Olympic Controversy

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

Dulcinea
Weekend Warrior

Member since 3/08

2530 total posts

Name:
Dulcinea

Olympic Controversy

Anyone here watched women's gymnastic and heard the unfortunate news that Jordyn Wieber, the reigning World Champion in gymnastic, is not allowed to compete in the Olympic All Around final?

Apparently, there is a rule that was implemented back in 2004 whereby only the top 2 gymnastic from each country can move on to compete in the all around final. How can it be called a final if some of the best gymnasts in the world are not allowed to compete? Jordyn Wieber was 4th best at the trials but scored behind her 2 other compatriots. She wasn't the only one affected by this rule, at least 5 other gymnasts that I know of are also affected.

I can't believe the absurdity of the rule and how it's robbing Jordyn Wieber and other top gymnasts who trained their whole life for this event to medal .... If you too find this unfair, please sign the petition.

Petition to remove 2 per country gymnastic rule.

Posted 7/31/12 12:16 AM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

BigB
C & J are 10!

Member since 6/05

5914 total posts

Name:
Stacey

Re: Olympic Controversy

It was set up this way so that the top 12 countries are represented.....trying to level the playing field!

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 7/31/12 12:18 AM
 

nrthshgrl
It goes fast. Pay attention.

Member since 7/05

57538 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

I don't really see the controversy. I'm assuming it's because the IOC wants representation from each country so they made a 2 gymnast per country rule. They implemented a rule 8 years ago. She knew the rules when she signed up to compete. She had to finish in the top 2 to move on.

I don't see it as robbing her of a medal. She didn't qualify.

Posted 7/31/12 5:51 AM
 

sasha96
lovin' my 2 little ladies!

Member since 5/05

7401 total posts

Name:
Julianne

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by nrthshgrl

I don't really see the controversy. I'm assuming it's because the IOC wants representation from each country so they made a 2 gymnast per country rule. They implemented a rule 8 years ago. She knew the rules when she signed up to compete. She had to finish in the top 2 to move on.

I don't see it as robbing her of a medal. She didn't qualify.



While I agree with this, the Olympics should be about showcasing the world's best. If that means 3, 4, or even all 5 of one country's gymnasts score highest in qualifiers, then then should go to compete for medals.

Posted 7/31/12 6:52 AM
 

ItsTime2011
Meh...

Member since 1/11

2148 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

I guess I don't get the controversy. If she was the world champion she would have qualified. She had an off day and her teammates pushed her out. It happens. Now she will just have to work harder to take home the team gold.

Posted 7/31/12 7:08 AM
 

GoldenRod
10 years on LIF!

Member since 11/06

26792 total posts

Name:
Shawn

Re: Olympic Controversy

Would Americans be so quick to repeal this rule if China happened to take all 24 spots themselves, and no other country was able to compete with them in the finals?

Posted 7/31/12 7:10 AM
 

alli3131
Peanut is here!!!!!!

Member since 5/09

18388 total posts

Name:
Allison

Olympic Controversy

It's not controversy. This rule has been in place for years and it's just now a problem cause a talented gymnast had a bad day..... It happens. They new the rules going in and her personal coach was telling her after every event that she was in danger of not making it.

Posted 7/31/12 7:11 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Olympic Controversy

I don't know. I guess this is part of the "excitement" of the Olympics for me.

Those that are considered "THE BEST" often don't make it to medal........and sometimes a newer athlete does, and especially someone the focus is not on.

While I am sure that most of these athletes don't feel this way, I think it's amazing that so many of them even make it as far as they do.

That alone is a huge accomplishment.

Look at the men yesterday. Weren't they originally considered definites and they ALL had horrible days and didn't qualify.

Message edited 2012-07-31 07:42:22.393000.

Posted 7/31/12 7:41 AM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

I watched. She wasn't as good as her crew. Plain and simple. She slipped in beam, and wasn't 100%. She knew the rules going in. The two best got it. It sucks, but it is what it is. No controversy.

Posted 7/31/12 7:44 AM
 

MorningCuppaCoffee
Tired!

Member since 12/07

16353 total posts

Name:
Allison

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by JennZ

I watched. She wasn't as good as her crew. Plain and simple. She slipped in beam, and wasn't 100%. She knew the rules going in. The two best got it. It sucks, but it is what it is. No controversy.



Yep. I also am sure that when you have it drilled in your head that you are the best in the world, and that the whole world is watching and expecting you to do even better, it fuks with you mentally and will cause you to screw up.

They kept saying that about several of the women gymnasts the other night.....they really have a tough time handling the pressure. When they are good, they are really really good, but when they have an off day, it's really not good.

There's so much going on in that room too. I guess I never noticed it much before, but there are other people competing at the same time.

That must be so distracting.

Posted 7/31/12 7:50 AM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

And would be such a controversy if she made it and another didn't?

Posted 7/31/12 7:52 AM
 

2boys1girl4me
LIF Infant

Member since 5/12

321 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by JennZ

I watched. She wasn't as good as her crew. Plain and simple. She slipped in beam, and wasn't 100%. She knew the rules going in. The two best got it. It sucks, but it is what it is. No controversy.



As much as sux for her, ITA agree with this

Posted 7/31/12 7:55 AM
 

PearlJamChick
No one sings like you anymore.

Member since 7/10

9264 total posts

Name:
Petticoated Swashbuckler

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by 2boys1girl4me

Posted by JennZ

I watched. She wasn't as good as her crew. Plain and simple. She slipped in beam, and wasn't 100%. She knew the rules going in. The two best got it. It sucks, but it is what it is. No controversy.



As much as sux for her, ITA agree with this



I watched as well, and I agree...the rules were changed years ago and everyone knew of this. She wasn't as good as the two on her team who qualified. Hopefully she can bring it together for the team competition.

Posted 7/31/12 8:13 AM
 

sarahbelle
Little drummer boy

Member since 5/05

2377 total posts

Name:
Sarah

Olympic Controversy

The rule is odd. I'd rather see the top athletes compete, even if that means only a few nations are represented.

Posted 7/31/12 8:27 AM
 

Teachergal
We made a snowman!

Member since 1/08

3239 total posts

Name:

Olympic Controversy

The rule is ridiculous. The best of the best should be there. And if I were an athlete I'd want to be competing against the best, not just the best 12 teams. That means a #1 after preliminary could be competing against, say #35, simply because multiple athletes from multiple teams scored in the top 24. That is silly!

Posted 7/31/12 8:32 AM
 

CAMCaps
Live Laugh Love Run

Member since 6/07

4922 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

It sucks and I understand her sentiment. Someone ranked 25th gets to go and she has to sit on the sidelines. I also understand the Olympics sentiment wanting to represent more countries.

It would bother me, but I would not expect them to change the rules for me. Perhaps in the future, the rules could be rewritten, but for this year it is too late.

Message edited 2012-07-31 08:34:52.217000.

Posted 7/31/12 8:32 AM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: Olympic Controversy

No controversy. Just people mad that their pick didn't make it. Yes she's the fourth best, but only the top two in each country makes it.

If it was truly controversial it should had been made a big deal prior to the start of the Olympics.

Posted 7/31/12 8:43 AM
 

bpmom
Feeling Blessed

Member since 6/07

2963 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by GoldenRod

Would Americans be so quick to repeal this rule if China happened to take all 24 spots themselves, and no other country was able to compete with them in the finals?



Well said. It was sad to watch Weiber get passed by her own teammates, but this is a rule the IOC made. Maybe if the American team wanted to guarantee Weiber a spot, they should've only sent Weiber + 1 other US gymnast to the overall semi's??

Posted 7/31/12 8:54 AM
 

tara73
carseat nerd

Member since 11/09

3669 total posts

Name:
Buttercup

Olympic Controversy

I'd rather see them bring back compulsories over this issue. This would be a non issue right now if we were discussing a Chinese or Russian gymnast who was considered the best and didn't qualify.

You don't get an automatic pass through because you're world champion. Fact remains, her teammates outperformed her.

Posted 7/31/12 8:58 AM
 

siren
LIF Infant

Member since 8/07

219 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

The thing that really bothered me is not that she didn't make it, rules are rules - it's that they wouldn't let her go have her breakdown in peace and made her go to the press area.

In general I think it's kind of awful that the press is going up to atheletes that didn't meet expectations and asking them why. Off day or whatever, isn't it enough that these people are disappointed in themselves? Do they have to answer the stupid "what happened" questions? I mean what else are they going to say that's not obvious?

Posted 7/31/12 9:22 AM
 

jerseypanda
Life is good.

Member since 1/07

9164 total posts

Name:
Amanda

Re: Olympic Controversy

Yes, it stinks for her, but like everyone else said, the rules are in place, she knew what they were and her teammates performed better than her.

It is just proof that with the 2 best performers from each country, you NEVER know who is going to take home gold. Whoever the #1 person is going into the finals, might just have a bad day and the person ranked last might have an amazing day and win. I think part of the Olympic games is being able to perform under pressure. Some will thrive because of it, others will fall and it makes it exciting that anyone has a chance to get gold!

Posted 7/31/12 9:25 AM
 

LeShellem
A new beginning

Member since 2/07

3600 total posts

Name:
LeShelle

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by siren

The thing that really bothered me is not that she didn't make it, rules are rules - it's that they wouldn't let her go have her breakdown in peace and made her go to the press area.



I totally agree. I was watching her and telling DH how bad I feel for her. She couldn't even cry alone.

Posted 7/31/12 10:00 AM
 

mamabear
LIF Adult

Member since 3/08

4539 total posts

Name:

Olympic Controversy

I don't think it's a controversy, but I also don't think it is a great rule. Each country is limited to how many people it can have on a team in the first place. From there, they qualify for team finals. For the all around, I think it really should be individual based from that point forward. Team medals are per country, individual medals should be for the top gymnasts (which is already limited by how many members you can have on a team). I don't think every country needs to be represented in the all around finals for individuals. And the country with the best gymnasts varies year to year.

So, I think it is a bad rule, but it's still the rule that was in place for awhile now, so I don't think it's a controversy. It's not like they announced it after the fact.

Posted 7/31/12 10:12 AM
 

maymama
my little loves

Member since 8/08

18453 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

Posted by bdmom

Posted by GoldenRod

Would Americans be so quick to repeal this rule if China happened to take all 24 spots themselves, and no other country was able to compete with them in the finals?



Well said. It was sad to watch Weiber get passed by her own teammates, but this is a rule the IOC made. Maybe if the American team wanted to guarantee Weiber a spot, they should've only sent Weiber + 1 other US gymnast to the overall semi's??



that isnt how you qualify. you qualify for the individual all around by the individual's overall scores in the team all around.

Message edited 2012-07-31 10:15:57.820000.

Posted 7/31/12 10:13 AM
 

Leb
LIF Adult

Member since 12/09

4166 total posts

Name:

Re: Olympic Controversy

I heard it was the US that were the ones who pushed for this rule to begin with. She was aware going into that only 2 could be all around.

Posted 7/31/12 10:13 AM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
If you want someone specific to cheer for in the Olympic Games..... waterspout4 8/7/08 1 Families Helping Families ™
Breaking NewsThe International Olympic Committee has banned Iraq from next month's Olympics in Beijing. KPtoys 7/24/08 7 Families Helping Families ™
Can someone please tell DH that I am not an Olympic highjumper? jambalady 2/13/08 8 Pregnancy
Funny after fallout from the whole plastic bottle controversy..... Sassyz75 3/7/07 16 Parenting
Grey's Controversy. TR Knight and Isaiah Washington. june262004 1/16/07 0 Celebrities & Entertainment
Sort of Wedding related....does anyone remember the flower controversy? btrflygrl 7/28/06 2 Families Helping Families ™