Nautilus vs. Frontier
| Posted By | Message |
|---|---|
|
Nautilus vs. Frontier If money wasn't an issue which one would you buy for a 4 year old? The seat will be going into a Honda Accord. TIA. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 1:13 PM
|
|
|
Long Island Weddings
Long Island's Largest Bridal Resource
| |
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier I don't have experience with the Frontier, but I can give you a vote for the Nautilus. We have one in each of our cars for our 4 year old DS and I love it! |
|
Posted 2/21/12 1:15 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier Frontier can be difficult to install with a seat belt in some vehicles this becomes important as LATCH use must be discontinued when a child reaches 40/48lbs depending upon vehicle. If you do get one, stay away from the mesh like covers, they tend to pill up, there's been a lot of complaints about that. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 1:23 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier I few girls on here recommend the Graco Nautilus when we were looking for a new carseat for my DD a month or so ago and I'm glad I took their advice.........it's a GREAT seat! (and ranked highly by Consumer Reports too) My DD is more comfortable in that now than the Britax Roundabout we had for her, I think she just outgrew that one. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 1:28 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier Posted by Hofstra26 I few girls on here recommend the Graco Nautilus when we were looking for a new carseat for my DD a month or so ago and I'm glad I took their advice.........it's a GREAT seat! (and ranked highly by Consumer Reports too) My DD is more comfortable in that now than the Britax Roundabout we had for her, I think she just outgrew that one. The Nautilus was pretty affordable too. Amazon had it the cheapest I found but I ended up getting it at BRU, they let you use the 20% coupon and I had some gift cards so it worked out better that way. Can the nautilus be used for babies too? I want to get Dd a convertible seat that will grow with her. She's 8 months now and about to outgrow the infant seat. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 1:38 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier Posted by MrsECullen7319 Posted by Hofstra26 I few girls on here recommend the Graco Nautilus when we were looking for a new carseat for my DD a month or so ago and I'm glad I took their advice.........it's a GREAT seat! (and ranked highly by Consumer Reports too) My DD is more comfortable in that now than the Britax Roundabout we had for her, I think she just outgrew that one. The Nautilus was pretty affordable too. Amazon had it the cheapest I found but I ended up getting it at BRU, they let you use the 20% coupon and I had some gift cards so it worked out better that way. Can the nautilus be used for babies too? I want to get Dd a convertible seat that will grow with her. She's 8 months now and about to outgrow the infant seat. The Nautilus is forward facing only. I think it's recommended to keep the baby rear facing as long as possible. I wouldn't buy a Nautilus until DC was above 3 years old. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 1:41 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier Posted by MrsECullen7319 Posted by Hofstra26 I few girls on here recommend the Graco Nautilus when we were looking for a new carseat for my DD a month or so ago and I'm glad I took their advice.........it's a GREAT seat! (and ranked highly by Consumer Reports too) My DD is more comfortable in that now than the Britax Roundabout we had for her, I think she just outgrew that one. The Nautilus was pretty affordable too. Amazon had it the cheapest I found but I ended up getting it at BRU, they let you use the 20% coupon and I had some gift cards so it worked out better that way. Can the nautilus be used for babies too? I want to get Dd a convertible seat that will grow with her. She's 8 months now and about to outgrow the infant seat. No, it is recommended that you keep babies rear facing until at least 2 and the Nautilus is front facing only. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 1:44 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier I have a Nautilus. Just transfered DS from Britax Decathlon to Nautilus. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 1:48 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier Thanks Everyone! |
|
Posted 2/21/12 2:06 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier I would go with your DC to BBB and have them sit in the different car seats to determine which one fits them the best. Also, the Nautilis/Argos/Frontier have an issue where the seat belt positioner is really far back so within a few months after turning four I can see a child no longer being able to use the five point harness. To me, that really decreases the value of getting these car seats for a four year old child. I like how safe they are, but if you are getting it to replace a convertible seat I am not sure I would. I would look at a HBB instead. Also, Britax manufactures the parkway with the latch system for children who weigh more than 40 lbs as that is the start point for the car seat. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 2:32 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier Posted by tarabelle99 Frontier can be difficult to install with a seat belt in some vehicles this becomes important as LATCH use must be discontinued when a child reaches 40/48lbs depending upon vehicle. If you do get one, stay away from the mesh like covers, they tend to pill up, there's been a lot of complaints about that. I would go play with them, and also check out the new seats that are out: BabyTrend TrendZ FastBack Evenflo Secure Kid 300/400 Graco Argos. This advice does not apply to the Britax Parkway SGL according to the manufacturer. Per Britax: Q. Is it ok to use the LATCH/Universal Anchoring System on the BRITAX PARKWAY SGL booster seat up to 120 lbs? A. Yes, the vehicle seat belt is bearing the crash loads and not the LATCH anchors since the LATCH anchors are just holding the seat in place and the vehicle seat belt is what is being used to restrain the child. The load of the child (weight X speed) is applied to the vehicle seat belt as that is what is restraining the child. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 2:37 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier Posted by LSP2005 Posted by tarabelle99 Frontier can be difficult to install with a seat belt in some vehicles this becomes important as LATCH use must be discontinued when a child reaches 40/48lbs depending upon vehicle. If you do get one, stay away from the mesh like covers, they tend to pill up, there's been a lot of complaints about that. I would go play with them, and also check out the new seats that are out: BabyTrend TrendZ FastBack Evenflo Secure Kid 300/400 Graco Argos. This advice does not apply to the Britax Parkway SGL according to the manufacturer. Per Britax: Q. Is it ok to use the LATCH/Universal Anchoring System on the BRITAX PARKWAY SGL booster seat up to 120 lbs? A. Yes, the vehicle seat belt is bearing the crash loads and not the LATCH anchors since the LATCH anchors are just holding the seat in place and the vehicle seat belt is what is being used to restrain the child. The load of the child (weight X speed) is applied to the vehicle seat belt as that is what is restraining the child. LATCH weigh limits apply to harnessed seats. A vehicle manufacturer AND car seat manufacturer both have limitations, although one may defer to the other. MOST vehicles and harnessed seats have a limit of 40 or 48lbs for car seats. In the case this thread, the seats being discussed are 5 point harness COMBINATION seats (Frontier, Nautilus - sometimes also called "harnessed boosters"). They are treated the same as infant and convertible seats when used in harness mode, therefore the lower anchors and connectors all have weight limits assigned to them (or will defer to the other, if both defer then you discontinue at 40lbs). You will always use the LOWER limit (so if the vehicle limit states to discontinue use and reinstall with a seat belt at 40lbs you do it at 40 even if the carseat says 48) Parkway is a belt positioning booster seat, not a harnessed booster/combination seat, used with the adult seat belt, not a 5 point harness. The only purpose to LATCH a booster in place is to hold it there and prevent it from being a projectile when unoccupied. The SEAT BELT is what is restraining the child, not the LATCH connectors. Because the seat belt is what is absorbing the force and not the lower anchors, the lower anchors can not fail as they are not restraining the seat at all. Britax clearly states this in their answer. Also, it's important to note the Parkway is a bit unique amongst boosters because it not only allows LATCH use but has the antisubmarine SlideGuard that is attached between the legs (that is the "SG" of the SGL, the L is LATCH.) By contrast, a harnessed seat is restraining the child AND absorbing the crash forces, as is the mechanism holding the seat in and the connectors/anchors are tested to load limits. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 3:07 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier Then it seems strange to me to recommend a car seat (Frontier/Nautilis/Argos) when a child is 4 and they will no longer receive the benefit of the 5 point harness/latch. I think most 4 year olds weigh about 40 lbs plus or minus a few pounds. If you can't use latch after 40 lbs then why recommend those car seats? They don't seem like they would serve the parents well for very long. I don't mean this to sound snarky. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 3:18 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier Posted by Hofstra26 I few girls on here recommend the Graco Nautilus when we were looking for a new carseat for my DD a month or so ago and I'm glad I took their advice.........it's a GREAT seat! (and ranked highly by Consumer Reports too) this |
|
Posted 2/21/12 3:19 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier Posted by LSP2005 Then it seems strange to me to recommend a car seat (Frontier/Nautilis/Argos) when a child is 4 and they will no longer receive the benefit of the 5 point harness/latch. I think most 4 year olds weigh about 40 lbs plus or minus a few pounds. If you can't use latch after 40 lbs then why recommend those car seats? They don't seem like they would serve the parents well for very long. I don't mean this to sound snarky. I don't really understand your question? The 5 point harness is part of the carseat, which can be used by many children up to 6, 7 even 8 years of age depending on the child's physical makeup and the limits of the seat. The 5pt harness and LATCH system are not synonymous. Every carseat sold in the US has the ability to be installed via a car's seat belt or using LATCH. One is not safer than the other if installed properly. The caveat is that LATCH can't be used any more as an install method once the child weighs 40/48lbs (depending on seat/vehicle). That doesn't make the seat unusable, it just means you have to install it with a seat belt. LATCH is merely the install method most people choose since it seems easier to get the seat installed right (it's really not always easier though) It is not recommended to booster a child until they have outgrown their harnessed seats, or at about age 5-6. The child not only needs to fit properly, they have to be mature enough to sit properly the entire time. As an aside, one of these days, I am going to get that FAQ on carseats done, I promise! |
|
Posted 2/21/12 3:29 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier I see what you are saying, you can use the latch (the clips to attach the seat to the car) until the child weighs 40 lbs. After that you need to attach the car sear some other way. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 3:45 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier Posted by LSP2005 I see what you are saying, you can use the latch (the clips to attach the seat to the car) until the child weighs 40 lbs. After that you need to attach the car sear some other way. Then the 5 point harness (what you use to attach the child to the seat) should be used until the child outgrows the seat weight/height/seated height. I guess my kid has a long torso because he outgrew the blvd. at 4 1/2 for seated height. Yes, yes, yes! You got it! |
|
Posted 2/21/12 3:57 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier I absolutely love the Nautilus. I think it's easy to install (it takes two of us, but it's simple) and my DD is very comfortable in it. I also like that it grows with the child. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 4:03 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier Posted by LSP2005 Then it seems strange to me to recommend a car seat (Frontier/Nautilis/Argos) when a child is 4 and they will no longer receive the benefit of the 5 point harness/latch. I think most 4 year olds weigh about 40 lbs plus or minus a few pounds. If you can't use latch after 40 lbs then why recommend those car seats? They don't seem like they would serve the parents well for very long. I don't mean this to sound snarky. The frontier and Nautilus ARE a 5 point harness. Up to 65Lbs there is a removable high back. They are a 3 in one carseat. 5 pt harness with high back, high back with booster with seat belt, booster only. They go to 65Lbs with the 5 pt harness. Then they both can be used as a booster up to 100 Lbs. Regardless we had the Britax Decathlon and now the Nautilus. You CANNOT use the latch system past 48Lbs. You MUST use the seat belt to secure the carseat. So the latch system is not because of the Nautilus/Frontier, the limit is the same on a convertible carseat. At 48 Lbs with a Britax convertible you must secure the carseat with the seatbelt. Message edited 2012-02-21 16:08:30.520000. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 4:05 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier I just debated over the same two seats. We get our seats professionally installed so ease of installation was not a concern. I was hesitant about nautilus because I read some negative reviews concerning the buckle sticking. Britax has served us well in the past and albeebaby.com has it on sale for an excellent price so we went with the frontier. So far we love it! |
|
Posted 2/21/12 4:55 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier We have both seats. IMO, they are both easy to install. I like our Nautilus better. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 5:30 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier Posted by jacquig Posted by MrsECullen7319 Posted by Hofstra26 I few girls on here recommend the Graco Nautilus when we were looking for a new carseat for my DD a month or so ago and I'm glad I took their advice.........it's a GREAT seat! (and ranked highly by Consumer Reports too) My DD is more comfortable in that now than the Britax Roundabout we had for her, I think she just outgrew that one. The Nautilus was pretty affordable too. Amazon had it the cheapest I found but I ended up getting it at BRU, they let you use the 20% coupon and I had some gift cards so it worked out better that way. Can the nautilus be used for babies too? I want to get Dd a convertible seat that will grow with her. She's 8 months now and about to outgrow the infant seat. The Nautilus is forward facing only. I think it's recommended to keep the baby rear facing as long as possible. I wouldn't buy a Nautilus until DC was above 3 years old. TY I thought it was rear facing. I will look for something else. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 10:40 PM
|
|
|
Re: Nautilus vs. Frontier Message edited 2012-02-21 22:51:15.267000. |
|
Posted 2/21/12 10:50 PM
|
|
Potentially Related Topics:
| Topic | Posted By | Started | Replies | Forum |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| If you were deciding between the nautilus and frontier... | beachgirl | 5/10/10 | 4 | Parenting |
| UPDATE : Graco Nautilus Spinoff to Bops post...4+ what type of carseats do you have? | jellybean78 | 1/16/12 | 19 | Parenting |
| Another Graco Nautilus question (but really applies to any high back booster)... | doublestroller | 9/11/10 | 0 | Parenting |
| Those with the Nautilus - Im going to rip my hair out! | eddiesmommy | 9/7/10 | 7 | Parenting |
| Wait, the graco nautilus 3 in 1 car seat is forward facing only???? | CaMacho | 6/23/10 | 2 | Parenting |
| Spin off to Graco® Nautilus™ 3-in-1 Car Seat? | LSP2005 | 1/11/10 | 12 | Parenting |







