Re: No Flames - Am I wrong?
Posted 12/16/2011 11:10:38 AM by PoppySeed


Posted by DavaDay

I'm not trying to be judgey, but I don't get the anger here. The AAP studies peer-reviewed journal articles, follows medical trials, etc. and makes recommendations based on them. Before this, they recommended that women BF for one full year, and only like 10% of women do. That's fine. No one was complaining about the AAP then, even though hardly anyone followed their advice. They're presenting the science of what's best for the baby, and it's a recommendation, not a mandate. Armed with that knowledge, you do what you can for your kid. And if you can't, or won't, or plain old don't want to... well, hardly anyone followed their previous recommendation and we're all getting along just fine anyway.

The AAP also says no bumpers, not even breathable ones, and there are a bazillion threads on LIF about how great breathable bumpers are.

The AAP says no television before age 2 and... yeah, right. My 3 month old cries and wails during her physical therapy exercises unless Mickey Mouse is on. So I put Mickey Mouse on 3 times a day.

I just see this recommendation as: We've studied the science, we think this is best, take it or leave it. I've got no beef with the AAP; they're only trying to give me info to make the best and most informed decision for my child.

A lactation consultant who won't tell moms about formula, though - that's plain wrong. And mean. And being mean to a mom of a newborn is a special kind of mean.



I agree with this wholeheartedly. The AAP is making a recommendation based on scientific evidence. If you want to do something else, that is your choice.

Are parents who let their kids watch TV before 2 years angry at the AAP for that recommendation? Or do you simply say "that's not what works for my family" and move on?

I would never expect a lactation consultant to recommend formula as a long-term solution, because her job is to consult on lactation. By feeding a baby formula, your breasts make less milk and the baby gets used to a bottle. Formula feeding does not promote lactation. BUT from a dietician's standpoint, of course formula will come up for various reasons, although if you believe (as the AAP does) that the science supports breastfeeding, you should do your best to encourage it, within reason.
Print Post      Close Window