Re: Olympic Controversy
Posted 7/31/2012 2:50:04 PM by MrsT809
Posted by GoldenRod
Posted by mbg1007
Posted by GoldenRod
Posted by mbg1007
Posted by JennP
Posted by GoldenRod
Would Americans be so quick to repeal this rule if China happened to take all 24 spots themselves, and no other country was able to compete with them in the finals?
You have a valid point and a lot of people would probably be pissed.
However, I honestly think I would rather see that than this. I would take that as a sign that this is not our sport and we would need to improve our training practices as a nation if we wanted to bring our standing up. I realize this is easy to say since I'm not an elite athlete - that's my opinion as a layperson American.
But China cant take all 24 spots though bc there are only 5 girls per team so even if they took all 5 it woud still leave room for the very best athletes from all the other countries to compete, which is what the olympics should be and is supposed to be about, competing with the best. If America's gymnasts werent the best, then they shouldnt be competing with the best.
So, even without the rules, it's still theoretically not "the best in the world". If there are only 5 per team, but the truly top 24 in the world are all from China, then it's the same thing. It's just a matter of where the line in the sand is. It's either 5 per country, or 2 per country. Either way, it's not purely "the best 24".
How so? The 5 members of each team are the best of their countries. The all around should be the top 24 from those countries.
but, purely hypothetically, the 6th best person in the entire world may not be able to compete in the Olympics because they were cut off at their country's competition. Again, theoretically, the #1 American athlete may not be as good as the #6 Chinese athlete, but the American gets to compete, and not the #6 Chinese athlete.
It's still a cutoff number based on a maximum allowed per country. It's not the top 24 in the world, per-se. It usually works out that way, so nobody notices, but hypothetically, it could happen.
Without the rule, there could never be more than 4 women from one country. Only 4 compete per event, so if the used the same 4 and didn't use their 5th teammate at all then theoretically those 4 could qualify for the all around. It would of course be ridiculous if all 24 could come from one country, but even in the very unlikely event that countries were using their best 4 in every event, then 6 countries would still be represented. That's not so bad.
I just think it's sad that they don't let at least 3 enter. If the US top 3 are the best in the world (not saying they actually are) then they each deserve a medal. I don't think it's right that if Jordan would be even the third best that she can't get the bronze medal.
|