Olympic Controversy

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 2 [3]

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by alli3131

It's not controversy. This rule has been in place for years and it's just now a problem cause a talented gymnast had a bad day..... It happens. They new the rules going in and her personal coach was telling her after every event that she was in danger of not making it.




Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/31/12 3:27 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Olympic Controversy

I feel badly for her b/c I know she must be heartbroken but this is LIFE. some days you win some, some days you lose some.

she was world champ but that does not mean she should automatically get in. maybe the US should only have fronted 2 athletes. why would it be better for some other athelte who worked just as hard to be heartbroken?

hopefully she will feel sufficiently inspired for tonight's team competition b/c she IS still good enough to win a gold medal if that is what she wants and works to earn.

Posted 7/31/12 4:14 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by Ophelia

I feel badly for her b/c I know she must be heartbroken but this is LIFE. some days you win some, some days you lose some.

she was world champ but that does not mean she should automatically get in. maybe the US should only have fronted 2 athletes. why would it be better for some other athelte who worked just as hard to be heartbroken?

hopefully she will feel sufficiently inspired for tonight's team competition b/c she IS still good enough to win a gold medal if that is what she wants and works to earn.




I know the answer to that but I won't spoil it for everyone.

But this is a good point. I feel badly for Jordyn but I would feel badly for Ally or Gabby (and do feel badly for the other 2 teammates and even for the teammate who scored higher than them at the trials but was not selected for the team).

In any case, there can only be one gold medal and I'll feel badly for any of the girls that don't get it.

Posted 7/31/12 4:24 PM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by Ophelia

I feel badly for her b/c I know she must be heartbroken but this is LIFE. some days you win some, some days you lose some.

she was world champ but that does not mean she should automatically get in. maybe the US should only have fronted 2 athletes. why would it be better for some other athelte who worked just as hard to be heartbroken?

hopefully she will feel sufficiently inspired for tonight's team competition b/c she IS still good enough to win a gold medal if that is what she wants and works to earn.




I know the answer to that but I won't spoil it for everyone.

But this is a good point. I feel badly for Jordyn but I would feel badly for Ally or Gabby (and do feel badly for the other 2 teammates and even for the teammate who scored higher than them at the trials but was not selected for the team).

In any case, there can only be one gold medal and I'll feel badly for any of the girls that don't get it.



you inspired me to look Chat Icon now I know too! Chat Icon

Posted 7/31/12 4:36 PM
 

Ophelia
she's baaccckkkk ;)

Member since 5/06

23378 total posts

Name:
remember, when Gulliver traveled....

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by maymama

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by Ophelia

I feel badly for her b/c I know she must be heartbroken but this is LIFE. some days you win some, some days you lose some.

she was world champ but that does not mean she should automatically get in. maybe the US should only have fronted 2 athletes. why would it be better for some other athelte who worked just as hard to be heartbroken?

hopefully she will feel sufficiently inspired for tonight's team competition b/c she IS still good enough to win a gold medal if that is what she wants and works to earn.




I know the answer to that but I won't spoil it for everyone.

But this is a good point. I feel badly for Jordyn but I would feel badly for Ally or Gabby (and do feel badly for the other 2 teammates and even for the teammate who scored higher than them at the trials but was not selected for the team).

In any case, there can only be one gold medal and I'll feel badly for any of the girls that don't get it.



you inspired me to look Chat Icon now I know too! Chat Icon



I HATE YOU BOTH Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

but I am NOT LOOKING

and don't you dare tell!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted 7/31/12 4:56 PM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by maymama

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by Ophelia

I feel badly for her b/c I know she must be heartbroken but this is LIFE. some days you win some, some days you lose some.

she was world champ but that does not mean she should automatically get in. maybe the US should only have fronted 2 athletes. why would it be better for some other athelte who worked just as hard to be heartbroken?

hopefully she will feel sufficiently inspired for tonight's team competition b/c she IS still good enough to win a gold medal if that is what she wants and works to earn.




I know the answer to that but I won't spoil it for everyone.

But this is a good point. I feel badly for Jordyn but I would feel badly for Ally or Gabby (and do feel badly for the other 2 teammates and even for the teammate who scored higher than them at the trials but was not selected for the team).

In any case, there can only be one gold medal and I'll feel badly for any of the girls that don't get it.



you inspired me to look Chat Icon now I know too! Chat Icon



I HATE YOU BOTH Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

but I am NOT LOOKING

and don't you dare tell!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



I didn't even realize I could look this up and now I hate you all because I lack self control. Chat Icon

Posted 7/31/12 5:31 PM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by eroxgirl

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by maymama

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by Ophelia

I feel badly for her b/c I know she must be heartbroken but this is LIFE. some days you win some, some days you lose some.

she was world champ but that does not mean she should automatically get in. maybe the US should only have fronted 2 athletes. why would it be better for some other athelte who worked just as hard to be heartbroken?

hopefully she will feel sufficiently inspired for tonight's team competition b/c she IS still good enough to win a gold medal if that is what she wants and works to earn.




I know the answer to that but I won't spoil it for everyone.

But this is a good point. I feel badly for Jordyn but I would feel badly for Ally or Gabby (and do feel badly for the other 2 teammates and even for the teammate who scored higher than them at the trials but was not selected for the team).

In any case, there can only be one gold medal and I'll feel badly for any of the girls that don't get it.



you inspired me to look Chat Icon now I know too! Chat Icon



I HATE YOU BOTH Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

but I am NOT LOOKING

and don't you dare tell!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



I didn't even realize I could look this up and now I hate you all because I lack self control. Chat Icon



and swimming .... mens swimming!!!!! Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/31/12 5:34 PM
 

lbelle821
Arghhhhh

Member since 2/06

5285 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by GoldenRod

Posted by mbg1007

...

How so? The 5 members of each team are the best of their countries. The all around should be the top 24 from those countries.



Why is the top 5 from each country fair, but the top 2 from each country isn't fair?



Because there are only 5 who can compete on the Olympic team. Meaning everyone is eligible and that is why op indicating that is more fair.

Posted 7/31/12 7:45 PM
 

lbelle821
Arghhhhh

Member since 2/06

5285 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by Ophelia

I feel badly for her b/c I know she must be heartbroken but this is LIFE. some days you win some, some days you lose some.

she was world champ but that does not mean she should automatically get in. maybe the US should only have fronted 2 athletes. why would it be better for some other athelte who worked just as hard to be heartbroken?

hopefully she will feel sufficiently inspired for tonight's team competition b/c she IS still good enough to win a gold medal if that is what she wants and works to earn.






Us can't just front 2 athletes...they need a team to compete. Which when you think about it isn't fair because let's say you have a terrific gymnast from a country where there is not enough talent to make a team they cannot compete in the all around or event finals because they can't even qualify without a

I don't like the rule. I think top 24 athletes should compete. Period. A rule is a rule though. She knew it going in. Doesn't mean it is right and doesn't mean people shouldn't feel bad for her.

Posted 7/31/12 7:51 PM
 

MM2004
...

Member since 5/05

1854 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

A similar situation happened at the 1992 Olympics with the "Unified team" (former Soviet Union). Tatiana Gutsu missed out on the all-around to another teammate due to a fall but the Unified Team coaches felt that she had the best chance to win the all-around gold. They forced her teammate Rozalia Galiyeva to give up her spot claiming a knee injury so Gutsu could compete. Gutsu ultimately won the gold, beating Shannon Miller by a small margin.

Posted 7/31/12 7:51 PM
 

SweetTooth
I'm a tired mommy!

Member since 12/05

20105 total posts

Name:
Lauren

Re: Olympic Controversy

It stinks, but I'm sure she will be fine.

Like others said the worst was when they made her go into the press area. They were interviewing Aly Reisman about how great she was while Jordyn was looking absolutely miserable right behind her. She may be an Olympic althlete, but she's also just a kid!

Posted 7/31/12 7:53 PM
 

CrankyPants
I'm cranky

Member since 7/06

18178 total posts

Name:
Mama Cranky

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by maymama

Posted by eroxgirl

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by maymama

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by Ophelia

I feel badly for her b/c I know she must be heartbroken but this is LIFE. some days you win some, some days you lose some.

she was world champ but that does not mean she should automatically get in. maybe the US should only have fronted 2 athletes. why would it be better for some other athelte who worked just as hard to be heartbroken?

hopefully she will feel sufficiently inspired for tonight's team competition b/c she IS still good enough to win a gold medal if that is what she wants and works to earn.




I know the answer to that but I won't spoil it for everyone.

But this is a good point. I feel badly for Jordyn but I would feel badly for Ally or Gabby (and do feel badly for the other 2 teammates and even for the teammate who scored higher than them at the trials but was not selected for the team).

In any case, there can only be one gold medal and I'll feel badly for any of the girls that don't get it.



you inspired me to look Chat Icon now I know too! Chat Icon



I HATE YOU BOTH Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

but I am NOT LOOKING

and don't you dare tell!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



I didn't even realize I could look this up and now I hate you all because I lack self control. Chat Icon



and swimming .... mens swimming!!!!! Chat Icon Chat Icon



I'm sorry! I accidentally found out when I clicked on a link to read an article supposedly about something else!

Posted 7/31/12 10:12 PM
 

smdl
I love Gary too..on a plate!

Member since 5/06

32461 total posts

Name:
me

Re: Olympic Controversy

You can't have your cake and eat it too.

The rule was set up because Countries were complaining that Russia and Romania were so dominant that nobody really had a chance.

So now that they had the potential to dominate this time around, the US complained about the same rule that could have guaranteed them a spot for a chance to even be in the competition in previous Olympics.

Posted 8/1/12 9:06 AM
 

eroxgirl
My Loves

Member since 5/05

15697 total posts

Name:
Rebecca

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by maymama

Posted by eroxgirl

Posted by Ophelia

Posted by maymama

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by Ophelia

I feel badly for her b/c I know she must be heartbroken but this is LIFE. some days you win some, some days you lose some.

she was world champ but that does not mean she should automatically get in. maybe the US should only have fronted 2 athletes. why would it be better for some other athelte who worked just as hard to be heartbroken?

hopefully she will feel sufficiently inspired for tonight's team competition b/c she IS still good enough to win a gold medal if that is what she wants and works to earn.




I know the answer to that but I won't spoil it for everyone.

But this is a good point. I feel badly for Jordyn but I would feel badly for Ally or Gabby (and do feel badly for the other 2 teammates and even for the teammate who scored higher than them at the trials but was not selected for the team).

In any case, there can only be one gold medal and I'll feel badly for any of the girls that don't get it.



you inspired me to look Chat Icon now I know too! Chat Icon



I HATE YOU BOTH Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

but I am NOT LOOKING

and don't you dare tell!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



I didn't even realize I could look this up and now I hate you all because I lack self control. Chat Icon



and swimming .... mens swimming!!!!! Chat Icon Chat Icon



I'm sorry! I accidentally found out when I clicked on a link to read an article supposedly about something else!



I was just teasing! I made a point to watch it, in part because I knew the end result so thank you! Chat Icon

And I didn't look up men's swimming so that part was still a surprise. Chat Icon

Posted 8/1/12 10:06 AM
 

DancinBarefoot
06ers Rock!!

Member since 1/07

9537 total posts

Name:
The One My Mother Gave Me ;-)

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by lbelle821
Us can't just front 2 athletes...they need a team to compete. Which when you think about it isn't fair because let's say you have a terrific gymnast from a country where there is not enough talent to make a team they cannot compete in the all around or event finals because they can't even qualify without a




This is completely NOT true. There are gymnasts who compete in the qualifying round to get one of those 24 spots that come from contries without enough athletes to front an entire team. Ana Sofia Gomez Porras from Guatemala will be competing, as will Jessica Lopes from Venezula, Celine van Gemer from Netherlands, Giulia Steingruber from Switzerland, and Marta Pihan-Kulesza from Poland. There were an additional 25 athletes in womens's gymnastics who performed during the qualifying round who didn't get one of those coveted 24 spots.

Posted 8/1/12 10:49 AM
 

nel
LIF Adult

Member since 5/06

1173 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by CrankyPants

Posted by maymama

Posted by tourist

Posted by BigB

Posted by maymama

ALSO - weiber was only tenth's of a point from bumping teamate Aly Riseman out of the overall final!! Would we have been hearing about this if Weiber scored 1/10th higher on floor and Riseman was out of the final?



No, because Riseman isn't the reigning World Champion.




But all that means is that Weiber *had* a great season. The Olympics are about what you can do right now. Michelle Kwan ( in figure skating) was a perfect example of that. She was a 5 time world champ but never won an Oylmpic gold medal. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

While kind of a bummer, I don't think it is a controversy, b/c the rule was followed correctly, but I am torn about whether I would prefer to see the absolute top 24 gymnasts or 24 of the best gymnasts from 12 or more countries.



entitlement at its best and this is what is wrong with the world. just because you are "world champion" one day doesnt mean you WILL win a medal the next.



I don't think she came off entitled, it's the press that is making this a thing. She is just a girl who is sad because she didn't get what she has been working for her whole life. That's not entitlemeent, it's just disappointment.

Same for Michelle Kwan. She was the most gracious competitor.



Chat Icon Agreed 1000%

Posted 8/1/12 11:08 AM
 

kahlua716
3 Girls for Me!

Member since 8/07

12475 total posts

Name:
Keri

Re: Olympic Controversy

Can she compete and win medals in each event separately, or do those 4 events only go towards the all around? Chat Icon

Message edited 2012-08-01 13:45:06.153000.

Posted 8/1/12 1:44 PM
 

My2Girlz11
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

785 total posts

Name:
Corrie

Re: Olympic Controversy

This isn't really a controversy. My opinion is that the rule sucks and they need to put the top overall scores to compete in the all around competition. But that is my opinion. As an athlete, I would want to be against the best. It would push me to do my best. The only thing that might be a controversy is that they were saying that she was under scored. She had a small wobble on the beam, but stepped out on floor. I forgot the coaches name, but he said they took away too many deductions. I think she missed getting in by .2.

I watched the interview and was crying. My heart broke for her. She is just a kid that had the biggest disappointment in her life and now there is a camera in her face. She was trying so hard to smile for her teammates. She stayed strong throughout it all.

I just want to add that I also don't like seeing the disappointment on the other athletes faces also (from other countries). Many can't imagine how much time they put into this. It is their whole lives.

Posted 8/1/12 2:05 PM
 

My2Girlz11
LIF Adolescent

Member since 1/11

785 total posts

Name:
Corrie

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by kahlua716

Can she compete and win medals in each event separately, or do those 4 events only go towards the all around? Chat Icon




Someone can correct me if I am wrong. I think the best two from each team compete against each other. Then another day the top scores on each event compete. So, if she had a top score from that first qualifying day, she can compete in an individual event.

Posted 8/1/12 2:08 PM
 

brownie
Baby #1 is here!

Member since 11/08

13903 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by blondiebabyZ

Posted by GoldenRod

Would Americans be so quick to repeal this rule if China happened to take all 24 spots themselves, and no other country was able to compete with them in the finals?



Exactly this...I think the rule is being fair. Its to give all countries a chance...because we all know if they didnt have the rule the olympics would end up just being 2-3 countries. And you know the US would dominate it. Maybe its just me but I dont think that's fair for something that is supposed to be a worldwide event.



Exactly...not all countries have the $$$ for training many athletes to Olympic level. This brings them to a level playing field. If Weiber did good enough that day, she would have been top 2 from the USA

Posted 8/1/12 2:29 PM
 

lbelle821
Arghhhhh

Member since 2/06

5285 total posts

Name:
Lisa

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by DancinBarefoot

Posted by lbelle821
Us can't just front 2 athletes...they need a team to compete. Which when you think about it isn't fair because let's say you have a terrific gymnast from a country where there is not enough talent to make a team they cannot compete in the all around or event finals because they can't even qualify without a




This is completely NOT true. There are gymnasts who compete in the qualifying round to get one of those 24 spots that come from contries without enough athletes to front an entire team. Ana Sofia Gomez Porras from Guatemala will be competing, as will Jessica Lopes from Venezula, Celine van Gemer from Netherlands, Giulia Steingruber from Switzerland, and Marta Pihan-Kulesza from Poland. There were an additional 25 athletes in womens's gymnastics who performed during the qualifying round who didn't get one of those coveted 24 spots.



Sorry, you're right. I misinterpreted what I was reading. It was specifically talking about mckayla marony and how if she wasn't on the team she would lose out on ability to compete in vault finals or something like that.

Posted 8/1/12 2:36 PM
 
Pages: 1 2 [3]
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
If you want someone specific to cheer for in the Olympic Games..... waterspout4 8/7/08 1 Families Helping Families ™
Breaking NewsThe International Olympic Committee has banned Iraq from next month's Olympics in Beijing. KPtoys 7/24/08 7 Families Helping Families ™
Can someone please tell DH that I am not an Olympic highjumper? jambalady 2/13/08 8 Pregnancy
Funny after fallout from the whole plastic bottle controversy..... Sassyz75 3/7/07 16 Parenting
Grey's Controversy. TR Knight and Isaiah Washington. june262004 1/16/07 0 Celebrities & Entertainment
Sort of Wedding related....does anyone remember the flower controversy? btrflygrl 7/28/06 2 Families Helping Families ™