Re: No indictment for nypd chokehold cop
Posted 12/4/2014 2:23:00 PM by kahlua716


Posted by LeeCR7


Posted by cowgirlkate

If you are not a law enforcement officer, and you have never tried to arrest an extremely large man who is resisting, I don't think you get to give your two cents on how they should have done it.



As with all authority figures, it is our right and our responsibility to make that judgment. If we could only have an opinion about things we are intimately familar with, most of us couldn't comment on much of anything.

My sister is NYPD. Before that, she worked for another law enforcement agency in a different part of NY (being vague on purpose here). She will be the first to tell you that most of her fellow officers are the best people she has met. It is like having a war buddy, almost, after they finish training.

But, as with everything, there is a dark side. There were many, many people she trained with who spouted racist garbage and misinformed nonsense. There were quite a few who joined the force so they could use force: they were looking for it, anticipating it. And police officers know they are unlikely to be punished legally. They are more worried about doing something that loses them their job. This is the minority, of course, but they exist.

My point is that police officers are humans, representing both the best and worst of humanity, who are given a little more power than the rest of us, and, fairly, given a little more leeway. What they are not given is absolute power and no accountability. Most of them don't even want that. To say we can't judge because we are not police officers is simplistic and, frankly, dangerous. Who, then, can judge them? Our whole system of justice is based on the fact that we are judged by our peers. That system resulted in no indictment. Whether fairly or not, I can't make a judgement without the transcripts.

With both of these cases I have been shocked at the assertion that we shouldn't question anything police officers do, ever, for any reason. America is not a police state, and we, as citizens, have the right to respectfully question them.



This is the best comment I have read on the thread so far.
Print Post      Close Window