No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted By Message
Pages: [1] 2 3

hdrd0411
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

1923 total posts

Name:
Maureen

No Flames - Am I wrong?

The AAP is putting out a new recommendation on BF - stating babies should BF until the self wean.
As a dietitian, I 1 million times support and encourage bf, however, as a mom I totally understand why not everyone BF's. For whatever personal or physical reason, some just don't want to, can't, etc. And I feel that it is NO ONES business to tell any mother how to feed their child. I also don't think restricting a sample of formula from a diaper bag (that we no longer give out) is going to tell a mom or make a mom not breastfeed.
Anyway...b/c of this new recommendation (which I get, but honestly don't see the need for a 5 year old to breastfeed unless you are in an underdeveloped country), I had a heated discussion with our lactation consultant. I am a firm believer in educating a mom in feeding her child - either via breast of formula...whatever she prefers....well..she flipped out...saying that I should never bring up formula b/c that is encouraging moms to not breast feed...I then went into a rant about how instead of banning formula, we should start banning happy meals, chips, fries, lunchables, etc. b/c why should we let a mom feed her child processed food (it was a more tounge in cheek suggestion)...I mean lets be real...of course I would not tell a mom to feed her kids junk food all day (however I do see a lot of moms that do this), but who am I to ban anything? I don't know..I think this whole BF initiative has gotten a bit out of hand...I just don't understand why anyone thinks its ok to tell anyone how to feed their child? Vent over....I will take suggestions on what to say to this lactation consultant at our next meeting....

Posted 12/15/11 3:41 PM
 
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource

phoenix913
LIF Adult

Member since 5/05

3034 total posts

Name:
V

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

I totally agree- it's a mother's choice how they feed their child and no one should judge. I'm a mom who went straight to formula. I just knew that breastfeeding was not for me and my baby.

I did get a lot of literature etc about breastfeeding and comments from people, but honestly none of it swayed me in the least. So the AAP can say whatever they want, but for me I just didn't even listen at all. I think as long as women are confident in themselves and their decision, whatever it is, then it doesn't really matter what others say, do or recommend.

Now if they start talking about banning formula, that's when I'll get upset...

Posted 12/15/11 3:46 PM
 

maybeamommy
Blessed beyond belief

Member since 10/07

17048 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

I would tell her that it's like ONLY talking to teens about abstinence. You KNOW that some are going to choose to have sex, so you might as well talk to them about protecting themselves and their partners.

NOT every mom is going to BF! It doesn't matter why the mom chose to use formula, but if she's going to use it.. she'll do it with or without your approval, so you might as well educate moms about the benefits of different kinds of formulas and how to find out if it's right for their children.

Posted 12/15/11 3:46 PM
 

KevinNKristin8-15-08
Welcome to the world Chase

Member since 9/08

6162 total posts

Name:
Kristin

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

I completely agree with you!! This was so well said!! Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon Chat Icon


Posted 12/15/11 3:48 PM
 

Pray4Baby2010
<3 Cutest Giants Fan

Member since 10/09

5796 total posts

Name:
MB

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

I think you are right and this is coming from someone that bf/pumped for a year for my son.

People need to stop forcing their own beliefs on people- its a personal choice- just like vaccination and almost every other decision we make as a parent

Posted 12/15/11 3:49 PM
 

nycgirl
Angels!

Member since 3/09

7721 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by maybeamommy

I would tell her that it's like ONLY talking to teens about abstinence. You KNOW that some are going to choose to have sex, so you might as well talk to them about protecting themselves and their partners.

NOT every mom is going to BF! It doesn't matter why the mom chose to use formula, but if she's going to use it.. she'll do it with or without your approval, so you might as well educate moms about the benefits of different kinds of formulas and how to find out if it's right for their children.



ITA and can add....

Some people can NOT follow these recommendations.

I would have loved to BF my baby forever (I did while on maternity leave)... but I work with chemicals & we all decided risks outweighed benefits.

It's a PERSONAL decision.

My pediatrician was very good at understanding...

Posted 12/15/11 3:53 PM
 

schmora15
LIF Adult

Member since 9/08

2476 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

I agree that no one should tell you what or how to feed your LO, but I'm happy that they won't be shoving formula at you in the hospital. DD was full term and had to be put in NICU because I had a temp post cs. I was soooo upset that they gave her formula. I made it very clear I was BFing and no formula was to be given. It was a big headache and I had to wean her off formula after being in NICU for a week. They gave me a ridiculous amount of formula and minimal bfing support.

Posted 12/15/11 3:53 PM
 

Goobster
:)

Member since 5/07

27557 total posts

Name:
:)

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

I am sorry but I believe way too many people are crazy about this BF stuff. I would tell anyone to shove it if they pushed it on me, esp as a new mom.

Posted 12/15/11 3:56 PM
 

LadyBug1209
Mommy to FOUR little men!

Member since 8/08

9655 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by Pray4Baby2010

I think you are right and this is coming from someone that bf/pumped for a year for my son.

People need to stop forcing their own beliefs on people- its a personal choice- just like vaccination and almost every other decision we make as a parent



Chat Icon

Posted 12/15/11 3:57 PM
 

maybesoon
LIF Adult

Member since 9/09

5981 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

The whole bf thing has gotten out of hand. In 10 years it will be another story. Don't bother listening or arguing with an lc , bc if everyone FF there would be no job for her. That's her reason for being so pushy about it.

Posted 12/15/11 3:59 PM
 

NYchic
Girl & boy

Member since 6/09

2357 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Completely agree with you...no one can tell me how I should feed my child.

Posted 12/15/11 4:01 PM
 

MrsFlatbread
Skinny jeans are in my future

Member since 6/06

10258 total posts

Name:
Baby Momma

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by Goobster

I am sorry but I believe way too many people are crazy about this BF stuff. I would tell anyone to shove it if they pushed it on me, esp as a new mom.

Chat Icon

Posted 12/15/11 4:02 PM
 

bluekat16
My boys :-)

Member since 3/09

6659 total posts

Name:
Kathy

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by maybeamommy

I would tell her that it's like ONLY talking to teens about abstinence. You KNOW that some are going to choose to have sex, so you might as well talk to them about protecting themselves and their partners.

NOT every mom is going to BF! It doesn't matter why the mom chose to use formula, but if she's going to use it.. she'll do it with or without your approval, so you might as well educate moms about the benefits of different kinds of formulas and how to find out if it's right for their children.



ITA!

I tried to BF wih DS #1 but decided early on I wasn't going to go crazy about and would do it if it worked out. Well it didn't and I decided to exclusively formula feed him. He wasn't a great boob latcher and I was miserable. When I tried excluively pumping I felt like a cow being milked and it made me feel worse. Both my Ped and OB said Happy mom = Happy baby so I went with that.

With DS 32 I decided to completely go to formula feeding and bypass even try BFing. i felt pretty much the same as I did with DS #1.

It was a personal decision and one I do not regret. I totally see the benefits to BFing and think it's great that many women do it but it is not for everyone.

Posted 12/15/11 4:07 PM
 

OffWithHerHead23
Keep passing the open windows

Member since 10/06

3627 total posts

Name:
Meaghan

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Even though the recommendations are that a child be BF, in practice, that's not done. I've had 3 kids, and every hospital the nurses pushed formula and made it difficult to BF. If I was wishy washy about it, I never would have followed through with BF.

My sister had a baby 5 months ago and just applied for WIC yesterday. At the WiC office, they wouldn't let her NOT select a formula, even though she repeatedly told them she was EBF. When she told them that the woman she talked to on the hotline had said she would be able to get a better breast pump than what she has, the lady looked at her like she was crazy. She told my sister that they didn't have breast pumps, and that she'd never heard of anyone asking for one Chat Icon

You can see, there's what's said, and then what's done, and the recomendations really don't count for much.

Posted 12/15/11 4:10 PM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by schmora15

I agree that no one should tell you what or how to feed your LO, but I'm happy that they won't be shoving formula at you in the hospital. DD was full term and had to be put in NICU because I had a temp post cs. I was soooo upset that they gave her formula. I made it very clear I was BFing and no formula was to be given. It was a big headache and I had to wean her off formula after being in NICU for a week. They gave me a ridiculous amount of formula and minimal bfing support.



I had the same experience only DD also had low blood sugar so they told me they HAD to give her formula or an IV of glucose to bring it up...WELL, she had already latched and nursed in the recovery room and wanted nothing to do with the bottle of formula. I watched multiple nicu nurses try to force feed her formula, and limit my bfing sessions...she finally got the IV and was fine within 24 hours.

I HATED the NICU nurses at St. Charles...they were nice but not supportive of BFing AT ALL! The one nurse actually told me that I should stay in my room and rest and let her feed the baby, bc if I push myself and stress out, my supply wont come in!!! Another one told me there is no such thing as nipple confusion. A third told me that she thinks that babies who nurse in the recovery room right away tend to have problems...SERIOUSLY?!? I ignored them and went to the NICU around the clock to BF, skin to skin, etc. I could also tell that most of the nurses did not like the lactation consultant. I was adamant about BFing, and had read books and made myself knowledgeable about it before giving birth but Im sure someone else would have listened to the nurses.

I dont think hospitals should be so quick to use formula to solve all problems. I agree that the moms should choose if they want to BF or FF, but I think hospitals need to respect these decisions, and not try to push a mom one way or the other.

I also was FORCED to take home a bunch of nursettes "just in case"...even after BFing was going well. Maybe they should re-educate some nurses about the benefits of BFing.

Posted 12/15/11 4:11 PM
 

Katareen
5,000 Posts!

Member since 4/10

7180 total posts

Name:
Katherine

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

I'm sorry but this is just not practical. I have a very high-stress job, and I pump at work, and some days its impossible to pump on any sort of schedule. I find myself sweating in conference calls and meetings, unable to concentrate, because I'm late for a pump session.

My job has been as understanding as possible but after one year, I can't do this anymore. It will put my job and my sanity and jeopardy, and having no income to pay bills will be far worse for my child than having cow's milk.

Posted 12/15/11 4:32 PM
 

lucyloo
nope

Member since 1/06

9758 total posts

Name:

....

Message edited 2013-03-07 14:52:05.030000.

Posted 12/15/11 5:01 PM
 

Bearcat
Love my little girls!!! <3

Member since 6/10

10818 total posts

Name:
E

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

ask your LC what she would say to me.

my milk never really came in. i tried and tried... i am STILL trying. DD will be 2 months on sunday. ive pumped, nursed on demand, taken every supplement out there.... she lost nearly a pound after birth and didnt get back to her birth weight until her 1 month visit. after i had been instructed that i had to supplement with formula (by an LC).

i now nurse her only in the morning and at night, and she still guzzles 6oz of formula immediately following the nursing... clearly shes getting an ounce at most from me. she took the 6oz bottle after every nursing sessioin even last week when i was still nursing 5-6 times a day.

was i supposed to let my child starve? is that what she would advise?

point being, some of us try so hard and still cant provide. i completely understand why some never try , and why some give up.... lord knows ive been close to giving up.

Posted 12/15/11 5:26 PM
 

MrsH2009
Thank you St. Gerard!

Member since 8/09

6631 total posts

Name:
M

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

I think most know breast is best, but some people can't or choose not to breast fed. Often that is a very emotional and hard decision to make. BUT, I think the lactation consultant is trying to help people that are unsure or uninformed, not those who can't breast feed, or know they don't want to. I have no source to the validity of this, but Stony Brook told us LI had one of the lowest breast feeding rates in the area, and the hospitals are concerned as to why, and are trying to change it.

Message edited 2011-12-15 17:37:49.167000.

Posted 12/15/11 5:36 PM
 

KennysMommy
Never knew LOVE like it before

Member since 3/10

2640 total posts

Name:
Danielle

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

I like the recommendation for one reason only: I chose to BF DS until he self weaned, which happened to be at 23 months. You have no idea how many people told me it wasn't right, not normal, gross, it was hurting him, etc. This rec. would've given me a LOT more ammunition than just my own personal beliefs to shut them up. So, I support it for that reason.

BUT I do support a woman's right to choose what she does with her own body, whether it's to BF or not, get an abortion or not, you name it. No one should be able to MAKE you do something differently.

Posted 12/15/11 6:08 PM
 

MrsDamonSalv7319
Somewhere in Westeros

Member since 10/10

4495 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by KennysMommy

I like the recommendation for one reason only: I chose to BF DS until he self weaned, which happened to be at 23 months. You have no idea how many people told me it wasn't right, not normal, gross, it was hurting him, etc. This rec. would've given me a LOT more ammunition than just my own personal beliefs to shut them up. So, I support it for that reason.




Chat Icon Chat Icon DD is only 6 months and ppl act like I should be done BFing now!

I think this recommendation should be geared more toward medical professionals who may help or hinder moms who already WANT to BF but have rough starts.

So many hospitals, nurses, and Peds are quick to suggest formula for any bump in the road (at least this is my experience).

I think that if a woman chooses not to BF, or really are unable to BF for medical/physical reasons that is 100% ok...formula is food too and is not going to hurt a baby...BUT, I know a few people who wanted to BF,and for whatever reason (NICU stay, Baby losing weight, mom needing to take an antibiotic) hit a speed bump and were told to give formula like it was no big deal. My own ped made me give formula when DD was diagnosed with a milk protein sensitivity, and he made it seem like it would be too hard for me to cut dairy (which I did). I think the people that are supposed to support women who WANT to BF really need to be more supportive...HOPEFULLY this new recommendation will help that, but NOT make people who CANT/WONT BF feel bad!

ETA my Ped even told me "The only thing that your breastmilk has that this formula doesnt is your antibodies" as if I shouldnt be so upset that he was telling me to stop BFing! Not very supportive!

Message edited 2011-12-15 19:03:28.730000.

Posted 12/15/11 7:00 PM
 

imyself

Member since 10/06

2938 total posts

Name:
me

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

Posted by KennysMommy

I like the recommendation for one reason only: I chose to BF DS until he self weaned, which happened to be at 23 months. You have no idea how many people told me it wasn't right, not normal, gross, it was hurting him, etc. This rec. would've given me a LOT more ammunition than just my own personal beliefs to shut them up. So, I support it for that reason.

BUT I do support a woman's right to choose what she does with her own body, whether it's to BF or not, get an abortion or not, you name it. No one should be able to MAKE you do something differently.



Same here. Ds self weaned at 14 months and dd at 25 months. It would have been nice to have some more extended bf'ing support. Instead I got she is still nursing or you really need to wean that baby. My favorite was if she is old enough to ask for it she needs to be weaned. She started talking early so that would have meant switching to formula. I ignored them all and did what I felt was right but it was hard at times.

Posted 12/15/11 7:32 PM
 

SummerMom
Now a mom of 2!

Member since 6/07

4970 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

I'm not trying to be judgey, but I don't get the anger here. The AAP studies peer-reviewed journal articles, follows medical trials, etc. and makes recommendations based on them. Before this, they recommended that women BF for one full year, and only like 10% of women do. That's fine. No one was complaining about the AAP then, even though hardly anyone followed their advice. They're presenting the science of what's best for the baby, and it's a recommendation, not a mandate. Armed with that knowledge, you do what you can for your kid. And if you can't, or won't, or plain old don't want to... well, hardly anyone followed their previous recommendation and we're all getting along just fine anyway.

The AAP also says no bumpers, not even breathable ones, and there are a bazillion threads on LIF about how great breathable bumpers are.

The AAP says no television before age 2 and... yeah, right. My 3 month old cries and wails during her physical therapy exercises unless Mickey Mouse is on. So I put Mickey Mouse on 3 times a day.

I just see this recommendation as: We've studied the science, we think this is best, take it or leave it. I've got no beef with the AAP; they're only trying to give me info to make the best and most informed decision for my child.

A lactation consultant who won't tell moms about formula, though - that's plain wrong. And mean. And being mean to a mom of a newborn is a special kind of mean.

Posted 12/15/11 8:26 PM
 

Porrruss
Nya nya nya

Member since 5/05

11618 total posts

Name:
Amy

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

You were both right. And wrong. As a dietitian is IS part of your job to discuss formula. As a lactation consultant it is NOT her job to discuss formula- her job is to educate and provide support for successful BFing. You both have different agendas so it's no wonder you didn't agree.

I admit I am a bit of a snob when it comes to BFing. I firmly believe it should be a 100% comittment. That's all I'll say about my opinion because it likely isn't a popular one. I absolutely support the AAP's stance. I also don't feel they're dictating what people have to do- like a PP stated, they are only recommendations.

Message edited 2011-12-15 20:45:59.157000.

Posted 12/15/11 8:43 PM
 

MayBbaby21
Baby no. 3 coming soon!

Member since 6/09

5738 total posts

Name:

Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?

I agree with you and I'm a BFing mom who is still going at 11+ months. I'm planning to wean my DD soon. We already started transitioning one feeding to whole milk, with doctor's ok. Sometimes I feel guilty about not letting her self-wean, but I was never one of those moms who loved, loved, loved BFing—so I'm extremely proud of myself for making it this far. I exceeded my goal of 6 months. I feel I've given her a great start, but now I'm ready to move on. My supply is dwindling and I had to start supplementing with formula at 9 months when I couldn't be with her. Worrying if I could pump out enough milk to leave her was stressing me out. So for that reason alone, I'm grateful formula exists and that we have options.

I understand why your LC doesn't want to bring up formula, but as a dietician, you should be allowed to discuss it as an option for your patients.

Posted 12/15/11 9:00 PM
 
Pages: [1] 2 3
 

Potentially Related Topics:

Topic Posted By Started Replies Forum
This may cause flames... but... question about "mean girls" Bxgell2 5/17/10 51 Parenting
Dog issue, please no flames, I'm at a loss here and no idea what to do. Please don't move this is parenting related pickles16 1/23/10 51 Parenting
for those who go to tanning salons--no flames about tanning please......... agnes 1/23/10 2 Fashion & Beauty!
I know this post will cause scandal and flames...but I'm really wondering what to do next... MrsRivera 12/27/09 18 Parenting
I have a question regarding Autism.....no flames, no opinions, but I am curious... KateDevine 10/20/08 42 Parenting
I think I have flames coming out of my ears I am so furious! JennChris 7/17/08 13 Parenting