No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted By Message
Pages: 1 [2] 3

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by MrsH2009

I think most know breast is best, but some people can't or choose not to breast fed. Often that is a very emotional and hard decision to make. BUT, I think the lactation consultant is trying to help people that are unsure or uninformed, not those who can't breast feed, or know they don't want to. I have no source to the validity of this, but Stony Brook told us LI had one of the lowest breast feeding rates in the area, and the hospitals are concerned as to why, and are trying to change it.



Probably because to live on LI you need a double income and working FT makes it a lot harder.

Posted 12/15/11 9:03 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

MrsNicolaxoxo
<3

Member since 6/09

3403 total posts

Name:
Jennifer

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

I am a firm believer in this new recommendation  I  would have followed  this if I didn't have to start a medication at 2yrs when i did wean. I also think it is fine to encourage breastfeeding even if a mom does want to go the formula route.  I know plenty of moms that were dead set against bfing and who were encouraged to try it by nurses and lactation consultants in the hospital and ended up successfully nursing.  If formula was given to their babies without pushing nursing they may have never nursed.  Breast is one  of the best things a mother can do for their baby and their is no denying that.   Is you boss being extreme...yes!  Formula is an option and may be the ONLY option in certain circumstances therefore your boss should be sensitive to this and provide support for all moms whether it be for exclusively breasting moms, moms that supplement or moms that formula feed only.    

Posted 12/15/11 9:04 PM
 

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Thanks ladies! You have all said exactly what I expected. Bottom line...it is a choice.

Posted 12/15/11 9:17 PM
 

PeasandCarrots
&hearts;

Member since 5/07

9579 total posts

Name:
L

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Like a pp said I am happy there is so muc "Breast is Best" campaigning going on, but I also think they are on a fine line of educating and being rude. I think most women know breast milk is "best" but to keep hearing about it or to feel pressure can make a women who tried or is trying and not doing well feel horrible. I think it's just to pushy. What I would like to see is more public education.....like why is seeing a Victoria's Secret lingerie show ok but me feeding my child in public not? Why is one gross and one is hot? That's my issue. I also wish that instead of giving people access to things like formula through WIC they made you do a consult with a LC. I'm not saying don't give a child food, but I think it would help weed out people who really need the public assistance and those who just look at it like free money. I know a few people that have WIC and when they asked what formula Saw was on I said none I am bfing. They said they never wanted to since there boobs would sag and they get free formula anyway so why bother trying. I'm not against just going to formula, but to say it's because your boobs will sag and it's freeChat Icon

Posted 12/15/11 9:34 PM
 

Champ
2 little ladies

Member since 1/11

2918 total posts

Name:
Rose

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by schmora15

I agree that no one should tell you what or how to feed your LO, but I'm happy that they won't be shoving formula at you in the hospital. DD was full term and had to be put in NICU because I had a temp post cs. I was soooo upset that they gave her formula. I made it very clear I was BFing and no formula was to be given. It was a big headache and I had to wean her off formula after being in NICU for a week. They gave me a ridiculous amount of formula and minimal bfing support.



I'm glad to say I had the complete opposite experience. They pushed bfing when my girls were in the nicu

Posted 12/15/11 10:15 PM
 

ISpoilHim
I think I got this

Member since 11/10

1523 total posts

Name:
K

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Prior to giving birth I was on the fence about bf'ing. My son was born at 29 weeks and I did not see him until almost 24 hours later because he was transferred after birth to another hospital. When we got to Stony Brook I was lectured on the importance of pumping and so I tried. I pumped every 2 hours. My son was too small to attempt bf'ing. Pumping all day I still did not produce enough for even 1 full feeding. I did this for the 7 wks he was in the nicu. Once he came home between attempting to bf and still having to bottle feed and pumping that was all I was doing. A week after he came home I was exhausted and stopped pumping and bf'ing. It was a hard decision. I felt like a total failure because I just never had a milk supply and all I ever heard was breast milk is best. It was hard on me. I think every woman should be educated about both but told that either is fine. Unfortunately bf'ing just doesn't work for everyone. Even now 3 months later people ask if I bf and I feel compelled to explain the entire story and why I stopped.

Posted 12/16/11 9:13 AM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

If anyone told me how to feed my child I'd punch them in the face. Straight up.
I'd also tell them to FLUCK off.

I really am starting to get fed up with everyone thinking they can tell us what to do in terms of our personal decisions- be it banning toys in Happy Meals, trying to force BFing, etc.
This country is moving more and more away from a democracy with freedom of CHOICE and it scares me.
Whatever happened to it being a free country??

And if they think not giving out free formula samples in the hospital will change anyone's mind- well to me that is ridiculous.
Even if the hospital I delivered at refused to give me formula for the 3 days I was there, I would have had DH go out to Target and bring me some.
These silly little moves to shove BFing down our throats really are ridiculous.
Chat Icon I'm not a child- you can't trick me into it.

I also feel like some of these breast feeding Nazi lactation consultants are a bit off the deep end and almost cultish.
They need to get a grip and stay out of other women's bras.

And I never ONCE felt my hospital shoved formula at me, or on the flip side, tried to shove BFing down my throat.
Maybe it was just my hospital, but they were fine with whatever choice I made ,didn't say word ONE about it- and that was it.
Right after she was born, the nurse said, are you going to be BFing. I said No. She wrote it on the chart and moved on.
Maybe that is why I'd go back there again if I ever had to deliver again.


Message edited 2011-12-16 09:33:47.060000.

Posted 12/16/11 9:31 AM
 

Bella01
LIF Adult

Member since 5/11

3708 total posts

Name:
Mama

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by NervousNell

Maybe it was just my hospital, but they were fine with whatever choice I made ,didn't say word ONE about it- and that was it.
Right after she was born, the nurse said, are you going to be BFing. I said No. She wrote it on the chart and moved on.
Maybe that is why I'd go back there again if I ever had to deliver again.





My hospital was the same way. I agree.

Posted 12/16/11 9:44 AM
 

computergirl
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3118 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

While I don't think anyone disputes that breast is indeed best, I don't think we need to somehow draw the conclusion that formula is some sort of poison. That's what always confused me-- when formula is treated like a toxic substance to be avoided at all costs. Even though I CHOSE not to breastfeed my second child, I still acknowledge that breast is best. That doesn't mean that formula is "bad" though. I would describe it more like saying-- 5 servings of vegetables a day is the ideal to strive for, but 3 or 4 is pretty decent too, kwim?

Posted 12/16/11 10:04 AM
 

Jonsgirl04
Love my two girls! xoxo

Member since 9/08

6079 total posts

Name:
Stephanie

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by NervousNell

If anyone told me how to feed my child I'd punch them in the face. Straight up.
I'd also tell them to FLUCK off.

I really am starting to get fed up with everyone thinking they can tell us what to do in terms of our personal decisions- be it banning toys in Happy Meals, trying to force BFing, etc.
This country is moving more and more away from a democracy with freedom of CHOICE and it scares me.
Whatever happened to it being a free country??

And if they think not giving out free formula samples in the hospital will change anyone's mind- well to me that is ridiculous.
Even if the hospital I delivered at refused to give me formula for the 3 days I was there, I would have had DH go out to Target and bring me some.
These silly little moves to shove BFing down our throats really are ridiculous.
Chat Icon I'm not a child- you can't trick me into it.

I also feel like some of these breast feeding Nazi lactation consultants are a bit off the deep end and almost cultish.
They need to get a grip and stay out of other women's bras.

And I never ONCE felt my hospital shoved formula at me, or on the flip side, tried to shove BFing down my throat.
Maybe it was just my hospital, but they were fine with whatever choice I made ,didn't say word ONE about it- and that was it.
Right after she was born, the nurse said, are you going to be BFing. I said No. She wrote it on the chart and moved on.
Maybe that is why I'd go back there again if I ever had to deliver again.







Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

AMEN SISTA!

I couldnt breast feed in the hospital I was very sick needed blood transfusions, very high BP, wound up in the hospital for a week. I did try after the LC made me feel like a piece of crap for not trying. She then insulted me. She then nastily asked if my nipples would come out anymore. I said NO..what you see is all I have!! she goes well then thats not gonna work if you have flat nipples says OH Well and left me there as I am trying to latch my poor DD. She wound up leaving and I told my DH I couldnt do it and cried for an hour! I will never make anyone make me feel like that again. No one is pushing anything on me again! Its MY body and MY choice!! You don't like my choice..too bad!

Posted 12/16/11 10:29 AM
 

PoppySeed
LIF Infant

Member since 10/09

358 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by DavaDay

I'm not trying to be judgey, but I don't get the anger here. The AAP studies peer-reviewed journal articles, follows medical trials, etc. and makes recommendations based on them. Before this, they recommended that women BF for one full year, and only like 10% of women do. That's fine. No one was complaining about the AAP then, even though hardly anyone followed their advice. They're presenting the science of what's best for the baby, and it's a recommendation, not a mandate. Armed with that knowledge, you do what you can for your kid. And if you can't, or won't, or plain old don't want to... well, hardly anyone followed their previous recommendation and we're all getting along just fine anyway.

The AAP also says no bumpers, not even breathable ones, and there are a bazillion threads on LIF about how great breathable bumpers are.

The AAP says no television before age 2 and... yeah, right. My 3 month old cries and wails during her physical therapy exercises unless Mickey Mouse is on. So I put Mickey Mouse on 3 times a day.

I just see this recommendation as: We've studied the science, we think this is best, take it or leave it. I've got no beef with the AAP; they're only trying to give me info to make the best and most informed decision for my child.

A lactation consultant who won't tell moms about formula, though - that's plain wrong. And mean. And being mean to a mom of a newborn is a special kind of mean.



I agree with this wholeheartedly. The AAP is making a recommendation based on scientific evidence. If you want to do something else, that is your choice.

Are parents who let their kids watch TV before 2 years angry at the AAP for that recommendation? Or do you simply say "that's not what works for my family" and move on?

I would never expect a lactation consultant to recommend formula as a long-term solution, because her job is to consult on lactation. By feeding a baby formula, your breasts make less milk and the baby gets used to a bottle. Formula feeding does not promote lactation. BUT from a dietician's standpoint, of course formula will come up for various reasons, although if you believe (as the AAP does) that the science supports breastfeeding, you should do your best to encourage it, within reason.

Posted 12/16/11 11:10 AM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

I agree with you

I hate that society seems to feel the NEED to be involved in my breasts. I BF for 11 days then stopped. Yeah, I had to but maybe I didnt fight all that hard for alternatives. I dont care.

Why is it such a earthshattering thing to say no. Why is it ok to shove breastfeeding down our throats, create a stigma about it that just adds to PPD?

External Image

I think its ignorance that implies we can't make our own decisions. I think its brainwashing to force media outlets to try to steer us to BF.

Posted 12/16/11 11:19 AM
 

FirstMate
My lil cowboy

Member since 10/10

7790 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Your LC has a conflict of interest. She needs to maintain the momentum of the BF movement so she has job security.

AAP guidelines are just that..guidelines. They are ever dynamic and certainly not hard, fast rules.

Women should be educated on all of their feeding options and make the choice that best suits them. End of story. If everyone made the choice that worked for them and not feel pressured by outsiders, there would be no debate about what is "better". It's not about "better", it's about what works for everyone to be happy and healthy - that's "better". Enough is enough with this whole thing! (Not at the OP, just generally speaking).

Posted 12/16/11 11:36 AM
 

Mrs007
Im obsessed w my lil man!

Member since 3/09

2528 total posts

Name:
K

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by NervousNell

If anyone told me how to feed my child I'd punch them in the face. Straight up.
I'd also tell them to FLUCK off.

I really am starting to get fed up with everyone thinking they can tell us what to do in terms of our personal decisions- be it banning toys in Happy Meals, trying to force BFing, etc.
This country is moving more and more away from a democracy with freedom of CHOICE and it scares me.
Whatever happened to it being a free country??

And if they think not giving out free formula samples in the hospital will change anyone's mind- well to me that is ridiculous.
Even if the hospital I delivered at refused to give me formula for the 3 days I was there, I would have had DH go out to Target and bring me some.
These silly little moves to shove BFing down our throats really are ridiculous.
Chat Icon I'm not a child- you can't trick me into it.

I also feel like some of these breast feeding Nazi lactation consultants are a bit off the deep end and almost cultish.
They need to get a grip and stay out of other women's bras.

And I never ONCE felt my hospital shoved formula at me, or on the flip side, tried to shove BFing down my throat.
Maybe it was just my hospital, but they were fine with whatever choice I made ,didn't say word ONE about it- and that was it.
Right after she was born, the nurse said, are you going to be BFing. I said No. She wrote it on the chart and moved on.
Maybe that is why I'd go back there again if I ever had to deliver again.





THANK YOU! I am so sick of seeing "breast is best." When BF was no longer an option for me, I cried my eyes out thinking I was doing harm to my DS. Its so shoved down our throats that BF is best for our DC, but sometimes it is not...it wasnt best in my situation for my DS.

When I was in the hospital, DS was in NICU and I tried BF but supplemented with formula, never got a lecture from anyone at the hospital on how to feed my DS. I also was never given any formula samples to take home. My neighbor is a NICU nurse in another hospital and she thought that was absurd and brought me home samples of formula to have just in case. Good thing she did because I didnt have ANYTHING for DS when I couldnt BF DS anymore.

Posted 12/16/11 12:31 PM
 

Mrs007
Im obsessed w my lil man!

Member since 3/09

2528 total posts

Name:
K

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by FirstMate


Women should be educated on all of their feeding options and make the choice that best suits them. End of story. If everyone made the choice that worked for them and not feel pressured by outsiders, there would be no debate about what is "better". It's not about "better", it's about what works for everyone to be happy and healthy - that's "better". Enough is enough with this whole thing! (Not at the OP, just generally speaking).




ITA

Posted 12/16/11 12:32 PM
 

TheDivineMrsM
2 girls 4 me!

Member since 8/08

7878 total posts

Name:
Mama mama mama....

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

To the OP - both of you are right.

Posted by PoppySeed
I would never expect a lactation consultant to recommend formula as a long-term solution, because her job is to consult on lactation. By feeding a baby formula, your breasts make less milk and the baby gets used to a bottle. Formula feeding does not promote lactation. BUT from a dietician's standpoint, of course formula will come up for various reasons, although if you believe (as the AAP does) that the science supports breastfeeding, you should do your best to encourage it, within reason.



Chat Icon Couldn't have said it better.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/16/11 1:42 PM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by FirstMate

Your LC has a conflict of interest. She needs to maintain the momentum of the BF movement so she has job security.

AAP guidelines are just that..guidelines. They are ever dynamic and certainly not hard, fast rules.

Women should be educated on all of their feeding options and make the choice that best suits them. End of story. If everyone made the choice that worked for them and not feel pressured by outsiders, there would be no debate about what is "better". It's not about "better", it's about what works for everyone to be happy and healthy - that's "better". Enough is enough with this whole thing! (Not at the OP, just generally speaking).




I dont think many of the women who BF do so bc they feel pressure to do so! At least that's the general idea I got from my spinoff thread...

Either you want to BF & BF, try to BF, but can't so give formula knowing you gave it your best shot but it wasn't for you, or you don't want to BF, so you FF.

Guidelines are not there to pressure anyone or make them feel guilty! Look at the co sleeping guidelines, the aap doesn't recommend sleeping in bed with your child. However, some people still do it bc it works for them! They don't feel guilty about it or pressure not to. People who choose to FF shouldn't feel pressure or guilt either. But that doesn't mean the aap shouldn't make guidelines about what they find to work best in ideal situations!!!

I don't even see why this is a debate.

Posted 12/16/11 2:04 PM
 

DRMom
Two in Blue

Member since 5/05

20223 total posts

Name:
Melissa

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by schmora15

I agree that no one should tell you what or how to feed your LO, but I'm happy that they won't be shoving formula at you in the hospital. DD was full term and had to be put in NICU because I had a temp post cs. I was soooo upset that they gave her formula. I made it very clear I was BFing and no formula was to be given. It was a big headache and I had to wean her off formula after being in NICU for a week. They gave me a ridiculous amount of formula and minimal bfing support.



I agree with this as well. I had virtually no support when trying to BF my preemie twins. Also its a recommendation. Not a law. I think there is nothing wrong with advising people that BF'ing is wonderful for a child and no one should be pressured by society to stop.

Posted 12/16/11 2:08 PM
 

JennZ
MY LIFE!!

Member since 8/05

25463 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

I agree with you. I pumped for 3 weeks, and HATED it. I couldnt keep up with him, wasnt getting sleep and was constantly annoyed over it. Its MY right as his mother to do whats best for MY child.

I think as a whole our society needs a reality check. We have turned into a bunch of know it alls, and you should do this, and you shouldnt do that. Whatever happened to doing whats best for YOU and YOUR family?

Posted 12/16/11 2:16 PM
 

KevinNKristin8-15-08
Welcome to the world Chase

Member since 9/08

6162 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by dita

Posted by MrsH2009

I think most know breast is best, but some people can't or choose not to breast fed. Often that is a very emotional and hard decision to make. BUT, I think the lactation consultant is trying to help people that are unsure or uninformed, not those who can't breast feed, or know they don't want to. I have no source to the validity of this, but Stony Brook told us LI had one of the lowest breast feeding rates in the area, and the hospitals are concerned as to why, and are trying to change it.



Probably because to live on LI you need a double income and working FT makes it a lot harder.

yep!! This is exactly it. If I had the luxury of staying home bf would be much much easier. Working while pumping is extremely difficult. Plus I don't have the type of job that I can pump every 3 hrs. Still somehow I managed and I'm still going at 8 months.

It just angers me that so many people act like bf should be the be-all-end-all to parenting. It annoys the crap out of me. There is nothing wrong with formula. It should be a womens choice and she should not have to hear criticism from others based on her choice.

Posted 12/16/11 2:22 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by NervousNell

I also feel like some of these breast feeding Nazi lactation consultants are a bit off the deep end and almost cultish.
They need to get a grip and stay out of other women's bras.




Chat Icon Chat Icon I think it's almost an obsession for some. Really irks me to no end.

Posted 12/16/11 2:37 PM
 

FirstMate
My lil cowboy

Member since 10/10

7790 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by MrsECullen7319

Posted by FirstMate

Your LC has a conflict of interest. She needs to maintain the momentum of the BF movement so she has job security.

AAP guidelines are just that..guidelines. They are ever dynamic and certainly not hard, fast rules.

Women should be educated on all of their feeding options and make the choice that best suits them. End of story. If everyone made the choice that worked for them and not feel pressured by outsiders, there would be no debate about what is "better". It's not about "better", it's about what works for everyone to be happy and healthy - that's "better". Enough is enough with this whole thing! (Not at the OP, just generally speaking).




I dont think many of the women who BF do so bc they feel pressure to do so! At least that's the general idea I got from my spinoff thread...

I don't even see why this is a debate.



I did not mean that women BF because they succumb to pressure. Not at all. That was not the point of what I was saying. I was not referring to BFing moms, I was speaking of all moms.

How to feed a baby should not be a debate at all. It's none of my business how another mother chooses to feed her child. But, as we see on these threads and elsewhere, people have very strong opinions on the subject and what is "better" and that was the debate to which I was referring.

Posted 12/16/11 2:54 PM
 

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Well...I shared a lot of this thread with her today...Let's just say "we are the problem" with why mothers don't breastfeed! LOL!

Posted 12/16/11 3:26 PM
 

NervousNell
Just another chapter in life..

Member since 11/09

54921 total posts

Name:
..being a mommy and being a wife!

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by hdrd0411

Well...I shared a lot of this thread with her today...Let's just say "we are the problem" with why mothers don't breastfeed! LOL!



Send her to me. I can assure her that is not you that is the reason why I didn't breastfeed.
And I can give her an earful on my thoughts on the subject as well.

Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon

Posted 12/16/11 3:31 PM
 

Xelindrya
Mommy's little YouTube Star!

Member since 8/05

14470 total posts

Name:
Veronica

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by Bella01

Posted by NervousNell

Maybe it was just my hospital, but they were fine with whatever choice I made ,didn't say word ONE about it- and that was it.
Right after she was born, the nurse said, are you going to be BFing. I said No. She wrote it on the chart and moved on.
Maybe that is why I'd go back there again if I ever had to deliver again.





My hospital was the same way. I agree.




I wish.. 2 days into my stay the LC came in (yeah thanks for the late appearance) then without ANY warning cut our family off with the curtain popped my tit out and put my kid to me.

Seriously lady?! Chat Icon

Thankfully AJ had a great latch but she went on and on how IMPORTANT breast feeding is. Every pediatrician visit had walls full of BREAST BREAST BREAST

Breast is best? So what? I'm a horrible mom if I can't or WON'T. I don't WANT to. I stopped at 11 days and she was a great feeder. Breast is best then I'm second best... nice pep talk.

I'd rather they just let me make my own choice and support whatever choice I made. I needed to switch to Gentlease. I needed someone to say its not you, its not the formula, is your baby's gas... here try this. I don't need to hear "Well if you BREASTFED..." screw off society. Chat Icon

You breastfeed right? No. Oh, why not? Seriously none of your f'ing business lady. I saw lots of doctors after AJ was born due to complications with my whole body. Heart, lungs, liver, etc. In the beginning the answer was yes, but the end it was no. I hated the questions, follow up questions and raised eyebrows. I wanted to SCREAM "F*CK OFF!" its a yes or no question.. move on.

I bet the same stigma is for married / unmarried with a child. Only diff is, not every poster, internet add and govt sponsered group is shoving down your through MARRIED WITH CHILDREN IS BETTER. Cause sh*t happens and not even happily married parents are guaranteed to be there together forever. but its ok to pressure mom in to popping out a tit. *sigh*

It really does anger me (as if you can't tell) Chat Icon

Posted 12/16/11 3:39 PM
 
Pages: 1 [2] 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
This may cause flames... but... question about "mean girls" Bxgell2 5/17/10 51 Parenting
Dog issue, please no flames, I'm at a loss here and no idea what to do. Please don't move this is parenting related pickles16 1/23/10 51 Parenting
for those who go to tanning salons--no flames about tanning please......... agnes 1/23/10 2 Fashion & Beauty!
I know this post will cause scandal and flames...but I'm really wondering what to do next... MrsRivera 12/27/09 18 Parenting
I have a question regarding Autism.....no flames, no opinions, but I am curious... KateDevine 10/20/08 42 Parenting
I think I have flames coming out of my ears I am so furious! JennChris 7/17/08 13 Parenting