but the top 2 from each country isn't fair?

Posted 7/31/12 2:41 PM
 

MrsT809
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

12167 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by mbg1007

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by mbg1007

Posted by JennP

Posted by GoldenRod

Would Americans be so quick to repeal this rule if China happened to take all 24 spots themselves, and no other country was able to compete with them in the finals?




You have a valid point and a lot of people would probably be pissed.

However, I honestly think I would rather see that than this. I would take that as a sign that this is not our sport and we would need to improve our training practices as a nation if we wanted to bring our standing up. I realize this is easy to say since I'm not an elite athlete - that's my opinion as a layperson American.



But China cant take all 24 spots though bc there are only 5 girls per team so even if they took all 5 it woud still leave room for the very best athletes from all the other countries to compete, which is what the olympics should be and is supposed to be about, competing with the best. If America's gymnasts werent the best, then they shouldnt be competing with the best.





So, even without the rules, it's still theoretically not "the best in the world". If there are only 5 per team, but the truly top 24 in the world are all from China, then it's the same thing. It's just a matter of where the line in the sand is. It's either 5 per country, or 2 per country. Either way, it's not purely "the best 24".



How so? The 5 members of each team are the best of their countries. The all around should be the top 24 from those countries.



but, purely hypothetically, the 6th best person in the entire world may not be able to compete in the Olympics because they were cut off at their country's competition. Again, theoretically, the #1 American athlete may not be as good as the #6 Chinese athlete, but the American gets to compete, and not the #6 Chinese athlete.

It's still a cutoff number based on a maximum allowed per country. It's not the top 24 in the world, per-se. It usually works out that way, so nobody notices, but hypothetically, it could happen.



Without the rule, there could never be more than 4 women from one country. Only 4 compete per event, so if the used the same 4 and didn't use their 5th teammate at all then theoretically those 4 could qualify for the all around. It would of course be ridiculous if all 24 could come from one country, but even in the very unlikely event that countries were using their best 4 in every event, then 6 countries would still be represented. That's not so bad.

I just think it's sad that they don't let at least 3 enter. If the US top 3 are the best in the world (not saying they actually are) then they each deserve a medal. I don't think it's right that if Jordan would be even the third best that she can't get the bronze medal.

Posted 7/31/12 2:50 PM
 

tourist

Member since 5/05

10425 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by Dulcinea

Besides, there is very little chance all 5 gymnasts from the same country would all medal in the all around final. Many gymnasts are only good at 1 or 2 of the apparatus, not all to make it through to the all around final.




It isn't common but it has happened--for women, just once in 1960 (Soviet Union. )In men's 1972 Japan took all 3 medals in all around, and in 1988 the Soviet Union did. It is interesting that this year several countries(US, Russian, Great Britain, China) had a 3rd person who would have qualified.

Message edited 2012-07-31 15:14:17.007000.

Posted 7/31/12 3:07 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
If you want someone specific to cheer for in the Olympic Games..... waterspout4 8/7/08 1 Families Helping Families ™
Breaking NewsThe International Olympic Committee has banned Iraq from next month's Olympics in Beijing. KPtoys 7/24/08 7 Families Helping Families ™
Can someone please tell DH that I am not an Olympic highjumper? jambalady 2/13/08 8 Pregnancy
Funny after fallout from the whole plastic bottle controversy..... Sassyz75 3/7/07 16 Parenting
Grey's Controversy. TR Knight and Isaiah Washington. june262004 1/16/07 0 Celebrities & Entertainment
Sort of Wedding related....does anyone remember the flower controversy? btrflygrl 7/28/06 2 Families Helping Families ™